Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The Law Is the Law. So Why Is Everyone Choosing Which Bits to Obey?

36 replies

IwantToRetire · 22/09/2026 18:35

This could belong in the Green thread and the Lib Dem thread. And many others - sadly.

... Women have a right to single-sex spaces. The law says so. The court says so. The regulator says so. A right that women must sue to enforce, one hospital at a time, at their own expense, while ministers say “imminently” and parties vote to repeal it by motion, is not a right. It is a privilege extended to those who can find a KC.

Publish the NHS guidance, date it and make it binding. Tell every trust that a policy allowing access by self-identification cannot survive the Supreme Court judgment, because Darlington has already shown what happens when one tries. Tell the unions that their duty is to their female members, not to a campaign against a ruling.

The Greens, Sir Ed Davey and the Liberal Democrats remain perfectly entitled to argue that Parliament should change the Equality Act. Trade unions are entitled to campaign for the same thing. That is democracy. Until Parliament changes the statute, however, organisations governed by it do not acquire an exemption because they dislike the judgment interpreting it. You may campaign to change the law. You may not pretend it is not there.

The law is the law. Women had to win it in the highest court in the land. They should not have to win it again in every changing room in Britain.

https://heartlandstribune.com/the-law-is-the-law-so-why-is-everyone-choosing-which-bits-to-obey/

Lib dems EHRC Code

The Law Is The Law. So Why Is Everyone Choosing Which Bits To Obey? - The Heartlands Tribune

Start where the law is supposed to bite: a hospital changing room. Last week two of the Darlington nurses who beat their NHS trust at tribunal sat down with

https://heartlandstribune.com/the-law-is-the-law-so-why-is-everyone-choosing-which-bits-to-obey/

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GrumpyPanda · 29/09/2026 16:47

Speaking of the suffragettes, can't resist adding this oldie but goodie:

The Law Is the Law. So Why Is Everyone Choosing Which Bits to Obey?
Dragonasaurus · 29/09/2026 15:45

Dbank · 29/09/2026 10:51

The OP raises an interesting point, and I believe it has become normalised to ignore the laws you don't agree with, as so many now aren't enforced and widely ignored.

See also the issues in N Ireland on Sunday, with MP’s encouraging people to join an illegal protest.

How single sex spaces should be enforced has always been a RRA argument - but really, everyone knows what sex they are, so they absolutely know if they are breaking social conventions (and let’s face it, some people enjoy precisely that)

iwishitwouldstartraining · 29/09/2026 11:05

PollyNomial · 29/09/2026 10:42

I have different concerns with both the second and third examples:

The signage could be fake and the overalls a costume; it could be opening up oneself to danger from 2+ males to accept their assertions without checking.

The third sounds like he may be a risk because his thinking is a little "unusual" and don't know what he might do next.

In the second option it's possible to check with whoever is in charge of the space, which is as much as can reasonably be expected in a public toilet.

The third option - the man who won't leave because he thinks he has a right to be there - is rather unusual, but isn't he the example that you are using?

I agree that the possibility of criminal charges doesn't arise from simply entering a space where you shouldn't be, but from the actions taken when made aware that you shouldn't be there.

It would also raise suspicion if somebody habitually attempted to use or enter a facility from which they were excluded, whether or not that was because of a protected characteristic.

Dbank · 29/09/2026 10:51

The OP raises an interesting point, and I believe it has become normalised to ignore the laws you don't agree with, as so many now aren't enforced and widely ignored.

PollyNomial · 29/09/2026 10:42

iwishitwouldstartraining · 29/09/2026 10:03

And how one reliably assesses deliberation in lieu of a confession/psychic powers (to a degree that has never been demonstrated) needs explanation.

A. Sorry, this is the ladies.
B. Oh my goodness I'm so sorry, I didn't realise! (leaves)

A: Sorry, this is the ladies.
B: Sorry to alarm you, but there is a sign outside. We are fixing the broken loo.

A: Sorry, this is the ladies
B: I know and I'm staying because it isn't actually against the criminal law for me to use this toilet.

It's a tricky one, but I think one of these people might be more of a concern than the others...

I have different concerns with both the second and third examples:

The signage could be fake and the overalls a costume; it could be opening up oneself to danger from 2+ males to accept their assertions without checking.

The third sounds like he may be a risk because his thinking is a little "unusual" and don't know what he might do next.

iwishitwouldstartraining · 29/09/2026 10:03

PollyNomial · 27/09/2026 21:45

Or they could be the cleaner, a paramedic, a police officer, a plumber/maintenance, ...
All of them can deliberately and legitimately walk into the "wrong toilets" without it being an offence.

And how one reliably assesses deliberation in lieu of a confession/psychic powers (to a degree that has never been demonstrated) needs explanation.

Edited

And how one reliably assesses deliberation in lieu of a confession/psychic powers (to a degree that has never been demonstrated) needs explanation.

A. Sorry, this is the ladies.
B. Oh my goodness I'm so sorry, I didn't realise! (leaves)

A: Sorry, this is the ladies.
B: Sorry to alarm you, but there is a sign outside. We are fixing the broken loo.

A: Sorry, this is the ladies
B: I know and I'm staying because it isn't actually against the criminal law for me to use this toilet.

It's a tricky one, but I think one of these people might be more of a concern than the others...

Treaclewell · 29/09/2026 09:29

PriOn1 · 27/09/2026 17:55

A lot of good posts so far, but one of the significant factors must be that a group of people with a huge sense of entitlement were told that they were entitled to exactly what they wanted over several years. Because some of them tend towards narcissism anyway, they are very much enjoying the power it gives them over women.

It’s obvious they still have the upper hand as many who should be enforcing the law were intensively schooled by transactivists before the ruling, but women’s groups don’t have the same reach as, say, Stonewall. Films in railway stations and so on, make it clear some of those who ought to intervene still don’t think they can. Many others don’t want to because telling a male narcissist to get out of women’s spaces is far more risky than telling the women they’re just going to have to put up with it.

It’s a perfect storm really, as with the wider spread of transactivism, where an incredible number of factors have allowed reach that no previous “rights” grab could have managed.

I recall being taught, in the context of protest, that morally, if someone felt driven to break the law in pursuit of changing ir (think suffragettes) they could, but must be prepared to take the consequences.
So where are the consequences.for these men and their enablers?

PollyNomial · 29/09/2026 09:28

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 28/09/2026 06:26

You're being deliberately obtuse.

Edited

Pointing out that the world isn't as simplistic as some misleadingly portray it, isn't being obtuse. Reality is awkward.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 28/09/2026 06:26

PollyNomial · 27/09/2026 21:45

Or they could be the cleaner, a paramedic, a police officer, a plumber/maintenance, ...
All of them can deliberately and legitimately walk into the "wrong toilets" without it being an offence.

And how one reliably assesses deliberation in lieu of a confession/psychic powers (to a degree that has never been demonstrated) needs explanation.

Edited

You're being deliberately obtuse.

Helleofabore · 27/09/2026 23:10

Maybe Pingpong

Or they could try the other false whataboutery and claim to be male children who need to come with their mother or carer. That was the two Whatabout points we kept seeing. ‘Whatabout cleaners and ambulance personnel’ and ‘whatabout male children’.

Pingponghavoc · 27/09/2026 23:04

Maybe, for their next trick, men who want to be seen as women will instead pretend to be professional with legitimate reason to be in women's spaces?

Helleofabore · 27/09/2026 22:23

Male people entering the female single sex provision to work, will generally have signage up to warn female people that a male person is inside. Unless it is an emergency first responder when there may not be time to put a sign up. These are exceptional circumstances.

It is a generally weak argument to use male people who are working in a female single sex provision as a comparative situation to any type of access of male people who demand to use the female single sex provision.

PollyNomial · 27/09/2026 21:45

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 27/09/2026 20:09

If a man deliberately walks into the ladies because he's claiming he's entitled to, that could be an offence. His intent was to flout the law, his act is deliberate it could be seen as a public order offence.

Or they could be the cleaner, a paramedic, a police officer, a plumber/maintenance, ...
All of them can deliberately and legitimately walk into the "wrong toilets" without it being an offence.

And how one reliably assesses deliberation in lieu of a confession/psychic powers (to a degree that has never been demonstrated) needs explanation.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 27/09/2026 20:09

If a man deliberately walks into the ladies because he's claiming he's entitled to, that could be an offence. His intent was to flout the law, his act is deliberate it could be seen as a public order offence.

PollyNomial · 27/09/2026 18:04

Apollo441 · 22/09/2026 23:18

A transwoman using a woman's toilet is breaking the law. Not criminal but civil and should be asked to leave. They are also denying women's rights to a single sex provision. Hardly seems reasonable

A service provider that advertises facilities by sex and doesn't take reasonable steps to enforce this is breaking the law, the individuals who ignore the service providers signage etc are not.

As it is, a woman can walk into the gents (and the reverse) without breaking any criminal law unless they do something on top of merely walking through the doorway; social conditioning usually ensures such action doesn't happen frequently.

PriOn1 · 27/09/2026 17:55

A lot of good posts so far, but one of the significant factors must be that a group of people with a huge sense of entitlement were told that they were entitled to exactly what they wanted over several years. Because some of them tend towards narcissism anyway, they are very much enjoying the power it gives them over women.

It’s obvious they still have the upper hand as many who should be enforcing the law were intensively schooled by transactivists before the ruling, but women’s groups don’t have the same reach as, say, Stonewall. Films in railway stations and so on, make it clear some of those who ought to intervene still don’t think they can. Many others don’t want to because telling a male narcissist to get out of women’s spaces is far more risky than telling the women they’re just going to have to put up with it.

It’s a perfect storm really, as with the wider spread of transactivism, where an incredible number of factors have allowed reach that no previous “rights” grab could have managed.

Rhamnusia · 27/09/2026 04:00

alcovecupboards · 22/09/2026 23:06

Perhaps you don't understand how we got our rights in the first place. It wasn't polite conversation - it was acts of terror. Which are and were against the law. A trans woman using the women's loo is hardly comparable to that.

I think it’s going to be funny when these trans women get their privileges to invade women’s spaces as much as they want, and the spaces just end up being full of men. Not a woman in sight. We’ll use our own toilets and find our own spaces. And if you think that trans-women should just keep invading every space we make? Well… that’s very colonial, to say the least.
Ah, the urge of man to spread his seed and dominate every corner of the earth.

And yeah, maybe that won’t happen for a while, plenty of women support trans women right now. But when these cis women realize the implications of what they’ve supported, and how actually they’ve willingly opened up their space to ALL genders, including men, they’ll start rethinking their kindness.

When men can go wherever women are, without any consent or repercussions, these bleeding hearts will realize what they’ve done, and they’ll have to hide like the rest of us. Does that make you happy?
Do you feel good?

Women in our past fought for sex-segregated spaces for a reason.

nutmeg7 · 23/09/2026 18:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 23/09/2026 12:16

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 23/09/2026 05:25

Claiming to be the new gay didn't work, so now they're claiming to be the new suffragettes. Comparing the 'trans' activities to the actions of the suffragettes is their newest and best appropriation of all things to do with women.

I think the disregard for the law is another sign of societal breakdown, a country of millions can only function if there's trust, trust in the government, the state, the law, one another. The trust works if you don't question the details, but take it on faith that everyone is doing their bit. Once the trust is gone, the details become apparent, the cracks and faults become obvious, they inevitably widen and like a sinkhole it all caves in.

Edited

What "new" next?
New anorexics?
New autists?
New dyslexics?
New left handers?
How about new AGPs?
When it comes to girls who historically never existed as any tangible group in claiming they were boys, maybe they're just New victims?

MarieDeGournay · 23/09/2026 12:10

Helleofabore · 23/09/2026 07:56

Yeah. The comparison with the suffrage movement and the movement to leverage male people into accessing female single sex provisions doesn’t work on many levels.

It is another flawed analogy being made because a group wishes to force team with other rights movements for credibility and immediate emotional acceptance.

As has been said in so many ways, the group have got the same human rights as all other groups. They are demanding additional privileges while gaslighting others that they see asking for basic human rights.

I agree.
The violent methods employed by the Suffrage movement were a last resort when centuries of arguing and campaigning for women's basic rights had been ignored.

Violence by trans activists is nearer to a first resort by a recently-constituted group who already have the same rights as anyone else.

edited to say 'I agree...' at the beginning of my post!

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 23/09/2026 11:44

As I've said before, Farage can look at all this and follow the law his way of he gains power. The left will have no leg to stand on if they try the "rule of law" attack.

FuzzySlippers · 23/09/2026 09:17

Peoplesfrontofjudea2000 · 22/09/2026 22:47

I think it reflects 1. As a society we have stopped understanding that we are responsible for the laws that are passed in parliament by who we choose to vote into power. And we don’t scrutinise policies as we should do so we are then are surprised to find the laws that we don’t like are being enacted by politicians that we voted for. 2. I think politicians have also been duplicitous by adding amendments to laws and not being transparent about the reason why they piggybacked these onto laws that would be passed so that the amendment can avoid scrutiny or challenge.3. There is poor journalism and the media does not scrutinise parliament in any deptH. 4. Politicians seem feel that they do not have to follow the law if they do not agree with it, whilst taking no responsibility for the law being there in the first place or accepting the law has been passed by a Democratic process. 5. there is a lack of trust in institutions which and leaves of government and there’s also been quite a lot of undermining of the judiciary as well. There’s been a move towards feelings or court of opinion. Being more important than the truth and due process.

Edited

Excellent post

Helleofabore · 23/09/2026 07:56

iwishitwouldstartraining · 23/09/2026 07:44

It’s debatable whether militant action helped women to get the vote or alienated potential supporters and plenty of suffragists opposed law breaking.

However, suffragettes (obviously) didn’t have the right to participate in democracy.

In contrast, actual MPs with the power to propose legislation in parliament have not come up with an alternative to the current law.

Yeah. The comparison with the suffrage movement and the movement to leverage male people into accessing female single sex provisions doesn’t work on many levels.

It is another flawed analogy being made because a group wishes to force team with other rights movements for credibility and immediate emotional acceptance.

As has been said in so many ways, the group have got the same human rights as all other groups. They are demanding additional privileges while gaslighting others that they see asking for basic human rights.

iwishitwouldstartraining · 23/09/2026 07:44

It’s debatable whether militant action helped women to get the vote or alienated potential supporters and plenty of suffragists opposed law breaking.

However, suffragettes (obviously) didn’t have the right to participate in democracy.

In contrast, actual MPs with the power to propose legislation in parliament have not come up with an alternative to the current law.

Helleofabore · 23/09/2026 07:14

I think there is also the factor of focus on the individual vs the collective segment of the population. A person’s conceptualisation of themselves as being the opposite sex to their body’s material reality is very personal and it is individual. This is individualism as opposed to campaigning for the needs of female people to be given equal opportunity compared to male people which is collective in nature.

Of course, the campaign female people to be given equal opportunity compared to male people is also one based in the collective group’s material reality not based purely on subjective reality.

Swipe left for the next trending thread