Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Forced hospital transfer in labour - for induction of labour - upheld by ECHR

115 replies

NibliaBiblia · 28/08/2026 11:58

Police and an ambulance arrived with a court order to compel the transfer to hospital if a woman safely labouring at home with her midwife - and forced her to undergo an induction of labour!

And the ECHR has upheld the court order. Dark day for our right to control our own bodies.

https://birthrights.org.uk/2026/08/27/cp-v-spain-why-a-major-european-court-ruling-on-maternity-care-is-a-wake-up-call-for-bodily-autonomy-rights/

CP v Spain: Why a major European court ruling on maternity care is a wake-up call for bodily autonomy rights - Birthrights

Birthrights 'End Coercion in Maternity Care in the UK' Report Case Study Social Services and Maternity Care blog long read

https://birthrights.org.uk/2026/08/27/cp-v-spain-why-a-major-european-court-ruling-on-maternity-care-is-a-wake-up-call-for-bodily-autonomy-rights/

OP posts:
NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 13:14

Oliwiaa · 29/08/2026 13:11

Are we legally obliged to follow all medical advice?
Does that apply to men too, or just women?

And which medical advice? It differs from country to country and practitioner to practitioner.

OP posts:
Oliwiaa · 29/08/2026 13:11

bababamama · 29/08/2026 13:03

was the mother refusing to transfer to hospital against medical advice? That is key. Health professionals adhere to do no harm, not transferring could come under this but I’m not familiar with this situation

Are we legally obliged to follow all medical advice?
Does that apply to men too, or just women?

bababamama · 29/08/2026 13:03

was the mother refusing to transfer to hospital against medical advice? That is key. Health professionals adhere to do no harm, not transferring could come under this but I’m not familiar with this situation

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 12:59

EvelynBeatrice · 29/08/2026 12:48

But most first time mothers in many areas won’t have a complicated free natural birth. I believe that the safety list ranges from
1 completely intervention free natural birth
2 elective C- section (ie non emergency)
3 instrumental ‘natural’ birth ( excluding forceps)
4 emergency section
5 forceps
In many cases individual women are never going to achieve a 1. because of personal physical and mental features, which makes 2. a sensible option for some women, particularly in the U.K. At least you’re assured of medical attention and pain relief for 2. !

There's a big one missing from your list - intervention heavy labor that still manages to result in a vaginal birth. Most women have sweeps, go to hospital, have vaginal exams, maybe their waters broken or syntocinon if they're "too slow", coached pushing, maybe ctg, probably syntocinon for the placenta, etc

OP posts:
Oliwiaa · 29/08/2026 12:58

Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 08:31

Obviously however if you go too far over your placenta can stop working. A risk of still birth is higher etc so why would anyone want to run these risks on their unborn child or themselves why would anyone want to risk loosing their baby and having to give birth and cause harm to yourself or the unborn it’s mental that some women are so okay with these choices because in my opinion it’s safer to bring labour on than sit around and watch the risks increase

That's fine, you can have that opinion about your own body.
It's not fine to impose your opinion on other women's bodies.
People do risky things all the time. I'd never go bungee jumping or ride a motorbike but if you want to, that's your choice.

EvelynBeatrice · 29/08/2026 12:48

Hoardasurass · 29/08/2026 09:53

Babies born by vaginal delivery are exposed to the mothers vaginal bacteria which improves their immune system and the squeezing action helps clear their lungs of fluid. Both of these are shown to lower the risks of asthma and allergies.
All in all where possible (ie no complications that would prevent a safe delivery) its better for both mother and baby to have a natural delivery.
Also it takes on average 4 weeks to recover from a vaginal birth whereas it takes 4 months to recover from a c section

But most first time mothers in many areas won’t have a complicated free natural birth. I believe that the safety list ranges from
1 completely intervention free natural birth
2 elective C- section (ie non emergency)
3 instrumental ‘natural’ birth ( excluding forceps)
4 emergency section
5 forceps
In many cases individual women are never going to achieve a 1. because of personal physical and mental features, which makes 2. a sensible option for some women, particularly in the U.K. At least you’re assured of medical attention and pain relief for 2. !

KnottyAuty · 29/08/2026 11:40

DitheringDaisyPetal · 29/08/2026 10:31

Yes your placenta can stop working. However I know from experience that dates
determined by scans can be very inaccurate. So you could say that every pregnant woman who gets to 40 +2 according to her scan dates will be forced to have an induction whether she likes it or not, and involve the police where necessary. But the date is arbitrary, many of those women won’t actually be that far along in their pregnancy. And how can a woman have trust in her care providers if she knows that they can force her to have a procedure against her will? That would result in women withholding information from the medics to give themselves breathing space,
and stepping back from the monitoring processes that can be helpful at that point. Overall it would do far more harm than good.
Am induction is no guarantee of safety, even without taking in to account some of the procedural issues that we were all aware of but have now been logged in Amos’s report.

I wish you well with your labour. Please bear in mind that you do have agency and are entitled to ask questions of your caregivers and are entitled to full answers.

Absolutely this!
The rough rules of thumb about due date are just that. Rough/approximate for the average woman. Statistically there will be maybe 5-10% of women who would safely exceed the 40+2 guidance. The problem is knowing who they are in advance. Both my pregnancies went over 40+2 by a couple of days. Before anyone says anything about being reckless - safety was addressed with increased observation and monitoring. There are different ways of doing things available to those who ask. The idea that there was only one option to the woman in the OP seems really odd - the article doesn't mention if she was offered a second opinion.

I'm reminded of that case where the family wanted a specialist cancer treatment for their child which was not available so they left an NHS hospital to go to their home country (Poland?). I think they were being told to accept a treatment with a poor chance of success? Their departure sparked a huge manhunt where the parents were to be arrested and it was suggested they had opted for quackery. I believe the eventually had him treated in poland. Much less reported is that the NHS built a massive specialist centre for UCL to offer this treatment in the UK... One doctor's opinion is not always 100% reliable. Patients have to be able to work with their carers. Calling the police is not OK in these borderline cases

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 11:39

tpwk · 29/08/2026 11:26

No. It’s not safer at all.

That's your opinion and it's perfectly valid but it should be her decision to make.

OP posts:
tpwk · 29/08/2026 11:26

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 11:05

This is such a frightening attitude to take. She almost certainly did it because she believed that giving birth with her known and trusted midwife at home was safer than going into hospital and submitting to an unknown number of vaginal exams, drugs, and monitoring (all of which have their own risks) without her consent.
Most women think an induction is safest at 42 weeks but many don't. It should be the woman's decision.

No. It’s not safer at all.

oviraptor21 · 29/08/2026 11:25

CoupDeToe · 28/08/2026 13:22

Don't @ me. It's considered bad etiquette on this forum.

Most ordinary people would consider that the baby has some form of rights at 42+ weeks. I have read accounts on the other boards of women having stillbirths because they have ignored their doctors suggesting induction because they want to do their natural thing.

There's no point arguing with people with such extreme positions. There are so many people on this forum who think that the woman should even have a right to an abortion at 40+ weeks. I won't be back on this thread and leave you to it.

Really. First I've heard of that "rule". If you don't want to quote an entire post then @ is the best way of referring back to that person's post. I will continue to do it when appropriate.

KnottyAuty · 29/08/2026 11:20

FunPartyIdeas · 28/08/2026 23:22

@EvelynBeatrice Failures of the current NHS system should not mean that natural birth is deemed as unsafe. Change the system, not push the mother into an unecessary C-section due to lack of staffing etc.
I personally chose not to have my last born with the NHS due to all of those things you have mentioned. But not all women have the choice.
To add, my baby was born at the height of Covid. My hospital trust advised that any woman in labour must have an internal check before their birthing partner would be permitted onto the labour ward with them.
If that isn't breach of women's rights then I don't know what is.
No chance I was ever going to accept that!

Edited

That is a shocking story. Internal checks are used on busy wards where people can't have one to one continuous care.They aren't an essential component of birthing safety but are so commonly used for the benefit of staff/treatment protocols many women are unaware. One-to-one care from a midwife who knows the mother is the gold standard on safety in birth but strangely isn't offered on the NHS... if maternity services were genuinely focussed on safety they would look a lot different.

Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 11:12

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 10:44

Fair enough! Some people make bad decisions.
I'm sorry you had that happen, those three days must have been really frightening.

i feel like we forget that no two births are the same no one’s birth is identical and everyone else’s views/wants are different. I managed it okay and I do think the fact I had been in hospital 5 days prior gave me the confidence and calm I needed. I don’t feel like anyone needs to be sorry for my experience because apart from my first labour midwife I had an incredible experience albeit painful to some degree I just know next time I’m around 5 weeks to advocate to the midwife in charge If I see same midwife or anything remotely similar, as I am facing complications in this pregnancy.

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 11:05

tpwk · 29/08/2026 11:02

Good. Why would she allow herself to go so overdue?

This is such a frightening attitude to take. She almost certainly did it because she believed that giving birth with her known and trusted midwife at home was safer than going into hospital and submitting to an unknown number of vaginal exams, drugs, and monitoring (all of which have their own risks) without her consent.
Most women think an induction is safest at 42 weeks but many don't. It should be the woman's decision.

OP posts:
tpwk · 29/08/2026 11:02

Good. Why would she allow herself to go so overdue?

FairKoala · 29/08/2026 11:01

I read the article that she did return only to find the department closed and being in Labour she returned home. She was about to give birth in the next few hours when police arrived, the results being that the birth was delayed for another 2 days

If the police and court order was about getting the baby birthed because baby was well overdue, that spectacularly back fired and had the opposite effect

I too cannot understand the ruling. If you are going to go in with all guns blazing, given they closed for the night and wouldn’t have had up to date information.

Wouldn’t a call to find out what has happened overnight been a better use of time and resources.

Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 10:47

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 10:41

Sounds like we're on the same side of the argument then.
When people say things like this:

a child in utero has the right to be born alive and not die because his/her mother worries more about her bodily autonomy than her child's life

That's the kind of argument that leads to women being given C-sections despite their refusal, because their doctors think a VBAC is dangerous, or being forced into hospital by court order because their doctors think it's safest to be induced at 42 weeks.

Edited

Oh absolutely I just think sometimes it can be portrayed in a way that women are choosing different things over their baby’s life however I guess now everyone has confidence or doesn’t in some cases like myself I guess that our bodies will do the right things for our babies. I trust my body but my anxiety wouldn’t allow me to do it at home and I have no interest in doing it at home but someone else may and that’s absolutely perfect for all involved! I feel like I’ve slightly been educated!

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 10:44

Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 10:41

No my point remains that every single pregnant woman can do as they wish to do. I however in my last pregnancy 5 years ago had to be induced because my waters slowly went at 36+2 and my child’s heart rate was dipping all the time. I told them after staying in for 3 days being monitored when they suggested C section when it dipped again that we wouldn’t need to as the heart rate would come back
to which it did every time and that was final even in actual labour once my waters had been manually popped they threw a gown at me and told me to put it on and I said no I am not going for a c section.

I didn’t like said midwife and I knew I needed to wait for 8pm for night shift staff lol

I don’t agree with anyone being forced to do anything against their will that’s where I don’t agree however it’s bonkers to me that people are that confident that the baby will survive the choices and decisions that we make.

Fair enough! Some people make bad decisions.
I'm sorry you had that happen, those three days must have been really frightening.

OP posts:
Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 10:41

DitheringDaisyPetal · 29/08/2026 10:31

Yes your placenta can stop working. However I know from experience that dates
determined by scans can be very inaccurate. So you could say that every pregnant woman who gets to 40 +2 according to her scan dates will be forced to have an induction whether she likes it or not, and involve the police where necessary. But the date is arbitrary, many of those women won’t actually be that far along in their pregnancy. And how can a woman have trust in her care providers if she knows that they can force her to have a procedure against her will? That would result in women withholding information from the medics to give themselves breathing space,
and stepping back from the monitoring processes that can be helpful at that point. Overall it would do far more harm than good.
Am induction is no guarantee of safety, even without taking in to account some of the procedural issues that we were all aware of but have now been logged in Amos’s report.

I wish you well with your labour. Please bear in mind that you do have agency and are entitled to ask questions of your caregivers and are entitled to full answers.

No my point remains that every single pregnant woman can do as they wish to do. I however in my last pregnancy 5 years ago had to be induced because my waters slowly went at 36+2 and my child’s heart rate was dipping all the time. I told them after staying in for 3 days being monitored when they suggested C section when it dipped again that we wouldn’t need to as the heart rate would come back
to which it did every time and that was final even in actual labour once my waters had been manually popped they threw a gown at me and told me to put it on and I said no I am not going for a c section.

I didn’t like said midwife and I knew I needed to wait for 8pm for night shift staff lol

I don’t agree with anyone being forced to do anything against their will that’s where I don’t agree however it’s bonkers to me that people are that confident that the baby will survive the choices and decisions that we make.

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 10:41

Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 10:33

I completely agree that every parent wants to make the decision they believe is safest. I think where we differ is in what we consider the safest option, and that’s okay. I’d never want to tell someone else what they should do with their pregnancy or birth, but I’m equally comfortable making my own decisions based on the guidance and medical advice available to me and also I feel like I’m more confident in a hospital setting with dozens of trained people that will do all they can to save the life of my unborn and myself if it came to it rather than being home with little support and or overdue but again it’s all personal preference and beliefs, wants and everyone’s are different. I’m not interested in C sections or epidural either i had induction at 37 last time due to waters breaking at 36+2 and I birthed within 5 hours

Sounds like we're on the same side of the argument then.
When people say things like this:

a child in utero has the right to be born alive and not die because his/her mother worries more about her bodily autonomy than her child's life

That's the kind of argument that leads to women being given C-sections despite their refusal, because their doctors think a VBAC is dangerous, or being forced into hospital by court order because their doctors think it's safest to be induced at 42 weeks.

OP posts:
Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 10:33

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 08:49

I put the needs of my baby above everything else. That's why I had a home birth outside of guidance, because I decided that was safest for my baby.
You might not agree with my decision that's safest, I might not agree with your decision that sweeps/hospital/VEs/induction/epidural/C-section is safest. But it's not up to me to decide what's best for you and your baby any more than it's up to you to decide what's best for me and my baby.

I completely agree that every parent wants to make the decision they believe is safest. I think where we differ is in what we consider the safest option, and that’s okay. I’d never want to tell someone else what they should do with their pregnancy or birth, but I’m equally comfortable making my own decisions based on the guidance and medical advice available to me and also I feel like I’m more confident in a hospital setting with dozens of trained people that will do all they can to save the life of my unborn and myself if it came to it rather than being home with little support and or overdue but again it’s all personal preference and beliefs, wants and everyone’s are different. I’m not interested in C sections or epidural either i had induction at 37 last time due to waters breaking at 36+2 and I birthed within 5 hours

Hoardasurass · 29/08/2026 10:33

NibliaBiblia · 29/08/2026 09:59

But would you prevent a woman from having a C-section if she wanted one anyway? It's not really about what's safer, especially as they're all relatively safe options.
It's about acknowledging that opinions differ and what's right for one mother and baby is not for another.
If someone is about to jump off a bridge it's right to stop them. If someone wants to go for a walk on a bridge that looks a bit rickety to you, you can explain your concerns but you can't tackle them to the ground.

No i wouldn't. I would advise her of all the risks and benefits of her options including the risk of needing instrumental interventions and/or emergency c section and then let her choose what she thinks is the best option for her.

DitheringDaisyPetal · 29/08/2026 10:31

Weirdwonderfully · 29/08/2026 08:31

Obviously however if you go too far over your placenta can stop working. A risk of still birth is higher etc so why would anyone want to run these risks on their unborn child or themselves why would anyone want to risk loosing their baby and having to give birth and cause harm to yourself or the unborn it’s mental that some women are so okay with these choices because in my opinion it’s safer to bring labour on than sit around and watch the risks increase

Yes your placenta can stop working. However I know from experience that dates
determined by scans can be very inaccurate. So you could say that every pregnant woman who gets to 40 +2 according to her scan dates will be forced to have an induction whether she likes it or not, and involve the police where necessary. But the date is arbitrary, many of those women won’t actually be that far along in their pregnancy. And how can a woman have trust in her care providers if she knows that they can force her to have a procedure against her will? That would result in women withholding information from the medics to give themselves breathing space,
and stepping back from the monitoring processes that can be helpful at that point. Overall it would do far more harm than good.
Am induction is no guarantee of safety, even without taking in to account some of the procedural issues that we were all aware of but have now been logged in Amos’s report.

I wish you well with your labour. Please bear in mind that you do have agency and are entitled to ask questions of your caregivers and are entitled to full answers.

AstonCanKissMyArse · 29/08/2026 10:30

"The right to refuse treatment is not the same as the right to have treatment."

You're correct, but the treatment would not be denied to her on the grounds of pregnancy, therefore this is a red herring. Any 'right' to treatment is not pregnancy dependant.

The right to abortion is another technicality. In practise, any woman who wants one could get an abortion in the UK (under the 24 week limit) .

Edit for clarity

Hoardasurass · 29/08/2026 10:22

Grammarnut · 28/08/2026 22:39

No, but most people - apart from extreme bodily autonomy ones who believe in the right to abort up to the point of birth - would think the child has the right to be born alive and to live without unnecessary damage.

You are conflating womens bodily autonomy with pro choice extremists and that is a dangerous conflation which risks stripping women of all rights including the right not to be raped or be bought and sold.
Please think long and hard about what you are arguing for when you talk about removing womens bodily autonomy

iwishitwouldstartraining · 29/08/2026 10:19

Hoardasurass · 29/08/2026 10:15

No it doesn't not in UK law.
A pregnant woman has the right to an abortion if she wants, has the right to take lifesaving medication that will kill her baby to have surgeries that will cause the death of her baby if she needs them.
That is just part of what a womens bodily autonomy means and is what you are trying to strip from women all so you can turn her onto a walking incubator

I think it's a bit of a stretch to argue that a woman has the right to an abortion whenever she wants under UK law.

Abortion may have been decriminalised, but that isn't the same as having the right to have one.

The right to refuse treatment is not the same as the right to have treatment.