Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Redvers v NHS Sussex Integrated Care Board & Mr Adam Doyle Thread 3

567 replies

fanOfBen · 21/10/2026 19:34

TT summary:

Dr Redvers, a named GP safeguarding lead, has a constructive dismissal case. Clinical concerns were raised about a specific doctor at WellBN, a Brighton GP practice. She claims that as a result of escalating those claims from 2020 onwards, she was constructively dismissed.

Her legal claim is discrimination on the grounds of her employer’s perception she had gender critical beliefs and on the grounds of her protected belief in evidence-based medicine (EBM). The respondent defends the latter claim by pleading that EBM is just an opinion.

Earlier coverage of this hearing can be found on TT's Substack at:
t.co/TwXeLCDnpt

TT report what they hear in good faith but do not provide a verbatim transcript of the hearing.

TT's list of abbreviations:

J - Judge Katherine Andrews (sitting alone)
DR/C - Doctor Sarah Redvers, claimant
CM/RB - Chris Milsom, claimant barrister
CE/RB - Charlotte Elves, Claimant Barrister
PD - Peter Daly, solicitor for the C

NHSSICB/R1 - NHS Sussex Integrated Care Board, first respondent
AD/R2 - Adam Doyle, second respondent, CEO of R1 2019-2025
Rs - collectively the respondents
RB/BW - Ben Williams, Respondent's barrister
EBM - Evidence-based medicine
SG - Safeguarding

WB - WellBN, Brighton based GP practice
GC - Gender Critical or sex realist beliefs
GI - Gender Identity belief
WS - Witness Statement
Ix - investigation
Gx - grievance
Cx - complaint

SH/DSH - Dr Sam Hall, GP at WellBN, Trustee - the Clare Project (TCP), Clinical Lead - Trans Health Hub, GIC Partner - Trans Health Improvement Board at R1, trans-identified female
DA - Dusty Amroliwala, ext consultant, investigated complaint filed by DSH against C
LB - Lola Banjoko, Exec Managing Director, chair of Trans Health Improvement Board, advised R1 on trans matters
NC - Nikky Cambridge, former trustee of TCP

AC - Allison Cannon, Chief Nursing Officer, R1, tasked w implementing the recommendations of the 1st grievance outcome
CCD - Dr Claire Cochrane-Dyet, Dep Medical Director for System Improvement & Professional Standards, NHSE, commissioned Warshafsky Report
HD - Dr Hannah Davies, Deputy Chief Medical Office, R1

SD - Samantha Durrant, Lay vice chair until July 2022, 1st grievance manager
NE - Naomi Ellis, dep director of Safeguarding, R1
MF - Dr Mary Flynn, Named GP for Safeguarding, also filed g/x in relation to Amroliwala Report
PF - Pennie Ford, Executive Managing Director, R1, 2nd grievance manager

EG - Dr Elizabeth Gill, Chief Medical Officer, R1
HH - Hannah Hamilton, Chief financial officer, R1, 2nd grievance appeal manager
BJ - Dr Becky Jarvis, clinical lead for mental health, R1
TM - Tom Micklewright, managing partner of Lime Tree Surgery

IM - Ian Mundy, HR Consultant, Your Consultancy, 1st grievance investigator
MP - Mark Power, interim Chief People Officer (until April 2022), R1, managed Amroliwala investigation
RR - Dr Rebecca Richards, GP partner, Lime Tree Surgery, raised concerns to C about SH
AR - Anne Robson, Interim Chief People Officer (April -August 2022), R1

DS - Dr Dinesh Sinha, Chief Medical Officer (June 2022 - April 2024), Chair of Trans Health Improvement Board (THIB)
MS - Mark Smith, Chief People Officer, R1 (Aug 2022 - Jan 2025) Acting CEO (Jan 2025 - June 2025) Deputy CEO & Director of Transition (June 2025 - present)
RW - Dr Robin Warshafsky, GP NHSE, Author of Warshafsky Report (WR)

Thread 1:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5586672-wellbn-brighton-gp-practice-do-not-believe-in-evidence-based-medicine-tt-at-employment-tribunal-tomorrow

Thread 2:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5588924-redvers-v-nhs-sussex-integrated-care-board-mr-adam-doyle-thread-2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
MyAmpleSheep · 25/10/2026 15:19

There is now a thread on UK trans reddit about the BBC article; it's wild, as you might imagine.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 25/10/2026 15:14

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 25/10/2026 14:56

We women are used to agitating from a position of disadvantage. I wonder if you feel the distress differently because you are a man. Not snipey. Genuine thought.

Of course I feel it differently because I'm a man.
Ironically I went thru a very "I don't feel like a male" as a sensitive teen as I was a bit ostracized by the sporty lads in my grammar school, and I had an <inkling> of AGP type feelings (such a hazy memory I can't recall it in detail). Today Id likely be diagnosed with some ADHD label, and maybe would tack to non binary. I don't know.
All I know is that I'm aware of that side of me from decades ago, my younger adult life in a not so healthy place re my attitude to women, I've moved past all that, and feel I have some deeper insight into trans ideology than 99% of men I converse with.
Re how I feel about it compared to women, there's no comparison.
Trans ideology is a clear and present danger to you, it's tangential to me.
A transman (I won't use a break in the word) is a moment of embarrassment in the men's loo at the pub or shower at the gym, no physical threat in my sports or prison if I ended up there.
No, for me, my anger is generated by the strong emotion of women being compromised by this bait and switch in society, kids at risk both medically and by society lying to them, and the threat as I see it to language, ethics, hight trust society and decay of liberal principles that the West has evolved and perfected since the Enlightenment.
It's why I call trans an illiberal anti-human(itarian) endeavour.
So, I don't experience trans ideology as a man in any physical way myself, but I'm hugely aware of the sheer frustration of women, feel hugely for kids caught up, and can't avoid the elephant in the room, the reordering of the post liberal future.

BlueLegume · 25/10/2026 15:14

The Hannah Barnes article in actual print in the Times is sobering. A full page. Much more impactful for me than reading online.

I teared up as I was sat reading at the very same table I read about the Tavistock years ago. I remember thinking then ‘thank goodness for the whistleblowers’. If only we knew then that it would just get worse and we would also be expected to embrace the increasing number of men in frocks.

Dark part of humanity all round.

It is half term in England. I do hope the article is being circulated around every safeguarding lead in every school. Time to wake up to this scandal.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 25/10/2026 15:14

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 25/10/2026 15:02

Even without Sam Hall WellBN are still operating their own shadow Gender Clinic funded by Surrey & Sussex ICB.

www.wellbn.co.uk/trans-health-hub/

We will have to hope that Cass and the DHSC investigate as promised. I suspect that we are beginning to witness a massive clash of ideologies at the highest levels.

ProfDrLapwing · 25/10/2026 15:09

Did I dream that someone from, I think nhs England, pretty much applauded the WellBN/Sussex/TransHealthHub approach of taking over from private prescribers. They observed that it could be a good model to promote more widely.

I’ve looked back through Tribunal Tweets but am now wondering if I imagined it. Does it ring a bell with anyone else?

ArabellaScott · 25/10/2026 15:09

Good to hear strong words from Hilary Cass.

ArabellaScott · 25/10/2026 15:09

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 14:08

I wish a solution would be found. But at this stage, having seen every argument from those considered moderate to extreme, I cannot see that there is an accommodation for using inaccurate language.

Agree.

I don't actually like using pronouns that I know will upset the person concerned. I feel sorry for many of them. But if it is a choice between vulnerable children being sterilised, mutilated, and harmed, and upsetting people, I can do nothing else but use the language that breaks the spell.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 25/10/2026 15:02

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 25/10/2026 14:49

For Cass, the scandal that has unfolded in Brighton “dwarfs” that of the Tavistock’s Gids. She called on the GMC to immediately suspend Hall. “I really would want to ask why he still has a licence to practise.”

Hilary Cass agrees.

Even without Sam Hall WellBN are still operating their own shadow Gender Clinic funded by Surrey & Sussex ICB.

www.wellbn.co.uk/trans-health-hub/

Trans Health Hub

https://www.wellbn.co.uk/trans-health-hub/

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 25/10/2026 14:56

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 25/10/2026 14:48

I'm reading a lot of Róisín Michaux in Europe/EU, things are absolutely ruined over there. The Anglophone world is in a very bad place, Australia, NZ, Canada.
The US? Shows signs of sanity, but one term of a radical Democrat president and Woke 2 will make Woke 1 look like a dress rehearsal.
The UK is holding the line, but it's a very tenuous thing.

We women are used to agitating from a position of disadvantage. I wonder if you feel the distress differently because you are a man. Not snipey. Genuine thought.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 25/10/2026 14:50

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 25/10/2026 14:44

It's a lot easier to train as a GP (3 years) than become a Consultant Endocrinologist (7-8 years minimum) & far less competitive. What I gathered from that article was something more sinister that Dr Hall deliberately retrained as a GP to maximise her ability to proselytise all things "trans" & prescribe PBs & CSH to children.

The full extent of the WellBN scandal has not yet been revealed but they seem to just be carrying on as before but without Dr Hall. They pathetically apologise on their website that "We have had to temporarily pause initiating new NHS prescriptions for gender affirming care to anyone under the age of 18." The Sussex & Surrey ICB is aware of what is going as they paying for it all.

www.wellbn.co.uk/trans-health-hub/

No true believers ever gave up their belief even under torture.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 25/10/2026 14:49

anyolddinosaur · 25/10/2026 14:45

Dr Hall should have been struck off by now.

For Cass, the scandal that has unfolded in Brighton “dwarfs” that of the Tavistock’s Gids. She called on the GMC to immediately suspend Hall. “I really would want to ask why he still has a licence to practise.”

Hilary Cass agrees.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 25/10/2026 14:48

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 25/10/2026 14:44

Yes, I agree. In the alternative timeline it could have happened. In this timeline, no. We gave an inch by allowing a handful of HSTS men to play at being women, without making a massive fuss. The TRAs ran with that and tried to take everything from women and fertility and health from children. There is no coming back from that in the timeline we inhabit.

I'm reading a lot of Róisín Michaux in Europe/EU, things are absolutely ruined over there. The Anglophone world is in a very bad place, Australia, NZ, Canada.
The US? Shows signs of sanity, but one term of a radical Democrat president and Woke 2 will make Woke 1 look like a dress rehearsal.
The UK is holding the line, but it's a very tenuous thing.

anyolddinosaur · 25/10/2026 14:45

Dr Hall should have been struck off by now.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 25/10/2026 14:44

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 25/10/2026 14:29

I'm just going to say this straight out. I would not feel safe or comfortable being treated by Dr Hall. The tone of this blog makes me feel that Hall has zero insight into other people and is utterly obsessed by gender, seeing everything through the lens of her own transition. I also don't understand why a consultant obstetric anaesthetist would feel that re-training as a GP was the best way to be able to help patients with gender issues, including prescribing hormones and puberty blockers. Surely her medical training and experience must have suggested that endocrinology was the discipline for this? (Not that I think anybody should be prescribing these drugs for gender dysphoria. These are psychological issues and they need psychological treatment.)

Hall gave birth to three children before transitioning. What a headfuck for them. https://managementinpractice.com/views/blogs/feeling-visible-for-the-first-time-my-trans-story/
https://managementinpractice.com/views/blogs/how-i-went-from-hospital-consultant-to-gp-my-trans-story/

It's a lot easier to train as a GP (3 years) than become a Consultant Endocrinologist (7-8 years minimum) & far less competitive. What I gathered from that article was something more sinister that Dr Hall deliberately retrained as a GP to maximise her ability to proselytise all things "trans" & prescribe PBs & CSH to children.

The full extent of the WellBN scandal has not yet been revealed but they seem to just be carrying on as before but without Dr Hall. They pathetically apologise on their website that "We have had to temporarily pause initiating new NHS prescriptions for gender affirming care to anyone under the age of 18." The Sussex & Surrey ICB is aware of what is going as they paying for it all.

www.wellbn.co.uk/trans-health-hub/

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 25/10/2026 14:44

ThreeNewWords · 25/10/2026 14:05

@Helleofabore and @HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 Yeah, you may both be right. I'm a bit undecided. If the situation hadn't become so distorted by authoritarianism, entitlement and narcissism there would be space for each of us to reach our own accommodation on the issue, without being monstered. That's the key failing, the complete replacement of normal plurality with a conjured-up orthodoxy that no-one can remember signing up to. If that went away, a solution might emerge.

Yes, I agree. In the alternative timeline it could have happened. In this timeline, no. We gave an inch by allowing a handful of HSTS men to play at being women, without making a massive fuss. The TRAs ran with that and tried to take everything from women and fertility and health from children. There is no coming back from that in the timeline we inhabit.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 25/10/2026 14:38

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 14:08

I wish a solution would be found. But at this stage, having seen every argument from those considered moderate to extreme, I cannot see that there is an accommodation for using inaccurate language.

The whole phenomenon is won or lost in the realm of language.
Foucault said "language is violence" and reality isn't objective but created by the words used.
The moment phrases like trans women are women became default, preferred pronouns as obligations, the situation was already gamed.
The ideology took advantage of a liberal society that always looks to compromise and "get along" to create an illiberalism that broaches no dissent.
15 years on, with almost a generation of liberal academics, educationalists, health professionals and law makers in thrall, rearguard action by GCs going to court and the JKR megaphone have been the only things attempting to push back.
Preferred pronouns is the language equivalent of toilets policy in this uncivil war.
The cry goes out, why the issue with pronouns, it's only decorum and respect and non victimisation, ditto why the issue with toilets, just showing trans IDd they're not shut out of civic life.
But of course they're "not just" nothing. Pronouns are the gateway drug in language changes, one day preferred pronouns, the next trans women are women, the next the battle is lost because language is sequestered.. Toilets are the gateway drug in day to day practicalities, one day TW can use women's toilets, the next the boundaries on sports and prisons are blurred to uselessness.
My fear is that the language pivot cannot easily if at all be reversed.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 25/10/2026 14:29

I'm just going to say this straight out. I would not feel safe or comfortable being treated by Dr Hall. The tone of this blog makes me feel that Hall has zero insight into other people and is utterly obsessed by gender, seeing everything through the lens of her own transition. I also don't understand why a consultant obstetric anaesthetist would feel that re-training as a GP was the best way to be able to help patients with gender issues, including prescribing hormones and puberty blockers. Surely her medical training and experience must have suggested that endocrinology was the discipline for this? (Not that I think anybody should be prescribing these drugs for gender dysphoria. These are psychological issues and they need psychological treatment.)

Hall gave birth to three children before transitioning. What a headfuck for them. https://managementinpractice.com/views/blogs/feeling-visible-for-the-first-time-my-trans-story/
https://managementinpractice.com/views/blogs/how-i-went-from-hospital-consultant-to-gp-my-trans-story/

How I went from hospital consultant to GP – my trans story

To increase understanding of trans peoples’ experiences, GP Dr Samuel Hall shares his journey of coming out as a trans man while working in the NHS.

https://managementinpractice.com/views/blogs/how-i-went-from-hospital-consultant-to-gp-my-trans-story/

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 14:08

ThreeNewWords · 25/10/2026 14:05

@Helleofabore and @HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 Yeah, you may both be right. I'm a bit undecided. If the situation hadn't become so distorted by authoritarianism, entitlement and narcissism there would be space for each of us to reach our own accommodation on the issue, without being monstered. That's the key failing, the complete replacement of normal plurality with a conjured-up orthodoxy that no-one can remember signing up to. If that went away, a solution might emerge.

I wish a solution would be found. But at this stage, having seen every argument from those considered moderate to extreme, I cannot see that there is an accommodation for using inaccurate language.

ThreeNewWords · 25/10/2026 14:05

@Helleofabore and @HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 Yeah, you may both be right. I'm a bit undecided. If the situation hadn't become so distorted by authoritarianism, entitlement and narcissism there would be space for each of us to reach our own accommodation on the issue, without being monstered. That's the key failing, the complete replacement of normal plurality with a conjured-up orthodoxy that no-one can remember signing up to. If that went away, a solution might emerge.

heathspeedwell · 25/10/2026 10:34

I can't get over the scale of all the under-25s affected by this. 1,100 people in the year from 24-25 alone.

And Hall hadn't even bothered to meet many of them, she just handed out prescriptions like sweeties. (Even though we're always told this never happens).

I really hope there's an inquiry and I hope Hall, Doyle and the other people who facilitated this scandal lose their jobs and their pensions.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 25/10/2026 10:09

ThreeNewWords · 25/10/2026 08:14

I'm not sure, really. The article does make clear that Hall is a biological woman who has had surgery to appear male (and we can infer hormones also). It might have detracted from the article to insist on correct-sex pronouns.

After all, whatever a return to normality involves, it is certain that there will be some transitioned people and that they should be treated with respect. Provided that there is no deceit involved, that sex can be indicated wherever necessary, and that no-one is forced to censor or silence themselves (unless they are speaking in a way that is genuinely hateful), I'd be happy to see flexibility about pronouns.

If the article had insisted on sex-based pronouns it would have seemed hostile to the whole concept of transgender, which would have undermined its factual representation of a failure to assess each gender-distressed child and young person in an evidence-respecting, non-ideological way

I agree with most of your points, but not flexibility about pronouns.

I think most of us have had a long time to think about the pronouns issue. The deciding factor for me was the confusion about sex that it might instill in small children, and the safeguarding issues that can follow. It really dwarfs any claim by an adult that they might 'feel more comfortable' if I refer to them by wrong-sex pronouns. The most I will ever give is a they/them or use of their chosen name.

Szygy · 25/10/2026 09:40

CohensDiamondTeeth · 24/10/2026 23:15

It does, thank you!

I tried but I haven't been able to archive anything for ages. I have no idea why.

I've found the same, and I used to archive a lot of things as well as read them. I think sites have recently found some way to avoid their articles being archived. I keep thinking there must be some clever workaround, and there probably is, but I haven’t found it.

If anyone can recommend a reliable alternative to the previously-trusty archive site, do share!

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 09:39

The use of wrong sex pronouns in the article requires people to both read the full article to understand that (and any quoting away from that full explanation will lose the context) and require a reader to have full understanding of all the terminology referenced.

Using pronouns that are the opposite sex to that person’s sex category builds in inaccuracy no matter how respectful someone is attempting to be.

There really is no way around this. The discussion has cover nearly every conceivable angle and that point remains. That inaccuracy may mean little to you, general you, but when you then look at how that can then build it is remarkable to see the impact. You, general you, using he for someone like Buckangel sets the expectation that Buck is male for anyone who hears that said, or reads it. Even in brief conversation.

Decisions get made based on that information, and those decisions may have been very different knowing buck is female.

borntobequiet · 25/10/2026 09:08

ThreeNewWords · 25/10/2026 08:14

I'm not sure, really. The article does make clear that Hall is a biological woman who has had surgery to appear male (and we can infer hormones also). It might have detracted from the article to insist on correct-sex pronouns.

After all, whatever a return to normality involves, it is certain that there will be some transitioned people and that they should be treated with respect. Provided that there is no deceit involved, that sex can be indicated wherever necessary, and that no-one is forced to censor or silence themselves (unless they are speaking in a way that is genuinely hateful), I'd be happy to see flexibility about pronouns.

If the article had insisted on sex-based pronouns it would have seemed hostile to the whole concept of transgender, which would have undermined its factual representation of a failure to assess each gender-distressed child and young person in an evidence-respecting, non-ideological way

Thank you for expressing my feelings about this far better than I could.

BettyBooper · 25/10/2026 08:16

ProudWomanXX · 25/10/2026 03:04

Shame HB referred to Dr Sam as "He" throughout, though

Well, quite. It's absolutely relevant that DSH is a woman with a 'trans identity' and yet, you'd probably miss this on reading the article.

'Talking to Redvers, I cannot help thinking that I have heard this before. Clinicians at the Tavistock’s Gids shared the exact same observations with me from 2019 onwards: weak leadership combined with ideological capture, perceived prestige for the organisation, and fear had all led to children being harmed.'

The irony.

Swipe left for the next trending thread