Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Women's Rights and Rejoining the EU

97 replies

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 01/10/2026 18:34

(I posted this earlier on my Burnham and women's rights thread, but I think it's going to get buried there, so started a new thread)

Following Andy Burnham's speech, someone started a thread about what the re-entry to the EU should be called:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/eu_referendum_2016_/5584173-what-shall-we-call-the-return

Let's not rehash the pros and cons of Brexit here (there are plenty of other threads for that). There might be some economic benefits to rejoining the EU, but if women's rights get lost in the shuffle (and you know they would!), I don't want any part of rejoining.

I think it's unlikely, but, in case it does happen...

What I'm wondering is what would be the ramifications for women's rights in Great Britain and NI if (and that's a very big if) we were to rejoin?

Would there be any? Could anybody with legal expertise enlighten us, please?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lovelyview · Today 13:53

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 21:39

"As far as I can see, we would have to automatically recognise legal gender changes granted to an EU citizen in another member state when that person exercises their freedom of movement to the UK"

First of all, that is not the case in the EU: member states are not required to recognise gender certificates issued by another EU state. There is also no obligation to recognise gender identity over biological sex - the UK as a member, for example, was never asked to amend the Equality Act to recognise gender above sex. There is no EU law that obliges member states to privilege gender identity over sex or even to recognise gender identity.

Secondly, the UK already automatically recognises gender certificates issued by many countries, including many non-EU countries as well as EU countries. With certain other countries, it simply requires some extra documentation. The UK already recognises the gender certificates of foreign nationals.

Lots of bendy bananas, side of a bus stuff here.

https://x.com/RoisinMichaux/status/2122667468501975266

Roisin Michaux was fired from the EU because she stood up against trans ideology.

She says: 'The FOI revealed that the European Commission made the decision to fire me on international women’s day, 8 march. At that very moment, senior EU officials were at the UN commission on the status of women in New York. The theme was “access to justice for all women and girls” lol. The delegation had brought a statement declaring that “trans women are women”.

The EU's position on this is completely captured. I would currently vote no to rejoining the EU.

Róisín Michaux profile picture

Róisín Michaux (@RoisinMichaux) on X

The FOI revealed that the European Commission made the decision to fire me on international women’s day, 8 march. At that very moment, senior EU officials were at the UN commission on the status of women in New York. The theme was “access to justice...

https://x.com/RoisinMichaux/status/2122667468501975266

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 08:51

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 20:56

Which "unelected bureaucrats" are issuing "diktats" on gender?

I posted you several links but you seem determined to minimise the importance or impact of EU directives on 'gender'. Why? As I enquired before is this due to your loyalty to the concept of the EU or to the unimportance of the concept of 'Gender Identity'?

Imdunfer · Today 08:22

Whatever the situation with regards to self ID, why would anyone join an organisation whose stated position, which they went to court to establish, is "Trans women are women" and who would, if their set-up allowed, enforce that legally across Europe in the same way they mandate weights and measures?

How long before newly joining countries, of which we would be one, are made to accept this along with changing their currency to the Euro as conditions of joining?

Clavinova · Yesterday 22:51

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 21:39

"As far as I can see, we would have to automatically recognise legal gender changes granted to an EU citizen in another member state when that person exercises their freedom of movement to the UK"

First of all, that is not the case in the EU: member states are not required to recognise gender certificates issued by another EU state. There is also no obligation to recognise gender identity over biological sex - the UK as a member, for example, was never asked to amend the Equality Act to recognise gender above sex. There is no EU law that obliges member states to privilege gender identity over sex or even to recognise gender identity.

Secondly, the UK already automatically recognises gender certificates issued by many countries, including many non-EU countries as well as EU countries. With certain other countries, it simply requires some extra documentation. The UK already recognises the gender certificates of foreign nationals.

Lots of bendy bananas, side of a bus stuff here.

First of all, that is not the case in the EU: member states are not required to recognise gender certificates issued by another EU state

This case?

The judgment is a milestone for the rights of trans and non-binary people. It ensures that a (new) identity lawfully acquired in one Member State must also be recognised in other Member States without additional checks and procedures.

https://www.anwaelte-schneider-stein.de/en/ssp-news/eugh-judgement-strengthens-the-rights-of-trans-and-non-binary-people-in-the-eu/

Secondly, the UK already automatically recognises gender certificates issued by many countries

It's clearly not automatic. In your link, applicants still have to formally apply for a UK Gender Recognition Certificate via the 'overseas route'.

moto748e · Yesterday 22:43

Well, it's perfectly fair to point out that none of the ridiculous claims made by Leave (remember those amazing new trade deals that could be cooked up in days, bringing UK industry vastly bigger markets than the EU offered?) ever came to pass. That's without starting on the bus.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 22:29

Andy's speech was... political (read "indecisive"), and he's pushed any thought of more serious EU connection past the next election (if he gets that far):

https://news.sky.com/story/politics-latest-jackdaw-begins-gas-production-in-north-sea-after-its-approval-was-criticised-by-environmentalists-12593360

(sorry about the link, it's one of those Sky News rolling pages)

However, any "real movement" likely won't be seen until after the next election, as the PM promised to put any new relationship to the British people.

He did use The Phrase:

Burnham says that while it may be "easier" not to bring up Brexit, "if we are going to be serious about growth, then we are going to have to have this conversation. It's like the Emperor's New clothes, where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth."
[my bold]

I'd really like him to explain to my face why this sentence is acceptable when discussing Brexit (which the majority of voters voted for), but unacceptable when discussing the fact that men do not become women...ever... but everyone was expected to agree to it (which NOBODY voted for).

Anyway, it appears that the "Let's rejoin some of the EU" is just some kind of ploy, and probably one which will lose him the next election, what an idiot.

I'll keep an eye on it, but it'll go on the back burner for now.

OP posts:
JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 21:54

Sadly,@BunnyBunbunbun whilst you can argue that there is no risk to the SCJ by rejoining the EU, my trust stops at the English Channel and the Irish Sea. To do otherwise is to place hope before expectation.

Heggettypeg · Yesterday 21:51

The one thing we can be sure of is that every possible ambiguity and grey area in the complex tangle of European legislation and its interaction with the legislation of member states will be exploited by transactivists to the utmost.

You only have to see how they carry on about the UK Equality Act, the Supreme Court judgement, and the relevant UK legislation around facilities for customers and employees. "But but but..."

Add the EU to the mix and there'd be no end to it.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 21:39

Clavinova · Yesterday 21:27

The sex discrimination law was probably inspired by the UK

A UK tribunal case referred to the ECJ (1996) -

the judges ruled that the school had failed to respect the dignity and freedom to which EU citizens were entitled and which the court had a duty to safeguard.

Before the case went to the ECJ, an industrial tribunal in Cornwall had already determined that the true reason for P’s dismissal was her decision to change sex, but found that English law did not cover such discrimination.

The tribunal then asked the European Court to verify whether or not the EU’s directive on equal opportunity for men and women in the workplace extended to P’s case.

https://www.politico.eu/article/court-rules-in-favour-of-sacked-transsexual/

The effect on the UK rejoining the EU in terms of gender ideology would be marginal to insignificant

As far as I can see, we would have to automatically recognise legal gender changes granted to an EU citizen in another member state when that person exercises their freedom of movement to the UK (likely to apply to family members/partners and dependants with a legal gender change in future as well, including non-EU family members - similar to other derived rights). Plus the EU would likely put pressure on us to amend the Equality Act 2010 before rejoining - since the 2025 Supreme Court interpretation on biological sex diverges from EU gender equality law, free movement and fundamental rights.

"As far as I can see, we would have to automatically recognise legal gender changes granted to an EU citizen in another member state when that person exercises their freedom of movement to the UK"

First of all, that is not the case in the EU: member states are not required to recognise gender certificates issued by another EU state. There is also no obligation to recognise gender identity over biological sex - the UK as a member, for example, was never asked to amend the Equality Act to recognise gender above sex. There is no EU law that obliges member states to privilege gender identity over sex or even to recognise gender identity.

Secondly, the UK already automatically recognises gender certificates issued by many countries, including many non-EU countries as well as EU countries. With certain other countries, it simply requires some extra documentation. The UK already recognises the gender certificates of foreign nationals.

Lots of bendy bananas, side of a bus stuff here.

Clavinova · Yesterday 21:35

interpretation of 'sex' in the Equality Act to mean biological sex

Clavinova · Yesterday 21:27

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 11:25

I responded above to the bit about transferring rights in the case of individuals above. It's very marginal and does not force member states to adopt legislation on gender self-id.

The sex discrimination law was probably inspired by the UK, which passed this crap about "gender reassignment" being a protected category way before any other country in Europe considered it.

None of these judgments impose gender self-ID on EU member states, force them to house men in women's prisons or to give puberty blockers to kids.

The effect on the UK rejoining the EU in terms of gender ideology would be marginal to insignificant.

The sex discrimination law was probably inspired by the UK

A UK tribunal case referred to the ECJ (1996) -

the judges ruled that the school had failed to respect the dignity and freedom to which EU citizens were entitled and which the court had a duty to safeguard.

Before the case went to the ECJ, an industrial tribunal in Cornwall had already determined that the true reason for P’s dismissal was her decision to change sex, but found that English law did not cover such discrimination.

The tribunal then asked the European Court to verify whether or not the EU’s directive on equal opportunity for men and women in the workplace extended to P’s case.

https://www.politico.eu/article/court-rules-in-favour-of-sacked-transsexual/

The effect on the UK rejoining the EU in terms of gender ideology would be marginal to insignificant

As far as I can see, we would have to automatically recognise legal gender changes granted to an EU citizen in another member state when that person exercises their freedom of movement to the UK (likely to apply to family members/partners and dependants with a legal gender change in future as well, including non-EU family members - similar to other derived rights). Plus the EU would likely put pressure on us to amend the Equality Act 2010 before rejoining - since the 2025 Supreme Court interpretation on biological sex diverges from EU gender equality law, free movement and fundamental rights.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 21:13

Imdunfer · Yesterday 20:21

That is not what I read from

"This directly forces states to honor legal recognition in cross-border scenarios".

Because you don't understand the case. It's about a Bulgarian national unable to gain the rights/privileges available to him as a resident of Italy, where there is some degree of gender recognition, because his documents issued by Bulgaria state that he is male and that is causing him issues in Italy. It's not about being able to move from Germany to Bulgaria as a man and say to the Bulgarian authorities "you have to recognise me as a woman because I have a gender certificate from another EU country".

It's a very specific scenario. Moreover, rejoining the EU would have no impact on the scenario you conjure up as an argument against joining the EU because the UK already recognises gender certificates from Germany and many other countries including non-EU countries. The UK still recognises gender recognition certificates from other countries that aren't on the list below, it simply requires further documentation.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/gender-recognition-certificate-list-of-approved-countries-and-territories/gender-recognition-certificate-list-of-approved-countries-and-territories

Gender Recognition Certificate: list of approved countries and territories

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/gender-recognition-certificate-list-of-approved-countries-and-territories/gender-recognition-certificate-list-of-approved-countries-and-territories

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 20:56

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 16:58

I voted Remian, but with no great emotional involvement in the whole toxic debate of that time. I can see that the EU brought some obvious benefits in terms of trade and shared resources, but I don't think it is the nirvana/promised land that many seem to feel it is. Many of the major euro zone countries ( including Germany and France - its original signatories) have all sorts of problems now that they did not have even then, and personally I don't trust to leave many of our social/cultural issues in the hands of un-elected bureaucrats in Brussels - many of whom are issuing diktats on 'gender', for example, that I really don't agree with.

Edited

Which "unelected bureaucrats" are issuing "diktats" on gender?

Imdunfer · Yesterday 20:21

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 20:08

It means what it says: if a Bulgarian man gets a gender recognition certificate in another EU state then Bulgaria has to recognise the documents or gender marker changes obtained in another EU member state. It does not mean that a Bulgarian man can use a document obtained in another EU member state to claim he is legally a woman in Bulgaria and should therefore be able to use women's spaces. Just as having a gender recognition certificate in the UK doesn't mean a man can use women's spaces.

This judgment does not oblige EU member states to recognise the rights/privileges acquired by nationals of other EU member states. It pertains to their own citizens.

A German man who says he is a woman can get a gender recognition certificate in Germany anyway. He can't take it to Bulgaria and then say "Bulgaria has to recognise me as a woman".

This judgment would have little effect if the UK were to rejoin the EU as the UK already has a gender recognition process, gender reassignment is a protected characteristic, and the UK would already currently - as far as I'm aware - recognise a German man with a gender recognition certifiate moving to the UK as a woman.

That is not what I read from

"This directly forces states to honor legal recognition in cross-border scenarios".

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 20:08

Imdunfer · Yesterday 16:22

What do you think "transfer rights acquired in one EU state to other states" means if it doesn't mean what I have illustrated?

Google says

"Impact on Member States: The ruling means countries that do not have domestic self-identification or easy legal gender recognition (LGR) procedures—such as Bulgaria, Hungary, Romania, and Slovakia—are legally barred from refusing to recognise documents or gender changes lawfully obtained by their citizens in another EU country. This directly forces states to honor legal recognition in cross-border scenarios, even if their internal laws remain restrictive".

Their internal laws can still prevent men from using women's spaces but this rule means that they are legally women and therefore can use those spaces. A Bulgarian man cannot become a woman but a German man who says he is one, is one.

Edited

It means what it says: if a Bulgarian man gets a gender recognition certificate in another EU state then Bulgaria has to recognise the documents or gender marker changes obtained in another EU member state. It does not mean that a Bulgarian man can use a document obtained in another EU member state to claim he is legally a woman in Bulgaria and should therefore be able to use women's spaces. Just as having a gender recognition certificate in the UK doesn't mean a man can use women's spaces.

This judgment does not oblige EU member states to recognise the rights/privileges acquired by nationals of other EU member states. It pertains to their own citizens.

A German man who says he is a woman can get a gender recognition certificate in Germany anyway. He can't take it to Bulgaria and then say "Bulgaria has to recognise me as a woman".

This judgment would have little effect if the UK were to rejoin the EU as the UK already has a gender recognition process, gender reassignment is a protected characteristic, and the UK would already currently - as far as I'm aware - recognise a German man with a gender recognition certifiate moving to the UK as a woman.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 19:10

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 16:58

I voted Remian, but with no great emotional involvement in the whole toxic debate of that time. I can see that the EU brought some obvious benefits in terms of trade and shared resources, but I don't think it is the nirvana/promised land that many seem to feel it is. Many of the major euro zone countries ( including Germany and France - its original signatories) have all sorts of problems now that they did not have even then, and personally I don't trust to leave many of our social/cultural issues in the hands of un-elected bureaucrats in Brussels - many of whom are issuing diktats on 'gender', for example, that I really don't agree with.

Edited

Same agree on this. It’s looking different now ten years later. I voted remain so no investment in voting the other way.

NorthXNorthWest · Yesterday 17:17

alcovecupboards · 01/10/2026 22:06

Who died as a result of Self-ID in Ireland? There must be hundreds, surely?

Women are entitled to biological sex based rights. Women actually died to get them.

moto748e · Yesterday 17:11

Sadly, we have our own un-elected bureaucrats in the UK issuing diktats on 'gender', But yeah, we don't need more.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 17:04

I'll reserve judgement until after I hear Andy's speech, and seeing his actions after the speech. Words are just words. He apparently is not intending to break manifesto pledges about freedom of movement, etc, but politicians always break manifesto promises if it's expedient and they think they can get away with it. So, we'll see if this leads anywhere.

I was just grimly amused by his use of "emperor's new clothes" seemingly without irony at all. He's such a weasel.

OP posts:
Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 16:58

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 15:35

What are its more problematical features? That it passed a judgment in a very narrow area that has pretty much zero impact in the real world? This judgment imposes no obligations on EU member states to pass any laws regarding gender ideology. Moreover, it offers that individual exactly the same "rights" as if he were in the UK, where the Gender Recognition Act is in force.

Perhaps you are heavily invested in opposing the EU and so have taken this small issue, misunderstood it and blown it out of proportion?

Still waiting for the actual EU laws that enforce gender self-ID, men in women's prisons and puberty blockers for kids on all EU member states. Please link to those laws, if they exist.

I voted Remian, but with no great emotional involvement in the whole toxic debate of that time. I can see that the EU brought some obvious benefits in terms of trade and shared resources, but I don't think it is the nirvana/promised land that many seem to feel it is. Many of the major euro zone countries ( including Germany and France - its original signatories) have all sorts of problems now that they did not have even then, and personally I don't trust to leave many of our social/cultural issues in the hands of un-elected bureaucrats in Brussels - many of whom are issuing diktats on 'gender', for example, that I really don't agree with.

AstonCanKissMyArse · Yesterday 16:32

JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 16:17

Besides, isn't it already the case that a German man with the equivalent of a gender recognition certificate move to the United Kingdom and be recognised as a woman?

This is not the case. The UK only recognises GRCs from other countries (or parts of those states) where the Gender Recognition process is at least as vigorous as that in the UK.

And as FWS confirmed, having a GRC doesn't entitle a man to be treated as a woman for all purposes.

Ie it doesn't matter which country awarded your GRC, you still can't wave it about to access women's services.

If we were back in the EU though there would be more pressure to accept EU documents.

It might not make a lot of difference to gender recognition in UK law, but its bound to make some, and personally I don't want any more risk to women's rights than we're currently facing.

Re the comment about referrenda in the USA - we're not the USA. The UK has a very different political landscape. Another EU referendum (or worse, simply deciding to ignore the previous one) would tear this country apart. What Nigel Farrage would or wouldn't have done 10 years ago is irrelevant, as is using that as some kind of moral compass.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 16:22

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 11:17

This is about being able to transfer rights acquired in one EU state to other states. It's not an EU law obligating self-ID in member states nor does it oblige EU member states to change their laws to adopt gender self-ID.

It's a crap ruling but it's very marginal and applies only in the case of individuals. I don't see the newspapers in Bulgaria referring to violent men who attack women as "she", as the endlessly do in the UK, nor do I see Bulgaria adopting gender self-ID laws.

Still waiting for the links to EU laws passed by the Commission, Council and parliament that oblige EU member states to adopt laws on gender self-ID.

What do you think "transfer rights acquired in one EU state to other states" means if it doesn't mean what I have illustrated?

Google says

"Impact on Member States: The ruling means countries that do not have domestic self-identification or easy legal gender recognition (LGR) procedures—such as Bulgaria, Hungary, Romania, and Slovakia—are legally barred from refusing to recognise documents or gender changes lawfully obtained by their citizens in another EU country. This directly forces states to honor legal recognition in cross-border scenarios, even if their internal laws remain restrictive".

Their internal laws can still prevent men from using women's spaces but this rule means that they are legally women and therefore can use those spaces. A Bulgarian man cannot become a woman but a German man who says he is one, is one.

JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 16:17

Besides, isn't it already the case that a German man with the equivalent of a gender recognition certificate move to the United Kingdom and be recognised as a woman?

This is not the case. The UK only recognises GRCs from other countries (or parts of those states) where the Gender Recognition process is at least as vigorous as that in the UK.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 16:08

Imdunfer · Yesterday 14:39

Stop making light of the cross border problems, please. They do impact women in the countries which don't accept that female identified trans people are women.

How does a Bulgarian woman insist on her right to single sex spaces, clubs and sport when the German man who lives next door or works in the same office has self ID as a woman and the EU says must be treated in every respect legally as if they were a woman?

That's not what that judgement says. It's about an EU national from a country without gender recognition, in this case Bulgaria, seeking ID documentation from his home country so that he can reside in a country that does have gender recognition (in this case, Italy, I believe) and have ID (issued by his home country) with the "gender" marker that he is recognised as in the country of residence so he can use it in that country, which does recognise his gender identity. It doesn't oblige Bulgaria to recognise gender on German ID - or a UK passport, when the UK was in the EU.

You completely misunderstood that judgement if you think it says (let alone "the EU says") that a German man can self-ID as a woman and be treated legally as a woman in every respect in Bulgaria. It doesn't.

Besides, isn't it already the case that a German man with the equivalent of a gender recognition certificate move to the United Kingdom and be recognised as a woman? Although, as we also know, that doesn't mean he can use the women's loos at work or be treated legally as a woman in every respect. Because while a country may issue gender recognition certificates and change gender markers on passports and ID, it can also restrict activity based on biological sex.

So, no, that judgment doesn't mean what you think it does.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 15:35

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 12:13

Is it that you are very invested in the idea of the EU and therefore willing to over-look its more probelmatical features, or is it that you are very invested in gender identity as a concept that has legal protection such as exist in many EU countries?

Edited

What are its more problematical features? That it passed a judgment in a very narrow area that has pretty much zero impact in the real world? This judgment imposes no obligations on EU member states to pass any laws regarding gender ideology. Moreover, it offers that individual exactly the same "rights" as if he were in the UK, where the Gender Recognition Act is in force.

Perhaps you are heavily invested in opposing the EU and so have taken this small issue, misunderstood it and blown it out of proportion?

Still waiting for the actual EU laws that enforce gender self-ID, men in women's prisons and puberty blockers for kids on all EU member states. Please link to those laws, if they exist.