Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Thoughts on this tweet?

343 replies

walkthedino · 29/08/2026 15:24

I saw the below tweet today and agreed with a lot of it. I wondered what people on this forum thought.

I have copied and pasted so the post doesn’t have to wait for a screenshot to be approved:

My trans positions are VERY CONTROVERSIAL because they are so dead moderate they make both cocaine-fueled extremes angry.

✅ Yes, most children are being overmedicalized. But rare true trans children deserve help or they psychologically shatter
✅ No, trans women do not belong in professional sports. But it’s hateful to call them men.
✅ Trans women are not automatically women. But with hard work and medical intervention, most of us can have fulfilling lives where people perceive us as women.
✅ Self-ID must end. Women’s feelings and safety matter, so if you cannot use the ladies non-disruptively - don’t.
✅ If you can’t understand why women should never see a penis in a locker room, you’re mentally still a man.
✅ We need research to figure out what is happening with this explosion of non-binary identities. They are not trans, and it’s medical malpractice to give them transsexual healthcare.
✅ You have to do the work to be percieved as a woman. Far left politics cannot do this work for you.

I promise you. The overwhelming majority of the public agrees with all of this. If trans people will go back to the non-insane positions of ten years ago, things will get better.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Heggettypeg · 31/08/2026 17:16

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 10:56

Agree RTB.

Yet, we have seen mandated language being introduced into workplaces and legal systems.

Governments have allowed people’s demands for personalised language to become punishable offences.

Kirralie Smith is fighting a massive fine for pointing out two male people playing female sport were not female.

Dora Moutot is being prosecuted for saying a male caller into a televised panel discussion was a man.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5532554-in-france-dora-moutot-convicted-of-transphobia-for-identifying-a-tw-as-male-when-asked

There was a Brazilian feminist who had to go to court for using accurate language for a male person.

Court proceedings here may require male people to have mandated female language used at risk of contempt of court. Naomi Cunningham gets reported to the bar standards board for using accurate sex based language.

None of this is ‘kind’, ‘respectful’ or ‘reasonable’.

"Just be kind, it's only pronouns" was the inch.
This legalised tyranny is the mile.

Shedmistress · 31/08/2026 17:13

The issue is; Left wing lesbians and feminists raised the alarm, some of them decades ago.

Right wing men decided that what they were seeing was indeed 'absofuckinglutely batshit crazy' and ever since, all the left wing lesbians and feminists have been 'aligned' with the 'far right'.

It never goes the other way, that the right wing men are aligned with left wing lesbians and feminists, probably because the left wing lesbians and feminists are not worthy of being thought of as important enough to have influenced anyone of note.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/08/2026 15:08

Imdunfer · 31/08/2026 14:11

Don't put words in my mouth I've never told anyone to "be kind" , I hate that expression, it's a charter for psychopaths.

"Being kind" was two words in a five paragraph post. I'll make a note not to suggest in future you use that exact phrase.

You have described Feminists who reject cross sex language as "Ultras". And you have said that Feminists need to be more moderate, more polite, more conciliatory towards the "other side" to make progress.

My point that to use cross sex language is to concede the crucial point upon which the Feminist argument rests before the discussion has started.

Rephrase "be kind" as "respectful" or "moderate" - it doesn't change my argument.

ElenOfTheWays · 31/08/2026 14:42

Imdunfer · 31/08/2026 09:13

"Try listening rather than being a cloth eared sanctimonious bully who demeans and undermines women as independent humans rather than merely support humans to make egos."

"To me, you are someone who hasn't a fucking clue, copies and pastes AI guff and doesn't apply critical thinking or you are another one of these ploppers who is disingenuously starting threads to be 'thought-provoking' not realising we have had this same conversation twice a week for years."

"I suggest you get up off your arse and do some research on this properly rather than just using Twitter to inform you as your sole source of information. And no I can not be arsed to repeat myself ...."

My earlier point about both sides sounding more and more like each other made for me, I think. Sinking to the level of the opposition will not help win the battle

Edited

Yes indeed. Note in particular the death and rape threats in these posts. The name calling and implied erasure of the poster leading to the posters suicide or the suicide of their kids.

Exactly the same as TRAs.
Such terrible wimmin.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 14:29

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 14:14

I suppose what we are seeing is the post-hoc rationalisation.

Explanations roughly 'Of course I always knew this was correct, but wasn't nasty enough to say so'.

I suppose it's the Nicola Sturgeon 'rapist gender' stage of denial. Won't outright defend Isla Bryson's right to be placed in a women's jail, but will grimly maintain the women complaining are just as bad as the rapist.

Another word for the supposed 'moderate' position is 'prevarication'.

The number of times we have been either

a) told that there is this magic solution, only for that ‘solution’ to be the same one suggested a decade ago and very thoroughly discussed.

and / or b) told that because we use accurate language we are mean and hateful even though the person agrees with the sentiment we are expressing.

It is the classic bananarama moment. It isn’t the content of what we say, it how we say it that renders us inaudible to some because they will not hear of any male person being described as a male person if they have a gender identity. And we are the problem. If we just said it nicely within the right tonality that that person can hear, then maybe they would stop censuring us.

It is a well run script now.

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 14:14

Wishesandhorses · 31/08/2026 13:59

I can never see anything beyond someone scolding me about 'kindness' when it is very bleeding obvious that they don't value 'kindness' at all.

They mean 'do what I want for this person I see as valuable, which involves trampling, ignoring and deriding others regardless of how vulnerable they are too'.

Fuck that. Seriously. It's coercion and sexism trying to hide under a figleaf of 'I'm a nice person'. I'm never sure who they think they're kidding.

And when they encounter someone unpicking it, we get the hurt/superior flounce of 'well I know I'm right and I won't bother explaining it to you awful women'. Because that avoids all responsibility too.

Be prejudiced. Hate women. Whatever, you do you. But have the guts to be honest with yourself and with women about it ffs.

I suppose what we are seeing is the post-hoc rationalisation.

Explanations roughly 'Of course I always knew this was correct, but wasn't nasty enough to say so'.

I suppose it's the Nicola Sturgeon 'rapist gender' stage of denial. Won't outright defend Isla Bryson's right to be placed in a women's jail, but will grimly maintain the women complaining are just as bad as the rapist.

Another word for the supposed 'moderate' position is 'prevarication'.

6ate9 · 31/08/2026 14:14

Imdunfer · 31/08/2026 14:11

Don't put words in my mouth I've never told anyone to "be kind" , I hate that expression, it's a charter for psychopaths.

#BeKind is a red flag!!

Imdunfer · 31/08/2026 14:11

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/08/2026 13:36

But you are.

When you paint Feminists who will not use female language for men as "Ultras" and tell us that being kind will be more effective than being truthful that is exactly what you are doing.

If we cannot say openly and honestly that a man is a man bexause we need to cloak that truth in "polite" conciliatory cross sex or sexless language, we are agreeing not to talk about the fundamental issue with cross sex identity before the conversation has even started. Of course it then hampers us explaining the problem!

Again, it's a pattern of abusive relationships. The abuser wraps any of their bad behaviour in emotional issues that are "too painful", "unfair" to bring up, meaning the abused partner who approaches openly and honestly is the only one whose problems/behaviour can be criticised or discussed, and eventually they too end up thinking the problem must be them.

A display of vulnerability is a great silencer of criticism.

Don't put words in my mouth I've never told anyone to "be kind" , I hate that expression, it's a charter for psychopaths.

iwishitwouldstartraining · 31/08/2026 14:06

Some women are happy to use preferred pronouns, and some women aren't, generally for reasons explained in the 'pronouns are rohypnol' essay. Neither of these positions is particularly extreme.

However, if somebody has convinced themself that their happiness depends on everyone else perceiving them as the opposite sex, there is no 'nice' way to observe their actual sex, and there is no way to protect women's rights unless it is possible to observe actual sex.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 14:03

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 13:52

All the way along, since feminists first raised the alarm, and all through all the court cases, the underground meetings, the silencings, the cancellations, the attacks, the doxxings, the swattings, the monsterings, the 'die in a grease fire', the 'if you see a terf, punch them in the fucking face', the 'decapitate terfs', etc, women have been told over and over that we are 'extreme' and 'bigots' and 'unkind' and 'on the wrong side of history'.

All we were asking for was women's rights, that the Supreme Court established we are entitled to in law. The right to believe that there are two sexes, and that sex is immutable, established by Maya Forstater's EAT. The fact that children shoudl not be pathologised for 'gender incongruence', as (partly) established by the Cass Report. And yes, the right to say a man is a man, and we have the right to say that a man is a man. Rapist or otherwise.

This is not extreme. It's not even contentious. The problem was that a very determined movement spent years and years, backed by inordinately well funded organisations like Stonewall and Mermaids and GIRES, telling women that there was 'no debate' and that nobody could question anything that was said if it was said by a 'trans' person.

We weren't ever extreme. It was the gender movement that was extreme.

yeah... but... 'both sides' ...

Wishesandhorses · 31/08/2026 13:59

I can never see anything beyond someone scolding me about 'kindness' when it is very bleeding obvious that they don't value 'kindness' at all.

They mean 'do what I want for this person I see as valuable, which involves trampling, ignoring and deriding others regardless of how vulnerable they are too'.

Fuck that. Seriously. It's coercion and sexism trying to hide under a figleaf of 'I'm a nice person'. I'm never sure who they think they're kidding.

And when they encounter someone unpicking it, we get the hurt/superior flounce of 'well I know I'm right and I won't bother explaining it to you awful women'. Because that avoids all responsibility too.

Be prejudiced. Hate women. Whatever, you do you. But have the guts to be honest with yourself and with women about it ffs.

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 13:55

Way back when we were told we were 'extreme' and 'bigots' for saying men shouldn't be in women's prisons.

And for saying that puberty blockers can cause harm.

And for saying that women should be free to talk about women's rights without being attacked.

The lines shift a bit, but we are pretty used to being vilified and insulted. It maybe worked for a bit, for some, because nobody wants to be called a bigot, but in the end, it doesn't really shift the dial.

Insults and vilification now just alert me to the fact the person using them has an agenda and is trying to win using attack, rather than reasoned argument.

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 13:52

All the way along, since feminists first raised the alarm, and all through all the court cases, the underground meetings, the silencings, the cancellations, the attacks, the doxxings, the swattings, the monsterings, the 'die in a grease fire', the 'if you see a terf, punch them in the fucking face', the 'decapitate terfs', etc, women have been told over and over that we are 'extreme' and 'bigots' and 'unkind' and 'on the wrong side of history'.

All we were asking for was women's rights, that the Supreme Court established we are entitled to in law. The right to believe that there are two sexes, and that sex is immutable, established by Maya Forstater's EAT. The fact that children shoudl not be pathologised for 'gender incongruence', as (partly) established by the Cass Report. And yes, the right to say a man is a man, and we have the right to say that a man is a man. Rapist or otherwise.

This is not extreme. It's not even contentious. The problem was that a very determined movement spent years and years, backed by inordinately well funded organisations like Stonewall and Mermaids and GIRES, telling women that there was 'no debate' and that nobody could question anything that was said if it was said by a 'trans' person.

We weren't ever extreme. It was the gender movement that was extreme.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2026 13:51

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/08/2026 13:36

But you are.

When you paint Feminists who will not use female language for men as "Ultras" and tell us that being kind will be more effective than being truthful that is exactly what you are doing.

If we cannot say openly and honestly that a man is a man bexause we need to cloak that truth in "polite" conciliatory cross sex or sexless language, we are agreeing not to talk about the fundamental issue with cross sex identity before the conversation has even started. Of course it then hampers us explaining the problem!

Again, it's a pattern of abusive relationships. The abuser wraps any of their bad behaviour in emotional issues that are "too painful", "unfair" to bring up, meaning the abused partner who approaches openly and honestly is the only one whose problems/behaviour can be criticised or discussed, and eventually they too end up thinking the problem must be them.

A display of vulnerability is a great silencer of criticism.

I think that some people believe that them saying that it is not 'kind' and not 'respectful' or 'reasonable' is not emotionally manipulating others to change their behaviour to match that person's perception of 'kind' and 'respectful' and 'reasonable'.

That is fine, because frankly, if they wish to do that, that is their choice. People are free to push back and explain how it is not the things that those people say it is. Judgement goes both ways. If they then claim to be 'piled' on, frankly, that is another of their perceptions that they might need to review. Because if they perceive people saying they are wrong and explaining why as being 'piled on', then they may feel that they should be free of any challenge to their moralising.

It usually goes hand in hand with people who declare that they are the 'moderate' thinkers or the 'reasonable' ones who cannot articulate the reasons their opinions are an accurate representation of the reality of the situation. I guess we are so used to being treated as being the 'extremists' and being unkind, hateful bigots that we just plough on and keep explaining with evidence and detailed thinking.

I have been on threads where it was just me and then others telling me how hateful I have been and frankly, after the first review of what I said and whether it was still accurate with all the other information that was presented, I didn't feel 'piled' on. Despite the language being used to describe me. If I didn't think I could cope with people pointing out the I was wrong and why, I would not post on MN on any board.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/08/2026 13:36

Imdunfer · 31/08/2026 11:17

It hides the problem if we can't speak directly about the problem.

It's a good job nobody is suggesting doing that then.

But you are.

When you paint Feminists who will not use female language for men as "Ultras" and tell us that being kind will be more effective than being truthful that is exactly what you are doing.

If we cannot say openly and honestly that a man is a man bexause we need to cloak that truth in "polite" conciliatory cross sex or sexless language, we are agreeing not to talk about the fundamental issue with cross sex identity before the conversation has even started. Of course it then hampers us explaining the problem!

Again, it's a pattern of abusive relationships. The abuser wraps any of their bad behaviour in emotional issues that are "too painful", "unfair" to bring up, meaning the abused partner who approaches openly and honestly is the only one whose problems/behaviour can be criticised or discussed, and eventually they too end up thinking the problem must be them.

A display of vulnerability is a great silencer of criticism.

RedToothBrush · 31/08/2026 13:27

Mmmnotsure · 31/08/2026 13:03

One of the worst things for me - and you know this only too well - is that this ideology inserts itself into and destroys relationships between people. Any group which is intent, as this one appears to be, on separating the bonds between friends and relatives, and especially between parents and children, cannot be good.

The only groups / individuals that do this are groomers, cults, abusers and extremists.

We need to say this out loud.

It's one of those really hard inconvenient truths that needs to be seen and acknowledged because it's a massive problem.

Datun · 31/08/2026 13:19

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 12:51

The women who established women's rights in law have done an immense service for all women and girls. The time and effort and risk put in has been immense. Little by little we made gains. On behalf of many who have no idea. Thats fucking 'kind'!

But they'll be vilified as 'extreme' for failing to observe the very social niceties that were weaponised against us. By people that either fail to grasp the underlying issues or are more invested in maintaining their image as on the RSOH as super 'kind' people who never dirtied their hands with risk.

Twas ever thus.

By people that either fail to grasp the underlying issues or are more invested in maintaining their image as on the RSOH as super 'kind' people who never dirtied their hands with risk.

Yep.

i'd love to see one of these be kinders explain how you can fight for women's rights in a society that constantly tries to stop you.

Mmmnotsure · 31/08/2026 13:03

RedToothBrush · 31/08/2026 12:56

You are saying the elephant in the room.

You are saying out loud what they all think but don't feel free to say. They don't like you being the messenger and questioning their stupidity and inability to have a straightforward conversation because they are so busy tripping over themselves to prove their virtue vanity.

One of the worst things for me - and you know this only too well - is that this ideology inserts itself into and destroys relationships between people. Any group which is intent, as this one appears to be, on separating the bonds between friends and relatives, and especially between parents and children, cannot be good.

RedToothBrush · 31/08/2026 12:56

Mmmnotsure · 31/08/2026 12:42

I had something similar with a young male relative.

He overheard a conversation I was having regarding a girl who ids as nb and thus wants they/them. I was getting very confused - it was to do with her travel arrangements - about how many people we were talking about, and used 'she'.

This young man reacted with absolute fury (not tears, presumably because of not being female). I am still shocked at the level of his rage, which I see partly as resulting from his cognitive dissonance.

The nb girl we were talking about wasn't there at the time. She wasn't even on the same continent.

You are saying the elephant in the room.

You are saying out loud what they all think but don't feel free to say. They don't like you being the messenger and questioning their stupidity and inability to have a straightforward conversation because they are so busy tripping over themselves to prove their virtue vanity.

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 12:51

Datun · 31/08/2026 12:44

Totally.

Women have been battered, beaten, threatened, excluded, bullied, fired and arrested.

Just to make the court reiterate what the bloody law IS.

Apart from anything else, asking for kindness now, is such a monumental fucking cheek and tells you everything you need to know about who has the power.

Edited

The women who established women's rights in law have done an immense service for all women and girls. The time and effort and risk put in has been immense. Little by little we made gains. On behalf of many who have no idea. Thats fucking 'kind'!

But they'll be vilified as 'extreme' for failing to observe the very social niceties that were weaponised against us. By people that either fail to grasp the underlying issues or are more invested in maintaining their image as on the RSOH as super 'kind' people who never dirtied their hands with risk.

Twas ever thus.

Mmmnotsure · 31/08/2026 12:46

Helen Joyce bio on X. [My bold]

Author of book about gender-ID ideology. Show me the 3rd gamete & then we can talk.Shame needs to change sides. No, you be kind. Newsletter: Joyce Activated

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 12:45

JK Rowling runs and funds an orphanage and a service for rape survivors, ffs, and mouth breathers on the internet want to try to harangue her about being 'kind'.

There isnt an agreed way to be 'kind' so its just used as an admonishment, generally a slightly dishonest way of saying 'shut up'.

I suppose the response I'd favour is - 'no, you'.

Datun · 31/08/2026 12:44

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 12:38

Its easy to position oneself as 'moderate' after the battles have been largely won by others sacrificing their careers, safety, and reputation.

Totally.

Women have been battered, beaten, threatened, excluded, bullied, fired and arrested.

Just to make the court reiterate what the bloody law IS.

Apart from anything else, asking for kindness now, is such a monumental fucking cheek and tells you everything you need to know about who has the power.

Mmmnotsure · 31/08/2026 12:42

SadSadTimes · 31/08/2026 11:37

My experience with the language bomb that is they/them:

SST: so what is Sally up to this weekend?
niece: oh, they went to the festival
SST: they? who did she go with?
niece: how could you?!! you know Sally is nb and asks for they/them!! That is so disrespectful (actual tears)
SST: but but...I really didn't know or if I did I didn't remember and Sally isn't even here so not so very horrible?
niece: (howls) but if I don't always remember and be very careful in my thoughts I might make a mistake when talking to Sally that would be really hurtful, she would hate me, you are mean etc etc
SST: (quietly because niece is clearly miserable) your friend makes you police your thoughts and utterings, in her presence and beyond?

I had something similar with a young male relative.

He overheard a conversation I was having regarding a girl who ids as nb and thus wants they/them. I was getting very confused - it was to do with her travel arrangements - about how many people we were talking about, and used 'she'.

This young man reacted with absolute fury (not tears, presumably because of not being female). I am still shocked at the level of his rage, which I see partly as resulting from his cognitive dissonance.

The nb girl we were talking about wasn't there at the time. She wasn't even on the same continent.

ArabellaScott · 31/08/2026 12:38

Theeyeballsinthesky · 31/08/2026 08:38

Apparently so

its the old both sideism

Its easy to position oneself as 'moderate' after the battles have been largely won by others sacrificing their careers, safety, and reputation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread