The thing here is the cognitive dissonance where allies and trans people themselves know sex - the very definition of transgender requires you to know sex. It is a reference to sex. The supreme court noted that if you couldn't see the sex of a transperson you can not define a trans person and give them rights as a transperson.
So you have this situation where everyone involved sees sex but must be silent about sex, but sex remains even though speaking it is forbidden and invisible. It's frankly ridiculous.
Then family members trip over themselves trying to 'get it right' with this doublethink in their head.
Someone posted a couple of pages back about the concept of authentic and the bizarre stories on Reddit which are clearly fake. Well that's the point. The foundation of trans is fantasy. It isn't real. It's a made up notion. Once you get into the habit of lying and having drama about being 'misgendered' it becomes a performance you have to uphold every time. But that's just it. It's a performance 24/7. You perform gender. You perform allyship. It's superficial and image led because you always retain this point of knowing.
And the thing that's hated is others who don't want to play the game and identify what's going on because it shatters the fantasy.
Btw I do think transparent is real simply because of that unintended slipup in mentioning sons. That's a lapse in the facade but it's a genuine facade. It's a lot of effort to go to, to fake - to double bluff.
But this goes back to performance. Allies have to prove their worth. It's the purity spiral. And true believers must adhere or they will be punished father sins. Those of the faith themselves must demonstrate their purity and commitment to the faith. And that's why you get India Willyouby professing he's biologically female.
And yes the pressure in a core family unit is unreal. In some ways my brother's behaviour towards my husband did me a favour because it allowed me to free myself by forcing me to make a choice. But I suffered with guilt for a long time. I can't imagine that as a parent. The thoughts of how and why are unspoken but are consuming. "What did I do wrong?" and other similar ideas about failure are again unspoken and there is a desire to somehow put it all right. This is precisely why, when I've spoken to my close friend who is going through her son transitioning, I've made the point to both of them that everyone involved is allowed to have feelings of their own and they may be conflicting but it's all driven by love no matter what despite this performance thing. No one else could in the way I can because I understand the dynamics in a way only family members can and I have a good enough relationship with both to be able to do it.
I've never wanted to play along with the fantasy. I see the fantasy as ultimately self destructive and there is always an implosion of some kind at some point amongst everyone trying so hard to uphold it. Precisely because of the weight of trying to uphold a lie, requires lie after lie to follow. This always ultimately collapses in on itself eventually.
It is important to write this down. For all the threats of losing a loved one - you lose them when they ask you to lie. You lose them when they can no longer keep lying. You lose them when you accidentally slip up because you have a momentary lapse of thought and just see the person you love for who they are not what they try and project. You are never going to win in this scenario. Whatever you do it's never good enough and that's the bottom line. The sooner you see this and realise, you can not ever live up to false expectations and impossible standards, the better. Cos that's the point you realise you aren't doing it wrong at all and you have just been caught in a web of the impossible you have no choice but to reject. Hello detransitioners. Hello parents who very much love their child but realise lying is a road to nowhere and is the cause of the harm and do not wish to participate in the harming.
This idea that you can only love some one by being perfect is insane. Humans are imperfect beings. It doesn't stop us really really loving someone and acting in a way we believe to be best if it's deemed 'wrong'. It's ok to be 'wrong'. It's ok to not live up to ideas of masculine and feminine. I certainly don't live up to them. Why do transpeople have to? This is separate from the notion of safeguarding too. Understanding that your family member is a nice person who doesn't have the intention to be a perv is all well and good, but that family member is a stranger to others who don't have this 'inside knowledge' and we have to be mindful of this in the Be Kind narrative. Cos it doesn't work.
I am long past the guilt traps and the threats. It doesn't bother me the way it did. But I absolutely do understand the power of them.
I don't use the word 'cultlike' lightly and without good reason from lived experience. Understanding the dynamics of cults is really really important in this whole discussion and understanding.