Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Women's Rights and Rejoining the EU

96 replies

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 01/10/2026 18:34

(I posted this earlier on my Burnham and women's rights thread, but I think it's going to get buried there, so started a new thread)

Following Andy Burnham's speech, someone started a thread about what the re-entry to the EU should be called:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/eu_referendum_2016_/5584173-what-shall-we-call-the-return

Let's not rehash the pros and cons of Brexit here (there are plenty of other threads for that). There might be some economic benefits to rejoining the EU, but if women's rights get lost in the shuffle (and you know they would!), I don't want any part of rejoining.

I think it's unlikely, but, in case it does happen...

What I'm wondering is what would be the ramifications for women's rights in Great Britain and NI if (and that's a very big if) we were to rejoin?

Would there be any? Could anybody with legal expertise enlighten us, please?

OP posts:
Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:29

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 10:25

In other words, you're talking about the policies of individual countries - not the EU.

The EU has formally adopted and drafted the term 'gender' equality.....by which it also refers to the concept of 'trans rights'.

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:31

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 10:27

Aside from basic equality, much of what you describe as social legislations is up to individual EU countries and is not EU law. Can you point to any specific EU social law that you object to?

The European parliament regularly passes resolutions (such as its November 2025 priorities and early 2026 stances) supporting equal rights, access to healthcare, protections for LGBTQ+ and trans individuals, and measures to combat 'gender-based' violence and democratic backsliding.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 10:34

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:29

The EU has formally adopted and drafted the term 'gender' equality.....by which it also refers to the concept of 'trans rights'.

Can you link to the EU laws that state this? Because there doesn't appear to be any obligation on EU countries to introduce "trans rights".

RareGoalsVerge · Yesterday 10:35

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 22:06

Who died as a result of Self-ID in Ireland? There must be hundreds, surely?

Way to lower the bar even further. First we had "shut up, you didn't get raped did you so of course there was no problem with a male being in your changing room"

Now thanks to @alcovecupboards the standard is even lower : "shut up, you didn't get murdered did you so of course there was no problem with a male being in your changing room"

My minimum standard for dignity and human rights is a lot higher than "not being raped or murdered today" thanks very much. Male people do not belong in female changing rooms even if they aren't rapists or murderers, and that is true regardless of their personal thoughts about the nature of their gender identity which is a phenomenon that exists solely within their head with no means to define or verify it.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 10:35

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:31

The European parliament regularly passes resolutions (such as its November 2025 priorities and early 2026 stances) supporting equal rights, access to healthcare, protections for LGBTQ+ and trans individuals, and measures to combat 'gender-based' violence and democratic backsliding.

Can you link to some of these resolutions with vote numbers and results? While also noting that these resolutions do not impose any obligations on the member states.

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:37

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 10:34

Can you link to the EU laws that state this? Because there doesn't appear to be any obligation on EU countries to introduce "trans rights".

  1. Sex Discrimination Law: The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) long ago established that EU sex discrimination directives apply to transgender individuals, protecting them from discrimination based on gender reassignment or gender identity in employment.

  2. In rulings such as Shipova (Case C-43/24) and related free-movement jurisprudence, the CJEU determined that EU member states must provide legal gender recognition procedures and recognize valid name and gender marker changes legally obtained in other EU member states

  3. Refusing to recognize legally established gender markers or denying LGR violates EU freedom of movement (Article 21 TFEU) and fundamental rights under the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. National courts are required to override domestic legal barriers that conflict with these EU-level movement rights

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:39

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:37

  1. Sex Discrimination Law: The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) long ago established that EU sex discrimination directives apply to transgender individuals, protecting them from discrimination based on gender reassignment or gender identity in employment.

  2. In rulings such as Shipova (Case C-43/24) and related free-movement jurisprudence, the CJEU determined that EU member states must provide legal gender recognition procedures and recognize valid name and gender marker changes legally obtained in other EU member states

  3. Refusing to recognize legally established gender markers or denying LGR violates EU freedom of movement (Article 21 TFEU) and fundamental rights under the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. National courts are required to override domestic legal barriers that conflict with these EU-level movement rights

https://www.europarl.europa.eu/EPRS/TD/LGBTI/result.html

RareGoalsVerge · Yesterday 10:41

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 10:34

Can you link to the EU laws that state this? Because there doesn't appear to be any obligation on EU countries to introduce "trans rights".

It's a ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union from March 2026

https://curia.europa.eu/site/upload/docs/application/pdf/2026-03/cp260033en.pdf

Worryingly this document claims that the EU law would supercede the Supreme Court of the member state in this matter.

moto748e · Yesterday 10:42

Can you link to some of these resolutions with vote numbers and results?

What did your last servant die of? 🙄

AstonCanKissMyArse · Yesterday 10:57

RareGoalsVerge · Yesterday 10:35

Way to lower the bar even further. First we had "shut up, you didn't get raped did you so of course there was no problem with a male being in your changing room"

Now thanks to @alcovecupboards the standard is even lower : "shut up, you didn't get murdered did you so of course there was no problem with a male being in your changing room"

My minimum standard for dignity and human rights is a lot higher than "not being raped or murdered today" thanks very much. Male people do not belong in female changing rooms even if they aren't rapists or murderers, and that is true regardless of their personal thoughts about the nature of their gender identity which is a phenomenon that exists solely within their head with no means to define or verify it.

I was going to say the same.

Not being killed' is a pretty fucking low bar.

Demonstrates what that poster really thinks of women.

I also have major reservations about rejoining the EU, and I was an enthusiastic remainer. As pp have said, the EU has enshrined the term transgender into law which is a step further than the UK away from women's rights.

I also feel pretty strongly (looking at you Labour 👀) that an incoming government shouldn't be able to ignore a previous referendum. It seems to be just another aspect of the trashing of the rule of law.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 11:11

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:39

A report by a committee of the European parliament that has no effect on EU member states. Bristol Council's trans resoutions have more real-world effect.

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 11:13

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 11:11

A report by a committee of the European parliament that has no effect on EU member states. Bristol Council's trans resoutions have more real-world effect.

So you decided to ignore the other examples I gave you because they don't confirm your denial.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 11:17

RareGoalsVerge · Yesterday 10:41

It's a ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union from March 2026

https://curia.europa.eu/site/upload/docs/application/pdf/2026-03/cp260033en.pdf

Worryingly this document claims that the EU law would supercede the Supreme Court of the member state in this matter.

This is about being able to transfer rights acquired in one EU state to other states. It's not an EU law obligating self-ID in member states nor does it oblige EU member states to change their laws to adopt gender self-ID.

It's a crap ruling but it's very marginal and applies only in the case of individuals. I don't see the newspapers in Bulgaria referring to violent men who attack women as "she", as the endlessly do in the UK, nor do I see Bulgaria adopting gender self-ID laws.

Still waiting for the links to EU laws passed by the Commission, Council and parliament that oblige EU member states to adopt laws on gender self-ID.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 11:25

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:37

  1. Sex Discrimination Law: The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) long ago established that EU sex discrimination directives apply to transgender individuals, protecting them from discrimination based on gender reassignment or gender identity in employment.

  2. In rulings such as Shipova (Case C-43/24) and related free-movement jurisprudence, the CJEU determined that EU member states must provide legal gender recognition procedures and recognize valid name and gender marker changes legally obtained in other EU member states

  3. Refusing to recognize legally established gender markers or denying LGR violates EU freedom of movement (Article 21 TFEU) and fundamental rights under the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. National courts are required to override domestic legal barriers that conflict with these EU-level movement rights

I responded above to the bit about transferring rights in the case of individuals above. It's very marginal and does not force member states to adopt legislation on gender self-id.

The sex discrimination law was probably inspired by the UK, which passed this crap about "gender reassignment" being a protected category way before any other country in Europe considered it.

None of these judgments impose gender self-ID on EU member states, force them to house men in women's prisons or to give puberty blockers to kids.

The effect on the UK rejoining the EU in terms of gender ideology would be marginal to insignificant.

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 12:13

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 11:25

I responded above to the bit about transferring rights in the case of individuals above. It's very marginal and does not force member states to adopt legislation on gender self-id.

The sex discrimination law was probably inspired by the UK, which passed this crap about "gender reassignment" being a protected category way before any other country in Europe considered it.

None of these judgments impose gender self-ID on EU member states, force them to house men in women's prisons or to give puberty blockers to kids.

The effect on the UK rejoining the EU in terms of gender ideology would be marginal to insignificant.

Is it that you are very invested in the idea of the EU and therefore willing to over-look its more probelmatical features, or is it that you are very invested in gender identity as a concept that has legal protection such as exist in many EU countries?

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 12:15

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 11:17

This is about being able to transfer rights acquired in one EU state to other states. It's not an EU law obligating self-ID in member states nor does it oblige EU member states to change their laws to adopt gender self-ID.

It's a crap ruling but it's very marginal and applies only in the case of individuals. I don't see the newspapers in Bulgaria referring to violent men who attack women as "she", as the endlessly do in the UK, nor do I see Bulgaria adopting gender self-ID laws.

Still waiting for the links to EU laws passed by the Commission, Council and parliament that oblige EU member states to adopt laws on gender self-ID.

Bulgaria is a bit of a outlier.....what about Germany, for example, or The Netherlands..... some of the countries that the EU was originally instituted to serve?

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 12:19

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 11:17

This is about being able to transfer rights acquired in one EU state to other states. It's not an EU law obligating self-ID in member states nor does it oblige EU member states to change their laws to adopt gender self-ID.

It's a crap ruling but it's very marginal and applies only in the case of individuals. I don't see the newspapers in Bulgaria referring to violent men who attack women as "she", as the endlessly do in the UK, nor do I see Bulgaria adopting gender self-ID laws.

Still waiting for the links to EU laws passed by the Commission, Council and parliament that oblige EU member states to adopt laws on gender self-ID.

How EU Rulings Work on Gender Identity

  • Supremacy of EU Law: Under the principle of EU law supremacy, binding judgments from the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) take precedence over national legislation. National courts are required to disregard domestic laws that run contrary to these rulings.
  • The Shipova (Case C-43/24) Ruling (March 2026): The CJEU ruled that EU member states must provide legal gender recognition (LGR) procedures and matching identity documents for citizens exercising their right to freedom of movement within the EU (Article 21 TFEU). The court determined that refusing to issue ID documents that reflect a person's lived gender identity creates travel and daily inconveniences that violate EU freedom of movement and private life rights.
  • Impact on Non-Compliant States: This ruling places direct legal obligations on countries with strict domestic bans or a lack of legal gender recognition procedures—such as Bulgaria, Hungary, and Slovakia—requiring them to adjust their practices so trans citizens can obtain consistent documentation.
moto748e · Yesterday 12:25

AstonCanKissMyArse · Yesterday 10:57

I was going to say the same.

Not being killed' is a pretty fucking low bar.

Demonstrates what that poster really thinks of women.

I also have major reservations about rejoining the EU, and I was an enthusiastic remainer. As pp have said, the EU has enshrined the term transgender into law which is a step further than the UK away from women's rights.

I also feel pretty strongly (looking at you Labour 👀) that an incoming government shouldn't be able to ignore a previous referendum. It seems to be just another aspect of the trashing of the rule of law.

Agree about the reservations. I voted Remain too, but the EU enthusiasm for gender ideology is a worry. Is it a serious enough concern to justify opposing re-joining? Possibly. I accept that the European Parliament is largely just a talking-shop, and it's resolutions need not have a major effect on member states, but it's undeniable that the EU hierarchy are fully behind genderism, and the ECtHR is equally sympathetic. We only have to look at the situation in Germany an Ireland. We do not want that here, and that has to made clear to Andy Burnham.

Lovelyview · Yesterday 12:39

I am also a remainer who is very cautious about rejoining the EU. Mainly because of the EU policy makers batshit support for self-id stuff but also because, as a previous poster said, overturning the results of a legal referendum is a very serious thing which would rip this country apart, as would the campaigning around a new referendum.

moto748e · Yesterday 12:56

Yeah, I don’t buy that "the referendum is sacrosanct" argument at all. That's not how referendums work, you only have to look at countries where they're commonplace, like the US. Referendums keep getting called for, until the public vote the 'right' way. And as is often pointed out, in a rare show of frankness, Farage admitted at the time that if the ref had gone narrowly the other way (as most expected at the time), he would have continued to campaign for another one. Which would have been absolutely fine. But sauce for the goose...

Imdunfer · Yesterday 14:39

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 11:25

I responded above to the bit about transferring rights in the case of individuals above. It's very marginal and does not force member states to adopt legislation on gender self-id.

The sex discrimination law was probably inspired by the UK, which passed this crap about "gender reassignment" being a protected category way before any other country in Europe considered it.

None of these judgments impose gender self-ID on EU member states, force them to house men in women's prisons or to give puberty blockers to kids.

The effect on the UK rejoining the EU in terms of gender ideology would be marginal to insignificant.

Stop making light of the cross border problems, please. They do impact women in the countries which don't accept that female identified trans people are women.

How does a Bulgarian woman insist on her right to single sex spaces, clubs and sport when the German man who lives next door or works in the same office has self ID as a woman and the EU says must be treated in every respect legally as if they were a woman?

Imdunfer · Yesterday 14:40

Does anyone know if the Erasmus incomers are going to be entitled to recognition as women in the UK?

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 15:35

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 12:13

Is it that you are very invested in the idea of the EU and therefore willing to over-look its more probelmatical features, or is it that you are very invested in gender identity as a concept that has legal protection such as exist in many EU countries?

Edited

What are its more problematical features? That it passed a judgment in a very narrow area that has pretty much zero impact in the real world? This judgment imposes no obligations on EU member states to pass any laws regarding gender ideology. Moreover, it offers that individual exactly the same "rights" as if he were in the UK, where the Gender Recognition Act is in force.

Perhaps you are heavily invested in opposing the EU and so have taken this small issue, misunderstood it and blown it out of proportion?

Still waiting for the actual EU laws that enforce gender self-ID, men in women's prisons and puberty blockers for kids on all EU member states. Please link to those laws, if they exist.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 16:08

Imdunfer · Yesterday 14:39

Stop making light of the cross border problems, please. They do impact women in the countries which don't accept that female identified trans people are women.

How does a Bulgarian woman insist on her right to single sex spaces, clubs and sport when the German man who lives next door or works in the same office has self ID as a woman and the EU says must be treated in every respect legally as if they were a woman?

That's not what that judgement says. It's about an EU national from a country without gender recognition, in this case Bulgaria, seeking ID documentation from his home country so that he can reside in a country that does have gender recognition (in this case, Italy, I believe) and have ID (issued by his home country) with the "gender" marker that he is recognised as in the country of residence so he can use it in that country, which does recognise his gender identity. It doesn't oblige Bulgaria to recognise gender on German ID - or a UK passport, when the UK was in the EU.

You completely misunderstood that judgement if you think it says (let alone "the EU says") that a German man can self-ID as a woman and be treated legally as a woman in every respect in Bulgaria. It doesn't.

Besides, isn't it already the case that a German man with the equivalent of a gender recognition certificate move to the United Kingdom and be recognised as a woman? Although, as we also know, that doesn't mean he can use the women's loos at work or be treated legally as a woman in every respect. Because while a country may issue gender recognition certificates and change gender markers on passports and ID, it can also restrict activity based on biological sex.

So, no, that judgment doesn't mean what you think it does.

JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 16:17

Besides, isn't it already the case that a German man with the equivalent of a gender recognition certificate move to the United Kingdom and be recognised as a woman?

This is not the case. The UK only recognises GRCs from other countries (or parts of those states) where the Gender Recognition process is at least as vigorous as that in the UK.