Para 659 of the judgement.
It was because Mr Borwick had expressed opinions beyond the factual evidence he was supposed to present, and the judge ruled that that challenged one element of the 'Kennedy definition' of an expert witness, i.e. impartiality.
I think he felt that Borwick had expressed enough personal opinions about the way DrU & co arrived at/presented their evidence to tainted the rest of his evidence. The exclamation mark - which I don't recall - may have been taken as proof that he was judging the quality of the other side's evidence, instead of just sticking to the facts.
That gave the impression that he was going in to bat for SP's side, and dissing the other side.
Just saying, not agreeing!