Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Thoughts on this tweet?

343 replies

walkthedino · 29/08/2026 15:24

I saw the below tweet today and agreed with a lot of it. I wondered what people on this forum thought.

I have copied and pasted so the post doesn’t have to wait for a screenshot to be approved:

My trans positions are VERY CONTROVERSIAL because they are so dead moderate they make both cocaine-fueled extremes angry.

✅ Yes, most children are being overmedicalized. But rare true trans children deserve help or they psychologically shatter
✅ No, trans women do not belong in professional sports. But it’s hateful to call them men.
✅ Trans women are not automatically women. But with hard work and medical intervention, most of us can have fulfilling lives where people perceive us as women.
✅ Self-ID must end. Women’s feelings and safety matter, so if you cannot use the ladies non-disruptively - don’t.
✅ If you can’t understand why women should never see a penis in a locker room, you’re mentally still a man.
✅ We need research to figure out what is happening with this explosion of non-binary identities. They are not trans, and it’s medical malpractice to give them transsexual healthcare.
✅ You have to do the work to be percieved as a woman. Far left politics cannot do this work for you.

I promise you. The overwhelming majority of the public agrees with all of this. If trans people will go back to the non-insane positions of ten years ago, things will get better.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Whatchamacallitt · 31/08/2026 03:00

Helleofabore · 30/08/2026 22:34

Thanks @Whatchamacallitt .

I remember this one too.

For those not on twitter, this supposed moderate man stated very clearly:

”I am not going to use a third toilet for some bigot. It’s insane.”

This shines a huge fucking beacon on statements such as

”Women’s feelings and safety matter”.

This man is only interested in validating his identity. There is not one skerrick of understanding of what female people need… despite his empty efforts to make himself appear to be ‘moderate’.

To those who believe that there are ‘some’ male people who should bypass female people’s consent and be treated as if they were female, do you see it yet?

What is it about these male people’s actions and behaviour towards female people who reject their subjective reality that is not sending red flags in regard to their intention to ignore female people’s consent ?

Why shouldn’t this act of ignoring female people’s lack of consent be described as predatory behaviour ?

Yes, that one gets even worse (Sonia Sodha = SS, Brianna Wu = BW) -

SS - The answer is third, gender neutral spaces. Always was, always has been. This is in the EHRC Code of Practice. The issue is that isn’t enough for activists as - in relation to toilets, anyway- this is more about identity validation than safety. There really isn’t an issue here.

BW - I am not going to use a third toilet for some bigot. It’s insane.

SS - Thank you for illustrating my point so beautifully.

BW - Thank you for illustrating mine.

SS - You’re welcome. Your expectation to use female-only spaces is unreasonable: they don’t exist to validate your identity. Part of being an adult is understanding that other people have needs and rights, too.

BW - Sonia, you’re not the center of the universe. Normal women do not notice or care if I’m in the ladies. Your bigotry and hate does not to define public policy. I grew up with whites that didn’t want blacks to live on their side of the town too. You are exactly like them. I’ve been married to a man for 18 years and I could not have less sexual interest in you.
[Complete with narcissistic selfie to prove how feminine]

SS - Grow up, Brianna.

BW - You grow up Sonia. You’re not a little girl. You are safe sharing the ladies with Trans women, and there’s no excuse to be a frothing ugly bigot.

SS - “Frothing ugly bigot.” Classy.

BW - Your bigotry is ugly.

SS - Your abuse is very male-pattern. It’s a good illustration of why most British women aren’t on board with men identifying into female-only spaces.

Hoardasurass · 31/08/2026 00:46

walkthedino · 30/08/2026 22:33

Surely, genuine question here, if you aren’t comfortable using someone’s preferred pronouns the medium ground is to use they/them as it doesn’t validate anything but it also remains neutral and respectful

Not really as it still requires effort and lies aswell as being grammatically incorrect language.
They/them implies that you are talking about more than 1 person because they are correctly uses for multiple people not for a singular person.
Your so called middle ground still requires me to mangle the English language and use mental effort to deny the reality that my eyes and ears see and hear just because someone else doesn't like hearing the truth.
So please can you explain how that would be the middle ground as im still having my speach and thoughts compelled so im not gaining anything back and a transperson is still getting to demand compelled speach and thought and is not giving up anything.
Look i get it you are trying to find a middle ground but a true middle ground would involve transpeople accepting that nobody else needs to see or think of them as anything but the biological sex they were born as and that we have the right to use accurate language when speaking about them and that they do not belong in any single sex space, group or or position set aside for someone of the opposite sex and for the rest of us to continue to accept that some people dress differently and like to think of themselves as something that they can never be.
I have 1 question for you to think about, which other acts of religious observance would you advocate that non believers be compelled to participate in and if the answer is none why is trans pronouns different?

Datun · 31/08/2026 00:11

walkthedino · 30/08/2026 22:35

I have actually read this and can’t say I agree really. The point re the extract of a sentencing is abhorrent regardless of the pronouns of the person involved to me 🤷🏻‍♀️

I don't quite understand what you mean. I've reread the article, and I can't see what 'extract of a sentencing' might actually be referring to.

Can you clarify?

ZoeCM · 30/08/2026 23:18

✅ Yes, most children are being overmedicalized. But rare true trans children deserve help or they psychologically shatter

Depends what you mean by "help". I agree they need help to understand there's nothing wrong with being a boy who likes dolls, or a girl who likes football.

✅ No, trans women do not belong in professional sports. But it’s hateful to call them men.

It's not hateful to call a man a man. This is how we ended up here: it became taboo to point out that people like Lia Thomas and Veronica Ivy are male. People would point out that women have a right to their own sport categories, and TRAs and their allies would pretend to be confused, saying, "But trans women are women, so why would they play on the men's team?"

✅ Trans women are not automatically women. But with hard work and medical intervention, most of us can have fulfilling lives where people perceive us as women.

I don't think it's true that they'll be perceived as women. Does anyone really see Caitlyn Jenner on TV and believe they're watching a woman? Honestly? And Caitlyn is mega-rich and has had more facial feminisation surgery than the average person can dream of, and has access to expensive vocal training. Realistically, only a small percentage of male humans will be able to pass as female.

✅ Self-ID must end. Women’s feelings and safety matter, so if you cannot use the ladies non-disruptively - don’t.

✅ If you can’t understand why women should never see a penis in a locker room, you’re mentally still a man.

✅ We need research to figure out what is happening with this explosion of non-binary identities. They are not trans, and it’s medical malpractice to give them transsexual healthcare.

I agree with all of these.

✅ You have to do the work to be percieved as a woman. Far left politics cannot do this work for you.

This goes back to what I said earlier: very few TIMs are going to be perceived as women. Look at Lia Thomas, for example: is there any amount of "work" he can do that will actually make people's brains register him as female?

WhatNextImScared · 30/08/2026 23:01

I agree too; nobody else here will. Argue among yourselves.

AimsAndObjectives · 30/08/2026 22:57

walkthedino · 30/08/2026 22:33

Surely, genuine question here, if you aren’t comfortable using someone’s preferred pronouns the medium ground is to use they/them as it doesn’t validate anything but it also remains neutral and respectful

Well, it's because after many of years of working with children, I will always come down on the side of safeguarding. Women and girls need to know who the men are in order to keep themselves safe. Someone on another thread said something very wise. We should always put safeguarding first. Then respect is second and kindness third.
Pronouns describe sex, not gender. I would imagine that any decent person, trans or otherwise, would not want to step over safeguarding boundaries, even if it means that they have to sometimes feel a twinge of disappointment in how they are being addressed or referred to.

A shorter answer to your question is that I doubt that many of the more aggressive trans-identified males would settle for being referred to as anything other than she/her.

Helleofabore · 30/08/2026 22:42

walkthedino · 30/08/2026 12:56

But surely I can think a person is kind or unkind without expecting them to do anything to change that? People are absolutely entitled to their opinions and beliefs but I can equally have my own opinion on that. The same way people here have said I am out of line for what I think, I can think their views aren’t nice or ones I’d want to have

Sure. Judge away!

Helleofabore · 30/08/2026 22:38

walkthedino · 30/08/2026 22:33

Surely, genuine question here, if you aren’t comfortable using someone’s preferred pronouns the medium ground is to use they/them as it doesn’t validate anything but it also remains neutral and respectful

Why though?

You have yet to say why any person should be pressured in anyway to act as if an individual’s self constructed and subjective reality should be treated as if it is material reality when it is not. Why should any person be pressured to act that way by people who deem it is as being ‘kind’ and ‘respectful’ when it is only kindness and respect going one direction. That is, to the person who is demanding society acts as if their subjective reality is material reality.

How is that respectful?

walkthedino · 30/08/2026 22:35

Datun · 30/08/2026 22:32

Op, on the assumption that you're still reading and I hope you are. Would you read this? It's by a Mumsnetter, funnily enough.

https://fairplayforwomen.com/pronouns/

There are lots of reasons why feminists object to the wrong pronouns, and this explains it very well.

I have actually read this and can’t say I agree really. The point re the extract of a sentencing is abhorrent regardless of the pronouns of the person involved to me 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 30/08/2026 22:34

Thanks @Whatchamacallitt .

I remember this one too.

For those not on twitter, this supposed moderate man stated very clearly:

”I am not going to use a third toilet for some bigot. It’s insane.”

This shines a huge fucking beacon on statements such as

”Women’s feelings and safety matter”.

This man is only interested in validating his identity. There is not one skerrick of understanding of what female people need… despite his empty efforts to make himself appear to be ‘moderate’.

To those who believe that there are ‘some’ male people who should bypass female people’s consent and be treated as if they were female, do you see it yet?

What is it about these male people’s actions and behaviour towards female people who reject their subjective reality that is not sending red flags in regard to their intention to ignore female people’s consent ?

Why shouldn’t this act of ignoring female people’s lack of consent be described as predatory behaviour ?

walkthedino · 30/08/2026 22:33

AimsAndObjectives · 30/08/2026 19:34

Just asking if you have read the entire thread? Happy to leave you alone with your thoughts if you have and you still agree with Brianna Wu. (I notice that you aren't using a female pronoun for him.)

Surely, genuine question here, if you aren’t comfortable using someone’s preferred pronouns the medium ground is to use they/them as it doesn’t validate anything but it also remains neutral and respectful

OP posts:
Datun · 30/08/2026 22:32

Op, on the assumption that you're still reading and I hope you are. Would you read this? It's by a Mumsnetter, funnily enough.

https://fairplayforwomen.com/pronouns/

There are lots of reasons why feminists object to the wrong pronouns, and this explains it very well.

Pronouns are Rohypnol • Fair Play For Women

There’s a lot of chat around about pronouns right now. Specifically, ‘preferred’ pronouns. By which is usually meant, the pronouns a person would prefer.

https://fairplayforwomen.com/pronouns/

ArabellaScott · 30/08/2026 22:21

'Men who want to use women's spaces because they are afraid of men' should be listened to, and the rules can change to accomodate them.

'Women who want to have women only spaces because they are afraid of men' are just bigots who should reframe their trauma, and the rules set up to protect them can be disregarded

ArabellaScott · 30/08/2026 22:18

'Be kind to men, and women can go whistle', is the unabridged statement.

ArabellaScott · 30/08/2026 22:16

Wishesandhorses · 30/08/2026 14:48

Yes.

Fundamentally: in this ideology you can break the human race into two groups: men with declared gender identities (and women a bit, sometimes, when they're useful, and children, when useful, but it's really only about the men and what works as a service/tool for them)

And everybody else. Who is of a lower caste.

Once you have that in mind, all this makes sense.

One man's self expression over the actual bodily safety, risk of permanent injury and death to every woman who plays that sport with him while indulging his wished for illusion? Yes. Absolutely he entirely outweighs them.

One man's self expression and inner fulfilment (maybe emotional, sexual, both, involve the thrill of partial or actual assault) outweighs the equality, access to resources and services and inclusion of every woman. Some will say they're personally not affected and yippee for them, it's nice to be privileged, isn't it? The women who are excluded, affected, harmed, left without services or with life long injuries? Whatever.

Many children permanently sterilised, regretting, left with lifelong severe side effects and medical troubles, a few of whom will die? Well they don't matter do they, the few kids who are 'actually trans' (judged by declaring they are happy - but check your facts and be prepared often the narrative varies wildly between 'this is fab, I love my transition' and explanation of medical horrors, misery, extreme mental health issues and regret) are ok.

You have to be mad to play along with this and think it's 'kind'.

It's many other things, but 'kind' is not one of them. It's also ridiculous to pretend this is not at its root a fixed belief in the value of males above females. If this was a woman-only thing, no one would give a damn about anyone's pronouns.

100%

ArabellaScott · 30/08/2026 22:13

walkthedino · 30/08/2026 11:11

I’d say my current views are as follows:

  1. Agree - in the sense of children who have these feelings need therapy and support not life changing procedures
  2. Agree - trans women should not be in female sports, also agree that it is unkind to call them men (I am aware i’ll get dogpiled around ‘being kind is the way things go to shit’ but that’s how I feel).
  3. Agree - self ID is a dangerous thing that leads to genuine predators etc having access to areas that can cause harm to others (including genuine trans people!).
  4. Agree to an extent - no woman wants to see a penis in a changing area and anyone, not just trans people, should respect that
  5. Kind of agree - I don’t really understand non binary and feel it’s a bad of a fad but I agree the solution to that isn’t trans healthcare
  6. Slightly disagree - I don’t think being trans should be measured as “oh you’ve had surgery so you’re allowed” but equally I think a person who is very clearly still a man but dresses as a woman etc can be very unnerving for some people.

All this sounds pretty reasonable to me.

So long as you aren't berating others for calling men, men. You're free to be as kind as you please, of course.

Whatchamacallitt · 30/08/2026 22:01

Some more bangers from Wu -

Speaking to a detransitioned woman.

Appropriating a female health condition by claiming that his inverted penis skin would atrophy without oestrogen.

Claiming that pretty women are nice to trans women because they aren't threatened by them.

Just one example of his regular claim that female trans people are the problem

Admitting to being bisexual years ago. These days he pretends to be a HSTS so no one can accuse him of AGP.

Brianna Wu profile picture

Brianna Wu (@BriannaWu) on X

@rentedocean I have tried as hard as possible to be polite to you and your deranged partner. This is too far. People like you make it nearly impossible to care about F2M detransitioners because you ultimately need attention and have convinced yoursel...

https://x.com/BriannaWu/status/1949405338454683958

Shedmistress · 30/08/2026 21:30

DisappearingGirl · 30/08/2026 19:29

I think I agree (broadly) with all the points OP. I've seen Brianna on Facebook and thought I mostly agreed with their posts. They all seem quite sensible to me.

In every instance he himself would be included in the 'let me into women's spaces' argument.

Society should not be writing policy based on one man's desires to get into female spaces.

It would be much easier to just say no to men, no? Him included.

Whatchamacallitt · 30/08/2026 21:30

I made reference to it earlier but thought it would be worth sharing, in full, this interaction between Brianna Wu and British journalist Sonia Sodha. Wu is not moderate and the aggressive male-pattern behaviour comes straight out as soon as someone says no to him.

TheKeatingFive · 30/08/2026 19:55

@DisappearingGirl do you think men who've had cosmetic surgery should get access to women's facilities?

AimsAndObjectives · 30/08/2026 19:34

DisappearingGirl · 30/08/2026 19:29

I think I agree (broadly) with all the points OP. I've seen Brianna on Facebook and thought I mostly agreed with their posts. They all seem quite sensible to me.

Just asking if you have read the entire thread? Happy to leave you alone with your thoughts if you have and you still agree with Brianna Wu. (I notice that you aren't using a female pronoun for him.)

DisappearingGirl · 30/08/2026 19:29

I think I agree (broadly) with all the points OP. I've seen Brianna on Facebook and thought I mostly agreed with their posts. They all seem quite sensible to me.

HenriettaHippopotamus · 30/08/2026 18:12

The framing of trans child as a thing is a problem. There are children who develop gender dysphoria from a young age. Calling them trans isn’t helpful. Especially if you agree children are over medicalised.

Helleofabore · 30/08/2026 18:08

GarlicAnything · 30/08/2026 14:46

I thought that was a typo and OP meant shouldn't?

Agree - trans women should not be in female sports

I know. But the thing is that some people ignore grass roots sports, as does Wu. So I felt it was worth checking that it was all levels.

Pingponghavoc · 30/08/2026 15:40

Calling a man his she/her or miss/mrs/ms isnt kind, its not like a nickname its removing a layer of safeguarding.

Referring to Wu as she in front of children will confused them into believing men are women. Your kindness may lead children not to raise the alarm when any man enters female space.

We're expected to see a difference between the Wu and Izzards and any other men, and 'teach' this to children in our actions.

But we dont know. If we did, the rules would be clear, and safeguarding part of it. We wouldn't have to tell each other to be kind.