Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Redvers v NHS Sussex Integrated Care Board & Mr Adam Doyle Thread 3

567 replies

fanOfBen · 21/10/2026 19:34

TT summary:

Dr Redvers, a named GP safeguarding lead, has a constructive dismissal case. Clinical concerns were raised about a specific doctor at WellBN, a Brighton GP practice. She claims that as a result of escalating those claims from 2020 onwards, she was constructively dismissed.

Her legal claim is discrimination on the grounds of her employer’s perception she had gender critical beliefs and on the grounds of her protected belief in evidence-based medicine (EBM). The respondent defends the latter claim by pleading that EBM is just an opinion.

Earlier coverage of this hearing can be found on TT's Substack at:
t.co/TwXeLCDnpt

TT report what they hear in good faith but do not provide a verbatim transcript of the hearing.

TT's list of abbreviations:

J - Judge Katherine Andrews (sitting alone)
DR/C - Doctor Sarah Redvers, claimant
CM/RB - Chris Milsom, claimant barrister
CE/RB - Charlotte Elves, Claimant Barrister
PD - Peter Daly, solicitor for the C

NHSSICB/R1 - NHS Sussex Integrated Care Board, first respondent
AD/R2 - Adam Doyle, second respondent, CEO of R1 2019-2025
Rs - collectively the respondents
RB/BW - Ben Williams, Respondent's barrister
EBM - Evidence-based medicine
SG - Safeguarding

WB - WellBN, Brighton based GP practice
GC - Gender Critical or sex realist beliefs
GI - Gender Identity belief
WS - Witness Statement
Ix - investigation
Gx - grievance
Cx - complaint

SH/DSH - Dr Sam Hall, GP at WellBN, Trustee - the Clare Project (TCP), Clinical Lead - Trans Health Hub, GIC Partner - Trans Health Improvement Board at R1, trans-identified female
DA - Dusty Amroliwala, ext consultant, investigated complaint filed by DSH against C
LB - Lola Banjoko, Exec Managing Director, chair of Trans Health Improvement Board, advised R1 on trans matters
NC - Nikky Cambridge, former trustee of TCP

AC - Allison Cannon, Chief Nursing Officer, R1, tasked w implementing the recommendations of the 1st grievance outcome
CCD - Dr Claire Cochrane-Dyet, Dep Medical Director for System Improvement & Professional Standards, NHSE, commissioned Warshafsky Report
HD - Dr Hannah Davies, Deputy Chief Medical Office, R1

SD - Samantha Durrant, Lay vice chair until July 2022, 1st grievance manager
NE - Naomi Ellis, dep director of Safeguarding, R1
MF - Dr Mary Flynn, Named GP for Safeguarding, also filed g/x in relation to Amroliwala Report
PF - Pennie Ford, Executive Managing Director, R1, 2nd grievance manager

EG - Dr Elizabeth Gill, Chief Medical Officer, R1
HH - Hannah Hamilton, Chief financial officer, R1, 2nd grievance appeal manager
BJ - Dr Becky Jarvis, clinical lead for mental health, R1
TM - Tom Micklewright, managing partner of Lime Tree Surgery

IM - Ian Mundy, HR Consultant, Your Consultancy, 1st grievance investigator
MP - Mark Power, interim Chief People Officer (until April 2022), R1, managed Amroliwala investigation
RR - Dr Rebecca Richards, GP partner, Lime Tree Surgery, raised concerns to C about SH
AR - Anne Robson, Interim Chief People Officer (April -August 2022), R1

DS - Dr Dinesh Sinha, Chief Medical Officer (June 2022 - April 2024), Chair of Trans Health Improvement Board (THIB)
MS - Mark Smith, Chief People Officer, R1 (Aug 2022 - Jan 2025) Acting CEO (Jan 2025 - June 2025) Deputy CEO & Director of Transition (June 2025 - present)
RW - Dr Robin Warshafsky, GP NHSE, Author of Warshafsky Report (WR)

Thread 1:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5586672-wellbn-brighton-gp-practice-do-not-believe-in-evidence-based-medicine-tt-at-employment-tribunal-tomorrow

Thread 2:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5588924-redvers-v-nhs-sussex-integrated-care-board-mr-adam-doyle-thread-2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
KeepupKardigans · 24/10/2026 14:28

Bias or not I found myself questioning BBC news coverage and interest programs being broadcast on contentious issues. I unconsciously switched to other news outlets for coverage. It was coverage and selection of interviewees on womens’/trans rights etc that highlighted to me the obvious bias and hidden agendas. Why did they have a ‘ GI rights desk’ that monitored/selected/influenced content.
We need to be able to trust our state broadcaster for factual unbiased reporting and biological sex reported as well as trans identities when reporting crime and public interest information. Clear plain BBC English used to be the norm and the viewing public are more than capable of making their own minds up.

Brainworm · 24/10/2026 12:01

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 24/10/2026 11:20

The BBC is losing viewers by the thousands every year, losing money, and laying off staff and cancelling whole channels or moving them back online because of this.

Someone at the BBC is clearly looking into possible causes for this, and perhaps has started to realize how detrimental the activism within the corporation has been overall.

Perhaps.

I’m not sure the decline in viewers is just because of their position on all things trans, but it fits into an overarching theme.

I think the majority of people want and expect neutrality within the BBC. Most will tolerate a standalone programme with an agenda when it’s presented as such and is not part of many programmes with the same agenda, even when they disagree with them. Agreeing with some programmes and not others points to neutrality.

In general programming, pitched as neutral, people object to ideological positions presented as universal truths or contested positions.

The challenge is, those who agree with the ideological position of a biased programme pitched as a neutral programme, tend to think that it is objective, because they are blind to their own biases.

With the BBC, I think there are some people who are consciously manipulative and pushing and agenda. Then there are people who agree with the agenda and are oblivious to the bias as a result.

singthing · 24/10/2026 12:00

MrsOvertonsWindow · 24/10/2026 07:14

Excellent post @ArabellaScott .

I'd add that it also targeted the youngest and most vulnerable in society - especially those who have yet to develop the critical insight and life skills needed to resist such a pernicious ideology.
I will always beleve that was deliberate.

As Glinner said way back in 2020: "You don't tell children that they were born in the wrong body, because they are children and they will believe you."

lcakethereforeIam · 24/10/2026 11:48

There is something that has changed at the Beeb. They had this article about Russell T Davies

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6wyvjeke0g4o

Obviously, he shouldn't be receiving abuse (yadda, yadda, it really should go without saying but here we are) and I started reading with a bit of an eyeroll but the article goes on with a relevant interview with Tonia Antonazzi who's quite fulsome about RTD while also being a counterweight.

I like to think this is an example of a way forward. Even how it should have been conducted all along by the BBC. It is a definite improvement although the bar is so low perhaps it's my expectations that should be raised?

Russell T Davies attending the 2024 BAFTA Cymru awards at the International Convention Centre Wales. Behind him is a sign that says BAFTA Cymru Awards. He is wearing a white shirt, black jacket and a red and dark blue tie. Davies has short brown hair a...

Trans rights support gets me daily abuse, says Doctor Who writer Russell T Davies

The Doctor Who writer says his latest mini-series TipToe has fuelled daily hate messages online.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6wyvjeke0g4o

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 24/10/2026 11:20

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 24/10/2026 09:09

They've clearly had a rethink on the style guide. 'Gender distressed' and 'gender questioning' children, not 'trans' ones; 'cross-sex hormones', not 'HRT'.

The BBC is losing viewers by the thousands every year, losing money, and laying off staff and cancelling whole channels or moving them back online because of this.

Someone at the BBC is clearly looking into possible causes for this, and perhaps has started to realize how detrimental the activism within the corporation has been overall.

Perhaps.

nauticant · 24/10/2026 10:48

DrBlackbird · 24/10/2026 09:55

I agree with @ThreeNewWords that in this case, EBM was significant because of its contrast to affirmative ‘care’ that excuses harming children, which was a sensible juxtaposition.

However, @HydrangeaFig is right in that there are reasonable criticisms about some of the limitations of EBM. For example, how it could disregard the social determinants of health approach vs a more biomedical model of EBM.

But in any case, and strictly speaking, I don’t see a direct comparison between it and GC/sex realist. There is always some scope for debates around contested evidence in the former, which calls subjective judgement into play. Whilst the latter is an objective fact.

It makes me wonder whether we're missing a Grainger criterion that relates to a belief permitting challenges against it, and not responding with aggression and/or cancellation. Although it might be there and hidden in WORIADS.

RunningforSam · 24/10/2026 10:39

Hedgehogforshort · 23/10/2026 23:23

Erm so what you appear to be saying is that the NHS should provide treatments based on no evidence of positive outcomes whatsoever, is that what you are saying?

A key issue is what constitutes a positive outcome.

Take someone who is living in squalor, rarely washing and dressing, rarely leaving the house, unemployed, isolated and lonely and distressed due to their sex and gender identity. They seek intervention to transition. They take cross sex hormones, delight in their softer skin and breast buds, leading to reduction in their ‘gender related distress’. This also results in increased washing and dressing, but nothing else changes.

  1. According to Sam Hall’s model, treatment has been successful.
  2. Some others might see this as a partially successful outcome, providing a better starting point from which to address other outcomes that must be sought for treatment to be deemed successful.
  3. Others might say that until the dysfunctional lifestyle issues improve and we have the patient engaging constructively in the world, we need to put ‘gender affirming’ physical intervention with significant and irreversible side effects on hold. Mental health intervention could be administered to address this.

Medical treatment focussing on trans activists’ myopic focus on ‘being who I really am’ and physical appearance contrast significantly to all other areas of medicine where outcomes are centred around health and activities of daily living. 16 years on from discovering this disparity, I am still blown away by the blindness so many have with regard for this.

I am all for EBM. What we need is an evidence base related to gender related treatment that goes a lot wider than patient self report about distress and mental health symptoms. Many patients I meet, covering all kinds of conditions, report all sorts of improvements and declines in subjective aspects of wellbeing. We use this as one type of indicator but look to much wider factors before concluding treatment has been effective.

DrBlackbird · 24/10/2026 09:55

I agree with @ThreeNewWords that in this case, EBM was significant because of its contrast to affirmative ‘care’ that excuses harming children, which was a sensible juxtaposition.

However, @HydrangeaFig is right in that there are reasonable criticisms about some of the limitations of EBM. For example, how it could disregard the social determinants of health approach vs a more biomedical model of EBM.

But in any case, and strictly speaking, I don’t see a direct comparison between it and GC/sex realist. There is always some scope for debates around contested evidence in the former, which calls subjective judgement into play. Whilst the latter is an objective fact.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 24/10/2026 09:52

I am waiting for a full BBC documentary on the WellBN scandal.

AlmostAnUnderAchiever · 24/10/2026 09:41

The Telegraph has done a lot of good work here. Maybe the mainstream news will have to actually give facts.

From the horse's mouth:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwjdmy20yjmno

borntobequiet · 24/10/2026 09:28

I think I will commend the BBC for once. God knows I’ve made enough complaints.

ProfDrLapwing · 24/10/2026 09:16

nauticant · 23/10/2026 23:05

I realise it's a positive but we're looking at a BBC report and marvelling that it's a reasonably decent attempt to give a factually correct account of a court case. Because we'd become so used to the BBC spreading disinformation in order to mislead the public when the truth would be ideologically inconvenient.

This absolutely bears repeating.

It’s nothing more than an account of what came to light during the tribunal. That we find honest reporting, or any reporting at all, remarkable speaks volumes about how partisan organisations have become.

Helleofabore · 24/10/2026 09:10

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 24/10/2026 09:09

They've clearly had a rethink on the style guide. 'Gender distressed' and 'gender questioning' children, not 'trans' ones; 'cross-sex hormones', not 'HRT'.

The language choices were noticeable.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 24/10/2026 09:10

And it's very good that they highlighted the lack of face-to-face assessments and the prescribing to pre-teens.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 24/10/2026 09:09

They've clearly had a rethink on the style guide. 'Gender distressed' and 'gender questioning' children, not 'trans' ones; 'cross-sex hormones', not 'HRT'.

Helleofabore · 24/10/2026 08:58

Here is a snipped video on twitter if anyone wants to see the report and interview

https://x.com/zeno001/status/2113703934762074571?s=46

It was nice to see no mention of people having ‘anti-trans’ views and for Sarah to have her position presented as the safeguarding failure it was. That she couldn’t do her job properly because safeguarding around this issue was failing but so too was the measures that were meant to strengthen the process.

Alan Henness (@zeno001) on X

Dr Sarah Redvers on @BBCNews this evening about her constructive dismissal employment tribunal case against (what is now) @NHSSurreySussex involving @brightwellbeing over ignored child safeguarding concerns:

https://x.com/zeno001/status/2113703934762074571?s=46

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 24/10/2026 08:54

ThreeNewWords · 24/10/2026 07:30

@HydrangeaFig Yes, the case wasn't related to this more formalised concept of EBM. The actual concept of EBM in play is given by the competing model of healthcare cited in the case, namely 'affirmative care', which positions any kind of medical assessment (i.e. evidence-seeking) before prescribing PBs and cross-sex hormones as 'gate-keeping'.

When I first heard that 'evidence based medicine" was being cited as a philosophical belief for the purposes of the Equality Act I found it hard to understand, since it it is just the absolute basic commonsense framework for medical competance.

But beliefs like this, that are so fundamentally accurate as to be almost invisible, spring into salience precisely when they are challenged.

The condition for 'gender crtitical beliefs' (i.e. noticing the existence of sex and its implications) to be defined as a philosphical belief was the arrival of an ideology that contradicted it. Similarly, the condition for the most basic and unformalised concept of evidence-based medicine to be defined as a philosphical belief was the arrival of the ideology of 'affirmative care', which steals from EBM the concept of 'informed consent' (intended as the final stage of legitimising a treatment after appropriate evidence for it has been obtained) and makes it the whole basis for prescribing.

Yes, as with 'gender critical belief' the court use of the term applies to a subset of the whole concept. It picks out a key part that is the hardest to argue with.

Useful to legal cases, but less so for those who want to discuss the finer details of the original concept and contrast 'gender critical'with 'sex realist ' or 'evidence based.medicine' with other forms of 'medicine based on some sort of evidence or scientific principle'.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 24/10/2026 08:42

ArabellaScott · 23/10/2026 22:40

Just dropping an archived BBC article in case anyone sanitises it.

https://archive.ph/ag1X1

Thanks for the archive. I agree with @nauticant that it's disturbing that we are so "grateful" for the crumbs of truth that the BBC has started to sprinkle into their reports. It really does show how bad they have become that we appreciate any amount of truth! It's shameful, really, that they allowed themselves to sink so low. I, for one, stopped trusting the BBC years ago, and am not likely to get that trust back, no matter what they say now.

I note they are still using wrong-sex pronouns for Hall.

BlueLegume · 24/10/2026 08:28

Great piece by the BBC. Hard to argue this at all however you view ‘gender’.

Toxicity in the NHS. Hard to argue otherwise.
Children being treated - massive red flag particularly as the Tavistock had closed under a cloud - all the dark ‘transing away the gay’ ‘jokes’.
Sam Hall - the short film screamed red flags re safeguarding of her own children.

I am pleased Sarah Redvers confirmed she views this as a scandal.

Let’s see what happens next but please hope it gives courage to others in the NHS who are experiencing the toxicity and have concerns about children.

Safeguarding concerns should never be explained away. It very much reminds me of the grooming gangs and the SW Sarah Champion (?) being told she had it wrong.

Helleofabore · 24/10/2026 08:11

ArabellaScott · 24/10/2026 07:02

AD and his enabling is certainly a large part of it.

The case also reveals though how 'trans' was and is used as a tool of control, manipulation, and abuse. Children have been irrevocably harmed by this pernicious bullshit, and the people who harmed them protected and enabled by a culture that has seen the doublethink and power dynamic as an opportunity.

Just as 'trans' damaged Sturgeon and the Scottish government, it has been abaorbed into the NHS at the very highest levels.

The ideology is useful to authoritarians, because it relies on abuse of power, fear, and lies, and anyone can therefore access and use it if they are ruthless enough.

I think this is one point that keeps coming up - the power dynamic. I know people in other organisations where a person with a transgender identity is protected because no one wants a tribunal case.

And in this case, children have been at risk.

More and more sunlight is highlighting these issues that also no discussion as that also gets shut down
.

rebax · 24/10/2026 08:10

Hopefully there are some journalists reading this thread who are prepared to a deeper dive, now that a story about AD has broken.

Alwayswaiting · 24/10/2026 08:00

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

Completely agree. Worked there at the same time and to be under the AD microscope was no joke. He is a bully and the entire exec team are toxic.
There seems to be a complete loss
of the notion that they are there to serve and protect the public - with a focus on vulnerable people who have now been harmed. It makes me furious.
I had light involvement in this when it came out with WellBN and was made to sign an NDA. Should have been an open and transparent process - but no it was all secret squirrel.
it all makes sense now why AD was sent to NHSE although I don’t think he should be working in any public sector role around vulnerable people as they are not at the heart of his agenda
And I think the health professions council should consider striking him off.
and your certainly right - people worked there one minute - gone the next - because he didn’t like them.
And agree re: DS - but he was another that ended up disappearing off too.
I don’t know how they can sleep at night.

nauticant · 24/10/2026 07:53

the arrival of the ideology of 'affirmative care', which steals from EBM the concept of 'informed consent' (intended as the final stage of legitimising a treatment after appropriate evidence for it has been obtained) and makes it the whole basis for prescribing

I wish I'd written that. It's such a good crystallisation of what happened.

ThreeNewWords · 24/10/2026 07:30

MyAmpleSheep · 24/10/2026 01:14

I suspect that a belief in this academic and scholarly meaning of EBM at its most specific isn’t entirely what this case was about.

@HydrangeaFig Yes, the case wasn't related to this more formalised concept of EBM. The actual concept of EBM in play is given by the competing model of healthcare cited in the case, namely 'affirmative care', which positions any kind of medical assessment (i.e. evidence-seeking) before prescribing PBs and cross-sex hormones as 'gate-keeping'.

When I first heard that 'evidence based medicine" was being cited as a philosophical belief for the purposes of the Equality Act I found it hard to understand, since it it is just the absolute basic commonsense framework for medical competance.

But beliefs like this, that are so fundamentally accurate as to be almost invisible, spring into salience precisely when they are challenged.

The condition for 'gender crtitical beliefs' (i.e. noticing the existence of sex and its implications) to be defined as a philosphical belief was the arrival of an ideology that contradicted it. Similarly, the condition for the most basic and unformalised concept of evidence-based medicine to be defined as a philosphical belief was the arrival of the ideology of 'affirmative care', which steals from EBM the concept of 'informed consent' (intended as the final stage of legitimising a treatment after appropriate evidence for it has been obtained) and makes it the whole basis for prescribing.

ArabellaScott · 24/10/2026 07:23

Yes, an easy route to power is to go for.the most vulnerable. Genderism has been one way mediocre white men can reclaim access to power and recoup some of the balance that was ceded to equity.