Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Redvers v NHS Sussex Integrated Care Board & Mr Adam Doyle Thread 3

567 replies

fanOfBen · 21/10/2026 19:34

TT summary:

Dr Redvers, a named GP safeguarding lead, has a constructive dismissal case. Clinical concerns were raised about a specific doctor at WellBN, a Brighton GP practice. She claims that as a result of escalating those claims from 2020 onwards, she was constructively dismissed.

Her legal claim is discrimination on the grounds of her employer’s perception she had gender critical beliefs and on the grounds of her protected belief in evidence-based medicine (EBM). The respondent defends the latter claim by pleading that EBM is just an opinion.

Earlier coverage of this hearing can be found on TT's Substack at:
t.co/TwXeLCDnpt

TT report what they hear in good faith but do not provide a verbatim transcript of the hearing.

TT's list of abbreviations:

J - Judge Katherine Andrews (sitting alone)
DR/C - Doctor Sarah Redvers, claimant
CM/RB - Chris Milsom, claimant barrister
CE/RB - Charlotte Elves, Claimant Barrister
PD - Peter Daly, solicitor for the C

NHSSICB/R1 - NHS Sussex Integrated Care Board, first respondent
AD/R2 - Adam Doyle, second respondent, CEO of R1 2019-2025
Rs - collectively the respondents
RB/BW - Ben Williams, Respondent's barrister
EBM - Evidence-based medicine
SG - Safeguarding

WB - WellBN, Brighton based GP practice
GC - Gender Critical or sex realist beliefs
GI - Gender Identity belief
WS - Witness Statement
Ix - investigation
Gx - grievance
Cx - complaint

SH/DSH - Dr Sam Hall, GP at WellBN, Trustee - the Clare Project (TCP), Clinical Lead - Trans Health Hub, GIC Partner - Trans Health Improvement Board at R1, trans-identified female
DA - Dusty Amroliwala, ext consultant, investigated complaint filed by DSH against C
LB - Lola Banjoko, Exec Managing Director, chair of Trans Health Improvement Board, advised R1 on trans matters
NC - Nikky Cambridge, former trustee of TCP

AC - Allison Cannon, Chief Nursing Officer, R1, tasked w implementing the recommendations of the 1st grievance outcome
CCD - Dr Claire Cochrane-Dyet, Dep Medical Director for System Improvement & Professional Standards, NHSE, commissioned Warshafsky Report
HD - Dr Hannah Davies, Deputy Chief Medical Office, R1

SD - Samantha Durrant, Lay vice chair until July 2022, 1st grievance manager
NE - Naomi Ellis, dep director of Safeguarding, R1
MF - Dr Mary Flynn, Named GP for Safeguarding, also filed g/x in relation to Amroliwala Report
PF - Pennie Ford, Executive Managing Director, R1, 2nd grievance manager

EG - Dr Elizabeth Gill, Chief Medical Officer, R1
HH - Hannah Hamilton, Chief financial officer, R1, 2nd grievance appeal manager
BJ - Dr Becky Jarvis, clinical lead for mental health, R1
TM - Tom Micklewright, managing partner of Lime Tree Surgery

IM - Ian Mundy, HR Consultant, Your Consultancy, 1st grievance investigator
MP - Mark Power, interim Chief People Officer (until April 2022), R1, managed Amroliwala investigation
RR - Dr Rebecca Richards, GP partner, Lime Tree Surgery, raised concerns to C about SH
AR - Anne Robson, Interim Chief People Officer (April -August 2022), R1

DS - Dr Dinesh Sinha, Chief Medical Officer (June 2022 - April 2024), Chair of Trans Health Improvement Board (THIB)
MS - Mark Smith, Chief People Officer, R1 (Aug 2022 - Jan 2025) Acting CEO (Jan 2025 - June 2025) Deputy CEO & Director of Transition (June 2025 - present)
RW - Dr Robin Warshafsky, GP NHSE, Author of Warshafsky Report (WR)

Thread 1:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5586672-wellbn-brighton-gp-practice-do-not-believe-in-evidence-based-medicine-tt-at-employment-tribunal-tomorrow

Thread 2:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5588924-redvers-v-nhs-sussex-integrated-care-board-mr-adam-doyle-thread-2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:11

Ooh judge pissed off.

Cailleach1 · 23/10/2026 11:09

‘She believes she was right, and wronged by SH; SH believes to be in the right, and wronged by the C.’

If they wanted to present what SH ‘believes’, then shouldn’t they have had her as a witness?

Also, blinkin’ heck, a unique manifestation of a unique belief. Are they presenting black as white, if that is SR understanding of a reality along the majority of the non indoctrinated world and has since time immemorial. Nuts.

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:07

TT
BW: The key point, I repeat, is the complaint made by SH - it was the first domino where this ET is the last. So the C has a problem with the time gap. Between resolution of that and events in 2023. I will finish there.

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:06

BW done

Judge asking Q

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:06

TT
BW: And re C's protected beliefs. MLF and I both address this but I still note, no mention at the time. BW: I am concerned that Grainger is being stretched - have written on this.
BW: [missed, re manifestation] BW: No doubt that C was raising safeguarding, and if that was the lens we use it would be entirely clear as whistleblowing, but, that is not the lens an ET uses.
BW: Judge I am not going to go through CM subs saying "disagree, disagree", you have the evidence.

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:04

TT
BW: I say "not perfect". Much is made of the appeal. C's evidence was clear I say - she had lost all confidence. I don't criticise her for that, but it creates a circular problem. C wants vindication for 2021-22 - that was not in the gift of the R at that time re the complaint / grievance.
BW: SO where are we. This is a factually complex case, but in some ways it is more straightforward. The thing to do is look at the reasonableness of what R1 did at the time.
BW: Was it reasonable to i/x SH complaint, considered at the time? I say yes. And so on for other events.

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:03

BettyBooper · 23/10/2026 11:03

It's just soooo complex 🙄

And yet CM is no doubt going to prove how simple it all was!!

BettyBooper · 23/10/2026 11:03

It's just soooo complex 🙄

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:02

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:01

(is he trying to bore the judge into submission?)

Well I'd drifted and clicked on a trending thread so if it has the same effect on the judge then job done for BW!

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 23/10/2026 11:02

HydrangeaFig · 23/10/2026 10:47

Is AD attending the tribunal in paid time or using his annual leave?

An FoI request to his employers Medway & Kent ICB should get the answer but as he is a respondent I think they have to give him time off in any case. Whether that is paid or not would depend on the employer's policy.

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:01

(is he trying to bore the judge into submission?)

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:01

TT
BW: Only way to sort that out would be a mediation type investigation, but at the time it was not what happened, hindsight again
BW: So the TNIB mtg. C argues that SH caused what was said. But, it was not SH that said it. Hindsight is imported again - says the speaker shd have been shut down. In an ideal world possibly - but in context, it could not be.
BW: The Chair found an unprecedented state of affairs, not clear what to do. She quite properly told the C shortly after.
BW: What's important is how R handled C's complaint about it (and yes no need to wait for complaint). I am not saying R's response to the complaint was perfect, but, don't accept that C can link everything back in that way.

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 10:58

TT
BW: SH was of course there, but is not the "missing piece of the jigsaw" C claims. BW: MLF says the period between was limbo, uncertain state etc - I disagree. It was a state of resolution, agreement to leave things be.
BW: The whole point of resolution of that kind is to let everyone get on with doing their job. Now the C says she was fearful - but nothing was said at the time.
BW: What C is seeking seems to be complete vindication re what happened in 2021-22. She believes she was right, and wronged by SH; SH believes to be in the right, and wronged by the C.

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 10:56

I'm currently imagining him spending half an hour, using this style of argument, explaining to his wife why he hasn't loaded the dishwasher and it's all her fault!

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 10:56

TT
BW: No, since then - with the benefit of hindsight again - the C says that the incident at the TNIB in 2023 was linked back.
BW: The workshop at the end of the year dealt with the final outstanding issues. C did not complain at the time eg that reputation not repaired, but, Dr Flynn was entirely clear that things had been cleared up.
BW: [reference to a legal argument]
BW: There is a significant time gap - problem for C - months and months when AD does nothing to upset C, nothing happens. Then the regrettable incident at the TNIB mtg, and C says, well that absolutely is linked in every way to what went before, bcs SH there.

Hedgehogforshort · 23/10/2026 10:52

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 10:50

TT
BW: Advocates do shape argument of course - but, the picture that C's case advances is that C had made complaints re SH - but, must be noted that SH had been cleared. The fundamentals - that SH not acting properly - were not upheld.
BW: The C's case is asking you judge to look behind the Rs action - but that is hindsight. Were C's complaints re SH well founded? Yes but nobody knew that till reported on later.

Well I would have thought it is R,s job to know

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 10:52

TT
BW: The key to this chapter - pre complaint - is how it came to an end. What we know is, that the external i/x commissioned was not fit for purpose. But the Rs have taken ownership of that - acknowledged the problem, ran another i/x into it, it was resolved.
BW: C says, it was not resolved, things hung over her. But, that is the nature of resolution - not everyone is happy with every aspect. In July 2022 it was resolved; the complaint by SH would not be revisited.

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 10:50

TT
BW: Advocates do shape argument of course - but, the picture that C's case advances is that C had made complaints re SH - but, must be noted that SH had been cleared. The fundamentals - that SH not acting properly - were not upheld.
BW: The C's case is asking you judge to look behind the Rs action - but that is hindsight. Were C's complaints re SH well founded? Yes but nobody knew that till reported on later.

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 23/10/2026 10:49

HydrangeaFig · 23/10/2026 10:47

Is AD attending the tribunal in paid time or using his annual leave?

Well I'm gonna guess he won't be expected to waste his annual leave on such a trivial matter.

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 10:48

TT
BW: p73-74 of CM subs - CM says, complaint shd not have been i/xd. That is hindsight. And, remind yuo that C's own evidence given here was that i/x-ing was appropriate.
BW: C's case is that Rs are responsible for how it was i/x'd. But I put it that MLF is trying to reshape matters (para 151) - saying that even though C agreed i/x was appropriate, it was not. MLF claiming Rs aware of things they were not.

HydrangeaFig · 23/10/2026 10:47

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 23/10/2026 10:45

Sooooo busy...
Sooooo important....

And so fucking well paid. People like AD should be willing and able to account for their time and decisions in any senior role.

Is AD attending the tribunal in paid time or using his annual leave?

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 10:47

.

Ew Wtf GIF by CBC
BettyBooper · 23/10/2026 10:45

nauticant · 23/10/2026 10:42

I also wonder if BW is going on and on about this in order to save AD by making the judge hesitate in saying he was dishonest in his conduct and evidence in the judgment. Not to win the case overall but to get something of considerable value for AD.

Agree. It does seem like damage limitation rather than a full-on 'we were right' defence.

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 23/10/2026 10:45

Sooooo busy...
Sooooo important....

And so fucking well paid. People like AD should be willing and able to account for their time and decisions in any senior role.

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 10:45

TT
BW: This is the C looking back from here, building a picture of history of relationship; that's an overstatement of things even from here.
BW: Will consider 3 periods, the first one being pre-SH-complaint. MLF says C's referrals were professional and proper - that again is import of hindsight, using the later report PSIR into WellBN. C says, proves me right - but that is hindsight, and cannot mean that at the time
BW: ... the Rs should have ignored SH complaint.