Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Lactation support conference in Ireland - the quiet part out loud

537 replies

ArabellaScott · 25/08/2026 11:16

https://genspect.org/where-does-male-lactation-fit-in-breastfeeding-support-networks/

'This year’s program lists a lactation consultant called Jacob Engelsman speaking on “communicating inclusively: creating gender-affirming clinical spaces for families” and “lactation support for gender-diverse families”.'

'Jacob Engelsman is a Certified Lactation Consultant based in the US. He describes himself as an infant care specialist, speaker, and writer. He is the author of a recently published book, Lactation for the Rest of Us: A Guide for Queer and Trans Parents and Helpers, and specialises in inducing lactation in non-gestational parents (parents who haven’t given birth). “Lactation is for anyone” Jacob tells us in this podcast interview.
Engelsman’s interest and expertise is not limited to lactation for the purpose of feeding an infant. One of his previous presentations was “Inducing Lactation for Kinksters” and according to his CV he has been giving various talks including on lactation at Frolicon, an adult lifestyle and fetish convention held annually in Atlanta, Georgia with substantial programming around kink, BDSM, sexuality, polyamory, LGBTQ+ relationships and alternative sexual/family cultures.
He is not a nurse, midwife, doctor, or healthcare professional (nor does he claim to be). He is not a parent or someone with personal experience of breastfeeding. He got his certification five years ago and prior to that worked in the food service industry.'
...
'Why would a man want to lactate? In Engelsman’s own words:
“There are several reasons a person may choose to lactate regardless of whether they can gestate a child…a non-gestational parent might choose to induce lactation as a way to feel emotionally closer to the baby, assert their own feelings of parenthood, gender euphoria, or just for the unique experience of it.” (p.49)
Writing specifically about “cis” men, that is men who identify as men, he says:
“As to the question of why they would want to, it seems reasonable to believe that cis men want to lactate for the same reasons as anyone else. Which is to say, usually to feed and bond with their baby and to a lesser extent for curiosity, fun, or sexual gratification.” (p.152)'

Where Does Male Lactation Fit in Breastfeeding Support Networks? — Genspect

The Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland (ALCI) will host its annual conference this coming October in Galway. Promotional posts on social media feature a lactation consultant, Jacob Engelsman, who promotes some practices that many people fi...

https://genspect.org/where-does-male-lactation-fit-in-breastfeeding-support-networks/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
40
Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 11:15

ArabellaScott · 05/09/2026 11:07

5 to 10% seems very high. I've not seen any evidence to support that figure.

I wonder too if it’s 5-10% of ALL women, which would include those with chronic illnesses which might all make BF-ing an extra strain on the body.
I think it’s important to point out that women in the past went on getting pregnant despite past miscarriages and other illnesses, so that it’s not surprising that after baby number 6 and pregnancy number 9 (say), a woman without lots of help at home would be so exhausted that her milk supply would suffer. I have no ideas of numbers though.

Extrapolating from those women to modern women who have two or three children, well spaced out, and moreover are not doing the sort of heavy physical work that someone like my grandmother would have done, to say that significant numbers of healthy women today can’t produce enough milk doesn't make a lot of sense to me.

Datun · 05/09/2026 11:09

ArabellaScott · 04/09/2026 18:12

https://www.feministcurrent.com/2018/02/27/munroe-bergdorf-like-please-keep-vaginas-feminism/

'I also want to stress that if you do attend, it is CRUICIAL that you do with an INTERSECTIONAL mindset. Centering reproductive systems at the heart of these demonstrations is reductive and exclusionary.
— Munroe Bergdorf 🌹🌹 (@MunroeBergdorf) January 20, 2018'

I remember him standing on a platform, telling women to shut up about their bodies, because snot fair. Flanked by women, who were happy to have him there.

I thoroughly enjoyed the Julia Long takedown of him at some event, where she challenged him about his approval of an 11 year-old drag queen. She was very brave, in a room full of men who clearly hated her, and indeed any woman.

we've definitely moved on since then. Thank heavens.

ArabellaScott · 05/09/2026 11:07

Fascinationstreet · 05/09/2026 10:43

""There are very, very few cases of non-starving women who truly cannot produce enough milk to keep a baby alive."" I do just want to highlight this isn't the case, the percentage of women who cannot physiologically produce any milk at all is relatively low ( not great stats reliability but perhaps 5 to10%) but plenty of mums aren't able to produce sufficient quantities to allow exclusive BF or who struggle in other ways. Considering many women faced the deaths of their children or their own deaths related to pregnancy and birth we perhaps shouldn't over extol the life experiences of women in time past. My own mum and her siblings were raised on milk straight from the cow, from birth onwards back in the 50's. Many young babies were also introduced to food well before 6 months in the fairly recent past - introducing foods at 2-3 mths was common in the 1970's! Hence why again it underlines the importance of giving mums adequate support for their own feeding journeys - and why a lactation conference should be centred on the needs of women and babies, not generating headlines that indicate anyone might wish to do so for sexual reasons or that biological men should be facilitated to BF .

5 to 10% seems very high. I've not seen any evidence to support that figure.

OP posts:
Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 11:06

Fascinationstreet · 05/09/2026 10:43

""There are very, very few cases of non-starving women who truly cannot produce enough milk to keep a baby alive."" I do just want to highlight this isn't the case, the percentage of women who cannot physiologically produce any milk at all is relatively low ( not great stats reliability but perhaps 5 to10%) but plenty of mums aren't able to produce sufficient quantities to allow exclusive BF or who struggle in other ways. Considering many women faced the deaths of their children or their own deaths related to pregnancy and birth we perhaps shouldn't over extol the life experiences of women in time past. My own mum and her siblings were raised on milk straight from the cow, from birth onwards back in the 50's. Many young babies were also introduced to food well before 6 months in the fairly recent past - introducing foods at 2-3 mths was common in the 1970's! Hence why again it underlines the importance of giving mums adequate support for their own feeding journeys - and why a lactation conference should be centred on the needs of women and babies, not generating headlines that indicate anyone might wish to do so for sexual reasons or that biological men should be facilitated to BF .

The exact dates for that claim matter hugely though: my mother was told in the mid 60s that she didn’t have enough milk to feed me because breastfeeding was actively discouraged at the time. She went on to breastfeed her 3rd and subsequent children perfectly well (in the 70s, when the “hippy movement had changed attitudes I suppose, not that my mum was a hippy obviously!), so clearly she just needed help with her first that she didn’t get, and then didn’t have the confidence to even try with the second.

Basically I don’t think we can assume that supposed problems with breastfeeding in the last century are necessarily indicative of physiological problems. Remember that even in famines many women continued to feed their children while their own bodies were starving - obviously they probably weren’t producing enough milk for the baby to thrive, but my point is that the body makes milk production one of its priorities, certainly over the woman’s physical comfort. It was always said that each baby cost its mother a tooth - that’s about her body using up its calcium stocks to provide what the baby needs.

So I was making a more general point that isn’t about what women in a medicalised situation were told by the “experts”. I’d be really surprised if anything like 10% of healthy women in societies where BF-ing is the norm are genuinely unable to produce enough milk to feed their babies other than occasional drops in production that don’t threaten the baby’s life.

I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if 10-15% of women were told that though, because the medical staff found it easier to give the baby a bottle than to wait and see.

Datun · 05/09/2026 11:05

AngleofRepose · 05/09/2026 08:45

Breast man | TERF Times

from 3 Sept-

Louise Guinness reports on the fallout after a ‘lactation for kinksters’ speaker was invited to address a conference for breastfeeding experts in Ireland

Jacob Engelsman is based in the US and specialises in helping non-gestational parents, meaning parents who have not given birth, to induce lactation. The Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland (ALCI) booked Engelsman to speak at its annual conference in Galway next month, and all hell broke loose.

Engelsman was reported to have given previous presentations including one entitled ‘Inducing Lactation for Kinksters’. In his book, Lactation for the Rest of Us, he writes that, aside from ‘cis men’ wanting to lactate for the same reasons as anyone else, namely to feed and bond with their baby, they may wish to do so ‘to a lesser extent for curiosity, fun or sexual gratification’. After press coverage, ALCI paused ticket sales and removed the programme from its website. It has since announced that the conference will move online and that Engelsman will no longer speak.

I found this an odd paragraph:

Engelsman is an International Board Certified Lactation Consultant (IBCLC), but for his critics, his willingness to discuss lactation for sexual gratification violates one of humanity’s most sacred taboos: the bond between a mother and her baby.
[my bold]

She does expand on this further on, but surely, what critcs are (or should be) objecting to is "one of humanity's most sacred taboos": child abuse?

I would think this was obvious??

his willingness to discuss lactation for sexual gratification violates one of humanity’s most sacred taboos: the bond between a mother and her baby.

It's a very odd sentence. Do they think that breastfeeding generally is arousing, and therefore we should be all talking about it.

I bet it's a very common misconception of many men, because really, what else are tits for, love?

Datun · 05/09/2026 11:03

When I was breastfeeding, solids could to be introduced at three months or 15lbs which ever came first.

Fascinationstreet · 05/09/2026 10:43

Emilesgran · 04/09/2026 17:26

They were more successful at breastfeeding because they were surrounded by women who had long experience of it. There were also more women who had breastfed half a dozen or more babies, so were absolute experts. Sadly that is expertise that has been mostly lost, and we now have "experts" whose knowledge is largely theoretical.

(And yes of course there were wet nurses for women who genuinely couldn't feed a baby - but in most cases throughout history, babies were wet nursed because the mother was seriously ill or dead. There are very, very few cases of non-starving women who truly cannot produce enough milk to keep a baby alive.)

""There are very, very few cases of non-starving women who truly cannot produce enough milk to keep a baby alive."" I do just want to highlight this isn't the case, the percentage of women who cannot physiologically produce any milk at all is relatively low ( not great stats reliability but perhaps 5 to10%) but plenty of mums aren't able to produce sufficient quantities to allow exclusive BF or who struggle in other ways. Considering many women faced the deaths of their children or their own deaths related to pregnancy and birth we perhaps shouldn't over extol the life experiences of women in time past. My own mum and her siblings were raised on milk straight from the cow, from birth onwards back in the 50's. Many young babies were also introduced to food well before 6 months in the fairly recent past - introducing foods at 2-3 mths was common in the 1970's! Hence why again it underlines the importance of giving mums adequate support for their own feeding journeys - and why a lactation conference should be centred on the needs of women and babies, not generating headlines that indicate anyone might wish to do so for sexual reasons or that biological men should be facilitated to BF .

moto748e · 05/09/2026 10:31

AngleofRepose · 05/09/2026 08:45

Breast man | TERF Times

from 3 Sept-

Louise Guinness reports on the fallout after a ‘lactation for kinksters’ speaker was invited to address a conference for breastfeeding experts in Ireland

Jacob Engelsman is based in the US and specialises in helping non-gestational parents, meaning parents who have not given birth, to induce lactation. The Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland (ALCI) booked Engelsman to speak at its annual conference in Galway next month, and all hell broke loose.

Engelsman was reported to have given previous presentations including one entitled ‘Inducing Lactation for Kinksters’. In his book, Lactation for the Rest of Us, he writes that, aside from ‘cis men’ wanting to lactate for the same reasons as anyone else, namely to feed and bond with their baby, they may wish to do so ‘to a lesser extent for curiosity, fun or sexual gratification’. After press coverage, ALCI paused ticket sales and removed the programme from its website. It has since announced that the conference will move online and that Engelsman will no longer speak.

I found this an odd paragraph:

Engelsman is an International Board Certified Lactation Consultant (IBCLC), but for his critics, his willingness to discuss lactation for sexual gratification violates one of humanity’s most sacred taboos: the bond between a mother and her baby.
[my bold]

She does expand on this further on, but surely, what critcs are (or should be) objecting to is "one of humanity's most sacred taboos": child abuse?

I would think this was obvious??

That's just bad English, though, surely. Should have been sub-edited. The bond between mother and baby is not a taboo.

Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 09:53

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 04/09/2026 16:53

In my family a relative born in the late 1920s was kept alive for a short time with a mixture of brandy and whey from a fountain pen dropper. She was a twin, the other twin died and she weighed under 3lb. Mum was completely beyond beyond, not at all well and unable to do anything so granny, mother of 11, swung in and held the fort with the fountain pen until mum could take over. Everyone else expected ths baby to die as well but granny wasn't having it.
I rather hope there was a lot more whey than brandy! But when the mother told me the story we didn't get that far. That baby grew up and had children of her own, sounds far fetched but it worked.

Edited

This bit strikes me about your relative’s life:
“granny, mother of 11, swung in and held the fort with the fountain pen
until mum could take over.”

She’d had 11 children so must have spent much of her own adult life breast feeding, and yet the fountain pen was the only option. Because I’ve never been convinced that milk does come back all that easily once it has actually dried up. I expect that women who wetnursed dozens of babies went straight from one to the next, without a real break in between.

I’d never really thought much about giving women domperidone etc to bring in their milk until this, but if it does happen, I think it’s really not great for the babies concerned either.

It’s not quite the same because the woman’s general hormonal profile is “natural” for the baby - hence why oestrogen contraceptive pills aren’t a given when a woman is feeding - whereas a transidentifying man will undoubtedly be taking oestrogen and possibly testosterone suppressing medication too.
And there’d obviously be an exception if induced lactation is only to get it started and the baby isn’t given the domperidone-affected milk.

EDIT: it was meant to be THE not there/their - honest!! 😅

AngleofRepose · 05/09/2026 08:45

Breast man | TERF Times

from 3 Sept-

Louise Guinness reports on the fallout after a ‘lactation for kinksters’ speaker was invited to address a conference for breastfeeding experts in Ireland

Jacob Engelsman is based in the US and specialises in helping non-gestational parents, meaning parents who have not given birth, to induce lactation. The Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland (ALCI) booked Engelsman to speak at its annual conference in Galway next month, and all hell broke loose.

Engelsman was reported to have given previous presentations including one entitled ‘Inducing Lactation for Kinksters’. In his book, Lactation for the Rest of Us, he writes that, aside from ‘cis men’ wanting to lactate for the same reasons as anyone else, namely to feed and bond with their baby, they may wish to do so ‘to a lesser extent for curiosity, fun or sexual gratification’. After press coverage, ALCI paused ticket sales and removed the programme from its website. It has since announced that the conference will move online and that Engelsman will no longer speak.

I found this an odd paragraph:

Engelsman is an International Board Certified Lactation Consultant (IBCLC), but for his critics, his willingness to discuss lactation for sexual gratification violates one of humanity’s most sacred taboos: the bond between a mother and her baby.
[my bold]

She does expand on this further on, but surely, what critcs are (or should be) objecting to is "one of humanity's most sacred taboos": child abuse?

I would think this was obvious??

AI edited Youtube still of Engelsman

Breast man | TERF Times

Louise Guinness reports on the fallout after a ‘lactation for kinksters’ speaker was invited to address a conference for breastfeeding experts in Ireland

https://www.terftimes.com/p/breast-man/

AncientBallerina · 05/09/2026 08:44

Emilesgran · 04/09/2026 17:26

They were more successful at breastfeeding because they were surrounded by women who had long experience of it. There were also more women who had breastfed half a dozen or more babies, so were absolute experts. Sadly that is expertise that has been mostly lost, and we now have "experts" whose knowledge is largely theoretical.

(And yes of course there were wet nurses for women who genuinely couldn't feed a baby - but in most cases throughout history, babies were wet nursed because the mother was seriously ill or dead. There are very, very few cases of non-starving women who truly cannot produce enough milk to keep a baby alive.)

When my first baby was born I attended a baby massage course at my local maternity hospital - very little massage actually got done ☺️. One woman would start feeding her baby and one by one most of the group would join them. It was really lovely and so supportive to be in that environment. Similarly meeting up with NCT groups etc. I imagine the olden days being a bit like that - much more of a community of women looking after their babies and children together. No men required.

CassOle · 04/09/2026 22:37

Waitingfordoggo · 04/09/2026 19:25

I'd forgotten how insulting some of the TRAs were, not wanting women to talk about their bodies, ffs.

I was just thinking the same @MarjorieWestriding. In fact I’d managed to forget Bergdof even existed, which was pleasant while it lasted. I still can’t really believe the audacity of that
message about centring reproductive systems at a WOMEN’S event. 😡

I remember when he was trying to remove his artistic nude photos from the internet as they showed his meat and veg. It rather shatters the illusion of the skull shaving, bolt-on tits and filters when you are clearly looking at a dude with boobs.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 04/09/2026 22:28

Examsareoverwoohoo · 04/09/2026 10:10

Quite. As always it's all about paedophile males and their sexual gratification and none at all about actual biological women - no matter their inner identity or feelings.

Transgender ideology leads women to cut off their breasts - surely that's the biggest issue for any kind of lactation group. Not men using babies for sexual pleasure. It's obscene and it's criminal.

But no, it's all about 'inclusion' of the men (thereby excluding both women and children).

Surely they should be advocating for women delaying mastectomies if there's any chance they might want to have children / breastfeed doing work in that area to raise awareness as there are several stupid doctors who've claimed you can 'just get new breasts' if you want but you can't, not ones that lactate. Bet this bloke's talk didn't cover that angle.

Edited

Surely they should be advocating for women delaying mastectomies if there's any chance they might want to have children / breastfeed

This lady could have spoken at the conference.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kjxIYqilXJg

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 04/09/2026 22:07

Cailin66 · 02/09/2026 19:06

They want the money generated by the attendees. Everyone of whom should demand their money back. To attend this is to support child abuse, sexual exploitation of children, a man who says all breastfeeding women lie about exclusively breastfeeding. That organisation is a disgrace.

Or to bag copies of the recordings...

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/09/2026 19:37

I would bet he wouldn't mind men centring their penises reproductive systems at a men's event.

Waitingfordoggo · 04/09/2026 19:25

I'd forgotten how insulting some of the TRAs were, not wanting women to talk about their bodies, ffs.

I was just thinking the same @MarjorieWestriding. In fact I’d managed to forget Bergdof even existed, which was pleasant while it lasted. I still can’t really believe the audacity of that
message about centring reproductive systems at a WOMEN’S event. 😡

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/09/2026 18:54

Well, not so good if actual mothers now lack a resource which might have been a help in the nutrition of actual babies.

MarjorieWestriding · 04/09/2026 18:40

Good, serves them right.

OP posts:
OP posts:
MarjorieWestriding · 04/09/2026 18:34

Back when LLL were a force for good. I wonder what they'd do these days, probably send some men to show it's done.

ArabellaScott · 04/09/2026 18:20

Re peer learning:

https://socialdigital.iadb.org/en/node/8502

'Some years ago, a zoo in Ohio celebrated the birth of a baby gorilla. The mother gorilla that gave birth to the baby had been born in captivity and, therefore, had never lived in a community with others of her kind. As such, she had never seen another female nurse. After giving birth to her first baby, the gorilla had no idea how to feed her and the baby died. Some time passed and the gorilla once again became pregnant. The zookeepers invited mothers from the breastfeeding support group known as La Leche League to visit the zoo and breastfeed their children near the gorilla’s cage. When the second gorilla baby was born, the mother successfully breastfed and it survived. This story suggests that breastfeeding is a learned behavior and that one of the ways this learning occurs is simply by watching other mothers in the act of nursing.'

The Nurse-in and the Gorillas | SOCIAL DIGITAL

https://socialdigital.iadb.org/en/node/8502

OP posts:
MarjorieWestriding · 04/09/2026 18:16

Some interesting history here. Our female ancestors were formidable, weren't they.

I'd forgotten how insulting some of the TRAs were, not wanting women to talk about their bodies, ffs.

ArabellaScott · 04/09/2026 18:16

Sorry, I know this is a derail. Last post (trumpets play forlornly)

'...the fact is not all women possess a functioning reproductive system, not all women have a vagina, not all women’s vaginas are pink. So, when ‘pink pussies’ are used as imagery intended to unify all women, what they are actually doing is excluding a large amount of women from feeling like they have a voice within feminism.'

OP posts:
EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 04/09/2026 18:16

Oh how I wish these men would all just fuck off.