Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Fonagy report due this week

66 replies

WarriorN · 21/09/2026 21:13

This is the government review into mental health, ADHD and autism for children in the U.K.

The interim report is here:

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/independent-review-into-mental-health-conditions-adhd-and-autism-interim-report/independent-review-into-mental-health-conditions-adhd-and-autism-interim-report

bbc report here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cqzrz0z4plk1o?app-referrer=deep-link

There is a clip / interview on Facebook from bbc breakfast with him. I’ve attached the screenshot

This is relevant to this board as it sits alongside the Cass review and mirrors how there has been an explosion of teens referred to GD services in the past decade.

Young woman looks out of her bedroom window

Young people are not snowflakes, head of mental health review says

Speaking exclusively to the BBC, Prof Peter Fonagy says being young is much harder now than it was.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cqzrz0z4plk1o?app-referrer=deep-link

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
8
Multibarpack · 16/10/2026 09:43

WarriorN · 09/10/2026 12:31

This is what I see over and over again.

Those with the greatest need are often least able to secure timely support

There is not much context in the picture itself but this statement is untrue. It is example of ignoring those who needs are actually greatest. Those with greatest needs DO get timely (though often inadequate) support because their needs are so great. A child with profound disability and high medical needs will have been receiving support from birth or they simply would no longer be alive. They will never receive a caution because they do not have capacity, nor the ability to do anything resulting in a caution.

Ignoring the group that actually have the greatest needs undermines the rest.

BetweenTheThoughts · 15/10/2026 21:01

This review highlights the need to understand rising referrals while ensuring children receive timely, evidence-based assessments and appropriate individualised support.

WarriorN · 09/10/2026 12:31

This is what I see over and over again.

Fonagy report due this week
OP posts:
OP posts:
WarriorN · 09/10/2026 11:44

Yes I agree.

Report out today apparently.

The diagnoses are worth nothing without the right system to support it. That’s what’s fucked. But if the system was “right” maybe so many kids wouldn’t need the diagnosis ….

OP posts:
Wishesandhorses · 07/10/2026 11:35

Really is what it needs to shift to. The diagnosis has its uses, but presenting needs are what should be met. Effectively. It's the 'diagnoses are rubbish now we can ignore the needs' spin and messaging that worries me. It would gel a bit too well with the EOTAS changes etc which are only about money and political beliefs, and not at all about children.

WarriorN · 07/10/2026 09:55

“Labels aren’t matching the needs.”

The later interview out of those two, around 16 mins in

OP posts:
WarriorN · 07/10/2026 09:27

I have taught children in a send school (MLD) who have no clear “diagnosis” of any sort.

We still provide the best of what they need.

OP posts:
OP posts:
WarriorN · 07/10/2026 09:25

The problem doesn’t lie solely in the child.

The system dictates what the child does and how they learn. The system is part of the problem.

all these diagnoses have fuzzy boundaries, the boundaries get re written but environmental factors feed into these boundaries.

these two recent episodes of dr Chris and xand explain it in more detail.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m003242k?partner=uk.co.bbc&origin=share-mobile

What's Up Docs? - How can we better understand neurodiversity? - BBC Sounds

Drs Chris and Xand van Tulleken explore the conversation around neurodiversity.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m003242k?partner=uk.co.bbc&origin=share-mobile

OP posts:
WarriorN · 07/10/2026 09:22

DrBlackbird · 03/10/2026 10:51

Likewise I’d be concerned about asserting that those with dyslexia can overcome it. That someone can learn to read with the right kind of help is indisputable, but that reading takes longer, makes more demands on cognitive processing and working memory and remains a disability when working alongside those without dyslexia is clear. I see this at the university all the time. Highly intelligent but nevertheless still struggling students because of the pace of learning. No time for consolidation, no time to reread complex papers can leave these students feeling they’re falling behind.

And theres a reason why young people aren’t getting enough exercise or enough sleep. Young autistic/adhd people, more males but enough females, are gaming because it provides the stimulation those brains seek. Tech firms are happy to build ever more stimulating and addictive games and technology using neuroscience and A/B testing to keep them online and make £££.

Ultimately, I don’t have faith in this government or Burnham’s cabinet to make the necessary policy changes our children with send need.

that’s the wrong way to frame it. It’s not overcoming.

Some children need to learn in a different way for longer to get to where most people are in reading, writing and maths. Some may not ever manage it but we can use technology and adjustments to support this. This is the approach taken in many (good) schools now for dyslexia, to the point where some children don’t need the diagnosis.

Just because many children CAN read and write and do mental maths at age 6 doesn’t mean they all can nor that really maybe they all should. As they’re not learning other skills such as organisational, emotional regulation, interpersonal relationships and gross physical things etc.

Because a capitalist society values literacy and numeracy above all others, that is how our exam and education system is structured.

OP posts:
DrBlackbird · 03/10/2026 13:12

ItsPeggyOlson · 03/10/2026 12:37

Thank you so much @DrBlackbird for the hypermobility resources - it is so kind of you to take the time to share these. Much appreciated.

And of course there are different subsets of hypermobility, some quite serious so it’s good to get clarity with a formal assessment.

IME, GPs are pretty unaware of this condition as there’s even still dispute within the medical community as to the existence of EDS.

DrBlackbird · 03/10/2026 13:08

StillSpartacus · 03/10/2026 12:42

Treatment for anxiety would usually begin with non-pharmacological therapy such as CBT, although for some children medication might be appropriate.

However my actual point is that for most children with ADHD and anxiety, medication doesn’t cause their anxiety. The anxiety was always there, but not necessarily picked up until they were calm enough for it to be noticeable.

I would agree with this. And I’d be sceptical that someone with adhd can engage sufficiently with CBT for it to make a difference. If only we could all experience the teaching methods used by Stephen Hawkins’ math teacher, I have no doubt we’d have far fewer struggling adhd/dyslexic students.

StillSpartacus · 03/10/2026 12:42

WarriorN · 01/10/2026 09:10

I’m confused with this concept.

Are you suggesting that the anxiety is then treated with more drugs?

As anxiety is a very common side effect of these drugs.

It is also entirely possible to overcome anxiety with the right tools, teaching, learning, and support.

I also have taught many autistic children who simply aren’t anxious. They’re very autistic but it doesn’t bother them. They might find sounds too loud but simply walk about with fingers in their ears, until handed ear defenders (which shouldn’t be used all the time.) And a couple who only become anxious on adhd medication. (And I’m not completely against meds; I’ve seen it occasionally be utterly life changing. But only occasionally.)

The episode where Naomi discusses the autism diagnosis of the daughter of a woman who is dyslexic, who’s life’s work is around schizophrenia is very interesting.

i wasn’t aware that the discussion with this condition is one of drugs when needed and complete recovery for some. Not a life long diagnosis.

Similarly, her dyslexia has changed, she’s learned some things but can’t spell. So that element is life long. Not the other issues. At the same time, many children diagnosed with dyslexia can overcome it with the right combination of interventions and support. To the point now that programmes such as rwi say to just teach repeatedly in short fun ways to any child who’s just not picking it up. Some LA dyslexia services have closed.

In that episode they discuss what I knew 30 odd years ago, that some autistic children are able to progress so well with the correct interventions and supports that they wouldn’t pass a diagnosis as an adult. Apparently this is now sacrilege. And seems to also be the idea around adhd - in the past it was always a childhood condition.

Treatment for anxiety would usually begin with non-pharmacological therapy such as CBT, although for some children medication might be appropriate.

However my actual point is that for most children with ADHD and anxiety, medication doesn’t cause their anxiety. The anxiety was always there, but not necessarily picked up until they were calm enough for it to be noticeable.

ItsPeggyOlson · 03/10/2026 12:37

Thank you so much @DrBlackbird for the hypermobility resources - it is so kind of you to take the time to share these. Much appreciated.

DrBlackbird · 03/10/2026 10:51

Likewise I’d be concerned about asserting that those with dyslexia can overcome it. That someone can learn to read with the right kind of help is indisputable, but that reading takes longer, makes more demands on cognitive processing and working memory and remains a disability when working alongside those without dyslexia is clear. I see this at the university all the time. Highly intelligent but nevertheless still struggling students because of the pace of learning. No time for consolidation, no time to reread complex papers can leave these students feeling they’re falling behind.

And theres a reason why young people aren’t getting enough exercise or enough sleep. Young autistic/adhd people, more males but enough females, are gaming because it provides the stimulation those brains seek. Tech firms are happy to build ever more stimulating and addictive games and technology using neuroscience and A/B testing to keep them online and make £££.

Ultimately, I don’t have faith in this government or Burnham’s cabinet to make the necessary policy changes our children with send need.

DrBlackbird · 03/10/2026 10:40

I find it puzzling that adhd is claimed to be a childhood condition. It may be much more readily apparent in childhood because of being in the unnatural classroom environment ie expected to sit still and take in large quantities of information for long periods of time.

However children don’t grow out of it when they become adults. Hopefully they have learned ways to manage plus move into environments where being adhd isn’t as much as a disability. On the other hand, I’ve known many adults with adhd and ultimately they’re earning less, or move from job to job or end up in less ‘typical’ jobs such as dog grooming or wild animal rescue. Before globalisation and offshoring, people with adhd could find regular, reasonably well paid jobs in factories. It’s my opinion that, thanks to A.I., contemporary workplaces will be even more challenging because of fewer entry level jobs, faster processing of data, and the A.I. will do the more mundane, easier jobs that used to be available to humans.

@ItsPeggyOlson re hypermobility, there’s the https://ehlers-danlos.uk/ org for resources, plus, https://www.redcliffhousepublications.co.uk/product-page/understanding-hypermobile-ehlers-danlos-syndrome-hypermobility-spectrum-disord this book. I’ve not used their services, so this isn’t a full endorsement but another mum i know used the London Hypermobility clinic / Professor Roger Wolman to get a diagnosis and help for their DC. Hypermobility known to be associated with anxiety.

Understanding Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome & Hypermobility Spectrum Disord | rchpublications

Whether you are newly diagnosed, or a patient or healthcare professional this ground breaking book, reviewed by leading experts and reflecting the most up to date knowledge from the EDS International Classification 2017, brings together all the informa...

https://www.redcliffhousepublications.co.uk/product-page/understanding-hypermobile-ehlers-danlos-syndrome-hypermobility-spectrum-disord

WarriorN · 01/10/2026 09:10

StillSpartacus · 30/09/2026 11:52

As well, there are some widely held misconceptions and fears about medication, which is successful in most people when the right formulation is found.

I agree with Warrier that anxiety and underlying causes which are often not considered or managed. However again, the mechanism with anxiety and ADHD medication is often misunderstood. For some people who have autistic traits/autism in addition to ADHD, controlling ADHD symptoms can allow autistic features such as anxiety to be more noticeable. Importantly, those symptoms are not caused by medication, they were always there, but less apparent because other traits like impulsivity and hyperactivity are more obvious. Siloed diagnosis, also means an ADHD assessment may not pick up a diagnosis of autism and vice versa. If someone medicated for ADHD is anxious, then their anxiety needs to be supported too.

I’m confused with this concept.

Are you suggesting that the anxiety is then treated with more drugs?

As anxiety is a very common side effect of these drugs.

It is also entirely possible to overcome anxiety with the right tools, teaching, learning, and support.

I also have taught many autistic children who simply aren’t anxious. They’re very autistic but it doesn’t bother them. They might find sounds too loud but simply walk about with fingers in their ears, until handed ear defenders (which shouldn’t be used all the time.) And a couple who only become anxious on adhd medication. (And I’m not completely against meds; I’ve seen it occasionally be utterly life changing. But only occasionally.)

The episode where Naomi discusses the autism diagnosis of the daughter of a woman who is dyslexic, who’s life’s work is around schizophrenia is very interesting.

i wasn’t aware that the discussion with this condition is one of drugs when needed and complete recovery for some. Not a life long diagnosis.

Similarly, her dyslexia has changed, she’s learned some things but can’t spell. So that element is life long. Not the other issues. At the same time, many children diagnosed with dyslexia can overcome it with the right combination of interventions and support. To the point now that programmes such as rwi say to just teach repeatedly in short fun ways to any child who’s just not picking it up. Some LA dyslexia services have closed.

In that episode they discuss what I knew 30 odd years ago, that some autistic children are able to progress so well with the correct interventions and supports that they wouldn’t pass a diagnosis as an adult. Apparently this is now sacrilege. And seems to also be the idea around adhd - in the past it was always a childhood condition.

OP posts:
Multibarpack · 30/09/2026 13:13

Motnight · 30/09/2026 11:33

It's meant to be but isn't. By needs led I mean removing the barriers around needing a diagnosis to receive support. It's a common concern raised again and again.

By needs led they mean in response to difficulties/disabilities experienced not simply based on a diagnosis which may have very broad presentations and levels of support needs.

StillSpartacus · 30/09/2026 11:52

Multibarpack · 30/09/2026 07:21

Not all drugs used for adhd are stimulants. For example one widely used drug, guanfacine, is not and does not have an impact on appetite like eg methylphenidate does. It takes a bit of trial and error to find the right drug.

As well, there are some widely held misconceptions and fears about medication, which is successful in most people when the right formulation is found.

I agree with Warrier that anxiety and underlying causes which are often not considered or managed. However again, the mechanism with anxiety and ADHD medication is often misunderstood. For some people who have autistic traits/autism in addition to ADHD, controlling ADHD symptoms can allow autistic features such as anxiety to be more noticeable. Importantly, those symptoms are not caused by medication, they were always there, but less apparent because other traits like impulsivity and hyperactivity are more obvious. Siloed diagnosis, also means an ADHD assessment may not pick up a diagnosis of autism and vice versa. If someone medicated for ADHD is anxious, then their anxiety needs to be supported too.

Motnight · 30/09/2026 11:33

Multibarpack · 28/09/2026 07:22

Support is already meant to be needs based, not diagnosis based.

It is interesting seeing the proposed changes to SEND in England which looks to bring it more in line with Scotland where pretty much the only legal route for forcing support is disability discrimination under the Equality Act.

It's meant to be but isn't. By needs led I mean removing the barriers around needing a diagnosis to receive support. It's a common concern raised again and again.

Multibarpack · 30/09/2026 07:21

WarriorN · 30/09/2026 06:40

but this is simplistic.

the medication doesn’t always work. It causes weight loss and loss of height and can cause extreme anxiety. I’ve seen it work for some children, very well, but not others. Same too with adults. I know to women diagnosed autistic and adhd who found the drugs appalling. Amphetamines “help” a great deal of individuals be more focussed; study drugs are a huge thing and parents have slipped themselves doses of their children’s drugs for a long time. Does that mean they’ve all got ADHD?

The concern is that the diagnosis also creates a tunnel vision which then may discount other factors that might help. OR the meds don’t help and you’re back to square one.

These diagnoses can be ripe for victim blaming (the school system can be so tight and putative that it’s affecting MH severely) or even missing health issues that are causing the inattention.

Fight, freeze or flight states of anxiety causes inattentive children and adults. There’s a huge bank of data on this by a dr in the states, biologically linked to how some children/ adults have more reactive sensory systems than others. It’s roughly 20% of the population and biological in nature. (Dandelion and orchid book/ research.) The children tested who matched the description of orchids couldn’t remember anything of what had happened during an experiment when they had been stressed. These children thrive in the right environment and really don’t in the worst environments. But also can respond the best to CBT/ therapy etc.

Poverty and trauma are a huge driving factors for chronic anxiety.

Not all drugs used for adhd are stimulants. For example one widely used drug, guanfacine, is not and does not have an impact on appetite like eg methylphenidate does. It takes a bit of trial and error to find the right drug.

WarriorN · 30/09/2026 06:42

Wishesandhorses · 28/09/2026 17:18

I think many families aren't bothered what it's called - and wait years for a label anyway - it's that at present many find unless there's a label there's nothing they can stand on to get help. What is badly needed is help to meet actual need, regardless of what it's called. Families dealing with children so distressed they're harming themselves or other family members, dealing with hours and hours of dysregulation, who can't face going into school any more, or who don't really sleep so the family hasn't slept in years just want help. Not half an hour group meeting or a few anxiety tips, or a suggested parenting course when the parents can parent perfectly well, but actual, proper resources, especially for early years and primary. There is no crisis team in my area that helps with anyone under secondary age.

100% this

I’m aware of some teens who have not met the diagnostic criteria . And then what? What happens for them?

OP posts:
WarriorN · 30/09/2026 06:40

StillSpartacus · 28/09/2026 16:21

I work on the health side of this, and these are broadly my concerns too. One of the very best parts of my job, is when we are able to treat a child successfully and see the difference to their confidence, learning, wellbeing, family life, behaviour and emotional regulation. It can be the difference between a child on the brink of expulsion doing well at school, or a family on the edge being able to enjoy quality time together.

We know the problems with overwhelming referrals, but we also know that for most, successful treatment involves stimulant medication combined with non-pharmacological therapies and support. More worryingly, we also know the outcomes for children who don’t get the right support, are far worse as adults in terms of relationships, work, addiction, health and contact with criminal justice.

Kicking the can down the road, might seem to be politically expedient right now, in the face of concerns about the rising welfare bill, but delayed assessments are inevitably going to cost - and cost dear - in future.

but this is simplistic.

the medication doesn’t always work. It causes weight loss and loss of height and can cause extreme anxiety. I’ve seen it work for some children, very well, but not others. Same too with adults. I know to women diagnosed autistic and adhd who found the drugs appalling. Amphetamines “help” a great deal of individuals be more focussed; study drugs are a huge thing and parents have slipped themselves doses of their children’s drugs for a long time. Does that mean they’ve all got ADHD?

The concern is that the diagnosis also creates a tunnel vision which then may discount other factors that might help. OR the meds don’t help and you’re back to square one.

These diagnoses can be ripe for victim blaming (the school system can be so tight and putative that it’s affecting MH severely) or even missing health issues that are causing the inattention.

Fight, freeze or flight states of anxiety causes inattentive children and adults. There’s a huge bank of data on this by a dr in the states, biologically linked to how some children/ adults have more reactive sensory systems than others. It’s roughly 20% of the population and biological in nature. (Dandelion and orchid book/ research.) The children tested who matched the description of orchids couldn’t remember anything of what had happened during an experiment when they had been stressed. These children thrive in the right environment and really don’t in the worst environments. But also can respond the best to CBT/ therapy etc.

Poverty and trauma are a huge driving factors for chronic anxiety.

OP posts:
WarriorN · 30/09/2026 06:27

Multibarpack · 28/09/2026 07:22

Support is already meant to be needs based, not diagnosis based.

It is interesting seeing the proposed changes to SEND in England which looks to bring it more in line with Scotland where pretty much the only legal route for forcing support is disability discrimination under the Equality Act.

oh I didn’t know this

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread