Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Forced hospital transfer in labour - for induction of labour - upheld by ECHR

115 replies

NibliaBiblia · 28/08/2026 11:58

Police and an ambulance arrived with a court order to compel the transfer to hospital if a woman safely labouring at home with her midwife - and forced her to undergo an induction of labour!

And the ECHR has upheld the court order. Dark day for our right to control our own bodies.

https://birthrights.org.uk/2026/08/27/cp-v-spain-why-a-major-european-court-ruling-on-maternity-care-is-a-wake-up-call-for-bodily-autonomy-rights/

CP v Spain: Why a major European court ruling on maternity care is a wake-up call for bodily autonomy rights - Birthrights

Birthrights 'End Coercion in Maternity Care in the UK' Report Case Study Social Services and Maternity Care blog long read

https://birthrights.org.uk/2026/08/27/cp-v-spain-why-a-major-european-court-ruling-on-maternity-care-is-a-wake-up-call-for-bodily-autonomy-rights/

OP posts:
RoyalCorgi · 29/08/2026 10:16

I agree, Aston. I don't want to live in a society where women are coerced into particular procedures to save their unborn baby. And I know it's frustrating and upsetting when women make decisions that might put their baby's life at risk, whether it's free birthing or refusing an emergency c-section. But the idea that women should be forced to give birth in hospital, or forced to have a c-section against their will is horrifying.

Hoardasurass · 29/08/2026 10:15

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:22

A child in utero has the right to be born alive and not die because his/her mother worries more about her bodily autonomy than her child's life. Honestly, this is what most people think.

No it doesn't not in UK law.
A pregnant woman has the right to an abortion if she wants, has the right to take lifesaving medication that will kill her baby to have surgeries that will cause the death of her baby if she needs them.
That is just part of what a womens bodily autonomy means and is what you are trying to strip from women all so you can turn her onto a walking incubator

AstonCanKissMyArse · 29/08/2026 10:12

The article says she was giving birth at home supported by her husband and a registered midwife.

This is not free birthing, which is giving birth alone.

A PP has repeatedly stated the mother was free birthing - that's not what the article says.

Equating the two is not helpful as they are completely different things.

I appreciate that risks to the baby need to be managed, but as PP have said, where do we draw the line? Its inconsistent to argue that the baby has absolute rights as a human but then to also say that you don't agree with women being strapped down and forced to have procedures they don't consent to.

You cant have one without the other. Therefore a line has to be drawn somewhere.

Affording total rights to the baby leads to situations like in Texas, Arizona and other southern US states where a mother cannot access proper medical care for a failed pregnancy 'in case' the medics are seen to be participating in an abortion. They just let nature take its course. Putting women at risk of infection, infertility and death for the sake of a principle seems to me to be taking it too far. But that is where the principle of the baby being a person leads.

Or the awful old fashioned scenario of the doctor asking the husband in a difficult birth whether they should save the mother or the child.

Its easy to argue in moral absolutes. Its rather more difficult to translate that into workable policy.

Hoardasurass · 29/08/2026 10:07

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:18

I think the law should protect the unborn child.

Would you like to see women who suffer miscarriages or stillbirths arrested and put on trial for murder?
Women who took medication that she was told was safe but the drs were mistaken or hadn't been informed or dangers to the baby prosecuted for gbh along with the Dr's?
Would you want women who find out that they have cancer when their pregnant to be forced to delay treatment until after the baby is born full term even if that ment that the cancer was untreatable.
I ask because these are just some of the consequences to women of giving rights and/or personhood to an unborn child.
Also think about this what dr or pharmaceutical company would treat pregnant women or make drugs for them if doing so risks jail?

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 09:59

Hoardasurass · 29/08/2026 09:53

Babies born by vaginal delivery are exposed to the mothers vaginal bacteria which improves their immune system and the squeezing action helps clear their lungs of fluid. Both of these are shown to lower the risks of asthma and allergies.
All in all where possible (ie no complications that would prevent a safe delivery) its better for both mother and baby to have a natural delivery.
Also it takes on average 4 weeks to recover from a vaginal birth whereas it takes 4 months to recover from a c section

But would you prevent a woman from having a C-section if she wanted one anyway? It's not really about what's safer, especially as they're all relatively safe options.
It's about acknowledging that opinions differ and what's right for one mother and baby is not for another.
If someone is about to jump off a bridge it's right to stop them. If someone wants to go for a walk on a bridge that looks a bit rickety to you, you can explain your concerns but you can't tackle them to the ground.

OP posts:
Hoardasurass · 29/08/2026 09:53

nocoolnamesleft · 28/08/2026 16:03

Yep. Cold sections are more likely to result in short term breathing difficulties and SCBU admission, but less likely to result in brain damage.

Babies born by vaginal delivery are exposed to the mothers vaginal bacteria which improves their immune system and the squeezing action helps clear their lungs of fluid. Both of these are shown to lower the risks of asthma and allergies.
All in all where possible (ie no complications that would prevent a safe delivery) its better for both mother and baby to have a natural delivery.
Also it takes on average 4 weeks to recover from a vaginal birth whereas it takes 4 months to recover from a c section

Dontknowwhocanhelp · 29/08/2026 09:43

CoupDeToe · 28/08/2026 13:22

Don't @ me. It's considered bad etiquette on this forum.

Most ordinary people would consider that the baby has some form of rights at 42+ weeks. I have read accounts on the other boards of women having stillbirths because they have ignored their doctors suggesting induction because they want to do their natural thing.

There's no point arguing with people with such extreme positions. There are so many people on this forum who think that the woman should even have a right to an abortion at 40+ weeks. I won't be back on this thread and leave you to it.

Don't @ me. It's considered bad etiquette on this forum.

Is it?
I’m really surprised by that.
People do it all the time, sometimes to thank a specific poster, sometimes for clarity if they’re addressing a variety of points that have been brought up by different posters.

What makes you say it’s poor etiquette? Genuinely perplexed here.

The actions described in the article above seem very heavy handed, but I’d like to have more detail before commenting. On the face of it, it seems wrong, but then I wonder why the decision was upheld.

EvelynBeatrice · 29/08/2026 08:52

And generalities do not make for good individual patient care. What works for 60 per cent of births may not for the woman in front of you because of her specific circumstances. Ask any (decent) midwife.

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 08:49

Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 08:37

This. What’s the point in becoming pregnant and carrying if you don’t care if the baby lives or dies as long as a woman has full body autonomy. I’m currently 32 weeks pregnant and I’m going to put the needs of my baby and myself above everything else

I put the needs of my baby above everything else. That's why I had a home birth outside of guidance, because I decided that was safest for my baby.
You might not agree with my decision that's safest, I might not agree with your decision that sweeps/hospital/VEs/induction/epidural/C-section is safest. But it's not up to me to decide what's best for you and your baby any more than it's up to you to decide what's best for me and my baby.

OP posts:
EvelynBeatrice · 29/08/2026 08:49

Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 08:31

Obviously however if you go too far over your placenta can stop working. A risk of still birth is higher etc so why would anyone want to run these risks on their unborn child or themselves why would anyone want to risk loosing their baby and having to give birth and cause harm to yourself or the unborn it’s mental that some women are so okay with these choices because in my opinion it’s safer to bring labour on than sit around and watch the risks increase

The problem is that we can’t trust that hospitals and medics in the U.K. are acting in the best interests of the individual mother and child. There are too many verified incidences of them not doing so.

If medical staff are to be given unbridled rights to do whatever they deem expedient to the mother, then we’d need a lawyer and independent doctor witness on every admission to discourage abuse.

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 08:44

Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 08:31

Obviously however if you go too far over your placenta can stop working. A risk of still birth is higher etc so why would anyone want to run these risks on their unborn child or themselves why would anyone want to risk loosing their baby and having to give birth and cause harm to yourself or the unborn it’s mental that some women are so okay with these choices because in my opinion it’s safer to bring labour on than sit around and watch the risks increase

The risks increase from around 39 weeks but remain small (around 0.3% at 42 weeks). At what point should we be forced into hospital?
There are lots of different opinions because we all have different attitudes to different types of risk. Maybe the stillbirth risk goes down a tiny bit but the chance of brain damage or breathing difficulties goes up a lot.
Mothers want what's best for their babies. They should be the ones to make the decision.

OP posts:
Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 08:37

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:22

A child in utero has the right to be born alive and not die because his/her mother worries more about her bodily autonomy than her child's life. Honestly, this is what most people think.

This. What’s the point in becoming pregnant and carrying if you don’t care if the baby lives or dies as long as a woman has full body autonomy. I’m currently 32 weeks pregnant and I’m going to put the needs of my baby and myself above everything else

Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 08:31

Oliwiaa · 28/08/2026 23:32

Women should have total rights over their own body even if you think they are stupid or make bad decisions.

Obviously however if you go too far over your placenta can stop working. A risk of still birth is higher etc so why would anyone want to run these risks on their unborn child or themselves why would anyone want to risk loosing their baby and having to give birth and cause harm to yourself or the unborn it’s mental that some women are so okay with these choices because in my opinion it’s safer to bring labour on than sit around and watch the risks increase

Oliwiaa · 28/08/2026 23:32

Weirdwonderfully · 28/08/2026 22:51

The thing is normal mothers would do anything to protect and ensure their baby would come into the world alive and well but the way some women free birth or refuse intervention it’s scary especially if your 42 weeks etc

Women should have total rights over their own body even if you think they are stupid or make bad decisions.

DitheringDaisyPetal · 28/08/2026 23:28

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:22

A child in utero has the right to be born alive and not die because his/her mother worries more about her bodily autonomy than her child's life. Honestly, this is what most people think.

But birth is unpredictable - medics can’t guarantee a safe delivery, and unfortunately intervention can in some cases cause more harm than good (anyone remember the case of the mother that died because they accidentally overdosed her with the induction hormone?). So you’re not dealing in absolutes, you’re dealing with a balance of probablilities and someone taking the responsibility to make the call. Since the mother is has the most to lose or gain, why can’t she be permitted to make that call?
From what I’ve read, the court order was to get the mother to go to hospital to be induced to start labour. However by the time the police arrived apparently labour was well underway, as you’re not allowed in the birth pool until you’re at a certain stage. So there was no longer a need to give the mother drugs she didn’t want to get the labour going.
In 2 of my labours the effort of getting to the hospital stalled the process, and it took a while to for it to pick up again once settled in a new environment. So it doesn’t surprise me at all that the stress of this team arriving mid labour and forcing her to go to hospital like some criminal being arrested stalled the Labour process and disrupted baby’s heart rate, resulting in a CS.
It’s great that the baby made it out safely, but the mother must be deeply traumatised and that has negative implications for her and her baby’s wellbeing which were probably not taken in to consideration at the outset. And once her labour had established at home there was no reason to assume that the baby wouldn’t have made it out safely if the police had sat back and allowed nature to take its course.
And I agree OP, the worrying thing is that the ECHR validates this.

FunPartyIdeas · 28/08/2026 23:22

@EvelynBeatrice Failures of the current NHS system should not mean that natural birth is deemed as unsafe. Change the system, not push the mother into an unecessary C-section due to lack of staffing etc.
I personally chose not to have my last born with the NHS due to all of those things you have mentioned. But not all women have the choice.
To add, my baby was born at the height of Covid. My hospital trust advised that any woman in labour must have an internal check before their birthing partner would be permitted onto the labour ward with them.
If that isn't breach of women's rights then I don't know what is.
No chance I was ever going to accept that!

Weirdwonderfully · 28/08/2026 22:51

Hoardasurass · 28/08/2026 14:51

Its not considered bad form to @ someone on this site or board.
As for the rights of an unborn child they have none as they are not legally a person until after birth.
Your anti women's rights and bodily autonomy will not go down well on this board if you continue to post in such an aggressive manner, however if you want to have a reasoned discussion without the frothing then you will find many of us are willing to do so

The thing is normal mothers would do anything to protect and ensure their baby would come into the world alive and well but the way some women free birth or refuse intervention it’s scary especially if your 42 weeks etc

FourSevenFive · 28/08/2026 22:45

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:39

No, but most people - apart from extreme bodily autonomy ones who believe in the right to abort up to the point of birth - would think the child has the right to be born alive and to live without unnecessary damage.

It is an idea many people would support on paper, but than no-one would agree what it means and how far it should go.

CS seems to be safer for the baby, at least from a short term point of view. Do you mean that every woman need to get a CS to protect baby from potential unnecessary damage (like broken bones) from hard vaginal birth?

RedToothBrush · 28/08/2026 22:44

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:39

No, but most people - apart from extreme bodily autonomy ones who believe in the right to abort up to the point of birth - would think the child has the right to be born alive and to live without unnecessary damage.

I'm not sure that would be legally upheld in a British court...

FourSevenFive · 28/08/2026 22:39

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:18

I think the law should protect the unborn child.

While it sounds good on the surface, it is an extremely slippery slope.

Protect the unborn child from what exactly?

In my country home birth is extremely rare and seen by many as putting the child at risk. It was illegal for a long time for any medical personel to assist at home birth, but even my country haven't try to criminalise women giving birth at home, because it sometimes just happens no matter what the plans are.

In the UK home birth seems to be a normal thing (when conditions are met).
Mother&child mortality is very similar between our two countries, which suggests that my country's perceived protection of unborn babies is probably not doing anything useful.

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:39

RedToothBrush · 28/08/2026 22:25

Most ordinary people would consider that the baby has some form of rights at 42+ weeks

Says who? What is your evidence for this?

There is no legal basis to this assumption in the UK.

No, but most people - apart from extreme bodily autonomy ones who believe in the right to abort up to the point of birth - would think the child has the right to be born alive and to live without unnecessary damage.

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:36

EvelynBeatrice · 28/08/2026 22:26

If that is to be the case, then in turn the law must support the tying down, physical restraint and effective torture of the mother. Not a world I want to live in.

I’m afraid that much as I respect many doctors and nurses, statistical and anecdotal evidence of failing maternity care in the U.K. makes it foolish to accord them unquestioning obedience.

In most cases I’d hope that we’d aspire to maternity education and healthcare that seeks to develop a relationship of trust between the medical staff and the patient which is almost entirely lacking in the U.K. system.

I also abhor the idea of strapping someone down but I do not think a woman has the right to cause the death of her child in utero because she values her bodily autonomy over its life.
Education and trust are the key. Currently the maternity services in the UK have neither. I doubt throwing money at the problem will help but more and better trained staff might (I know, that's also money).

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:30

CoupDeToe · 28/08/2026 13:22

Don't @ me. It's considered bad etiquette on this forum.

Most ordinary people would consider that the baby has some form of rights at 42+ weeks. I have read accounts on the other boards of women having stillbirths because they have ignored their doctors suggesting induction because they want to do their natural thing.

There's no point arguing with people with such extreme positions. There are so many people on this forum who think that the woman should even have a right to an abortion at 40+ weeks. I won't be back on this thread and leave you to it.

Hi CoupDeToe, Not @ you but it's not bad form (but I find it irritating as I have to go back to look for the original post and prefer to quote) but the point of my post - should you see it - is that I agree with you, the baby has a right to be born alive and the mother's wishes are subordinate to this especially if it is suspected that intervention will be needed. One can refuse treatment for oneself, but should one morally or ethically do this when the life of another person (ok, I know an unborn baby is not a person in UK law most of the time*) is at stake?
I also do not think a woman has a right to abort a viable child at 40 weeks. That's evil.

*Because the UK has an offence called, iirc, 'child destruction' which comes into play if a person other than the mother, and without the mother's consent, does something to cause destruction of a child in utero e.g. a man beating up his wife/partner so that she goes into premature labour or her child is killed resulting in the need for a termination. This offence confers no rights on the child in utero but makes it clear that destroying it without the consent of the mother (i.e. in an abortion) is a crime. Nothing to do with the Spanish case in question, of course.

EvelynBeatrice · 28/08/2026 22:26

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:18

I think the law should protect the unborn child.

If that is to be the case, then in turn the law must support the tying down, physical restraint and effective torture of the mother. Not a world I want to live in.

I’m afraid that much as I respect many doctors and nurses, statistical and anecdotal evidence of failing maternity care in the U.K. makes it foolish to accord them unquestioning obedience.

In most cases I’d hope that we’d aspire to maternity education and healthcare that seeks to develop a relationship of trust between the medical staff and the patient which is almost entirely lacking in the U.K. system.

RedToothBrush · 28/08/2026 22:25

Most ordinary people would consider that the baby has some form of rights at 42+ weeks

Says who? What is your evidence for this?

There is no legal basis to this assumption in the UK.