Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
MyAmpleSheep · 30/10/2026 12:23

FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 11:34

@Emilesgran It’s not getting any coverage at all. I’ve only seen it on The Daily Mail and here. I’m not in the same state that it’s happened in so maybe there’s coverage in the state in question.

@MyAmpleSheep I have no idea if patients have that sort of protection here.

It's a wider question: in most of the jurisdictions I know of, an injunction against unlawful discrimination is against the more powerful party in some kind of formal relationship: the service provider towards the customer, the employer towards their employees, the educational institution towards the students. It's not symmetric: service users and individual members of the public don't have those duties to each other.

It would be correct to note that you can't harass someone, but it would be a bold step to suggest that declining to be treated by an individual doctor (for any reason whatsoever) was an act of harassment against the Doctor.

Even in the genuine and disturbing case, I don't think the prisoner-patient who racially abused Nurse Melle was punished for it.

Wishesandhorses · 30/10/2026 14:52

FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 11:34

@Emilesgran It’s not getting any coverage at all. I’ve only seen it on The Daily Mail and here. I’m not in the same state that it’s happened in so maybe there’s coverage in the state in question.

@MyAmpleSheep I have no idea if patients have that sort of protection here.

I'd think it's not unlikely that the hospital has rushed to hush this up to avoid the patient taking it any more public. I suppose we'll see if more comes out or whether some sort of settlement was very quickly and quietly made.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 30/10/2026 16:35

MyAmpleSheep · 30/10/2026 08:40

I don’t know if the situation in Australia is different but in the UK as a patient you’re not required by law not to discriminate in any way; you can ask for a black doctor, a Jewish doctor, a gay doctor or a male or female (using anyone’s understanding of that word) doctor, the EA2010 doesn’t govern you and there are no legal consequences for you. The other staff might disapprove but you can’t get sued.

Edited

I'm a retired A&E consultant. On a few occasions I have had a patient request a white doctor or more subtly a British doctor. I would whisper in their ear if they didn't like the doctor offered then they could fuck off. Nobody ever did.

Totallygripped · 30/10/2026 18:41

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 30/10/2026 16:35

I'm a retired A&E consultant. On a few occasions I have had a patient request a white doctor or more subtly a British doctor. I would whisper in their ear if they didn't like the doctor offered then they could fuck off. Nobody ever did.

Edited

So you have no skin in the game now. The union which used to represent you seems to have taken the position now that biological sex is an unscientific nonsense. Do you agree? And do you think a gender critical viewpoint equates to outright racism? I haven't followed all your posts but are we all supposed to be impressed by "I'm a retired A&E consultant" intro?

Totallygripped · 30/10/2026 19:24

Totallygripped · 30/10/2026 18:41

So you have no skin in the game now. The union which used to represent you seems to have taken the position now that biological sex is an unscientific nonsense. Do you agree? And do you think a gender critical viewpoint equates to outright racism? I haven't followed all your posts but are we all supposed to be impressed by "I'm a retired A&E consultant" intro?

And your urology consultant colleagues are happily coining it (NHS and private) with surgery. Are they making women (or much more rarely) men? Or just neo this and thats? But 14k a pop in their pocket?
"Consultant" does not impress me.
But anyway you've got your pension now.

ProudWomanXX · 31/10/2026 04:33

Wow, how rude.

ScrollingLeaves · 31/10/2026 07:42

HermioneWeasley · 24/10/2026 18:40

You really hate women having boundaries don’t you?

Is transparently annoyed a male?

ScrollingLeaves · 31/10/2026 07:48

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 30/10/2026 16:35

I'm a retired A&E consultant. On a few occasions I have had a patient request a white doctor or more subtly a British doctor. I would whisper in their ear if they didn't like the doctor offered then they could fuck off. Nobody ever did.

Edited

Of course you whispered in their ear. Like many bullies you needed to intimidate a patient covertly. The patient may have been wrong but you could have dealt with their request in a more professional way.

anyolddinosaur · 31/10/2026 08:30

Jennifer Miele treated professionally a racist paedophile man pretending to be a woman who tried to attack her and had to be restrained by the prison staff accompanying him. Anyone can claim to be anything on the internet but if genuine MrPrettyDamnCosmic needed to take lessons from her. Bullies are disgusting.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 31/10/2026 08:40

TBH I'm amazed that the response to my little anecdote is people taking the side of drunken racists but apparently at least three people think I was in the wrong so it's just as well I'm retired & unable to cause further upset amongst the white supremacist community.

alteredimage · 31/10/2026 08:46

In contrast, DD has an amusing, but outing, anecdote from F1 days part of which involves a nurse asking her if she would see a patient, because the patient was refusing to be treated by her colleague. (Religion not race or other characteristics.) She obliged, on the assumption that both the colleague and the nurses had no sympathy for the patient's views but would see it as a societal problem, not one to be addressed individually or immediately. The patient was almost certainly old, probably frightened and vulnerable, and possibly with a level of dementia. The patient needed treating and they had a joint aim of getting through the night shift smoothly. Had she had been caught up in something else, the nurse would have told the patient there was no alternative to the first doctor. You don't get to hear the funny end to the story, but Karma happens.

Patients can request what they want. The NHS is often chaotically busy and I assume staff do what they can to meet reasonable, and sometimes unreasonable, requests. And sometimes it might be hard to tell. Another DD anecdote involved someone aged about 90 and with post-operative delirium, shouting quite outrageous things about DD. Two days later she reverted to being a sweet old lady with no memory of the preceding days.

What worries me about MrPrettyDamnCosmic's approach is the way it mirrors Upton's approach. A patient calling him "son" is complained about. Presumably Upton was wearing scrubs and presumably the patient was suffering, at minimum, a level of white coat fever. Yes the Australian legal system and their medial association may say that Upton is a man. But most humans would perceive him as a woman, and many of us if drowsy, medicated or whatever might be missing that level of executive function needed to correct their natural perception.

(I get the need to protect colleagues from racial or other abuse by patients, but patients are vulnerable and so a balance needs to be struck.)

I also get that if you live in Port Mac you might have no option but to be treated by Upton. I assume for certain procedures women (or men) have a right to ask for a chaperone if being treated by someone of the opposite sex. What would worry me is if the hospital/Upton decide that Upton is a woman, and so the right to a chaperone does not apply.

YourWatermelonship · 31/10/2026 08:53

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 30/10/2026 16:35

I'm a retired A&E consultant. On a few occasions I have had a patient request a white doctor or more subtly a British doctor. I would whisper in their ear if they didn't like the doctor offered then they could fuck off. Nobody ever did.

Edited

Racism is vile. Your behaviour sounds creepy and unprofessional.

SirChenjins · 31/10/2026 08:55

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 31/10/2026 08:40

TBH I'm amazed that the response to my little anecdote is people taking the side of drunken racists but apparently at least three people think I was in the wrong so it's just as well I'm retired & unable to cause further upset amongst the white supremacist community.

Oh come off it. If you really are a retired A&E consultant you'll know that not everyone who asks for a British Dr is a white supremacist - people with cognitive impairment and recurrent UTIs that make them delirious like my 90 year old MIL for example. If you would honestly have told her to fuck off rather than responding in a more professional and appropriate manner using the training given in the NHS to respond to these situations then it's probably a good thing you're retired.

SirChenjins · 31/10/2026 08:57

What would worry me is if the hospital/Upton decide that Upton is a woman, and so the right to a chaperone does not apply

This, 💯 I wonder if that's happening and it's why the woman's husband was going to have to act as her chaperone.

alteredimage · 31/10/2026 08:58

alteredimage · 31/10/2026 08:46

In contrast, DD has an amusing, but outing, anecdote from F1 days part of which involves a nurse asking her if she would see a patient, because the patient was refusing to be treated by her colleague. (Religion not race or other characteristics.) She obliged, on the assumption that both the colleague and the nurses had no sympathy for the patient's views but would see it as a societal problem, not one to be addressed individually or immediately. The patient was almost certainly old, probably frightened and vulnerable, and possibly with a level of dementia. The patient needed treating and they had a joint aim of getting through the night shift smoothly. Had she had been caught up in something else, the nurse would have told the patient there was no alternative to the first doctor. You don't get to hear the funny end to the story, but Karma happens.

Patients can request what they want. The NHS is often chaotically busy and I assume staff do what they can to meet reasonable, and sometimes unreasonable, requests. And sometimes it might be hard to tell. Another DD anecdote involved someone aged about 90 and with post-operative delirium, shouting quite outrageous things about DD. Two days later she reverted to being a sweet old lady with no memory of the preceding days.

What worries me about MrPrettyDamnCosmic's approach is the way it mirrors Upton's approach. A patient calling him "son" is complained about. Presumably Upton was wearing scrubs and presumably the patient was suffering, at minimum, a level of white coat fever. Yes the Australian legal system and their medial association may say that Upton is a man. But most humans would perceive him as a woman, and many of us if drowsy, medicated or whatever might be missing that level of executive function needed to correct their natural perception.

(I get the need to protect colleagues from racial or other abuse by patients, but patients are vulnerable and so a balance needs to be struck.)

I also get that if you live in Port Mac you might have no option but to be treated by Upton. I assume for certain procedures women (or men) have a right to ask for a chaperone if being treated by someone of the opposite sex. What would worry me is if the hospital/Upton decide that Upton is a woman, and so the right to a chaperone does not apply.

Edited

Missed the important edit.

"the Australian legal system and their medial association may say that Upton is a WOMAN. But most humans would perceive him as a MAN".

I'm getting confused, and I am not in hospital, frightened and discombobulated".

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 31/10/2026 09:07

SirChenjins · 31/10/2026 08:55

Oh come off it. If you really are a retired A&E consultant you'll know that not everyone who asks for a British Dr is a white supremacist - people with cognitive impairment and recurrent UTIs that make them delirious like my 90 year old MIL for example. If you would honestly have told her to fuck off rather than responding in a more professional and appropriate manner using the training given in the NHS to respond to these situations then it's probably a good thing you're retired.

Edited

I'm only referring to the drunken racists that I gave the option of seeing the allocated doctor or leaving the department. These were all cases where the junior came to me to ask what to do when the patient said they wanted a white doctor. Confused old ladies were handled sympathetically of course.

There is a responsibility to ensure that staff are not abused or harassed just as physical aggression isn't tolerated. On occasion I needed the police to eject people misbehaving.

SirChenjins · 31/10/2026 09:10

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 31/10/2026 09:07

I'm only referring to the drunken racists that I gave the option of seeing the allocated doctor or leaving the department. These were all cases where the junior came to me to ask what to do when the patient said they wanted a white doctor. Confused old ladies were handled sympathetically of course.

There is a responsibility to ensure that staff are not abused or harassed just as physical aggression isn't tolerated. On occasion I needed the police to eject people misbehaving.

Thank you for clarifying that you didn't actually whisper fuck off in the ear of everyone who asked for a British Dr, and understand that not everyone who does so is a white supremacist.

alteredimage · 31/10/2026 09:17

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 31/10/2026 09:07

I'm only referring to the drunken racists that I gave the option of seeing the allocated doctor or leaving the department. These were all cases where the junior came to me to ask what to do when the patient said they wanted a white doctor. Confused old ladies were handled sympathetically of course.

There is a responsibility to ensure that staff are not abused or harassed just as physical aggression isn't tolerated. On occasion I needed the police to eject people misbehaving.

Fair dinkum. (Do Australians actually say that?)

The issue here is that Upton appears to believe that he has a right to insist on being treated as a woman, whether by patients in an earlier hospital or by colleagues in Fife.

A man imposing his perceived needs in a hospital context, where patients are often vulnerable, and colleagues stretched. Not the place. Unfortunately his employers and Union were prepared to back him. And Australia, with its batty laws, and its medical set up which has him registered as a female doctor may do the same.

anyolddinosaur · 31/10/2026 09:36

Of course someone called out on their disgusting bullying tries to backtrack a bit. Bullies love being able to claim racism because they think it excuses their bullying - it doesnt.

Misogynists are not treated in the same way although there are many sexual assaults in hospitals. All abuse of staff needs to be responded to professionally and sometimes that means getting the police to arrest a patient. They still get necessary medical treatment.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 31/10/2026 10:18

anyolddinosaur · 31/10/2026 09:36

Of course someone called out on their disgusting bullying tries to backtrack a bit. Bullies love being able to claim racism because they think it excuses their bullying - it doesnt.

Misogynists are not treated in the same way although there are many sexual assaults in hospitals. All abuse of staff needs to be responded to professionally and sometimes that means getting the police to arrest a patient. They still get necessary medical treatment.

All abuse of staff needs to be responded to professionally and sometimes that means getting the police to arrest a patient. They still get necessary medical treatment.

They don't get treated if it's unsafe for the staff. I mean literally unsafe not hurty words unsafe.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 31/10/2026 10:45

anyolddinosaur · 31/10/2026 09:36

Of course someone called out on their disgusting bullying tries to backtrack a bit. Bullies love being able to claim racism because they think it excuses their bullying - it doesnt.

Misogynists are not treated in the same way although there are many sexual assaults in hospitals. All abuse of staff needs to be responded to professionally and sometimes that means getting the police to arrest a patient. They still get necessary medical treatment.

I have bullied nobody. I kept my staff safe & my department safe by ensuring that a drunken patient did not kick off but was left with the very clear knowledge that racism would not be tolerated. There is too much bad behaviour towards emergency services staff.

PriOn1 · 31/10/2026 11:33

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 31/10/2026 10:45

I have bullied nobody. I kept my staff safe & my department safe by ensuring that a drunken patient did not kick off but was left with the very clear knowledge that racism would not be tolerated. There is too much bad behaviour towards emergency services staff.

Would you respond in a similar way to someone who wanted to be treated by a doctor of a specific sex?

alteredimage · 31/10/2026 11:37

So its not really about the racism, sexism or transphobia, but whether the patient would provide a physical threat to staff.

A similarly racist frail old lady would be given a pass as they do not pose a threat.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 31/10/2026 11:51

PriOn1 · 31/10/2026 11:33

Would you respond in a similar way to someone who wanted to be treated by a doctor of a specific sex?

Asking for a male doctor if you have a swollen testicle is not misogyny. Asking for a female doctor when you have a vaginal discharge is not misandry. We would always try & accommodate a preference provided it didn't come from a bad place.

Asking to be seen by a Muslim lady doctor is fine but refusing to be seen by a Muslim lady doctor is not OK. You just need to accept that while you can express a preference & we would try & accommodate your preference that at the end of the day this might delay your treatment waiting for a particular doctor to become available. Your preference might be to be treated by a Jewish man but if we don't have one on shift then you can either leave or accept another doctor.

Newname26 · 31/10/2026 12:50

@MrPrettyDamnCosmic Asking to be seen by a Muslim lady doctor is fine but refusing to be seen by a Muslim lady doctor is not OK.

Really? Lets try swapping some words around.

Asking to be seen by a Christian lady doctor is fine but refusing to be seen by a Christian lady doctor is not OK.

Would any of that actually be acceptable in 2026? No it wouldn't.

Asking for woman or man yes, Religion should not play a part in medical treatment (beyond final prayers)

Swipe left for the next trending thread