Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Thoughts on this tweet?

343 replies

walkthedino · 29/08/2026 15:24

I saw the below tweet today and agreed with a lot of it. I wondered what people on this forum thought.

I have copied and pasted so the post doesn’t have to wait for a screenshot to be approved:

My trans positions are VERY CONTROVERSIAL because they are so dead moderate they make both cocaine-fueled extremes angry.

✅ Yes, most children are being overmedicalized. But rare true trans children deserve help or they psychologically shatter
✅ No, trans women do not belong in professional sports. But it’s hateful to call them men.
✅ Trans women are not automatically women. But with hard work and medical intervention, most of us can have fulfilling lives where people perceive us as women.
✅ Self-ID must end. Women’s feelings and safety matter, so if you cannot use the ladies non-disruptively - don’t.
✅ If you can’t understand why women should never see a penis in a locker room, you’re mentally still a man.
✅ We need research to figure out what is happening with this explosion of non-binary identities. They are not trans, and it’s medical malpractice to give them transsexual healthcare.
✅ You have to do the work to be percieved as a woman. Far left politics cannot do this work for you.

I promise you. The overwhelming majority of the public agrees with all of this. If trans people will go back to the non-insane positions of ten years ago, things will get better.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
RedToothBrush · 31/08/2026 12:21

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 11:56

A lot of men grasp the issues quicker than women.

Probably because they have a better understanding of male motivations. And less of the tedious 'be kind' messaging has been ingrained into them from birth.

These threads frustrate me sometimes.

Someone makes the point about a lack of being nice and a lack of kindness.

Then there's a bunch of responses twisting themselves in knots trying to say they are being nice and kind or just simply justifying What's been said.

When actually the most fundamental point is that we don't actually owe any kindness in the conversation. The conversation shouldn't be centred and focused on kindness at all and that this drive for niceness only succeeds in missing the most important and central issues of the whole damn subject.

Which is precisely why we are being asked to be nice and kind in the first fucking place.

One of the crucial and essential things in a democracy is you have the difficult conversations. The ones that are most sensitive and most controversial. Because they are always the points that revolve around the most vulnerable people in our society. When we neglect to have these conversations, the law of unintended consequences means these people get harmed in some way.

These areas of topic are the most fundamental and the most foundational too because they expose the limits of equality. They expose where people do not wish to be liberal minded after all and actually it's just about what they want and what suits their interests. And this is where rights are erased and justice flounders.

The exposed vast abuses of power and unethical behaviour. They show up unhealthy balances in relationships and where a group may have second class status.

But no one seems to get this.

When someone tells you to be kind, your first response should actually be "why?" Sometimes yes it's a valid point and you lose nothing from being civil. Other tips it's not about asking you to be nice. It's about telling you to shut up before you say something that is inconvenient to the politics and vision of the world they have set rigidly in their head which they don't want questioned. If you do so it forces them to question themselves and to re-examine what they have been told. This rocks the boat. This makes them see things they thought were good as potentially harms they have been an active participant in enabling.

That's why this point matters so bloody much.

It's not about being nice. It's about whether your arguments are actually reasonable and considered.

There is little that the regulars here say that doesn't fall under the fair and reasonable banner. And that's what pisses off militant TRAs most.

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 11:56

A lot of men grasp the issues quicker than women.

Probably because they have a better understanding of male motivations. And less of the tedious 'be kind' messaging has been ingrained into them from birth.

6ate9 · 31/08/2026 11:54

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 11:51

'They are ladies — look at their pronouns! What about this person isn't a lady?' 'Well, his penis.'
'Her penis, you fucking bigot!'

Ricky Gervais understands! 🤣🤣

Since when did women have a ‘lady penis”?
Utter madness!!

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 11:51

'They are ladies — look at their pronouns! What about this person isn't a lady?' 'Well, his penis.'
'Her penis, you fucking bigot!'

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 11:47

Datun · 31/08/2026 11:43

’She just wants to bond and breastfeed her baby’

What, that 60-year-old grandpa??

Quite.

Nothing to see here D ... Just a woman who wants to bond and breastfeed her baby.

Nothing being hidden at all in that statement....

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 11:43

SadSadTimes · 31/08/2026 11:37

My experience with the language bomb that is they/them:

SST: so what is Sally up to this weekend?
niece: oh, they went to the festival
SST: they? who did she go with?
niece: how could you?!! you know Sally is nb and asks for they/them!! That is so disrespectful (actual tears)
SST: but but...I really didn't know or if I did I didn't remember and Sally isn't even here so not so very horrible?
niece: (howls) but if I don't always remember and be very careful in my thoughts I might make a mistake when talking to Sally that would be really hurtful, she would hate me, you are mean etc etc
SST: (quietly because niece is clearly miserable) your friend makes you police your thoughts and utterings, in her presence and beyond?

This is a very good example. And one I experienced personally in talking to my teen a few years ago.

Datun · 31/08/2026 11:43

’She just wants to bond and breastfeed her baby’

What, that 60-year-old grandpa??

Quite.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 11:40

Another very topical example of the obfuscation of using wrong sex language would be:

’She just wants to bond and breastfeed her baby’

which looks very different with accurate language (I am not tackling the ‘bonding’ term in this thread at the moment as I don’t wish to derail it.).

‘He just wants to bond and feed untested secretions from his nipples to his baby’.

borntobequiet · 31/08/2026 11:38

I have simply reverted to saying “he or she” “him or her” “his or hers” instead of using neutral pronouns. It was easy years ago, and it’s easy now.

SadSadTimes · 31/08/2026 11:37

My experience with the language bomb that is they/them:

SST: so what is Sally up to this weekend?
niece: oh, they went to the festival
SST: they? who did she go with?
niece: how could you?!! you know Sally is nb and asks for they/them!! That is so disrespectful (actual tears)
SST: but but...I really didn't know or if I did I didn't remember and Sally isn't even here so not so very horrible?
niece: (howls) but if I don't always remember and be very careful in my thoughts I might make a mistake when talking to Sally that would be really hurtful, she would hate me, you are mean etc etc
SST: (quietly because niece is clearly miserable) your friend makes you police your thoughts and utterings, in her presence and beyond?

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 11:35

Datun · 31/08/2026 11:32

Right, so because one of the examples she uses to show the shift in perception didn't work for you, you decide her example is abhorrent and have ignored the entire premise on that basis.

It's a nonsense argument, and you know it.

Do you know that 98% of all sex crimes are committed by men? 90% of all violent crimes are committed by men, and in fact the majority of all crime is committed by men. Women's crimes tends to be shoplifting, etc, and minor in comparison.

Therefore, when deciding about risk, sex is obviously paramount.

The way to reduce risk immediately is to sex segregate.

So when you change a person's perception to view someone as female, when they are in fact male, the risk element is instantly disguised.

The article was showing how changing your perception is incredibly important.

If you say 'that woman has just gone into my daughter's toilet right after her', no one turns a hair. If you say that a man has, it's an instant red flag. And it's an instant red flag because you know they are going somewhere they shouldn't be and you know they are more of a risk. Even if you don't know the statistics.

Secondly, even if you ignore the violence, threats and horrible intimidation of transactivism to force people to change their language, the entire ideology is sexist.

Pretending that a man should access the spaces of the opposite sex, or be called the opposite sex, because he inhabits sex stereotypes is not deserving of respect.

One of the cornerstones of feminism is to eliminate sex stereotypes, why the fuck should women go out of their way to use language that reinforces them??

“One of the cornerstones of feminism is to eliminate sex stereotypes, why the fuck should women go out of their way to use language that reinforces them??”

This is another question that never gets answered.

Datun · 31/08/2026 11:32

walkthedino · 31/08/2026 08:06

About halfway though there is an extract of an article relating to a person who has been sentenced due to inappropriate behaviour around children. The article directs you to swap the pronouns to see if it reads differently. To me, the act that they did is disgusting and I’d feel no differently if it said he or she

Right, so because one of the examples she uses to show the shift in perception didn't work for you, you decide her example is abhorrent and have ignored the entire premise on that basis.

It's a nonsense argument, and you know it.

Do you know that 98% of all sex crimes are committed by men? 90% of all violent crimes are committed by men, and in fact the majority of all crime is committed by men. Women's crimes tends to be shoplifting, etc, and minor in comparison.

Therefore, when deciding about risk, sex is obviously paramount.

The way to reduce risk immediately is to sex segregate.

So when you change a person's perception to view someone as female, when they are in fact male, the risk element is instantly disguised.

The article was showing how changing your perception is incredibly important.

If you say 'that woman has just gone into my daughter's toilet right after her', no one turns a hair. If you say that a man has, it's an instant red flag. And it's an instant red flag because you know they are going somewhere they shouldn't be and you know they are more of a risk. Even if you don't know the statistics.

Secondly, even if you ignore the violence, threats and horrible intimidation of transactivism to force people to change their language, the entire ideology is sexist.

Pretending that a man should access the spaces of the opposite sex, or be called the opposite sex, because he inhabits sex stereotypes is not deserving of respect.

One of the cornerstones of feminism is to eliminate sex stereotypes, why the fuck should women go out of their way to use language that reinforces them??

RedToothBrush · 31/08/2026 11:30

BernardBlacksMolluscs · 31/08/2026 11:21

what, by using incorrect sex pronouns?

'she shouldn't be playing women's sport'

'he shouldn't be playing women's sport'

which one prevents people speaking directly about the problem?

I don't understand why this isn't super obvious

It is obvious. Hence resorting to "you should be nice/kind" and general tone policing.

Precisely because it's a way of shutting down conversation. It shames women into compliance.

I crossed that bridge of realising what utter bullshit and how much of an abuse of power it was a long time ago.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 11:29

"It's a good job nobody is suggesting doing that then."

I think that 2a is suggesting exactly that.

2 a) No, trans women do not belong in professional sports.
b) But it’s hateful to call them men.

And the OP says clearly - "it is unkind to call them men" and 'if you aren’t comfortable using someone’s preferred pronouns the medium ground is to use they/them as it doesn’t validate anything but it also remains neutral and respectful'.

Using language that obscures the full context of what is being said fits the statement of 'It hides the problem if we can't speak directly about the problem.'

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 11:21

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 11:17

As soon as 'kind' is set up as a dynamic, it creates a hierarchy. It asserts that one party has the capacity and power to be 'kind' to the other.

It tacitly suggests that one party has more power and agency than the other.

'Be kind' is an admonishment.

We can even say to the victims of a bully that they must 'be kind'. Despite them being the party with less power, agency, and ability.

Yep.

I think we need to start to be very clear about what 'kind' means on any level beyond the superficial.

BernardBlacksMolluscs · 31/08/2026 11:21

Imdunfer · 31/08/2026 11:17

It hides the problem if we can't speak directly about the problem.

It's a good job nobody is suggesting doing that then.

what, by using incorrect sex pronouns?

'she shouldn't be playing women's sport'

'he shouldn't be playing women's sport'

which one prevents people speaking directly about the problem?

I don't understand why this isn't super obvious

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 11:20

It's a lot like how men being excluded from women's spaces is 'genocide'.

While women being excluded from women's spaces that have been turned into mixed sex spaces by inclusion of men is - well, their own bigoty problem, fuck them.

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 11:19

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2026 10:02

We’ve seen this many times

Pronouns are the last bastion of those who have been taken in but aren’t ready to admit it.

Well not quite the last bastion. The last bastion is always ‘tone’. I’m sure the OP will get there soon.

It's interesting to see how pronouns have become such a key tenet.

They seem to have at the same time, enormous and sacred power, so that we must respect them.

And concurrently, be so meaningless and insignificant, that it costs us absolutely nothing to use the ones we're told to.

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 11:17

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 10:38

I think part of the issue I have with anyone judging what is ‘kind’ or not is that it is often forgotten that kindness by its nature is an outcome that comes at some cost to those being ‘kind’.

Those who judge another for being unkind may be forgetting that just because they see the cost as insignificant, others not following with the same action may have very legitimate concerns about the outcome and the cost associated. The labels of ‘unkindness’ and ‘kindness’ are moral judgements and often very superficially judged.

As soon as 'kind' is set up as a dynamic, it creates a hierarchy. It asserts that one party has the capacity and power to be 'kind' to the other.

It tacitly suggests that one party has more power and agency than the other.

'Be kind' is an admonishment.

We can even say to the victims of a bully that they must 'be kind'. Despite them being the party with less power, agency, and ability.

Imdunfer · 31/08/2026 11:17

It hides the problem if we can't speak directly about the problem.

It's a good job nobody is suggesting doing that then.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/08/2026 11:09

Imdunfer · 31/08/2026 09:13

"Try listening rather than being a cloth eared sanctimonious bully who demeans and undermines women as independent humans rather than merely support humans to make egos."

"To me, you are someone who hasn't a fucking clue, copies and pastes AI guff and doesn't apply critical thinking or you are another one of these ploppers who is disingenuously starting threads to be 'thought-provoking' not realising we have had this same conversation twice a week for years."

"I suggest you get up off your arse and do some research on this properly rather than just using Twitter to inform you as your sole source of information. And no I can not be arsed to repeat myself ...."

My earlier point about both sides sounding more and more like each other made for me, I think. Sinking to the level of the opposition will not help win the battle

Edited

Pretending a sexist movement is reasonable so as not to look "as bad as them" won't either though. It just obscures the issues.

This is something women deal with on a personal basis all the time - having to be polite through gritted teeth to men who can smilingly demean or dismiss us because society's double standards mean his sexism is normalised while our anger about his sexism is pathologised.

It hurts us. It hides the problem if we can't speak directly about the problem.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 10:56

Agree RTB.

Yet, we have seen mandated language being introduced into workplaces and legal systems.

Governments have allowed people’s demands for personalised language to become punishable offences.

Kirralie Smith is fighting a massive fine for pointing out two male people playing female sport were not female.

Dora Moutot is being prosecuted for saying a male caller into a televised panel discussion was a man.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5532554-in-france-dora-moutot-convicted-of-transphobia-for-identifying-a-tw-as-male-when-asked

There was a Brazilian feminist who had to go to court for using accurate language for a male person.

Court proceedings here may require male people to have mandated female language used at risk of contempt of court. Naomi Cunningham gets reported to the bar standards board for using accurate sex based language.

None of this is ‘kind’, ‘respectful’ or ‘reasonable’.

In France, Dora Moutot convicted of transphobia for identifying a TW as male when asked. | Mumsnet

While we await the full implementation of the FWS judgment in the UK, Australia and now France show that the battle is far from over. In 2021, Dora M...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5532554-in-france-dora-moutot-convicted-of-transphobia-for-identifying-a-tw-as-male-when-asked

RedToothBrush · 31/08/2026 10:47

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 10:38

I think part of the issue I have with anyone judging what is ‘kind’ or not is that it is often forgotten that kindness by its nature is an outcome that comes at some cost to those being ‘kind’.

Those who judge another for being unkind may be forgetting that just because they see the cost as insignificant, others not following with the same action may have very legitimate concerns about the outcome and the cost associated. The labels of ‘unkindness’ and ‘kindness’ are moral judgements and often very superficially judged.

We should not be making law on the basis of kindness.

We should be making law on the basis of workability, fairness and keeping in mind other laws and legal obligations about protecting everyone not just a singular group.

The laws we have are often about protecting two parties - one in a position of power and one in a position of vulnerability. Both have importance and a failure to do both undermines the protection of both. For example the doctor who treats a transperson still has to act within rules and ethics - this protects both the transperson, someone who thinks they might be trans but isn't and the doctor themselves. When we fail to do this adequately the fallout has implications for all parties. It isn't about being kind - it's about safeguarding.

It always comes back to safeguarding in some form or other. That's what the focus of law is. Not a fuzzy notion of indefinable niceness (which often isn't nice to everyone).

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 10:38

I think part of the issue I have with anyone judging what is ‘kind’ or not is that it is often forgotten that kindness by its nature is an outcome that comes at some cost to those being ‘kind’.

Those who judge another for being unkind may be forgetting that just because they see the cost as insignificant, others not following with the same action may have very legitimate concerns about the outcome and the cost associated. The labels of ‘unkindness’ and ‘kindness’ are moral judgements and often very superficially judged.

nutmeg7 · 31/08/2026 10:34

Imdunfer · 31/08/2026 09:13

"Try listening rather than being a cloth eared sanctimonious bully who demeans and undermines women as independent humans rather than merely support humans to make egos."

"To me, you are someone who hasn't a fucking clue, copies and pastes AI guff and doesn't apply critical thinking or you are another one of these ploppers who is disingenuously starting threads to be 'thought-provoking' not realising we have had this same conversation twice a week for years."

"I suggest you get up off your arse and do some research on this properly rather than just using Twitter to inform you as your sole source of information. And no I can not be arsed to repeat myself ...."

My earlier point about both sides sounding more and more like each other made for me, I think. Sinking to the level of the opposition will not help win the battle

Edited

People on both sides get angry and say hurtful things to others.

However, only one side issues death and rape threats, violently pickets and attacks meetings, vandalises buildings that host meetings or house offices of people they disagree with, pours bottles of piss everywhere, tries to destroy any single sex groups, and makes vexatious complaints to the police about misgendering.

Women do not try to prevent trans people meeting by picketing, barricading, screaming abuse in the street, or vandalise venues that host trans meetings, or issue threats of violence (with associated graphic imagery).

I think that is what people generally mean by “both sides”. People getting snarky on a forum is universal. Real life violence and attempts to destroy what you can’t have isn’t coming from women. We are completely happy for trans people to meet up to their hearts content, to discuss their needs. It would be nice if that respect was reciprocated for female people and female spaces.