Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Lactation support conference in Ireland - the quiet part out loud

537 replies

ArabellaScott · 25/08/2026 11:16

https://genspect.org/where-does-male-lactation-fit-in-breastfeeding-support-networks/

'This year’s program lists a lactation consultant called Jacob Engelsman speaking on “communicating inclusively: creating gender-affirming clinical spaces for families” and “lactation support for gender-diverse families”.'

'Jacob Engelsman is a Certified Lactation Consultant based in the US. He describes himself as an infant care specialist, speaker, and writer. He is the author of a recently published book, Lactation for the Rest of Us: A Guide for Queer and Trans Parents and Helpers, and specialises in inducing lactation in non-gestational parents (parents who haven’t given birth). “Lactation is for anyone” Jacob tells us in this podcast interview.
Engelsman’s interest and expertise is not limited to lactation for the purpose of feeding an infant. One of his previous presentations was “Inducing Lactation for Kinksters” and according to his CV he has been giving various talks including on lactation at Frolicon, an adult lifestyle and fetish convention held annually in Atlanta, Georgia with substantial programming around kink, BDSM, sexuality, polyamory, LGBTQ+ relationships and alternative sexual/family cultures.
He is not a nurse, midwife, doctor, or healthcare professional (nor does he claim to be). He is not a parent or someone with personal experience of breastfeeding. He got his certification five years ago and prior to that worked in the food service industry.'
...
'Why would a man want to lactate? In Engelsman’s own words:
“There are several reasons a person may choose to lactate regardless of whether they can gestate a child…a non-gestational parent might choose to induce lactation as a way to feel emotionally closer to the baby, assert their own feelings of parenthood, gender euphoria, or just for the unique experience of it.” (p.49)
Writing specifically about “cis” men, that is men who identify as men, he says:
“As to the question of why they would want to, it seems reasonable to believe that cis men want to lactate for the same reasons as anyone else. Which is to say, usually to feed and bond with their baby and to a lesser extent for curiosity, fun, or sexual gratification.” (p.152)'

Where Does Male Lactation Fit in Breastfeeding Support Networks? — Genspect

The Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland (ALCI) will host its annual conference this coming October in Galway. Promotional posts on social media feature a lactation consultant, Jacob Engelsman, who promotes some practices that many people fi...

https://genspect.org/where-does-male-lactation-fit-in-breastfeeding-support-networks/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
40
AngleofRepose · 03/09/2026 10:53

A breastfeeding advisory group has been forced to move its annual conference online after threats were issued

I'd be interested to know who issued the "threats" and in what form they were to be. I highly doubt they were threats of violence (now, who do we know who threatens violence? hmmm... it's not women). More likely to be threats of a massive protest. No wonder the hotel pulled out.

If Engelsman is no longer part of this conference, it's possible that whoever should have done some due diligence before signing him up, has now done their research. If I had paid someone to research all the prospective speakers prior to final confirmation of the conference programme, they would no longer be in my employ. The reputational damage here could be huge.

I wonder if it's online now because no other hotel would have them?

Waitingfordoggo · 03/09/2026 10:47

I keep coming back to that ‘for the same reasons as anyone else’. I find it deeply offensive as a woman who breastfed. How dare he imply that some women breastfeed for ‘curiosity, fun or sexual gratification’? As well as being deeply offensive, he is surely completely incorrect. Has he ever even met breastfeeding women and asked them questions? I really do think he’d be hard pushed to find even one woman who breastfed just for kicks.

nicepotoftea · 03/09/2026 10:33

So he is no longer a speaker at the event?

He says straight or cis men wish to produce milk “for the same reasons as anyone else. Which is to say usually to feed and bond with their baby and to a lesser extent, for curiosity, fun or sexual gratification".

And the ALCI still can't spot the massive red flag?

Genesis1v27 · 03/09/2026 10:27

The Irish Examiner's "Health Correspondent" prints ALCI's version of events.

Breastfeeding conference forced to move online after threats over 'men chest-feeding' advocate

Wed, 02 Sep, 2026 - 19:35
Niamh Griffin, Health Correspondent

A breastfeeding advisory group has been forced to move its annual conference online after threats were issued over plans for it be addressed by a male speaker on gender-diverse families.

The Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland represents healthcare workers who support women breastfeeding.

Its annual conference was scheduled for Galway next month. One of the speakers was to be Jacob Engelsman, an international board certified lactation consultant from America.

He is no longer speaking at the event, but had been due to give two talks on advice for healthcare workers supporting gender-diverse families in breastfeeding.

The controversy centred on allegations that his talks would cover advice for men who wish to breastfeed themselves. Some objectors called for more focus on women instead but many comments were personal in nature.

The ALCI told members on Tuesday the switch to a virtual event is “due to health & safety concerns and direct personal safety concerns for our delegates, speakers, members, venue staff and Council”.

The email said: “We would like to be clear that the reasoning behind this has been taken completely out of context and is not as has been alleged.

“This misrepresentation is deeply upsetting to ALCI Council and to our speakers, where education on supporting lactating families has always been at the forefront of what we do.”

The council told the Irish Examiner: “This was not about encouraging or endorsing male lactation in any way whatsoever.”

It acknowledged members felt it was slow in responding to the avalanche of claims.

“We have done that on legal advice and PR advice, and also that has come about because we are all volunteers on this council. No decision is made until all nine of us are in on it,” it said.

The council is now seeking legal advice. The hotel confirmed it is no longer hosting the event.

Much of the controversy centred on Mr Engelsman’s book: Lactation for the Rest of Us: A guide for queer and trans parents and helpers.

Extracts available through Google Books show he refers to parents and chest-feeding rather than mothers and breast-feeding.

He says straight men have asked him about male lactation.

He says straight or cis men wish to produce milk “for the same reasons as anyone else. Which is to say usually to feed and bond with their baby and to a lesser extent, for curiosity, fun or sexual gratification".

He says in his personal experience “none have ever produced milk”.

It is understood he was to be paid around €375 at a rate of €2.50 per minute, as were other speakers. The event is funded through ticket-sales.

The HSE has said it provides €9,000 in annual funding to ALCI. This is used for training at separate events.

Datun · 03/09/2026 05:58

One thing's for sure, there will now be women signing up for this online conference who will be forensically scrutinising every single speaker.

ArabellaScott · 02/09/2026 21:28

INeedAPensieve · 02/09/2026 21:01

That's a great letter @ArabellaScott . I'll do a complaint too. It's sickening, and to not even attempt to apologise or remove this paedophile from the programme.

We don't know if they've taken him off the programme, to be fair.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 02/09/2026 21:27

Cailin66 · 02/09/2026 19:06

They want the money generated by the attendees. Everyone of whom should demand their money back. To attend this is to support child abuse, sexual exploitation of children, a man who says all breastfeeding women lie about exclusively breastfeeding. That organisation is a disgrace.

I wonder if they've given any thought to how this will affect their standing and reputation going forward.

I just cannot imagine all.the women who work so hard to support other women are okay with this.

OP posts:
INeedAPensieve · 02/09/2026 21:01

That's a great letter @ArabellaScott . I'll do a complaint too. It's sickening, and to not even attempt to apologise or remove this paedophile from the programme.

Emilesgran · 02/09/2026 21:00

Kingdomofsleep · 28/08/2026 21:33

I'm talking about how wrong it is for the baby that there is milk specifically being naturally produced for that baby that is going to waste while its new mother induces some with drugs.

I don't know if wetnursing is any crueller to the birth mother than removing at birth.

I suspect the reason they don’t encourage it is because there’s far more risk that the surrogate mother will refuse to give up the baby at the end. Taking it from her straightaway while she’s still groggy from the birth and possibly unable to move, is much easier.

I’m not sure which is worse for the birth mother, but I don’t think it’s about her interests anyway. It’s simply that it would be a bad look for contracting parents or their legal representatives to have to regularly rip babies from their protesting mothers’ arms in order to complete the financial contract.

AncientBallerina · 02/09/2026 20:49

Just when you think it can’t get any worse

moto748e · 02/09/2026 20:30

Jeez, what a world.

mrshoho · 02/09/2026 20:16

Male Lactation: The New Frontier in Evidence Laundering https://share.google/l5QjX4bkVOSh1SUrM

I think this may have previously been posted on MN, but thought I'd post it here. It's long but well thought out and Carrie refers to the children of transitioners group and their plea to the NHS practioners.

Won’t Somebody Think of the Children?

It will be many years before the generation of newborns currently being breastfed by their trans-identified fathers can speak for themselves. However, adult children of transitioners are overwhelmingly opposed to the practice. They remain a largely invisible group, rarely given a platform to speak about the complex emotional impact of witnessing a parents’ transition, unless it is to celebrate and “affirm” the parent’s adoption of a trans identity. Given the consistent disregard for the rights of the child that I have observed in the literature on transgender lactation, I feel their concerns deserve to be quoted here at some length.

The following quote is taken from a letter authored by the much-needed British campaign group Children of Transitioners (CoTs) to the NHS practitioners who facilitate lactation in trans identified males:

We understand some NHS Trusts are now seeking to enable and enforce the sexual and emotional abuse of children who are CoTs [children of transitioners], and are introducing policies that not only fail to safeguard these children…but also actively encourage the sexual assault and grooming of vulnerable babies and children who come into contact with NHS staff. Some of our dads ‘transition’ for sexual reasons, and many just change their clothing choices or have breast implants. CoTs’ still have both the legal right and the emotional need to be safeguarded by NHS staff – just like all other children…We have seen evidence that some hospital Trusts are making children of transitioners suck their father’s nipples- an act of sexual assault and grooming that deeply shocks us as NHS staff should be protecting COT infants not enabling their abuse…We have no idea of how many NHS Trusts are doing this. It fails to consider the health, welfare, and safeguarding of children of transitioners. It encourages our fathers and other men to feed children like us, as babies, drug induced secretions from their bodies and to commit, and groom us for, sexual assault

Cailin66 · 02/09/2026 19:06

Genesis1v27 · 02/09/2026 13:19

The conference is to go ahead online, according to this report. The rest of the story is behind a paywall.

Edited

They want the money generated by the attendees. Everyone of whom should demand their money back. To attend this is to support child abuse, sexual exploitation of children, a man who says all breastfeeding women lie about exclusively breastfeeding. That organisation is a disgrace.

mrshoho · 02/09/2026 18:26

Excellent @ArabellaScott . Thank you xx

ArabellaScott · 02/09/2026 18:12

Drafting a complaint. If anyone else wants to use this to refer to, please feel free:

Certificant: Jacob Engelsman, IBCLC, Atlanta, Georgia, USA
Nature of complaint: Public statements concerning breastfeeding, professional accuracy, safeguarding and public trust

I wish to raise concerns regarding public statements made by Jacob Engelsman while publicly identifying and presenting himself as an International Board Certified Lactation Consultant.

My complaint concerns the following material:

1. Sexual gratification presented as a reason for male lactation

In Lactation for the Rest of Us: A Guide for Queer and Trans Parents and Helpers, Mr Engelsman writes:

“As to the question of why they would want to, it seems reasonable to believe that cis men want to lactate for the same reasons as anyone else. Which is to say, usually to feed and bond with their baby and to a lesser extent for curiosity, fun, or sexual gratification.”

This appears on page 152.

Mr Engelsman has also reportedly delivered a presentation entitled “Inducing Lactation for Kinksters” at Frolicon, an adult fetish convention.

I am concerned by the treatment of sexual gratification as a possible motivation within professional material dealing with lactation and infant feeding, without an explicit and unequivocal distinction between consensual adult lactation and any activity involving an infant. Where babies and vulnerable postpartum families are concerned, professional boundaries and safeguarding must be unambiguous. I ask the Commission to consider whether this material is compatible with the standards of professional conduct, judgement and public trust expected of an IBCLC.

2. False and disparaging statements about mothers who exclusively breastfeed

In a publicly available recorded interview, Mr Engelsman discussed a mother saying that her friends’ babies were exclusively breastfed. He responded:
“No, they’re lying to you. They don’t want to lose face because there’s shame surrounding it. You are all just lying to each other. And if one of you would own up and say at some point my baby had some formula and it wasn’t the end of the world, you would all be better off for it.”

The assertion that mothers who report exclusively breastfeeding are lying is plainly unsustainable. Many babies are exclusively breastfed, and exclusive breastfeeding is a recognised infant-feeding category used by public-health and clinical bodies internationally.

The statement does not merely acknowledge that some parents may use formula while feeling unable to disclose it. It dismisses mothers’ accounts as dishonest and presents an unsupported generalisation as fact. Such comments may undermine women’s confidence in seeking lactation support and damage trust between breastfeeding mothers and IBCLCs.

Further, WHO and UNICEF recommend exclusive breastfeeding for the first six months. Frequent, unrestricted breastfeeding establishes and maintains milk supply; replacing breastfeeds with formula reduces milk removal and can undermine supply. Engelsman’s claim is therefore not only insulting to mothers but contrary to basic lactation physiology and international breastfeeding guidance.

I ask the Commission to consider whether these statements breach the following provisions of the Code of Professional Conduct:

  • Principle 1, including the obligation to provide services protecting, promoting and supporting breastfeeding and to provide evidence-informed care.
  • Principle 2, concerning professional diligence, accountability and practice within the IBCLC scope.
  • Principle 6.1, requiring an IBCLC to behave honestly and fairly as a health professional.
  • Principle 7.2, requiring IBCLCs to provide accurate information to the public and colleagues concerning lactation-consultant services.
  • Any applicable requirements concerning professional boundaries, public communications and maintaining public confidence in the IBCLC credential.

I am requesting an ethics review of specific professional statements concerning infant feeding, sexual motivation, the truthfulness of breastfeeding mothers, and the safeguarding standards expected of an IBCLC.

Please confirm whether this complaint satisfies the Commission’s threshold for investigation and whether further material is required.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 02/09/2026 18:07

https://ibclc-commission.org/ibclc-information/

'The IBCLC Commission, like most certification boards, has a complaint process with respect to alleged violations of the Code of Professional Conduct. Any complaints must be signed and submitted to the IBCLC Commission (see form above). Before submitting a complaint, one should familiarise themselves with the Disciplinary Procedures and ensure compliance with the requirements.'

IBCLC Information

Professional Standards & Advisory Opinions Clinical Competencies for IBCLCs Code of Professional Conduct for IBCLCs Scope of Practice for IBCLCs Blueprint for Action on Breastfeeding in Europe …

https://ibclc-commission.org/ibclc-information

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 02/09/2026 16:57

https://alcireland.ie/events/vgXmMqIczz2txISSbvcf

'ALCI's National Conference, October 9th and 10th 2026 - Online
9 October 2026 - 08:00 AM
Virtual Conference - Recordings available to all ticket holders for 4 weeks post event
Conference Update - 9th & 10th October Programme Change
This conference will now be delivered as a fully online event. An updated timetable will follow as soon as possible.

September 1 2026
_
Join us for two inspiring days of learning and professional development. We have an exciting programme featuring national and international speakers.
Speaker announcements and programme updates will continue to be shared on our social media channels.
This is an Online Virtual Conference - recordings will be available to all ticket holders for 4 weeks post-event.'

I wonder if Jacob is still being 'supported' to be a speaker.

ALCI - Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland

ALCI - Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland

https://alcireland.ie/events/vgXmMqIczz2txISSbvcf

OP posts:
Fascinationstreet · 02/09/2026 16:40

JellySaurus · 02/09/2026 09:49

I hope no woman is upset by my previous post. It's not in any way a judgement. I found breastfeeding incredibly difficult to establish with each of my babies, and I appreciate that I was able to breastfeed due to the support I had, my life circumstances, and the fact that my babies were born large and healthy.

Gosh no it wouldn’t upset me, female bodies are amazing, my own mum ( like a previous poster on here) many years ago was asked by her hospital to donate milk to poorly babies because she was able to produce ample supplies . I think for all the challenges I had it was one of the most “female “experiences I’ve had in my life - in both good and bad ways- and it’s hard to consider ( alongside ideas like uterine transplants for TW) that there appears literally no area of womanhood that TW don’t want to muscle in on. Like the trans surgeries that the NHS is funding , if you can’t even provide and adequately fund services for the main groups that need this - whether that is BF support or reconstructive surgeries and after care for those post cancer then why should any funding be granted to those who are not “ biologically eligible” in the first place.

MarjorieWestriding · 02/09/2026 16:03

Because society has been groomed.

But it's so obviously wrong, in every way, and there's nothing kind about accepting things that are obviously utterly wicked. Yet, apparently intelligent women are supporting these awful men to abuse helpless babies. Do they have no misgivings at all?

AngleofRepose · 02/09/2026 15:53

ALCI are determined to support Englesman in his "approach" aren't they? Instead of dumping the guy who wants to use babies for his nefarious purposes, and holding a normal conference, they have chosen to proceed in a way in which they can still enable him.

Who does that? Who doesn't choose the path of least resistance when you are on shaky ground, and all your instincts are telling you you're heading down the wrong path? Normally, activists who know that everything they do and say is 100% right and everyone else is 100% wrong. Or people who are afraid of someone else or who have been threatened. I wonder if it's any of those things? I would be looking into the people leading the governance of ALCI now, as well.

I wonder if Englesman was afraid to leave the US, perhaps worried he would have difficulty getting into Ireland, or perhaps face serious questioning upon arrival back in the US? If I had published the things he has published, I would be.

nicepotoftea · 02/09/2026 15:49

ArabellaScott · 02/09/2026 15:41

It's just very difficult to type out the facts here without certain conclusions looking overwhelmingly likely.

What's the alternative? Man talks about lactation for sexual gratification and also baby care, but keeps a bright line between the two? Man who say women are 'all all lying to each other' and that 'nobody' exclusively breastfeeds, while purporting to be a 'lactation consultant', is really about helping women?

Is it possible he is just a boorish opportunist who really likes babies and also supports lactation kink, but the two are unconnected?

I suppose that is the argument that the ALCI are positing.

Obviously I don't agree, but I can believe the they think that the kink element can be compartmentalised.

However, that still leaves them inviting to a breastfeeding conference a man who claims exclusive breastfeeding is not possible.

I remember the days when Gina Ford was persona non grata in some circles, but she never said anything like this!

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 02/09/2026 15:47

nicepotoftea · 02/09/2026 13:56

The thing is there is nothing new about any of this.

Men have always accessed victims by joining a sacred cast, whether that is as pillars of the community or beloved tv personalities or members of the clergy or teachers, and there have always been women to tell you to wash your mouth out with soap and water if you suggest that anything suspect is going on.

Maybe we shouldn't be surprised.

Oh, I am not in the slightest surprised. I have known about this for lo, this fifty years. If anyone else was surprised, refer to the wiki page on PIE and look at what various members of the Paedophile Information Exchange went on to do after the organisation was disbanded (there's a list in the final paragraph). And that is the ones we know about; the others may well just be more clever or better-connected, and have managed to slip under the Met radar or float over it.

One at least was very well thought-of and got away with it because the BTB colluded in letting him off: "Peter Henderson", revealed by Private Eye to be Sir Peter Telford Hayman. At one point he was arrested for cottaging and Margaret Thatcher smacked his wrist, called him a naughty boy and told him that if he did it again he'd be un-Knighted, He's in Wikipedia as well, if anyone wants to look.

ArabellaScott · 02/09/2026 15:41

It's just very difficult to type out the facts here without certain conclusions looking overwhelmingly likely.

What's the alternative? Man talks about lactation for sexual gratification and also baby care, but keeps a bright line between the two? Man who say women are 'all all lying to each other' and that 'nobody' exclusively breastfeeds, while purporting to be a 'lactation consultant', is really about helping women?

Is it possible he is just a boorish opportunist who really likes babies and also supports lactation kink, but the two are unconnected?

I suppose that is the argument that the ALCI are positing.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 02/09/2026 15:35

MarjorieWestriding · 02/09/2026 14:55

I truly do not understand why there isn't a more widespread disgust reaction at the very idea of men attempting to 'chest' feed babies. It's one of the most gag-inducing and enraging things I've ever come across.

Because society has been groomed. Deliberately and bit by bit. That's how predators work. They find the loopholes and gaps and sacred castes, and build cases around them and extending from them. It's always layered like an onion. Can't cast aspersion on this man, because of x, y, or z. Can't doubt. Can't ask questions in case of a,b, and c.

Always coupled with, if you do doubt/ask questions/cast aspersions, then you are [evil/bigoted/prudish/stupid/backward/old-fashioned/etc], maligned, smeared, ridiculed, etc.

Good people are kind. Good people are supportive, have empathy, are nice. Good girls stay quiet for their own good.

Anything that seeks to shut women up, anything that casts women's questions/voices/ideas/speech in a negative light, springs from this same enterprise, which protects predators, promotes sexism, is rooted in misogyny, is all about seeking ways to coerce, manipulate, and at base, abuse.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread