Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Redvers v NHS Sussex Integrated Care Board & Mr Adam Doyle Thread 3

567 replies

fanOfBen · 21/10/2026 19:34

TT summary:

Dr Redvers, a named GP safeguarding lead, has a constructive dismissal case. Clinical concerns were raised about a specific doctor at WellBN, a Brighton GP practice. She claims that as a result of escalating those claims from 2020 onwards, she was constructively dismissed.

Her legal claim is discrimination on the grounds of her employer’s perception she had gender critical beliefs and on the grounds of her protected belief in evidence-based medicine (EBM). The respondent defends the latter claim by pleading that EBM is just an opinion.

Earlier coverage of this hearing can be found on TT's Substack at:
t.co/TwXeLCDnpt

TT report what they hear in good faith but do not provide a verbatim transcript of the hearing.

TT's list of abbreviations:

J - Judge Katherine Andrews (sitting alone)
DR/C - Doctor Sarah Redvers, claimant
CM/RB - Chris Milsom, claimant barrister
CE/RB - Charlotte Elves, Claimant Barrister
PD - Peter Daly, solicitor for the C

NHSSICB/R1 - NHS Sussex Integrated Care Board, first respondent
AD/R2 - Adam Doyle, second respondent, CEO of R1 2019-2025
Rs - collectively the respondents
RB/BW - Ben Williams, Respondent's barrister
EBM - Evidence-based medicine
SG - Safeguarding

WB - WellBN, Brighton based GP practice
GC - Gender Critical or sex realist beliefs
GI - Gender Identity belief
WS - Witness Statement
Ix - investigation
Gx - grievance
Cx - complaint

SH/DSH - Dr Sam Hall, GP at WellBN, Trustee - the Clare Project (TCP), Clinical Lead - Trans Health Hub, GIC Partner - Trans Health Improvement Board at R1, trans-identified female
DA - Dusty Amroliwala, ext consultant, investigated complaint filed by DSH against C
LB - Lola Banjoko, Exec Managing Director, chair of Trans Health Improvement Board, advised R1 on trans matters
NC - Nikky Cambridge, former trustee of TCP

AC - Allison Cannon, Chief Nursing Officer, R1, tasked w implementing the recommendations of the 1st grievance outcome
CCD - Dr Claire Cochrane-Dyet, Dep Medical Director for System Improvement & Professional Standards, NHSE, commissioned Warshafsky Report
HD - Dr Hannah Davies, Deputy Chief Medical Office, R1

SD - Samantha Durrant, Lay vice chair until July 2022, 1st grievance manager
NE - Naomi Ellis, dep director of Safeguarding, R1
MF - Dr Mary Flynn, Named GP for Safeguarding, also filed g/x in relation to Amroliwala Report
PF - Pennie Ford, Executive Managing Director, R1, 2nd grievance manager

EG - Dr Elizabeth Gill, Chief Medical Officer, R1
HH - Hannah Hamilton, Chief financial officer, R1, 2nd grievance appeal manager
BJ - Dr Becky Jarvis, clinical lead for mental health, R1
TM - Tom Micklewright, managing partner of Lime Tree Surgery

IM - Ian Mundy, HR Consultant, Your Consultancy, 1st grievance investigator
MP - Mark Power, interim Chief People Officer (until April 2022), R1, managed Amroliwala investigation
RR - Dr Rebecca Richards, GP partner, Lime Tree Surgery, raised concerns to C about SH
AR - Anne Robson, Interim Chief People Officer (April -August 2022), R1

DS - Dr Dinesh Sinha, Chief Medical Officer (June 2022 - April 2024), Chair of Trans Health Improvement Board (THIB)
MS - Mark Smith, Chief People Officer, R1 (Aug 2022 - Jan 2025) Acting CEO (Jan 2025 - June 2025) Deputy CEO & Director of Transition (June 2025 - present)
RW - Dr Robin Warshafsky, GP NHSE, Author of Warshafsky Report (WR)

Thread 1:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5586672-wellbn-brighton-gp-practice-do-not-believe-in-evidence-based-medicine-tt-at-employment-tribunal-tomorrow

Thread 2:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5588924-redvers-v-nhs-sussex-integrated-care-board-mr-adam-doyle-thread-2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:43

TT
The bastard or incompetence defence of Anya must be demonstarted. DA gave her an interrogation. Re dishonesty: Miss Durrant finds dishonesty by DA. Re concerns by other professionals - dishonesty was only part of it. Was a chilling effect by Ix yet it continued

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:42

TT
WAs enough in NHSE to conclude there was a protected act - belief in one is sufficient. She said they had substandard treatment as were T identifying - see Cass and PSIR. I dont know how he can say spiking wasnt accurate by NHSE

CM A responsible CEO wld want to find out the facts but he did nothing until July suggesting he didnt see them as serious. Para 101: MLF says [reads re ToR] but ToR say he did. Para 102: the R lapsed into tautology re proper motivation - we say was no personal animosity betwn DSH and C

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:40

Or worse it's an abandoned tissue

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:39

There's a crumpled up piece of paper on the floor under the desk by CM's feet and it's annoying me.

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:39

TT
CM Para 50 onwards - all allegations other than ? lie at both Rs. He's the CEO and painting in brushstrokes and he installed Sinha that impacted . Para 57-8: J I'm just checking list of issues CM All except Gx is at both Rs doors.
CM We dont understand what MLF suggests that as AD not acting at personal, he's not responsible. There has to be ostensible authority throughout. Re the protected act: y'll see the Cx saying best to view as harassment, and say the breadth od test, is also related to a PC

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 23/10/2026 11:37

that lie may have remained on records

Oh excellent, no dancing about trying to avoid calling a lie a lie.

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:37

CM is a definitely more interesting to listen to than BW

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:36

TT
How was long mtg set up? etc. We dont put mentoring centre stage - it is odd why Rs do. And to suggest is ADs credibility re WS 4! Said wasnt access to diary - he was asked for all contact and not just mentoring.

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:35

CM calling out BWs claim that Wednesdays debacle was a sign of Doyle's credibility

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:35

TT
On mentoring he protests too much. In a WS of 120 p it occupies 4 lines only. Its the R who put the mentoring centre stage and continue to do in writing. What is the urge of The Rs to keep digging here. No apology or retraction about her not believing re their first interaction

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 23/10/2026 11:34

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 10:41

It was the "Ah ha" that finished me off!

Me to, I am only reading it but now I've got an indelible impression of a Victorian chap with side whiskers wombling on and proclaiming Rumpole-ishly, but a lot more crap than Rumpole.

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:33

Glad he's calling out AD lies

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:33

Mentoring...

"Me thinks the respondent's doth protest too much"

Love CM!

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:33

TT
CM He accepted Nortons 7 but rejected all in his evidence, including ? The incompatibe statements linger on central matters and not clarified or rectified. Its clear the evid wasnt honest - when 1st contact w DSH / 1st receiving PBs and CSH

July 22 mtg - failing to tell her he's been driving attempts against her w GMC> This contrast w his behav w her shows this. The Rs baseless suggestion its a contrived case is unworthy of MLF. Then disclosure:

MLF says the central point is when Cx comes in. When did we get the email re this? On day 1 of trial at 6pm. The paramaters were set by the trib and the Rs repeatedly said unnecces and too much but time and again docs have arrived

A fundamentla and proposterate lie in WS 4. Said no prior contact at all and he was sat in here while she was called a fantasist. He said he'd checked his email etc. We may never know what led to Weds deabcle - that lie may have remained on records w/out 4th order

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:31

"Fundamental and preposterous lie"

ETA again he's on about Adam Doyle!

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:29

TT
CM It helps us under stand whats happening. Why the ICB so far from basic standard care. whether a fear of backlash or ? ideology at heart of whats happening. MLF said left to subs to address the Cs beleif. Said lacked cogency until now but central to Cs profession. Cannot leave hanging in the air and then say not going to vhallenge on day 10

CM Re demonstrating allyship - may be vid relevent here but isnt detertative. Is an assertion that C is contriving a discrim case - matters crafted legally rather than what happening at the time. If suggested C doesnt believe her case is rejected.

CM She believes it to be true. She's correct on facts and law. Are sev attempts to impune Cs cred as a witness which go nowhere. She was a paradigm witness. Only followed the evid trail. Her evid demonstrate her beliefs in action - only follow the evid. ADs evid only covered his abilities

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:28

"Believed in little other than his own abilities."

Who is CM describing?

Of course it's Adam Doyle!!

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:23

TT
CM They were trated v differentently - a witchhunt that was shared w regs and prob WBM but prob not her. The Rs spike the GMC proceedings and patient X operate as a protection racket. No other way to look at the evidence. This disparity also in Aug 23. DSH fires at weel. The employer is expected to put up w it. The Cs beliefs [missed] Emperical reality may disapper into the ether. The Q of weather the Cx is well founded. A PC can be grounded in reality. [discussion of manifesting a protected beleif]

Kirschcherries · 23/10/2026 11:21

BW is right that SHs complaint/grievance should be investigated. All complaints/grievances should be considered even if unfounded. That’s the whole point of having a grievance procedure.

it’s a regular feature of complaints, performance management etc. that the person(s) complained about lodge a grievance often bullying and harassment and/or discrimination. In this case the C lodged a safeguarding referral and SH retaliated with a complaint/grievance.

The issue for the C is that she was labelled as transphobic in a meeting she wasn’t present at. The transphobic slur was minuted and came from the initial whistleblowing/safeguarding because R had not dealt with that correctly. BW is trying to use the gap between the initial safeguarding and the meeting to time limit what is actually part of the timeline for constructive dismissal.

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:21

TT
CM DAs report p1270: reads re quotes indictating beliefs. Its outrageous to suggest has an underlying motive... CM Now addressing the R: para 6 and 129 of subs of MLF: they advance posn of a polarised debate w equal legitimacy. There are a range of legit GC views
CM The C says GI belief may be protected and DSHs views of consent. But isnt the same that vaalues are of equal worth. The C was employed by R and put pat safety front and centre, based on basic precept of Western Medicine. The dr was well outside service specification

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:17

TT
CM I have 3 matters including distilling this case with 7 propositions of law. Our amendments to subs: para 300 o p115 - we withdraw. p340 explains why end of para can be withdrawn starting email from LEA
CM p125: Conrathe was the solic rather than parent. para 416 p170: isnt an exhaustive account re a PC. Want to add ToR referring to irreg or improper - relating to 16 Aug mtg and the original Cx. The mtg w AD in 2022 re speaking to motives of complainant

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:14

TT
CM: So our appendix 2 sets out the position throughout on children whihch didn't change; and then afterwards the position re adults, which did
J: But BW does not agree it?
BW: I will take instructions on that.
J: OK - Mr Milsom [new thread will be started now]

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 11:14

Judge finished asking questions

CM up now

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:13

TT
J: So compare your appendix 2 with the PSIR and work it out?
CM: Not exactly - the point is only that at no point, outside a GIDS clinic, could a GP prescribe to under 18s. Mr Doyle admitted this. Set out in App2.
J: In my judgment I need to give context and background, so I was looking for an agreed document on the medical and regulatory matters.

StSpiridian · 23/10/2026 11:11

TT
J: One question - I asked for joint legal args where you agree. CM has put much law, do I understand you agree with that? BW: No Judge - see my subs [is looking for ref]
J: My intention was to get a factual account of events also eg Cass Review dates?
CM: My appendix 2 - re under 18s.
J: If I have to piece together every fact, it's almost inevitable I will make mistakes because I'm not a medic.
CM: I did ask what of my app2 was disputed, but have not had an answer.
BW: [refs to his own subs where he disagrees] I think we all agree this important doc does set out legal and regulatory framework - it's an external document so not 'argued' by either of us.

Swipe left for the next trending thread