Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

WellBN Brighton GP practice do not believe in evidence based medicine. TT at employment tribunal tomorrow

1000 replies

impossibletoday · 07/10/2026 19:53

In case anyone is interested

https://x.com/LoudBonnet/status/2107877530602443058

Naomi Cunningham profile picture

Naomi Cunningham (@LoudBonnet) on X

@tribunaltweets For CVP log-in, email [email protected] citing Redvers v NHS Sussex 6020988/2024.

https://x.com/LoudBonnet/status/2107877530602443058

OP posts:
Thread gallery
36
Justabaker · 10/10/2026 11:15

Another thread becomes infected.

3D Corona GIF by Matthew Butler
Davros · 10/10/2026 11:18

I’m a bit late to this but it has made me think about when the NHS stopped funding homeopathy in 2018 due to lack of evidence of effectiveness. They used to fund the National Homeopathic Hospital in Queen Square amongst other things. I was referred there by my GP which is when I realised it is a load of old pony. I can’t find a brilliant link but maybe this will do
https://www.nationalhealthexecutive.com/Health-Care-News/homeopathy-no-longer-available-in-nhs-as-last-ccg-ends-funding

BlueLegume · 10/10/2026 11:35

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 10:52

I really wouldn't get your information from these types of blogs- they are highly ideologically driven and biased. Better to read the facts of the case and consider a range of different perspectives/ commentaries.

Ok @Lacksie thanks for the advice. So with this in mind would you suggest I dismiss Nick Wallis as a valid source for anything? I find a lot of his work highly factual.

PachacutisBadAuntie · 10/10/2026 11:49

Borg off

Assimilate Star Trek GIF by Paramount+
MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 12:25

BlueLegume · 10/10/2026 11:35

Ok @Lacksie thanks for the advice. So with this in mind would you suggest I dismiss Nick Wallis as a valid source for anything? I find a lot of his work highly factual.

Nick Wallis is an excellent source. He is a respected journalist who did so much to expose the The Great Post Office Scandal (also the title of his book on the subject). His articles have plenty of links to evidence & source materials.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Great-Post-Office-Scandal-multimillion/dp/1739099206/

Amazon

Amazon

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Great-Post-Office-Scandal-multimillion/dp/1739099206?tag=mumsnet&ascsubtag=mnforum-womens-rights-5586672-wellbn-brighton-gp-practice-do-not-believe-in-evidence-based-medicine-tt-at-employment-tribunal-tomorrow

BlueLegume · 10/10/2026 12:27

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 12:25

Nick Wallis is an excellent source. He is a respected journalist who did so much to expose the The Great Post Office Scandal (also the title of his book on the subject). His articles have plenty of links to evidence & source materials.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Great-Post-Office-Scandal-multimillion/dp/1739099206/

I agree @MrPrettyDamnCosmic I followed the PO scandal and enquiry and he is also a journalist of integrity re the trans/gender issue.

DrBlackbird · 10/10/2026 12:35

Well that is a complicated and confusing case. I’d sum it up as: witch hunt.

It’s enraging that Dr Redvers was targeted at the highest level of NHS Sussex (isn’t Sussex where the police are quick to arrest people who hold the outrageous belief that humans cannot change sex? And where the head of Sussex Pride was jailed for rape?) with the investigation - much of it run by men - designed from the start to find a particular conclusion. Yet, none of them are unlikely to have any negative repercussions.

Mr Amroliwala was the business partner in a consultancy firm with the complaints manager, the [NHS Sussex] Chief People Officer, Mark Power [with] Mr Amroliwala omitting the consultancy firm from his CV.”

Adam Doyle is alleged to have signed off both Amroliwala’s appointment and the scope and scale of his investigation. Whilst this was going on, Adam Doyle, the CEO of NHS Sussex, released a joint statement on trans inclusion with the Clare Project, of which Dr Hall was a trustee.

All sounds so cosy.

Convenient for these men to not have had skin in the game. All the sanctimonious and righteous glow of being on TRSOH alongside the secret pleasure of putting a mouthy female in her place.

Even the parent’s complaint was only a JR. What is needed is a whacking great class action lawsuit for these people to be held accountable for their decisions and choices. It is the only way to ever achieve this.

BlueLegume · 10/10/2026 13:29

@Lacksie you derailed the Sandie Pegg thread 24/7 in between your preparation of work presentations/the school run/work/feeding your kids.

This case is very different. It involves the safeguarding of children.

If you are a TRA trying to stir up the debate just remember - children were harmed. That is a very different discussion than adults being uncomfortable around a man in their changing room.

We do not treat anorexia by affirming the patient is fat and weight loss drugs.

ArabellaScott · 10/10/2026 13:31

'A consistent concern throughout the course of the investigation was poor and disorganised record keeping, with important information about the 78 children and young people contained in emails and messaging apps. This made it extremely difficult to state definitively what information was or was not available for each case'

'The Practice was not commissioned by NHSE or the ICB to provide specialist care to children and young people under 18 who presented with gender dysphoria/gender incongruence.'

'the Practice failed to recognise the importance for patient safety of adherence to NHSE service specifications and national clinical policies'

'Care at the Practice for the 78 children and young people fell substantially below that set out in service specifications and national clinical policy'

'Puberty blockers and gender enhancing medications were prescribed without a comprehensive bio-psychosocial assessment (in 22 cases without even face-to-face appointments having taken place) without essential baseline and ongoing investigations and in 75 cases without referrals to paediatric endocrinologists.'

'In 37 cases the Practice took over prescribing gender medications from private prescribers accepting without assurance that the child had been adequately assessed and investigated, and accepting without seeing that a completed and signed consent form was available. In 14 cases the Practice wrongly stated that a consent form was not needed before assuming prescribing from a private prescriber.'

'the children/young people’s capability to consent was only confirmed in 6 of the 78 cases'.

' Gillick competence was not expressly confirmed for 50 children under 16 years of age.'

'Children and families were not appropriately informed of the impact of medication on fertility'

'Safeguarding risk and safety assessments were inadequate'

From the Executive summary of the NHS findings.

rebax · 10/10/2026 13:41

Schedule for next week
J: On Monday I will have some Qs and then Mr Milsom will have some re-examination.
J: After that we will have R witnesses.
BW: We will have Mr Smith first then Mr Doyle. Will be most of the week.

MS - Mark Smith, Chief People Officer, R1 (Aug 2022 - Jan 2025) Acting CEO (Jan 2025 - June 2025) Deputy CEO & Director of Transition (June 2025 - present)
AD/R2 - Adam Doyle, second respondent, CEO of R1 2019-2025

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 13:48

'The Practice was not commissioned by NHSE or the ICB to provide specialist care to children and young people under 18 who presented with gender dysphoria/gender incongruence.'

The Practice was however doing exactly that with the tacit approval & knowing connivance of both NHSE & the ICB. It was only because of the JR by the parents of a child who had been mistreated by WellBN that the independent report was commissioned.

The report does a decent job of showing the scandalous malpractice of Dr Hall & others but what it doesn't show is the way that Sam Hall & WellBN were facilitated by the ICB & NHSE. Hopefully the complicity of the ICB in permitting WellBN to mistreat patients will be exposed over the next couple of weeks. It's going to be fascinating to see Adam Doyle skewered by Naomi Cunningham next week.

Thehorticulturalhussie · 10/10/2026 13:50

ArabellaScott · 10/10/2026 13:31

'A consistent concern throughout the course of the investigation was poor and disorganised record keeping, with important information about the 78 children and young people contained in emails and messaging apps. This made it extremely difficult to state definitively what information was or was not available for each case'

'The Practice was not commissioned by NHSE or the ICB to provide specialist care to children and young people under 18 who presented with gender dysphoria/gender incongruence.'

'the Practice failed to recognise the importance for patient safety of adherence to NHSE service specifications and national clinical policies'

'Care at the Practice for the 78 children and young people fell substantially below that set out in service specifications and national clinical policy'

'Puberty blockers and gender enhancing medications were prescribed without a comprehensive bio-psychosocial assessment (in 22 cases without even face-to-face appointments having taken place) without essential baseline and ongoing investigations and in 75 cases without referrals to paediatric endocrinologists.'

'In 37 cases the Practice took over prescribing gender medications from private prescribers accepting without assurance that the child had been adequately assessed and investigated, and accepting without seeing that a completed and signed consent form was available. In 14 cases the Practice wrongly stated that a consent form was not needed before assuming prescribing from a private prescriber.'

'the children/young people’s capability to consent was only confirmed in 6 of the 78 cases'.

' Gillick competence was not expressly confirmed for 50 children under 16 years of age.'

'Children and families were not appropriately informed of the impact of medication on fertility'

'Safeguarding risk and safety assessments were inadequate'

From the Executive summary of the NHS findings.

This is so damning, thank you for showing it.
How much damage does a clinician have to wilfully inflict on vulnerable children who have MH problems before they can be charged with criminal negligence or, as seems here, ABH?

ArabellaScott · 10/10/2026 13:56

A good question. But if Dr Hall is going to be charged, then so should some of the NHS high-ups that covered up and colluded.

Rightsraptor · 10/10/2026 13:57

BlueLegume · 09/10/2026 13:21

Agree and also that Sophie Molly (Euan Weddell) had ‘interviewed’ Sam Hall. If you do not know who Weddell is feel free to Google. He is quite the lady.

I do indeed know who he is! Nice chap.

I'm sure someone must have mentioned Hall's arm on display in that interview - I couldn't get past the first few minutes of it, so maybe it was explained that that arm was the source of the flesh for Hall's phaloplasty.

The voice surprised me though.

Thehorticulturalhussie · 10/10/2026 13:58

ArabellaScott · 10/10/2026 13:56

A good question. But if Dr Hall is going to be charged, then so should some of the NHS high-ups that covered up and colluded.

Definitely.

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 14:13

BlueLegume · 10/10/2026 13:29

@Lacksie you derailed the Sandie Pegg thread 24/7 in between your preparation of work presentations/the school run/work/feeding your kids.

This case is very different. It involves the safeguarding of children.

If you are a TRA trying to stir up the debate just remember - children were harmed. That is a very different discussion than adults being uncomfortable around a man in their changing room.

We do not treat anorexia by affirming the patient is fat and weight loss drugs.

Edited

I'm very much over the personal comments from you. If you would like to discuss the issues, I welcome that. I shan't be reading or responding to any personal comments.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 10/10/2026 16:19

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 14:13

I'm very much over the personal comments from you. If you would like to discuss the issues, I welcome that. I shan't be reading or responding to any personal comments.

You won't be able to tell whether they are personal without reading them.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 10/10/2026 16:24

DrBlackbird · 10/10/2026 12:35

Well that is a complicated and confusing case. I’d sum it up as: witch hunt.

It’s enraging that Dr Redvers was targeted at the highest level of NHS Sussex (isn’t Sussex where the police are quick to arrest people who hold the outrageous belief that humans cannot change sex? And where the head of Sussex Pride was jailed for rape?) with the investigation - much of it run by men - designed from the start to find a particular conclusion. Yet, none of them are unlikely to have any negative repercussions.

Mr Amroliwala was the business partner in a consultancy firm with the complaints manager, the [NHS Sussex] Chief People Officer, Mark Power [with] Mr Amroliwala omitting the consultancy firm from his CV.”

Adam Doyle is alleged to have signed off both Amroliwala’s appointment and the scope and scale of his investigation. Whilst this was going on, Adam Doyle, the CEO of NHS Sussex, released a joint statement on trans inclusion with the Clare Project, of which Dr Hall was a trustee.

All sounds so cosy.

Convenient for these men to not have had skin in the game. All the sanctimonious and righteous glow of being on TRSOH alongside the secret pleasure of putting a mouthy female in her place.

Even the parent’s complaint was only a JR. What is needed is a whacking great class action lawsuit for these people to be held accountable for their decisions and choices. It is the only way to ever achieve this.

Edited

And where the head of Sussex Pride was jailed for rape?

Do you mean Stephen Ireland? He was Surrey Pride I think, but that's just next door.

FarriersGirl · 10/10/2026 16:52

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 13:48

'The Practice was not commissioned by NHSE or the ICB to provide specialist care to children and young people under 18 who presented with gender dysphoria/gender incongruence.'

The Practice was however doing exactly that with the tacit approval & knowing connivance of both NHSE & the ICB. It was only because of the JR by the parents of a child who had been mistreated by WellBN that the independent report was commissioned.

The report does a decent job of showing the scandalous malpractice of Dr Hall & others but what it doesn't show is the way that Sam Hall & WellBN were facilitated by the ICB & NHSE. Hopefully the complicity of the ICB in permitting WellBN to mistreat patients will be exposed over the next couple of weeks. It's going to be fascinating to see Adam Doyle skewered by Naomi Cunningham next week.

The ICSI report linked earlier was damning but only included 78 children in its scope. It has been estimated that Sam Hall had 'treated' over 2000 children in her time at WellBN so the scale of the harm is certain to be much larger.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 17:01

FarriersGirl · 10/10/2026 16:52

The ICSI report linked earlier was damning but only included 78 children in its scope. It has been estimated that Sam Hall had 'treated' over 2000 children in her time at WellBN so the scale of the harm is certain to be much larger.

Sam Hall was seeing patients from all over the country. It was extraordinary that the ICB was funding this. My suspicion is that the ICB were deeply ideological about this & that there was an inappropriately close relationship (I don't mean sexual) between Adam Doyle & Sam Hall that allowed the scandal to develop. There must have been other facilitators in the ICB but the strategy was driven from the top. This is why Adam Doyle will spend most of next week in the witness box.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 17:04

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 13:48

'The Practice was not commissioned by NHSE or the ICB to provide specialist care to children and young people under 18 who presented with gender dysphoria/gender incongruence.'

The Practice was however doing exactly that with the tacit approval & knowing connivance of both NHSE & the ICB. It was only because of the JR by the parents of a child who had been mistreated by WellBN that the independent report was commissioned.

The report does a decent job of showing the scandalous malpractice of Dr Hall & others but what it doesn't show is the way that Sam Hall & WellBN were facilitated by the ICB & NHSE. Hopefully the complicity of the ICB in permitting WellBN to mistreat patients will be exposed over the next couple of weeks. It's going to be fascinating to see Adam Doyle skewered by Naomi Cunningham next week.

Whoops! My mistake. Adam Doyle will not be skewered by Naomi Cunningham next week it will be Charlotte Elves &/or Christopher Milson wielding the skewer

YourWatermelonship · 10/10/2026 17:25

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 17:01

Sam Hall was seeing patients from all over the country. It was extraordinary that the ICB was funding this. My suspicion is that the ICB were deeply ideological about this & that there was an inappropriately close relationship (I don't mean sexual) between Adam Doyle & Sam Hall that allowed the scandal to develop. There must have been other facilitators in the ICB but the strategy was driven from the top. This is why Adam Doyle will spend most of next week in the witness box.

I wonder if Doyle wil turn out to be an enthusiastic enabler ally à la Dr Kate Searle (from the Sandie Peggie case

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 17:32

The dateline on the article is 18th November 2025 but must have occurred long before that as Sam Hall left WellBN in July 2025 but she speaks in the interview as though she is still working at WellBN.

Here are a couple of the lies from her interview with my comments in bold

We are careful not to give any irreversible treatment
What like testosterone, oestrogen & puberty blockers?

multiple Prevention of Future Death reports from coroners urging NHSE and other NHS bodies to provide better care for this growing cohort of young people.
I have searched. There is a single Prevention of Future Death report that highlighted delays in referral to a Gender Clinic.

There is also something that isn't a lie but needs to be given in evidence to the ET

I believe NHS Sussex are themselves being pressured to carry out this investigation when they have been fully aware of our service, and the high quality of care we provide, for the past 5 years.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread