Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Redvers v NHS Sussex Integrated Care Board & Mr Adam Doyle Thread 3

567 replies

fanOfBen · 21/10/2026 19:34

TT summary:

Dr Redvers, a named GP safeguarding lead, has a constructive dismissal case. Clinical concerns were raised about a specific doctor at WellBN, a Brighton GP practice. She claims that as a result of escalating those claims from 2020 onwards, she was constructively dismissed.

Her legal claim is discrimination on the grounds of her employer’s perception she had gender critical beliefs and on the grounds of her protected belief in evidence-based medicine (EBM). The respondent defends the latter claim by pleading that EBM is just an opinion.

Earlier coverage of this hearing can be found on TT's Substack at:
t.co/TwXeLCDnpt

TT report what they hear in good faith but do not provide a verbatim transcript of the hearing.

TT's list of abbreviations:

J - Judge Katherine Andrews (sitting alone)
DR/C - Doctor Sarah Redvers, claimant
CM/RB - Chris Milsom, claimant barrister
CE/RB - Charlotte Elves, Claimant Barrister
PD - Peter Daly, solicitor for the C

NHSSICB/R1 - NHS Sussex Integrated Care Board, first respondent
AD/R2 - Adam Doyle, second respondent, CEO of R1 2019-2025
Rs - collectively the respondents
RB/BW - Ben Williams, Respondent's barrister
EBM - Evidence-based medicine
SG - Safeguarding

WB - WellBN, Brighton based GP practice
GC - Gender Critical or sex realist beliefs
GI - Gender Identity belief
WS - Witness Statement
Ix - investigation
Gx - grievance
Cx - complaint

SH/DSH - Dr Sam Hall, GP at WellBN, Trustee - the Clare Project (TCP), Clinical Lead - Trans Health Hub, GIC Partner - Trans Health Improvement Board at R1, trans-identified female
DA - Dusty Amroliwala, ext consultant, investigated complaint filed by DSH against C
LB - Lola Banjoko, Exec Managing Director, chair of Trans Health Improvement Board, advised R1 on trans matters
NC - Nikky Cambridge, former trustee of TCP

AC - Allison Cannon, Chief Nursing Officer, R1, tasked w implementing the recommendations of the 1st grievance outcome
CCD - Dr Claire Cochrane-Dyet, Dep Medical Director for System Improvement & Professional Standards, NHSE, commissioned Warshafsky Report
HD - Dr Hannah Davies, Deputy Chief Medical Office, R1

SD - Samantha Durrant, Lay vice chair until July 2022, 1st grievance manager
NE - Naomi Ellis, dep director of Safeguarding, R1
MF - Dr Mary Flynn, Named GP for Safeguarding, also filed g/x in relation to Amroliwala Report
PF - Pennie Ford, Executive Managing Director, R1, 2nd grievance manager

EG - Dr Elizabeth Gill, Chief Medical Officer, R1
HH - Hannah Hamilton, Chief financial officer, R1, 2nd grievance appeal manager
BJ - Dr Becky Jarvis, clinical lead for mental health, R1
TM - Tom Micklewright, managing partner of Lime Tree Surgery

IM - Ian Mundy, HR Consultant, Your Consultancy, 1st grievance investigator
MP - Mark Power, interim Chief People Officer (until April 2022), R1, managed Amroliwala investigation
RR - Dr Rebecca Richards, GP partner, Lime Tree Surgery, raised concerns to C about SH
AR - Anne Robson, Interim Chief People Officer (April -August 2022), R1

DS - Dr Dinesh Sinha, Chief Medical Officer (June 2022 - April 2024), Chair of Trans Health Improvement Board (THIB)
MS - Mark Smith, Chief People Officer, R1 (Aug 2022 - Jan 2025) Acting CEO (Jan 2025 - June 2025) Deputy CEO & Director of Transition (June 2025 - present)
RW - Dr Robin Warshafsky, GP NHSE, Author of Warshafsky Report (WR)

Thread 1:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5586672-wellbn-brighton-gp-practice-do-not-believe-in-evidence-based-medicine-tt-at-employment-tribunal-tomorrow

Thread 2:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5588924-redvers-v-nhs-sussex-integrated-care-board-mr-adam-doyle-thread-2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
MrsOvertonsWindow · 24/10/2026 07:14

Excellent post @ArabellaScott .

I'd add that it also targeted the youngest and most vulnerable in society - especially those who have yet to develop the critical insight and life skills needed to resist such a pernicious ideology.
I will always beleve that was deliberate.

ArabellaScott · 24/10/2026 07:08

With its opaque lore, arbitrary rules, hierarchy of self declared moral arbiter and quasi religious structures, 'genderism' has been a very useful tool/vehicle for those willing to make the most absurd and bad faith declarations.

It has offered a route to power for the least skilled, least humane, most venal and most vicious, and in the process terribly undermined every institution and the whole fabric of democratic society.

I very much hope its on the way out.

ArabellaScott · 24/10/2026 07:04

Of course the loss of womens rights and the harming of vulnerable children are huge scandals, but they have not even been the main aim of 'gender ideology's most powerful proponents. Their only aim was only ever power.

ArabellaScott · 24/10/2026 07:02

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

AD and his enabling is certainly a large part of it.

The case also reveals though how 'trans' was and is used as a tool of control, manipulation, and abuse. Children have been irrevocably harmed by this pernicious bullshit, and the people who harmed them protected and enabled by a culture that has seen the doublethink and power dynamic as an opportunity.

Just as 'trans' damaged Sturgeon and the Scottish government, it has been abaorbed into the NHS at the very highest levels.

The ideology is useful to authoritarians, because it relies on abuse of power, fear, and lies, and anyone can therefore access and use it if they are ruthless enough.

MyAmpleSheep · 24/10/2026 01:14

I suspect that a belief in this academic and scholarly meaning of EBM at its most specific isn’t entirely what this case was about.

HydrangeaFig · 24/10/2026 00:20

Hedgehogforshort · 23/10/2026 23:23

Erm so what you appear to be saying is that the NHS should provide treatments based on no evidence of positive outcomes whatsoever, is that what you are saying?

No not at all. The concept of EBM has been around for about 30 years. But before that the NHS still provided treatments based on evidence of positive outcomes - I think when I posted previously I used the example of how people had transplants and test-tube babies before EBM. And infections were treated with antibiotics, etc. There were randomised controlled trials of treatments and drugs. There are valid criticisms of EBM and its reliance on systematic reviews and lots of people who are explaining the criticisms much better than I can if you search for critique of EBM. Here for example is a critique from a feminist viewpoint https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1089/whr.2022.0032 (I have only read the abstract).

Hedgehogforshort · 23/10/2026 23:47

okay I will go first. If indeed this is you Sarah hello.

tell us more then, now your are free to do so.

it is a trans issue as regards trying to protect children from being affirmed.

YourWarmKhakiUser · 23/10/2026 23:41

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

YourWarmKhakiUser · 23/10/2026 23:37

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn by MNHQ

YourWarmKhakiUser · 23/10/2026 23:33

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Hedgehogforshort · 23/10/2026 23:26

Ramblingnamechanger · 23/10/2026 23:23

I was truly astonished by the report on the 6pm and 10 pm news. We have been getting such gaslighting rubbish for so long I could hardly believe what I was hearing. The bit about a medical scandal was very good. We know that but for the watchers at large it must have been quite shocking.

Well we will see but maybe the BBC are looking at retrieving their credibility in the neck of the woods of genderism and the harms done, as a way of climbing away from pop reporting

Hedgehogforshort · 23/10/2026 23:23

HydrangeaFig · 23/10/2026 23:18

It goes back to the beginning of the thread when everyone was shocked because the Respondent was denying that Dr Redver's belief in evidence based medicine was a protected belief. I think the Respondent conceded that point early on, although I am still a bit confused about all the twists and turns, so it is academic now. But I wasn't quite as shocked as everyone else (except for the interloper who was more of my way of thinking - oh dear). I think there are valid criticisms to be made of evidence based medicine. Also, even if something is generally seen as good, it doesn't, depending on the circumstances, qualify as a protected belief - in a recent case a belief in social and environmental justice was rejected, although that was because the Respondent successfully argued that the Claimant did not live up to her own standards.

Erm so what you appear to be saying is that the NHS should provide treatments based on no evidence of positive outcomes whatsoever, is that what you are saying?

Ramblingnamechanger · 23/10/2026 23:23

I was truly astonished by the report on the 6pm and 10 pm news. We have been getting such gaslighting rubbish for so long I could hardly believe what I was hearing. The bit about a medical scandal was very good. We know that but for the watchers at large it must have been quite shocking.

MyAmpleSheep · 23/10/2026 23:21

HydrangeaFig · 23/10/2026 23:18

It goes back to the beginning of the thread when everyone was shocked because the Respondent was denying that Dr Redver's belief in evidence based medicine was a protected belief. I think the Respondent conceded that point early on, although I am still a bit confused about all the twists and turns, so it is academic now. But I wasn't quite as shocked as everyone else (except for the interloper who was more of my way of thinking - oh dear). I think there are valid criticisms to be made of evidence based medicine. Also, even if something is generally seen as good, it doesn't, depending on the circumstances, qualify as a protected belief - in a recent case a belief in social and environmental justice was rejected, although that was because the Respondent successfully argued that the Claimant did not live up to her own standards.

I can see the ET rejecting the idea of EBM as a "belief", and it going to the EAT. I can't see the EAT rejecting it.

YourWarmKhakiUser · 23/10/2026 23:20

Hedgehogforshort · 23/10/2026 21:59

I am unsure what you mean by “i may not share DR R belief in EBM”

Can you explain please.

Evidence based medicine

HydrangeaFig · 23/10/2026 23:18

Hedgehogforshort · 23/10/2026 21:59

I am unsure what you mean by “i may not share DR R belief in EBM”

Can you explain please.

It goes back to the beginning of the thread when everyone was shocked because the Respondent was denying that Dr Redver's belief in evidence based medicine was a protected belief. I think the Respondent conceded that point early on, although I am still a bit confused about all the twists and turns, so it is academic now. But I wasn't quite as shocked as everyone else (except for the interloper who was more of my way of thinking - oh dear). I think there are valid criticisms to be made of evidence based medicine. Also, even if something is generally seen as good, it doesn't, depending on the circumstances, qualify as a protected belief - in a recent case a belief in social and environmental justice was rejected, although that was because the Respondent successfully argued that the Claimant did not live up to her own standards.

musicalfrog · 23/10/2026 23:11

My god!

Sorry not followed this story before now but having just read the report on the bbc it seems huge.

And also huge, the article itself used clear language!

I'm gobsmacked tbh.

nauticant · 23/10/2026 23:05

I realise it's a positive but we're looking at a BBC report and marvelling that it's a reasonably decent attempt to give a factually correct account of a court case. Because we'd become so used to the BBC spreading disinformation in order to mislead the public when the truth would be ideologically inconvenient.

KnownTroublemaker · 23/10/2026 22:53

ArabellaScott · 23/10/2026 22:42

I think often these cases are better reported on substantially once concluded.

Not everyone follows the live courtroom dramas!

And reading that balanced, factual, and thorough BBC report is ... astonishing.

The bare facts laid out are thoroughly informative.

The case laid out so clearly in this BBC article is to me, staggering. In a good way!

ArabellaScott · 23/10/2026 22:42

lcakethereforeIam · 23/10/2026 21:39

I missed it! It's probably on catch up somewhere. I admit I've been disappointed by the lack of coverage this ET had been getting. It was just a local rag, it seemed, that had published anything about it. I'm pretty gobsmacked that the Beeb has reported on it!!

I think often these cases are better reported on substantially once concluded.

Not everyone follows the live courtroom dramas!

And reading that balanced, factual, and thorough BBC report is ... astonishing.

The bare facts laid out are thoroughly informative.

ArabellaScott · 23/10/2026 22:40

Just dropping an archived BBC article in case anyone sanitises it.

https://archive.ph/ag1X1

Boiledbeetle · 23/10/2026 22:35

impossibletoday · 23/10/2026 21:00

I rather enjoyed this bit:

Although Doyle at first denied to the tribunal he knew Hall before this, it emerged during the tribunal that he had previously had a number of mentoring meetings with the GP.

Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!

MarthaBeach · 23/10/2026 22:35

LesLavandes · 23/10/2026 18:49

Wellbn is just on border of Brighton and Hove. I am a heterosexual patient there. I have been following this thread. Am gobsmacked

This practice has caused issues for local mental health services, as patients register there even though they live miles away, because the GP practice are pro-trans and prescribe hormone therapy. Then as they're registered with a Brighton GP, any other mental health issues they might have need to be treated by local MH services despite them not living in the area.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 23/10/2026 22:26

CriticalCondition · 23/10/2026 22:21

On BBC News at Ten now.

Pleased to see this still on the BBC news and a pleasing change to their previous "trans sacred caste that can never be challenged" approach.

Small steps but so important - especially when reporting on child abuse.

CriticalCondition · 23/10/2026 22:21

On BBC News at Ten now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread