Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Services and spaces should be separated according to gender, not sex

256 replies

BackToLurk · 29/08/2026 19:19

Because that’s the argument isn’t it? If trans rights activists and their allies accept that no one changes sex, then what they are really arguing for is that any separation should actually be made on the basis of gender.

As I’m a helpful sort, I’ve started a whole thread for people to make that argument. Off you go fellas. Bring your brightest. Make your case. I really do want to hear it. (And I’m not, for once, being sarcastic).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Shortshriftandlethal · 01/09/2026 08:17

RareGoalsVerge · 01/09/2026 08:10

I don't think these conversations can be separated though.

Before we can properly consider whether something should be split on the basis of sex or split on the basis of gender we need to properly consider why it is split at all, for what justification? Many of the justifications available intrinsically lead to the conclusion that the split must be sex-based because if it isn't sex based then the root purpose for which the split is required cannot be achieved. IF the justification is not in this category, then maybe it shouldn't be split at all or maybe there is valid justification for splitting be by gender. Consider a space whose primary purpose is to provide a feminine-gendered respite and recuperation zone for anyone with a feminine gender to escape from the constant onslaught of toxic masculinity out there in the wide world. Of course that could include transwomen. I don't think that is the primary purpose of most spaces that are reserved for Female people but I wonder whether some people think it should be.

Train stations used to often have a separate Ladies Waiting Room but now they don't. Why not? What changed such that Victorian women expected to be able to wait for the train separately from the men, but now have no problem sitting next to a male stranger in a mixed-sex waiting room? Is that a cultural change that is continuing and may extend further? The fact that change was possible suggests that the justification for Ladies Waiting Rooms was more about a culture and tradition that is changeable and fluid, whereas the justification for, say, a separate female-only category for a 100m sprint competition is fundamentally based on the biological fact that women's hips are a different shape to men's to allow space for Childbirth and the male shape is more optimised for sprinting and there is no point whatsoever having a category for people with female hip-structure PLUS anyone with male hip-structure who would prefer to be in this category.

Interesting, though, that we occasionally hear of reports of cities laying on female only train carriages and other forms of public transport - largely because of the amount of sexual abuse and predatory behaviour that women can be subjected to on nights out, and at other times. Being sexually assaulted is apparently not uncommon on crowded tubes, or on the Paris underground.

Another example is of a new floating sauna in my city. To begin with it was entirely mixed sex - but now they are expanding the business and running women only sessions ( due to demand), and in my view, for obvious reasons.

6ate9 · 01/09/2026 08:11

MarieDeGournay · 31/08/2026 09:33

A derail, sorry, I can't help myself😏

There's a story told about a smartarse student at one of the posh old unis, it might well have been Trinity College Dublin, in the days when attendance at religious service was obligatory.
He put down his religion as 'Sunworshipper' and looked forward to long lie-ins.
Instead, he was rudely awoken at 6am by a college servant knocking on the door and calling out 'Sir, the sun is rising in half an hour, you'll want to be up to worship it!'
Grin

Love this, the student was outsmarted! 🤣

RareGoalsVerge · 01/09/2026 08:10

BackToLurk · 29/08/2026 19:55

Those are not the ones we are talking about. Feel free to start a “things that don’t need separating by sex” thread. I’d also be quite interested to see more posters honestly make that case too, rather than hiding behind weasely words.

I don't think these conversations can be separated though.

Before we can properly consider whether something should be split on the basis of sex or split on the basis of gender we need to properly consider why it is split at all, for what justification? Many of the justifications available intrinsically lead to the conclusion that the split must be sex-based because if it isn't sex based then the root purpose for which the split is required cannot be achieved. IF the justification is not in this category, then maybe it shouldn't be split at all or maybe there is valid justification for splitting be by gender. Consider a space whose primary purpose is to provide a feminine-gendered respite and recuperation zone for anyone with a feminine gender to escape from the constant onslaught of toxic masculinity out there in the wide world. Of course that could include transwomen. I don't think that is the primary purpose of most spaces that are reserved for Female people but I wonder whether some people think it should be.

Train stations used to often have a separate Ladies Waiting Room but now they don't. Why not? What changed such that Victorian women expected to be able to wait for the train separately from the men, but now have no problem sitting next to a male stranger in a mixed-sex waiting room? Is that a cultural change that is continuing and may extend further? The fact that change was possible suggests that the justification for Ladies Waiting Rooms was more about a culture and tradition that is changeable and fluid, whereas the justification for, say, a separate female-only category for a 100m sprint competition is fundamentally based on the biological fact that women's hips are a different shape to men's to allow space for Childbirth and the male shape is more optimised for sprinting and there is no point whatsoever having a category for people with female hip-structure PLUS anyone with male hip-structure who would prefer to be in this category.

dazzlingdeborahrose · 01/09/2026 07:41

Technically gender and sex are the same thing. Gender identity on the other hand…

GeneralPeter · 01/09/2026 07:40

AimsAndObjectives · 30/08/2026 09:38

I think number 1 probably would have the best traction with the public at large. It is roughly the situation we had back in the day, when there was just a handful of HSTS men using women's spaces and most women rarely encountered them. I don't think that I would have spent so much money, time and effort trying to dislodge them as I have with this current crop of TIMs. However, as frequently directed, I educated myself and realised that the HSTS men violate our privacy, dignity and safety just as much as other men.

Number 2 is a queer theory argument and jo/joe public would just say 'wtf?'.

Number 3 is also a bit of a niche sell. I think most people would decide that you need the stats in order to address the risks to as well as from a group.

Edit to add last 7 words.

Edited

Yes, I think 1 is the strongest with jo/e public. It’s still very common: “they wouldn’t put themselves through all that if they didn’t really need it”, etc.

I also think it’s fairly reasonable in its own terms. But utterly unworkable now, especially in a culture where judging between worthy and unworthy has been delegitimised.

AimsAndObjectives · 31/08/2026 14:12

Sweetbeansandmochi · 31/08/2026 12:59

So we just had a case in my area where a man (not a trans woman, nothing trans) has been convicted of taking thousands of pictures of women and girls in our local leisure centre swimming pool changing rooms. They have cubicals but there is nothing else to separate them by sex. It’s just one big mixed sex area.

The point is you can’t stop vile men with agendas but you don’t have to make it easier for them either. And this open/mixed environment made it easier.

And I would argue that to have prevented and protected one child from being photographed in a state of undress - is enough to warrant putting certain barriers such as properly segregated changing areas in a swimming pool.

I agree. From the Women's Rights Network:

We know mixed-sex changing facilities are high-risk. In a 2018 FOI investigation there were 134 complaints of sexual misconduct in sports centres and swimming pools in the UK, 120 (nearly 90%) occurred in mixed facilities.

In January 2025 Swim England held an emergency safeguarding meeting. Cases of voyeurism and using mobile phones to photograph women and girls changing at swim competitions had DOUBLED.

The WRN Leisure Centre Report 2024 published in 2024 found that one-third of council swimming pools have only mixed-sex changing areas for swimmers, providing easy hunting grounds for predatory males seeking access to women and children.

In 2025, WRN published a further report that outlines police data on sexual violence in leisure centres. Figures reveal that in one year (2023) there were 16 rapes, 80 sexual assaults and 65 acts of voyeurism across 257 leisure centres in England and Wales.

https://www.womensrights.network/post/red-flag-campaign

I'm not in favour of mixed sex or mixed gender.

Red Flag Campaign | Women's Rights Network | UK

Millions of women and children will be heading to swimming pools and leisure centres over the summer blissfully unaware of the dangers they face from sexual predators seeking victims in mixed-sex changing rooms.

https://www.womensrights.network/post/red-flag-campaign

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 31/08/2026 13:13

Thanks! But I suspect it's not what I would call usual, these days, in any religion.

I don't think the Southern Baptists do it, do they? They're the ones I'd think most likely to have taken it up recently. And whatever sect Mike Pence belongs to that makes him not want to be alone with any woman other than "Mother", even in full sight in a restaurant.

Octavia64 · 31/08/2026 13:10

Some Buddhists separate some services.

i don’t know enough to know why.

RobinEllacotStrike · 31/08/2026 13:02

It’s all nonsense with the ultimate goal of removing women’s rights to spaces without men.

apparently “very special men” with professed ladyfeels having access to womens changing rooms is a vital civil rights issue (but only for the “very special men” of course not for the women or girls).

Sweetbeansandmochi · 31/08/2026 12:59

AimsAndObjectives · 29/08/2026 19:28

Great, I too am looking for some clarity on why we should separate by gender, rather than just make all the current separate-sex spaces into mixed gender spaces.

So we just had a case in my area where a man (not a trans woman, nothing trans) has been convicted of taking thousands of pictures of women and girls in our local leisure centre swimming pool changing rooms. They have cubicals but there is nothing else to separate them by sex. It’s just one big mixed sex area.

The point is you can’t stop vile men with agendas but you don’t have to make it easier for them either. And this open/mixed environment made it easier.

And I would argue that to have prevented and protected one child from being photographed in a state of undress - is enough to warrant putting certain barriers such as properly segregated changing areas in a swimming pool.

BackToLurk · 31/08/2026 12:46

iwishitwouldstartraining · 31/08/2026 09:34

I think this is a fair point.

I don't want services to be randomly segregated for no obvious reason. It is important to me that when they do discriminate they are complying with the Equality Act.

I have no idea why a service would be segregated by gender. It just sounds either complete meaningless or a license to exclude based on reasons that nobody understands.

Most services aren’t separated. They aren’t relevant. Having said that, there are those that use this subject to pushback against anything being offered separately.

OP posts:
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 31/08/2026 12:30

The only sort of services I know of that are segregated, male from female, would be ultra-orthodox Jewish, and some but not all Muslim. I don't think Christianity has ever practised segregation by sex at services, and I don't know enough about such religions as Daoism or Zoroastrianism to have the faintest idea how sexist they are in their worship.

(Yes, I know perfectly well this was not the sort of service that was meant in the OP, but I was sort of led to it by the sail-locker.)

And there would be no point in segregation by gender in these circs, nor would it be feasible. Nor do I think God would give a tuppeny fsck.

iwishitwouldstartraining · 31/08/2026 09:34

Octavia64 · 29/08/2026 19:23

Most services and spaces don’t need to be separated at all.

I think this is a fair point.

I don't want services to be randomly segregated for no obvious reason. It is important to me that when they do discriminate they are complying with the Equality Act.

I have no idea why a service would be segregated by gender. It just sounds either complete meaningless or a license to exclude based on reasons that nobody understands.

MarieDeGournay · 31/08/2026 09:33

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 30/08/2026 13:56

The navy dealt with the one Satanist in a crew, who insisted on his right to worship as his conscience dictated, by giving him a sail-locker for his chapel, and shutting him into it for the duration of every church parade.

NB: I have no idea what they meant by a sail-locker, since the ship was nuclear-powered. Something small and uncomfortable, I suspect. And I don't know what they would have done if a Pastafarian then came to light in one of the messes; lost patience, probably, or insisted they use the same chapel in rotation, or something equally practical.

A derail, sorry, I can't help myself😏

There's a story told about a smartarse student at one of the posh old unis, it might well have been Trinity College Dublin, in the days when attendance at religious service was obligatory.
He put down his religion as 'Sunworshipper' and looked forward to long lie-ins.
Instead, he was rudely awoken at 6am by a college servant knocking on the door and calling out 'Sir, the sun is rising in half an hour, you'll want to be up to worship it!'
Grin

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 31/08/2026 08:57

@BackToLurk I note that you have had no takers yet. I'm so surprised!
Yet again, the magic word goes undefined.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 30/08/2026 13:56

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 30/08/2026 07:12

If we make provision for the genderists, then we have to make provision for all the other subcults, where are the provisions for the punks, the emo's, the goths etc.
We're gonna need a bigger planet.

The navy dealt with the one Satanist in a crew, who insisted on his right to worship as his conscience dictated, by giving him a sail-locker for his chapel, and shutting him into it for the duration of every church parade.

NB: I have no idea what they meant by a sail-locker, since the ship was nuclear-powered. Something small and uncomfortable, I suspect. And I don't know what they would have done if a Pastafarian then came to light in one of the messes; lost patience, probably, or insisted they use the same chapel in rotation, or something equally practical.

AimsAndObjectives · 30/08/2026 09:45

solerolover · 30/08/2026 09:16

So, the posters who constantly derail legitimate topics with their nonsense and word salads, who love to describe women who want single sex spaces and services as bigoted fools, are nowhere to be found on this thread?🤔That's interesting to say the least.

I got the impression that they were mostly absent from the whole of FWR in the second half of yesterday, but I only dipped in and out myself so I'm not certain of this.

AimsAndObjectives · 30/08/2026 09:38

GeneralPeter · 30/08/2026 00:41

Slightly different question, but what is the best steel-man version of the genderist argument?

I see three (I’m not that interested in discussing why these fail or don’t generalise, as I suspect everyone on this board largely agrees on that. But I’m interested what people think the best arguments are).

  1. the “witness protection” argument (Helen Joyce). Yes it’s a lie and yes it may create some risk, but as society we accept there are sometimes exceptional cases that demand this. Provided the numbers aren’t high, we can accommodate this. The acute distress averted for the few who need it is worth the mild discomfort or slightly elevated risk for everyone else.
  2. The argument that sex-based separation is unnecessary in most cases it’s applied anyway, and undermining that is thus a good thing (like a “must speak Chinese” rule for roles that don’t in fact require it, it’s an unjust barrier).
  3. The argument that singling out sex-based risk stats is unfair. (Eg one wouldn’t do it for race or nationality even if crime stats show large disparities). Dealing with large disparities in risk is part and parcel of having a civilised society. Singling trans people out as the exception to this is unfair.

Just to repeat, these aren’t arguments I think ultimately are convincing. But I think these are the strongest ones I’ve heard.

Edited

I think number 1 probably would have the best traction with the public at large. It is roughly the situation we had back in the day, when there was just a handful of HSTS men using women's spaces and most women rarely encountered them. I don't think that I would have spent so much money, time and effort trying to dislodge them as I have with this current crop of TIMs. However, as frequently directed, I educated myself and realised that the HSTS men violate our privacy, dignity and safety just as much as other men.

Number 2 is a queer theory argument and jo/joe public would just say 'wtf?'.

Number 3 is also a bit of a niche sell. I think most people would decide that you need the stats in order to address the risks to as well as from a group.

Edit to add last 7 words.

ItsCoolForCats · 30/08/2026 09:38

I would absolutely love for someone like Nadia Whittome to argue her case for this. She posts polemics on her social media and she gets some really constructive replies, including from legal professionals, but she never ever engages with them.

BackToLurk · 30/08/2026 09:31

solerolover · 30/08/2026 09:16

So, the posters who constantly derail legitimate topics with their nonsense and word salads, who love to describe women who want single sex spaces and services as bigoted fools, are nowhere to be found on this thread?🤔That's interesting to say the least.

It’s quite the head scratcher. I’m happy for them to be directed over here next time they derail.

Like I said, helpful.

OP posts:
solerolover · 30/08/2026 09:16

So, the posters who constantly derail legitimate topics with their nonsense and word salads, who love to describe women who want single sex spaces and services as bigoted fools, are nowhere to be found on this thread?🤔That's interesting to say the least.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 30/08/2026 07:12

If we make provision for the genderists, then we have to make provision for all the other subcults, where are the provisions for the punks, the emo's, the goths etc.
We're gonna need a bigger planet.

akkakk · 30/08/2026 06:11

Gender is a societal reflection on the stereotype of a man or woman at this point in time.

As it is an outside snapshot no one can change or transition gender - they simply change the perception… so a man in a dress doesn’t reflect a female gender, they change perception of being a man to include wearing dresses…

so your gender is the same as your sex as the only truth is your biology

all those born male remain male… the society perception of the male stereotype can change and does (high heels came into the UK for men, they are now seen as a female item etc) but whatever a man does they remain male

so it is pointless to define anything by gender as it changes pattern and appearance every day, the only constant is the underlying sex so anyone with a male gender can only have been born male and vv

TLDR - your sex is biological and immutable and defines your gender - so no point using anything other than sex.

GeneralPeter · 30/08/2026 00:41

Slightly different question, but what is the best steel-man version of the genderist argument?

I see three (I’m not that interested in discussing why these fail or don’t generalise, as I suspect everyone on this board largely agrees on that. But I’m interested what people think the best arguments are).

  1. the “witness protection” argument (Helen Joyce). Yes it’s a lie and yes it may create some risk, but as society we accept there are sometimes exceptional cases that demand this. Provided the numbers aren’t high, we can accommodate this. The acute distress averted for the few who need it is worth the mild discomfort or slightly elevated risk for everyone else.
  2. The argument that sex-based separation is unnecessary in most cases it’s applied anyway, and undermining that is thus a good thing (like a “must speak Chinese” rule for roles that don’t in fact require it, it’s an unjust barrier).
  3. The argument that singling out sex-based risk stats is unfair. (Eg one wouldn’t do it for race or nationality even if crime stats show large disparities). Dealing with large disparities in risk is part and parcel of having a civilised society. Singling trans people out as the exception to this is unfair.

Just to repeat, these aren’t arguments I think ultimately are convincing. But I think these are the strongest ones I’ve heard.

Heggettypeg · 30/08/2026 00:38

AimsAndObjectives · 29/08/2026 19:35

8.3 billion, because that is the population of the planet and gender is just personality.

Yes. It seems the gender idea is either a binary (or binary- plus- "non-binary") system derived from sex, or a limitation of personality to a larger but arbitrary number of labels. There is no overall coherence.