Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Lactation support conference in Ireland - the quiet part out loud

537 replies

ArabellaScott · 25/08/2026 11:16

https://genspect.org/where-does-male-lactation-fit-in-breastfeeding-support-networks/

'This year’s program lists a lactation consultant called Jacob Engelsman speaking on “communicating inclusively: creating gender-affirming clinical spaces for families” and “lactation support for gender-diverse families”.'

'Jacob Engelsman is a Certified Lactation Consultant based in the US. He describes himself as an infant care specialist, speaker, and writer. He is the author of a recently published book, Lactation for the Rest of Us: A Guide for Queer and Trans Parents and Helpers, and specialises in inducing lactation in non-gestational parents (parents who haven’t given birth). “Lactation is for anyone” Jacob tells us in this podcast interview.
Engelsman’s interest and expertise is not limited to lactation for the purpose of feeding an infant. One of his previous presentations was “Inducing Lactation for Kinksters” and according to his CV he has been giving various talks including on lactation at Frolicon, an adult lifestyle and fetish convention held annually in Atlanta, Georgia with substantial programming around kink, BDSM, sexuality, polyamory, LGBTQ+ relationships and alternative sexual/family cultures.
He is not a nurse, midwife, doctor, or healthcare professional (nor does he claim to be). He is not a parent or someone with personal experience of breastfeeding. He got his certification five years ago and prior to that worked in the food service industry.'
...
'Why would a man want to lactate? In Engelsman’s own words:
“There are several reasons a person may choose to lactate regardless of whether they can gestate a child…a non-gestational parent might choose to induce lactation as a way to feel emotionally closer to the baby, assert their own feelings of parenthood, gender euphoria, or just for the unique experience of it.” (p.49)
Writing specifically about “cis” men, that is men who identify as men, he says:
“As to the question of why they would want to, it seems reasonable to believe that cis men want to lactate for the same reasons as anyone else. Which is to say, usually to feed and bond with their baby and to a lesser extent for curiosity, fun, or sexual gratification.” (p.152)'

Where Does Male Lactation Fit in Breastfeeding Support Networks? — Genspect

The Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland (ALCI) will host its annual conference this coming October in Galway. Promotional posts on social media feature a lactation consultant, Jacob Engelsman, who promotes some practices that many people fi...

https://genspect.org/where-does-male-lactation-fit-in-breastfeeding-support-networks/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
40
OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 04/09/2026 18:12

Datun · 04/09/2026 16:30

He knows it's bollocks. Transactivism is all about decoupling women from their biology in order that men with male biology can be women.

See also Monroe Berkdorf demanding that women not centre their biology in any way during the women's march in London because it's 'exclusive'.

'Pussy hats' were the headwear du jour as a protest about Trump and his grab 'em by the pussy comments (🤮).

Bergdorf took exception to the sea of pink hats. I think he even said the quiet bit out loud and in that not every women has a vagina.

Meaning men.

https://www.feministcurrent.com/2018/02/27/munroe-bergdorf-like-please-keep-vaginas-feminism/

'I also want to stress that if you do attend, it is CRUICIAL that you do with an INTERSECTIONAL mindset. Centering reproductive systems at the heart of these demonstrations is reductive and exclusionary.
— Munroe Bergdorf 🌹🌹 (@MunroeBergdorf) January 20, 2018'

Munroe Bergdorf would like you to please keep your vaginas out of his feminism

Female bodies in feminism? Not on our watch!

https://www.feministcurrent.com/2018/02/27/munroe-bergdorf-like-please-keep-vaginas-feminism

OP posts:
EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 04/09/2026 18:04

Oh yes, same here with the trifle!
I have now been wondering why the whey and brandy was opted for because of course formula was available then. Maybe that granny had Opinions about formula, or maybe she just had to get on with whatever was at hand, maybe it was the middle of the night and no shops open.
Whatever it was it must have been her experience with her own 11 that gave her the grit to not give up, and you can't buy that.
I'd love to have 10 minutes to ask her.

edited to add, that was 11 living children, there was a gap in the middle and although I don't know for sure I suspect that such a fecund union and no effective birth control wouldn't have had that gap unless there were at least 2 others who died. It certainly happened to other women in my family of the same generation.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/09/2026 18:01

There were always a few who employed the services of a wet-nurse because they could afford to and didn't want the hassle of feeding their own child; they probably though erroneously that they would get their figures back better, too. (Heavens, can you imagine Lady Caroline Lamb sticking to breast-feeding her own baby for more than ten days or so? She'd have got bored and wandered off to see if she could find Byron. Though it may be that I malign her and she was a devoted mama.)

That's why you get the horror stories in novels about wealthy women whose hired wet-nurse turned out to be "addicted to the bottle", which did the baby no good at all.

In more recent years, my grandmother gave birth to nine children of whom eight survived, and breast-fed all of them except the last one, for whom she simply didn't produce any milk to speak of. She was mortified, and her dear old nanny (who still lived with the family and looked after all the children once they were weaned) went and found a woman in a local village whose baby had died and who was prepared to use her otherwise surplus milk to feed the rector's little daughter.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 04/09/2026 17:55

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 04/09/2026 16:53

In my family a relative born in the late 1920s was kept alive for a short time with a mixture of brandy and whey from a fountain pen dropper. She was a twin, the other twin died and she weighed under 3lb. Mum was completely beyond beyond, not at all well and unable to do anything so granny, mother of 11, swung in and held the fort with the fountain pen until mum could take over. Everyone else expected ths baby to die as well but granny wasn't having it.
I rather hope there was a lot more whey than brandy! But when the mother told me the story we didn't get that far. That baby grew up and had children of her own, sounds far fetched but it worked.

Edited

Brandy was a popular cure-all. My great grandmother was given brandy enemas on her deathbed to keep her going until the family could get there to say goodbye. Probably not with a fountain pen filler.

The family was strict chapel, so theoretically teetotal, but very fond of a brandy-based tonic¹. Brandy (or whisky), milk and glucose was the cold remedy of choice. Brandy was switched to sherry for young children.

¹ Trifle also had an exemption. Driving after a portion of my grandmother's xmas trifle would have been decidedly unwise.

Emilesgran · 04/09/2026 17:26

moto748e · 04/09/2026 14:01

So were mothers more 'successful' at breast-feeding three, four, five hundred years ago? I suppose if they couldn't manage they just gave them cow's milk or goat's. In the days before NHS guidelines.

They were more successful at breastfeeding because they were surrounded by women who had long experience of it. There were also more women who had breastfed half a dozen or more babies, so were absolute experts. Sadly that is expertise that has been mostly lost, and we now have "experts" whose knowledge is largely theoretical.

(And yes of course there were wet nurses for women who genuinely couldn't feed a baby - but in most cases throughout history, babies were wet nursed because the mother was seriously ill or dead. There are very, very few cases of non-starving women who truly cannot produce enough milk to keep a baby alive.)

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 04/09/2026 16:53

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 04/09/2026 14:56

They probably were more successful because of higher levels of community support and more people in their circle having breastfeeding experience. And a much smaller proportion of children were firstborns, so the mother herself would usually have experience.

If they couldn't feed, or wouldn't because of social status, or if the mother died, the best option was a wet nurse. Everyone knew that substitute foods were a last resort and very rarely successful.

If a wet nurse wasn't possible they would have tried (depending on age of baby and time in history) watered down cow or goat milk, very thin gruel or rice, watered down clear soup, weak tea, or bread soaked in water or diluted milk. Very little was known about nutritional composition of any food so the main concern was to avoid overwhelming delicate infant stomachs with anything too rich. This was sometimes just about enough to keep older babies alive, but before about 3 months it was almost never successful. The lack of the immune benefits of breastfeeding was also a massive disadvantage, given medical treatments at the time.

Babies were exclusively breastfed by their mother. Or by another woman. Or they died. If you spend any time with historical death certificates the number of babies with marasmus (wasting and starvation) as cause of death is heartbreaking.

When formula was invented in the mid 19th century it was not much better nutritionally than the home concoctions, but the worse problem was the invention of bottles with rubber tubes or teats rather than open feeding cups. Advice was specifically to not wash them more than once every few weeks, so bacterial build up killed far more than the malnutrition.

In my family a relative born in the late 1920s was kept alive for a short time with a mixture of brandy and whey from a fountain pen dropper. She was a twin, the other twin died and she weighed under 3lb. Mum was completely beyond beyond, not at all well and unable to do anything so granny, mother of 11, swung in and held the fort with the fountain pen until mum could take over. Everyone else expected ths baby to die as well but granny wasn't having it.
I rather hope there was a lot more whey than brandy! But when the mother told me the story we didn't get that far. That baby grew up and had children of her own, sounds far fetched but it worked.

Datun · 04/09/2026 16:32

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 04/09/2026 14:56

They probably were more successful because of higher levels of community support and more people in their circle having breastfeeding experience. And a much smaller proportion of children were firstborns, so the mother herself would usually have experience.

If they couldn't feed, or wouldn't because of social status, or if the mother died, the best option was a wet nurse. Everyone knew that substitute foods were a last resort and very rarely successful.

If a wet nurse wasn't possible they would have tried (depending on age of baby and time in history) watered down cow or goat milk, very thin gruel or rice, watered down clear soup, weak tea, or bread soaked in water or diluted milk. Very little was known about nutritional composition of any food so the main concern was to avoid overwhelming delicate infant stomachs with anything too rich. This was sometimes just about enough to keep older babies alive, but before about 3 months it was almost never successful. The lack of the immune benefits of breastfeeding was also a massive disadvantage, given medical treatments at the time.

Babies were exclusively breastfed by their mother. Or by another woman. Or they died. If you spend any time with historical death certificates the number of babies with marasmus (wasting and starvation) as cause of death is heartbreaking.

When formula was invented in the mid 19th century it was not much better nutritionally than the home concoctions, but the worse problem was the invention of bottles with rubber tubes or teats rather than open feeding cups. Advice was specifically to not wash them more than once every few weeks, so bacterial build up killed far more than the malnutrition.

Fascinating. Love it.

Datun · 04/09/2026 16:30

MarjorieWestriding · 04/09/2026 13:35

Thinking - rather unwillingly, I admit - about this ghastly man, I'm trying to get my head around why he thinks women are lying when they say their babies were exclusively breastfed. I mean, what does he think happened before formula milk was invented? Surely if it wasn't for women exclusively breastfeeding their babies, humanity wouldn't even exist. What on earth is going on in that man's mind? The more I think about it, the more of an idiot he is.

He knows it's bollocks. Transactivism is all about decoupling women from their biology in order that men with male biology can be women.

See also Monroe Berkdorf demanding that women not centre their biology in any way during the women's march in London because it's 'exclusive'.

'Pussy hats' were the headwear du jour as a protest about Trump and his grab 'em by the pussy comments (🤮).

Bergdorf took exception to the sea of pink hats. I think he even said the quiet bit out loud and in that not every women has a vagina.

Meaning men.

MarjorieWestriding · 04/09/2026 15:04

Waitingfordoggo · 04/09/2026 14:14

This was my thought too- ‘How come this ‘expert’ knows so little about breastfeeding? Or has given its history so little thought?’

But I’m sure @ArabellaScott is right that it’s absolutely deliberate and is all about undermining women, because painting us all as liars makes it easier for him to facilitate perverts in plain sight.

I agree, undermining women seems to be quite de rigueur these days. The thing is, all I can see it doing is backfiring massively because it'll piss off so many women. I long for the day when the women of Ireland give these men a 'fuck off' you could hear from Mars.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 04/09/2026 14:56

moto748e · 04/09/2026 14:01

So were mothers more 'successful' at breast-feeding three, four, five hundred years ago? I suppose if they couldn't manage they just gave them cow's milk or goat's. In the days before NHS guidelines.

They probably were more successful because of higher levels of community support and more people in their circle having breastfeeding experience. And a much smaller proportion of children were firstborns, so the mother herself would usually have experience.

If they couldn't feed, or wouldn't because of social status, or if the mother died, the best option was a wet nurse. Everyone knew that substitute foods were a last resort and very rarely successful.

If a wet nurse wasn't possible they would have tried (depending on age of baby and time in history) watered down cow or goat milk, very thin gruel or rice, watered down clear soup, weak tea, or bread soaked in water or diluted milk. Very little was known about nutritional composition of any food so the main concern was to avoid overwhelming delicate infant stomachs with anything too rich. This was sometimes just about enough to keep older babies alive, but before about 3 months it was almost never successful. The lack of the immune benefits of breastfeeding was also a massive disadvantage, given medical treatments at the time.

Babies were exclusively breastfed by their mother. Or by another woman. Or they died. If you spend any time with historical death certificates the number of babies with marasmus (wasting and starvation) as cause of death is heartbreaking.

When formula was invented in the mid 19th century it was not much better nutritionally than the home concoctions, but the worse problem was the invention of bottles with rubber tubes or teats rather than open feeding cups. Advice was specifically to not wash them more than once every few weeks, so bacterial build up killed far more than the malnutrition.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/09/2026 14:50

Poor babies. Condemned to a life of disappointment from day one. What a sickening little brute he is.

AimsAndObjectives · 04/09/2026 14:41

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/09/2026 14:38

In which he says

What if I don’t have nipples?
gives a couple of examples of people without nipples, and then cheerfully suggests
Neither of these scenarios means that you can’t feed your baby at your chest, and even latch them if you would like to.

I wonder what someone without nipples would latch a baby onto? I suspect i might prefer not to know, though.

It seems to be 'latch them' onto a silicone nipple shield.🙄

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/09/2026 14:38

ArabellaScott · 04/09/2026 14:16

https://www.badoulatrainings.org/blog/top-surgery-and-lactation-what-you-need-to-know?rq=engelsman

Blog from Engelsman on females breastfeeding post mastectomy etc. I don't actually see how it would be possible 'if you don't have nipples'.

In which he says

What if I don’t have nipples?
gives a couple of examples of people without nipples, and then cheerfully suggests
Neither of these scenarios means that you can’t feed your baby at your chest, and even latch them if you would like to.

I wonder what someone without nipples would latch a baby onto? I suspect i might prefer not to know, though.

ArabellaScott · 04/09/2026 14:33

Engelsman contributed a short section to this book.

https://global.oup.com/academic/product/trans-bodies-trans-selves-9780190092726

In the 'transfeminine' (i.e. male) section, he talks about womb transplants. He also talks about 'non nutritive' sucking.

He states: 'there is no reason to feel that offering the baby your nipple if you are not lactating is an attempt to trick or deceive your child'.

Odd phrasing.

Older babies and toddlers may suck for comfort, but in the early days, this may well interfere with establishing feeding. It's irresponsible at very best.

Lactation support conference in Ireland - the quiet part out loud
OP posts:
BruachAbhann · 04/09/2026 14:25

BruachAbhann · 04/09/2026 14:21

Further attempts by our government to erode the very concept of motherhood and being a woman. In the family and care referendum (2024), Irish citizens were asked to vote on a change in the wording of the constitution which would have changed the legal nature and role of family and the role of 'mother' as primary caregiver.
Thank God the people voted against this change in an overwhelming majority thanks to some excellent campaigners (67% voted no to change the family referendum, 32% voted yes, 73.9 per cent 'no' to change care referendum (which proposed to remove the role of mother in the family).

The gall of the HSE not to condemn this speaker and the ALCI is very worrying. And the lack of media coverage in mainstream media at this issue is frightening. I mean, his intentions are obvious; he promotes breastfeeding for men for sexual gratification and has proudly and unashamedly stated this. There is no spin a reasonably-minded person could put on this which would make it ok. Why is he not being arrested as I type??

Don't know how to edit- excellent campaigners who showed us what the government were trying to sneak in, I mean

Whosthetabbynow · 04/09/2026 14:24

🤮

BruachAbhann · 04/09/2026 14:21

ArabellaScott · 04/09/2026 14:04

Diisrupting the mother/baby bond and dyad, and planting the seeds that mothers are unreliable liars, or that breastfeeding involves 'everyone', including single men, or pansexual non monogamous men.

He also describes how he didn't want to be a doula because he wanted to work with babies and didn't want to work with parents.

Further attempts by our government to erode the very concept of motherhood and being a woman. In the family and care referendum (2024), Irish citizens were asked to vote on a change in the wording of the constitution which would have changed the legal nature and role of family and the role of 'mother' as primary caregiver.
Thank God the people voted against this change in an overwhelming majority thanks to some excellent campaigners (67% voted no to change the family referendum, 32% voted yes, 73.9 per cent 'no' to change care referendum (which proposed to remove the role of mother in the family).

The gall of the HSE not to condemn this speaker and the ALCI is very worrying. And the lack of media coverage in mainstream media at this issue is frightening. I mean, his intentions are obvious; he promotes breastfeeding for men for sexual gratification and has proudly and unashamedly stated this. There is no spin a reasonably-minded person could put on this which would make it ok. Why is he not being arrested as I type??

ArabellaScott · 04/09/2026 14:21

https://www.badoulatrainings.org/blog/5-meaningful-ways-to-be-a-gender-inclusive-provider

' Practice using the singular ‘they’ (a great thing about ‘they’ is that everyone can be ‘they’) and try an exercise, either by yourself in the mirror or with a friend, where you practice misgendering a person, briefly apologize, and get back on track. That way, when you do misgender a patient you don’t get flustered and make it more uncomfortable.'

5 Meaningful Ways to Be a Gender Inclusive Provider — Birthing Advocacy Doula Trainings

For a few weeks now two subjects have been floating around in my brain like hot air balloons drifting past each other but not quite touching. When I was asked to write this piece, the two balloons finally made contact. I’ve been thinking about queer i...

https://www.badoulatrainings.org/blog/5-meaningful-ways-to-be-a-gender-inclusive-provider

OP posts:
AimsAndObjectives · 04/09/2026 14:19

MarjorieWestriding · 04/09/2026 13:35

Thinking - rather unwillingly, I admit - about this ghastly man, I'm trying to get my head around why he thinks women are lying when they say their babies were exclusively breastfed. I mean, what does he think happened before formula milk was invented? Surely if it wasn't for women exclusively breastfeeding their babies, humanity wouldn't even exist. What on earth is going on in that man's mind? The more I think about it, the more of an idiot he is.

@Cailin66 gave a good answer upthread.

Men cannot breastfeed. Some of the transexuals that take enough of a cocktail of drugs can eventually secrete something, but it’s not breast milk. And it most certainly wouldn’t be more than a couple of spoonfuls. So the only reason to do it is for that man’s sexual fetish. Because it’s not milk and it’s not enough, the baby obviously has to be fed instead by formula. If you say women who breastfeed also use formula, that means the transexuals are just as much a woman as a real woman.

Asserting that every woman who breastfeeds also uses formula, sets the scene for men to 'chestfeed and use formula', just like women.
I wouldn't be surprised if the word 'chestfeed', ostensibly introduced to avoid word-trauma for trans-identified females, has actually been introduced to help to normalise this fetish.

ArabellaScott · 04/09/2026 14:19

https://www.badoulatrainings.org/blog/inducing-lactation-an-informational-guide-from-an-ibclc

Here, he talks about buying Domperidone using bitcoin.

'The reason it isn’t prevalent in the US is that it isn’t FDA approved due to a risk of cardiac arrhythmia. However, this risk primarily exists when people are being given injections instead of pills and for an older population who are more likely to have heart troubles to begin with.
This is definitely something amab people need to be aware of since they have a higher risk of heart disease, but healthy afab people are generally in the clear if your doctor approves.
While you can’t get it anywhere in the US, it is fairly easy to order online and can be purchased in Canada if you’re up for a road trip. One of the websites most known for selling it (Inhouse Pharmacy) was only accepting bitcoin for a while, but as of this writing it looks like they’re back to accepting US dollars. '

All About Inducing Lactation: An Informational Guide From an IBCLC — Birthing Advocacy Doula Trainings

by Jacob Engelsman Inducing lactation seems to be one of those things that many people don’t hear about until after it’s relevant to their life. I don’t know how many times I’ve had someone shocked to learn it was an option, and dismayed that no o...

https://www.badoulatrainings.org/blog/inducing-lactation-an-informational-guide-from-an-ibclc

OP posts:
Waitingfordoggo · 04/09/2026 14:17

ArabellaScott · 03/09/2026 15:27

I can imagine that a woman who is 'trans' identifying may have additional support needs when it comes to infant feeding.

My first concern would be whether it would be in the best interests of both mother and/or baby to breastfeed.

If the trans-identifying woman takes testosterone (or wants to), that would surely be a factor to consider in breastfeeding. I know that women have testosterone naturally, but presumably the amount is much higher for trans-identifying women. I don’t know science so I could be wrong.

OP posts:
Waitingfordoggo · 04/09/2026 14:14

MarjorieWestriding · 04/09/2026 13:35

Thinking - rather unwillingly, I admit - about this ghastly man, I'm trying to get my head around why he thinks women are lying when they say their babies were exclusively breastfed. I mean, what does he think happened before formula milk was invented? Surely if it wasn't for women exclusively breastfeeding their babies, humanity wouldn't even exist. What on earth is going on in that man's mind? The more I think about it, the more of an idiot he is.

This was my thought too- ‘How come this ‘expert’ knows so little about breastfeeding? Or has given its history so little thought?’

But I’m sure @ArabellaScott is right that it’s absolutely deliberate and is all about undermining women, because painting us all as liars makes it easier for him to facilitate perverts in plain sight.

ArabellaScott · 04/09/2026 14:13

https://www.polyfriendly.org/entry/2119_jacob-engelsman_qtp-doula-the-birth-geek-independent-contractor/

'Jacob Engelsman
Birth Doula, Postpartum and Infant Care Doula - (at QTP Doula/The Birth Geek (Independent Contractor))
I own the company QTP Doula and am an independent contractor through The Birth Geek in Atlanta, GA where I serve as a birth doula as well as a postpartum and infant care doula. I did my postpartum training through ProDoula and my birth training through DONA so as to have a variety of perspectives to draw from. My emphasis is working with non-traditional families, specifically those of the LGBT and poly variety.

Jacob Engelsman - Family and Childbirth from US-GA

I own the company QTP Doula and am an independent contractor through The Birth Geek in Atlanta, GA where I serve as a birth doula as well as a postpartum and infant care doula. I did my postpartum training through ProDoula and my birth training through...

https://www.polyfriendly.org/entry/2119_jacob-engelsman_qtp-doula-the-birth-geek-independent-contractor

OP posts: