Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Fonagy report due this week

66 replies

WarriorN · 21/09/2026 21:13

This is the government review into mental health, ADHD and autism for children in the U.K.

The interim report is here:

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/independent-review-into-mental-health-conditions-adhd-and-autism-interim-report/independent-review-into-mental-health-conditions-adhd-and-autism-interim-report

bbc report here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cqzrz0z4plk1o?app-referrer=deep-link

There is a clip / interview on Facebook from bbc breakfast with him. I’ve attached the screenshot

This is relevant to this board as it sits alongside the Cass review and mirrors how there has been an explosion of teens referred to GD services in the past decade.

Young woman looks out of her bedroom window

Young people are not snowflakes, head of mental health review says

Speaking exclusively to the BBC, Prof Peter Fonagy says being young is much harder now than it was.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cqzrz0z4plk1o?app-referrer=deep-link

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Obviousquestion · 28/09/2026 17:22

Completely agree

Wishesandhorses · 28/09/2026 17:18

DidAnyoneSeeMyGlassess · 28/09/2026 15:58

In my experience, ADHD was no considered a disability several years ago, even by those assessing. It shifted 2-3 years ago with an increase in adult assessments. I stepped away from assessments as I felt things are being missed and mislabeled, and I did not want to take part in it.

I listened to Naomi's podcast, and there were some really valid points.

I think many families aren't bothered what it's called - and wait years for a label anyway - it's that at present many find unless there's a label there's nothing they can stand on to get help. What is badly needed is help to meet actual need, regardless of what it's called. Families dealing with children so distressed they're harming themselves or other family members, dealing with hours and hours of dysregulation, who can't face going into school any more, or who don't really sleep so the family hasn't slept in years just want help. Not half an hour group meeting or a few anxiety tips, or a suggested parenting course when the parents can parent perfectly well, but actual, proper resources, especially for early years and primary. There is no crisis team in my area that helps with anyone under secondary age.

StillSpartacus · 28/09/2026 16:21

WarriorN · 21/09/2026 21:19

From what I have read of leaks there will be a move away from chasing diagnosis as a first step and looking at immediate need for distressed and struggling children and putting certain things in to place earlier on, rather than waiting 3 years for a diagnosis which will only lead to doing exactly the same things, but 3 years later. During which time a lot of damage occurs.

I work on the health side of this, and these are broadly my concerns too. One of the very best parts of my job, is when we are able to treat a child successfully and see the difference to their confidence, learning, wellbeing, family life, behaviour and emotional regulation. It can be the difference between a child on the brink of expulsion doing well at school, or a family on the edge being able to enjoy quality time together.

We know the problems with overwhelming referrals, but we also know that for most, successful treatment involves stimulant medication combined with non-pharmacological therapies and support. More worryingly, we also know the outcomes for children who don’t get the right support, are far worse as adults in terms of relationships, work, addiction, health and contact with criminal justice.

Kicking the can down the road, might seem to be politically expedient right now, in the face of concerns about the rising welfare bill, but delayed assessments are inevitably going to cost - and cost dear - in future.

Obviousquestion · 28/09/2026 16:19

I’m surprised that in the BBC clip Fonagy mentions uncertainty over the future, online comparison, lack of community interaction/belonging and recovery (sleep, exercise) as factors in adolescent poor mental health (all can arise as presenting or exacerbating issues/anxieties) but he makes no reference to early caregiving and parenting. This lays foundations (robust or not) for all children and seems to be the elephant in the room. Most parents try their hardest for their children but issues in adolescence commonly stem from how the child is handled early on, and how s/he sees and experiences the world as a result. Parents need help, support, education and incentives to get it right in the early years.

DidAnyoneSeeMyGlassess · 28/09/2026 15:58

WarriorN · 28/09/2026 06:24

I’ve spent some time listening to Naomi Fisher’s podcasts around adhd but also other things. The one on dyslexia was interesting- not least as the interviewee works in the schizophrenia field.

the discussion is wide, balanced but evidence based and informative.

A key theme is that in particular with adhd, it doesn’t necessarily mean “it” is life long. Which has implications for things like drugs and pip. In the past adhd was only a childhood issue. I’m also well aware that some children diagnosed with autism at a very early age and given a lot of SALT support can do so well that they wouldn’t pass an autism diagnosis as adults.

The other issue is that psychiatric diagnoses - which these are - are observed behaviour. As such subjective. ADHD has apparently been long contested and is hard to distinguish between other issues such as early trauma, the impact of DV etc.

wrt conditions such as dyslexia they’re starting to not diagnose this but identify children struggling and use a lot of resources to give early consistent and ongoing intervention. Also tailored to the precise issue they’re having, reading, writing/ spelling and/ or maths. Some children simply need more time and better more visual ways to learn. All are always hyper aware they they can’t and this creates anxiety which is in itself a barrier to learning.

Why are so many teenagers on benefits for ADHD?

https://www.thetimes.com/article/444cad96-8ba7-43d3-861c-00265c84b435?shareToken=9bfb78afd0645ceeba7684f64b007c4a

In my experience, ADHD was no considered a disability several years ago, even by those assessing. It shifted 2-3 years ago with an increase in adult assessments. I stepped away from assessments as I felt things are being missed and mislabeled, and I did not want to take part in it.

I listened to Naomi's podcast, and there were some really valid points.

Multibarpack · 28/09/2026 07:22

Motnight · 21/09/2026 21:55

Yes, I believe the emphasis is going to be on needs led support. The Government's response will be interesting - a lot of money will be needed to do this well

Support is already meant to be needs based, not diagnosis based.

It is interesting seeing the proposed changes to SEND in England which looks to bring it more in line with Scotland where pretty much the only legal route for forcing support is disability discrimination under the Equality Act.

WarriorN · 28/09/2026 06:35

ArabellaScott · 22/09/2026 06:18

And crucial but easily ignored phrase 'on average'

As a total aside I started reading the chimp paradox week and it’s very clear about sex differences in how “inner chimp” comes out between men and women. It’s also very clear that this is on average and sets out the reasoning very clearly.

Notably the focus on how women become more anxious under pressure and stress and the evolutionary reasoning for this. Talks about fight flight or freeze. Etc

OP posts:
WarriorN · 28/09/2026 06:24

I’ve spent some time listening to Naomi Fisher’s podcasts around adhd but also other things. The one on dyslexia was interesting- not least as the interviewee works in the schizophrenia field.

the discussion is wide, balanced but evidence based and informative.

A key theme is that in particular with adhd, it doesn’t necessarily mean “it” is life long. Which has implications for things like drugs and pip. In the past adhd was only a childhood issue. I’m also well aware that some children diagnosed with autism at a very early age and given a lot of SALT support can do so well that they wouldn’t pass an autism diagnosis as adults.

The other issue is that psychiatric diagnoses - which these are - are observed behaviour. As such subjective. ADHD has apparently been long contested and is hard to distinguish between other issues such as early trauma, the impact of DV etc.

wrt conditions such as dyslexia they’re starting to not diagnose this but identify children struggling and use a lot of resources to give early consistent and ongoing intervention. Also tailored to the precise issue they’re having, reading, writing/ spelling and/ or maths. Some children simply need more time and better more visual ways to learn. All are always hyper aware they they can’t and this creates anxiety which is in itself a barrier to learning.

Why are so many teenagers on benefits for ADHD?

https://www.thetimes.com/article/444cad96-8ba7-43d3-861c-00265c84b435?shareToken=9bfb78afd0645ceeba7684f64b007c4a

OP posts:
BetweenTheThoughts · 27/09/2026 17:09

This is an important area for discussion, particularly given the significant rise in ADHD and autism referrals and waiting lists in recent years. The interim review highlights how complex these trends are, with increased service demand alongside uncertainty around underlying prevalence.

Motnight · 22/09/2026 14:57

Unfortunately past experience suggests that it might be 😔

BetweenTheThoughts · 22/09/2026 14:48

An important discussion that highlights the need for better understanding, accurate assessment, and timely support for children and young people. Behind every referral is an individual experience, so improving access to appropriate care should remain the focus.

13RidgmontRoad · 22/09/2026 12:56

I’m smiling to myself as Fonagy and David Bell were my uni lecturers together a million years ago.

I generally have a lot of time for Fonagy; he does all sorts of interesting work and has been at the coalface of his profession for decades.

DidAnyoneSeeMyGlassess · 22/09/2026 12:51

I'm partly in favour, as we cannot continue to diagnose in those numbers in the absence of postdiagnostic support, and the higher the diagnosis numbers, the less support will be available overall. There is no point spending money on assessing if there is none left for follow up support.

I believe however there is also a fair degree of sexism in the way neurodivergence - or assessments - functions in practice. Maybe because of my personal experience. Men are statistically more likely to act out distress (rather than internalise it as women tend to) in a way that's socially problematic to others. I'm tired being asked to be kind and understanding of males who are unpredictable or aggressive and who may or may not be autistic or ADHD.

Imnobody4 · 22/09/2026 10:56

This starts earlier than teens. Childhood has changed completely. Children no longer play freely without adult supervision. They can't develop the interpersonal skills involved in solving disagreements. Not allowed to take calculated risks.
They don't walk to school alone. Can't build up the self confidence required to meet challenges. I used to ride my bike around alone or with friends. Not possible now even on country roads.

We've built an environment that works against children thriving and growing into independent adults. We really need to focus on younger children's resilience and confidence.

NImumconfused · 22/09/2026 10:02

WarriorN · 21/09/2026 21:19

From what I have read of leaks there will be a move away from chasing diagnosis as a first step and looking at immediate need for distressed and struggling children and putting certain things in to place earlier on, rather than waiting 3 years for a diagnosis which will only lead to doing exactly the same things, but 3 years later. During which time a lot of damage occurs.

Or, as in our experience, you wait three years for a diagnosis and then there's no help available anyway.

There is no version of solving this problem that doesn't involve putting a lot more money into providing support, and unfortunately I don't think it's very likely that an appropriate level of funding will be forthcoming.

WarriorN · 22/09/2026 08:08

I work in send. I see all sides. There’s a fundamental issue with education right now.

OP posts:
Wishesandhorses · 22/09/2026 07:42

Mmn.

This is a girder in the campaign to radically cut SEND funding for schools. My guess it will be rather like care in the community; in that it'll sound a good idea in theory (big, cold, badly run hospitals, institutionalisation, isolation, etc etc, wouldn't it be so lovely to have community provided care where people live) - and then turns out that there is no 'care' to be in the community, very little actual resources, just the person and community left without anything and required to find a way to manage. But it's going to sound absolutely lovely on paper.

Step one of this will be to devalue those working in SEND and suggest they're all madly over diagnosing for funsies (while actually working from the relatively decent documentation etc from the Blair Labour govt which did, actually, care and do things for this section of society, children and adults)
Then to discredit diagnoses a lot so the public stop having any respect for them and start expecting those with diagnoses to be hypochondriacs/just get on with it
Then to identify other things it could possibly be instead such as lack of exercise, diet, screens, mental health support, parenting styles, all of which would have a point and be really key to look at - but won't involve any actual proper research and certainly no action
It certainly won't be to look at why schools are becoming increasingly somewhere many children can't cope, or think about changing the fundamental issues

This is about removing funding and support from SEND children and getting society primed and messaged not to sympathise with the families and school staff that are going to be left high and dry, unable to cope, so when the outcry starts, there won't be public support for them. It's money driven, not child/need driven.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 22/09/2026 07:28

Thank you. This looks really important. Wonder how influential it will be?

WarriorN · 22/09/2026 07:17

We’ve a generation of children for whom this hasn’t happened. They are now young adults. NEETS. The interim report stated that society had not been very good at telling these kids what actually helps them.

OP posts:
WarriorN · 22/09/2026 07:16

But they won’t be prepared to recognise how much funding and cross societal support it will need.

It’s essentially a very leftist, holistic approach designed to avoid pathologicalisation as much as possible and help people help themselves. (Obviously not the children, children rely on adults to make sure this happens for them.)

OP posts:
WarriorN · 22/09/2026 07:13

It’s extremely radical and a big risk.

Ironically I feel those who support reform etc will agree with a lot of the main findings and suggestions.

OP posts:
dreamingofgoodhair · 22/09/2026 06:58

Motnight · 21/09/2026 21:55

Yes, I believe the emphasis is going to be on needs led support. The Government's response will be interesting - a lot of money will be needed to do this well

this will need huge funding and resources, the MH provision in England is dire , I hope this won’t be the same.

WarriorN · 22/09/2026 06:37

From what I’ve seen in recent bbc press is that it’s starting to be taken more seriously so it’s worth seeking out any advice from gp - there could be a hypermobility service locally on the nhs

OP posts:
WarriorN · 22/09/2026 06:36

What helped me as an adult is probably not what is going to help a child. The best person to help a child with hypermobility is an OT. Children also present very differently.

The OT we have at work has helped me recently via work she’s done with our hypermobile pupils!

The key thing is that it can be fully overcome as an adult, or it can be well managed and it’s only a chronic issue in some cases.

OP posts:
ItsPeggyOlson · 22/09/2026 06:28

@WarriorN sorry to pick up a point slightly away from the main topic, but would you mind sharing hypermobility resources? A physio I know advised me to try ChatGPT for help for my DC as it’s such a poorly understood condition but I haven’t yet gone down that route. Happy for you to DM if you are happy to share what helped, so as not to hijack this thread. Thanks.