Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Forced hospital transfer in labour - for induction of labour - upheld by ECHR

115 replies

NibliaBiblia · 28/08/2026 11:58

Police and an ambulance arrived with a court order to compel the transfer to hospital if a woman safely labouring at home with her midwife - and forced her to undergo an induction of labour!

And the ECHR has upheld the court order. Dark day for our right to control our own bodies.

https://birthrights.org.uk/2026/08/27/cp-v-spain-why-a-major-european-court-ruling-on-maternity-care-is-a-wake-up-call-for-bodily-autonomy-rights/

CP v Spain: Why a major European court ruling on maternity care is a wake-up call for bodily autonomy rights - Birthrights

Birthrights 'End Coercion in Maternity Care in the UK' Report Case Study Social Services and Maternity Care blog long read

https://birthrights.org.uk/2026/08/27/cp-v-spain-why-a-major-european-court-ruling-on-maternity-care-is-a-wake-up-call-for-bodily-autonomy-rights/

OP posts:
NibliaBiblia · 28/08/2026 13:51

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 13:47

She wasn't perfectly healthy but into the 43rd week of pregnancy and there was a suggestion that the baby's head was too big to pass her pelvis. And she wasn't forced to have an induction or anything else. When labour would not restart she agree to a caesarian - not sure why labour stalled but presumably had it done so at home the midwife would have called an ambulance since this might be an emergency. I am in favour of home birth but sometimes it is not possible. Baby and mother have the right to be delivered.

Sometimes it is not possible to have a safe home birth, but this is not a woman deciding to transfer for her safety. It's the police turning up and forcing her into the hospital. It's barbaric.

OP posts:
Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 13:47

NibliaBiblia · 28/08/2026 13:25

Lots of people think a woman should be forced to undergo a C-section because VBAC is too dangerous but I'm surprised to see someone on a feminist forum advocating forcible administration of invasive medical treatment to a perfectly healthy pregnant woman.

She wasn't perfectly healthy but into the 43rd week of pregnancy and there was a suggestion that the baby's head was too big to pass her pelvis. And she wasn't forced to have an induction or anything else. When labour would not restart she agree to a caesarian - not sure why labour stalled but presumably had it done so at home the midwife would have called an ambulance since this might be an emergency. I am in favour of home birth but sometimes it is not possible. Baby and mother have the right to be delivered.

iwishitwouldstartraining · 28/08/2026 13:47

NibliaBiblia · 28/08/2026 13:25

Lots of people think a woman should be forced to undergo a C-section because VBAC is too dangerous but I'm surprised to see someone on a feminist forum advocating forcible administration of invasive medical treatment to a perfectly healthy pregnant woman.

It demonstrates clearly that treating foetuses as children under Spanish law has the consequence of destroying the bodily autonomy of pregnant women and birthing persons in Spain.

I'm a bit confused about this.

I don't know what status foetuses have in the UK, but I don't think any doctor would be thinking 'It's OK folks, the baby doesn't have any rights yet, no need to worry until it does'.

NibliaBiblia · 28/08/2026 13:43

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 13:38

Yes, wow! That anyone should care that the baby might die as a result of stupid behaviour on the part of the mother, who appears to have been 'free birthing'! Two people are involved in childbirth, a woman and a child. Both have the right to come out of it alive.
I note that the writers of this report refer to 'women and birthing people' thus kowtowing to the most misogynistic ideology on the planet - gender identity. I am shocked that UK law allows a woman with capacity to refuse treatment that would save the life of her baby - I think this needs looking at, because that is taking bodily autonomy (which, really, we do not have) much too far. What woman answers the question, 'can we save your baby by doing a caesarian?' with 'No, I want a natural birth even if it is of a dead baby'? One would question the capacity of a woman who made such a decision.

Edited

She had a midwife and was healthy, but even if she had been free birthing, yes she should absolutely have the right to do so.
I can guarantee she cares a lot more about her baby than the hospital and the court!

OP posts:
BIWI · 28/08/2026 13:42

Since when did tagging people become poor etiquette @CoupDeToe ? It's a way to ensure that a) you're responding to the right poster b) that other posters know to whom you're replying and c) that the poster to whom you're replying sees your response.

Not much point having the feature if we're not supposed to use it!

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 13:38

NibliaBiblia · 28/08/2026 12:59

Wow.

Yes, wow! That anyone should care that the baby might die as a result of stupid behaviour on the part of the mother, who appears to have been 'free birthing'! Two people are involved in childbirth, a woman and a child. Both have the right to come out of it alive.
I note that the writers of this report refer to 'women and birthing people' thus kowtowing to the most misogynistic ideology on the planet - gender identity. I am shocked that UK law allows a woman with capacity to refuse treatment that would save the life of her baby - I think this needs looking at, because that is taking bodily autonomy (which, really, we do not have) much too far. What woman answers the question, 'can we save your baby by doing a caesarian?' with 'No, I want a natural birth even if it is of a dead baby'? One would question the capacity of a woman who made such a decision.

Jellybunny98 · 28/08/2026 13:32

My understanding of the case is that she was not forced to have an induction, she actually didn’t have an induction, her checks at the hospital initially had not been satisfactory and she had not returned after saying she would. Their laws extend to unborn children and so between the unsatisfactory checks, failing to return & being post-term she was brought back to hospital to be checked again. Those checks were okay and so she just waited for labour to restart, and did ultimately agree to a c section. She was not forced to have an induction.

NibliaBiblia · 28/08/2026 13:25

CoupDeToe · 28/08/2026 13:22

Don't @ me. It's considered bad etiquette on this forum.

Most ordinary people would consider that the baby has some form of rights at 42+ weeks. I have read accounts on the other boards of women having stillbirths because they have ignored their doctors suggesting induction because they want to do their natural thing.

There's no point arguing with people with such extreme positions. There are so many people on this forum who think that the woman should even have a right to an abortion at 40+ weeks. I won't be back on this thread and leave you to it.

Lots of people think a woman should be forced to undergo a C-section because VBAC is too dangerous but I'm surprised to see someone on a feminist forum advocating forcible administration of invasive medical treatment to a perfectly healthy pregnant woman.

OP posts:
CoupDeToe · 28/08/2026 13:22

KnottyAuty · 28/08/2026 13:03

Blimey - no wonder the labour stalled! I doubt anyone could birth a baby under those circumstances. The adrenaline from hearing police at the door must have been off the charts.

@CoupDeToe the hospital checks on initial hospital admission confirmed there was no problem with the birth at that time. Based on the evidence on the article it’s unclear whether this intervention by the authorities improved or increased risk for mum and baby. We would need to know more - notably theres no detail about whether the baby did have a large head as suspected. The fact it wasnt mentioned at all and that the mother sued suggests to me it was a false positive which meant the whole debacle might have been avoidable. Very sad story

ETA advice is not to get into a birthing pool until the birth is progressing so it must have completely stalled/reversed due to the police arriving.

Edited

Don't @ me. It's considered bad etiquette on this forum.

Most ordinary people would consider that the baby has some form of rights at 42+ weeks. I have read accounts on the other boards of women having stillbirths because they have ignored their doctors suggesting induction because they want to do their natural thing.

There's no point arguing with people with such extreme positions. There are so many people on this forum who think that the woman should even have a right to an abortion at 40+ weeks. I won't be back on this thread and leave you to it.

KnottyAuty · 28/08/2026 13:03

Blimey - no wonder the labour stalled! I doubt anyone could birth a baby under those circumstances. The adrenaline from hearing police at the door must have been off the charts.

@CoupDeToe the hospital checks on initial hospital admission confirmed there was no problem with the birth at that time. Based on the evidence on the article it’s unclear whether this intervention by the authorities improved or increased risk for mum and baby. We would need to know more - notably theres no detail about whether the baby did have a large head as suspected. The fact it wasnt mentioned at all and that the mother sued suggests to me it was a false positive which meant the whole debacle might have been avoidable. Very sad story

ETA advice is not to get into a birthing pool until the birth is progressing so it must have completely stalled/reversed due to the police arriving.

NibliaBiblia · 28/08/2026 12:59

CoupDeToe · 28/08/2026 12:57

You're being ridiculous and are completely out of touch.

Good on Spain for saving the baby.

Wow.

OP posts:
CoupDeToe · 28/08/2026 12:57

You're being ridiculous and are completely out of touch.

Good on Spain for saving the baby.

Octavia64 · 28/08/2026 12:54

having read this it is in Spain and the article makes clear it does not apply to Britain.

NibliaBiblia · 28/08/2026 12:53

It was the ECHR upholding it that i find even more shocking tbh. So sad.

OP posts:
DitheringDaisyPetal · 28/08/2026 12:49

Shocking. But less surprising when you see where this took place. Spain’s lawmakers don’t seem to have much respect for women.

Swipe left for the next trending thread