Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Lactation support conference in Ireland - the quiet part out loud

537 replies

ArabellaScott · 25/08/2026 11:16

https://genspect.org/where-does-male-lactation-fit-in-breastfeeding-support-networks/

'This year’s program lists a lactation consultant called Jacob Engelsman speaking on “communicating inclusively: creating gender-affirming clinical spaces for families” and “lactation support for gender-diverse families”.'

'Jacob Engelsman is a Certified Lactation Consultant based in the US. He describes himself as an infant care specialist, speaker, and writer. He is the author of a recently published book, Lactation for the Rest of Us: A Guide for Queer and Trans Parents and Helpers, and specialises in inducing lactation in non-gestational parents (parents who haven’t given birth). “Lactation is for anyone” Jacob tells us in this podcast interview.
Engelsman’s interest and expertise is not limited to lactation for the purpose of feeding an infant. One of his previous presentations was “Inducing Lactation for Kinksters” and according to his CV he has been giving various talks including on lactation at Frolicon, an adult lifestyle and fetish convention held annually in Atlanta, Georgia with substantial programming around kink, BDSM, sexuality, polyamory, LGBTQ+ relationships and alternative sexual/family cultures.
He is not a nurse, midwife, doctor, or healthcare professional (nor does he claim to be). He is not a parent or someone with personal experience of breastfeeding. He got his certification five years ago and prior to that worked in the food service industry.'
...
'Why would a man want to lactate? In Engelsman’s own words:
“There are several reasons a person may choose to lactate regardless of whether they can gestate a child…a non-gestational parent might choose to induce lactation as a way to feel emotionally closer to the baby, assert their own feelings of parenthood, gender euphoria, or just for the unique experience of it.” (p.49)
Writing specifically about “cis” men, that is men who identify as men, he says:
“As to the question of why they would want to, it seems reasonable to believe that cis men want to lactate for the same reasons as anyone else. Which is to say, usually to feed and bond with their baby and to a lesser extent for curiosity, fun, or sexual gratification.” (p.152)'

Where Does Male Lactation Fit in Breastfeeding Support Networks? — Genspect

The Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland (ALCI) will host its annual conference this coming October in Galway. Promotional posts on social media feature a lactation consultant, Jacob Engelsman, who promotes some practices that many people fi...

https://genspect.org/where-does-male-lactation-fit-in-breastfeeding-support-networks/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
40
JellySaurus · 05/09/2026 21:01

Genesis1v27 · 05/09/2026 14:18

Alison O'Connor has a piece for the Sunday Times, to be in the paper tomorrow. The online article is behind a paywall, but here's an automated summary.

The ALCI position is ‘supporting lactating families’.

Once upon a time I would have interpreted ’supporting lactating families’ as a clumsy abbreviation for ‘supporting families where a mother is lactating’. Now, though, it feels like they are saying the quiet bit quietly. Still won’t say it? Families do not lactate, only women lactate.

OP posts:
Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 20:16

BruachAbhann · 05/09/2026 16:58

No, I read what you said clearly.
I never said the figure was 10%, I said it was 5%. Either you're not reading my posts correctly or you're engaging in bad faith. So yes, I agree we should leave the topic there.

I didn't say YOU said it though: you joined in an ongoing conversation based on that claim which a PP made: "the percentage of women who cannot physiologically produce any milk at all is relatively low ( not great stats reliability but perhaps 5 to10%)" - it's only about a page back.

Fascinationstreet · 05/09/2026 18:30

@EmpressDomesticatednottamed i am neither a dr nor a nurse/ midwife but this quote sums it up to me “”Domperidone is a relatively safe drug, but it would be unethical and unprofessional to expose you and your baby to a drug you do not need, and all measures to improve breastfeeding management should be made and documented prior to a decision to advocate its use””. For me there are understandable reasons why a woman with a pre term baby in NICU would take this, seeing as women are generally weaned off it once their supply gets established - but I can’t see any ethically justifiable reason for a biological man to take this.

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 05/09/2026 17:56

Bit late with this but regarding Domperidone, my understanding is that when women use it to induce lactation they stop taking it when they start producing milk because they no longer need it. I also thought there was a period of time when they express and dispose of the milk to ensure the drug is out of their system, is that correct?
Whereas men have to keep taking it and nobody knows how much babies have ingested? Selfish bastards, the men not the babies.

I have a bit of an interest because I am prescribed Domperidone for nausea as I have to avoid throwing up and get migraines. I have only ever taken one tablet at a time because it works, thank goodness! I think I can take it 3 time a day but I have stern advice from the GP to be very careful with it because it has undesirable side effects.

Also, sorry to be annoying, I found breastfeeding as easy as falling off a log, and was a bit taken aback because surely it couldn't be that easy and I must be doing it wrong! But when a young relative was expecting her first and getting very wound up about being determined to feed but gloomily exepocting it to be difficult I mentioned that she might find it really easy, after all I did. She told me it was the most helpful thing anyone said to her about it.
Just another aspect of this whole marvellous, infuriating, easy and impossible thing.

ArabellaScott · 05/09/2026 17:21

BruachAbhann · 05/09/2026 13:39

It's estimated at 1-5 percent. Like most women's issues it probably hasn't been studied or addressed enough. I don't blame you being sceptical about it. Even the first two lactation consultants were unaware of the specific issue I had ( which I would rather not post scientific research on as I already feel I've shared too much personal info). I just want to flag that it does happen. This is the kind of thing that the ALCI should actually be addressing, and should be helping women where they can.

Very much agree. And it would be useful for peer supporters etc to have this info, thabks to PP for sharing links.

Glad to see the weekend papers picking up the kinkster Lactator.

OP posts:
BruachAbhann · 05/09/2026 16:58

Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 14:20

So nowhere near 10% then
I think (as so often on this issue) you're taking it personally and not reading what I actually said.

Of COURSE there are some women who won't be able to breast feed, and in the VAST majority of those cases, there will be an actual physical explanation. Which in fact fits with what you're saying.

I was making a very different point, but as you have decided to take it as personal criticism, I can't expect you to read it objectively, so I'll leave it at that.

No, I read what you said clearly.
I never said the figure was 10%, I said it was 5%. Either you're not reading my posts correctly or you're engaging in bad faith. So yes, I agree we should leave the topic there.

Fascinationstreet · 05/09/2026 14:36

@ArabellaScott @Emilesgran theres a reason that I wrote “the percentage of women who cannot physiologically produce any milk at all is relatively low ( not great stats reliability but perhaps 5 to10%)” 5% is generally quoted by WHO/ UNICEF but as soon as you start to look into it any deeper you find that lactation issues aren't even clearly defined….so is a particular study looking at primary lactation failure, secondary lactation failure , breast hypoplasia, hormone issues,p ( thyroid, PCOS) failure to produce milk due to the stress of a c-section or a pethidine assisted birth etc??. Is there a true failure of primary lactation or is it because hospitals/ midwives are unable to care and support women enough through those difficult early days until their milk comes in properly, so babies losing weight are moved onto formula early on? researchhttps://www.droracle.ai/articles/1255677/what-is-the-prevalence-of-primary-lactation-failure-caused (https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s13006-025-00699-4) comments that “””There is very little research on the incidence of primary low milk supply. One large epidemiological study conducted in New Zealand in 1958 found that at least 6% of participants did not breastfeed due to primary low milk supply caused by IGT or other medical issues 11]. A more recent study of 319 breastfeeding mothers in the U.S. conducted in 1990 found that 15% of participants had persistent lactation insufficiency 12]. However, the principal author subsequently stated that she believed the true rate of primary low milk supply for western women to be 4% 13]. There have been no further large-scale studies in recent decades to investigate the incidence of primary low milk supply“””. I will try and post a pic of a very valid quote taken from https://www.lowmilksupplyfoundation.org/. medical misogyny as per usual

Lactation support conference in Ireland - the quiet part out loud
FanOfGailDines · 05/09/2026 14:29

Genesis1v27 · 05/09/2026 14:18

Alison O'Connor has a piece for the Sunday Times, to be in the paper tomorrow. The online article is behind a paywall, but here's an automated summary.

Thanks, I'll buy the paper tomorrow. Trying to gather together some examples of how the story is covered differently (if at all) for conversations on dog walks! I find if you can say something like... I read this in the paper, what do you think? It is a good intro to the conversation.
I'm enjoying the line of wondering what it will be like when The President meets The President soon. How the conversation might go if this topic was discussed...

Genesis1v27 · 05/09/2026 14:21

Laoise de Brún of the Countess had a good article in the Irish Daily Mail on Friday. The images are from Wicklow Women 4 Women.

Online version: https://tinyurl.com/mwscfvde

Lactation support conference in Ireland - the quiet part out loud
Lactation support conference in Ireland - the quiet part out loud
Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 14:20

BruachAbhann · 05/09/2026 13:39

It's estimated at 1-5 percent. Like most women's issues it probably hasn't been studied or addressed enough. I don't blame you being sceptical about it. Even the first two lactation consultants were unaware of the specific issue I had ( which I would rather not post scientific research on as I already feel I've shared too much personal info). I just want to flag that it does happen. This is the kind of thing that the ALCI should actually be addressing, and should be helping women where they can.

So nowhere near 10% then
I think (as so often on this issue) you're taking it personally and not reading what I actually said.

Of COURSE there are some women who won't be able to breast feed, and in the VAST majority of those cases, there will be an actual physical explanation. Which in fact fits with what you're saying.

I was making a very different point, but as you have decided to take it as personal criticism, I can't expect you to read it objectively, so I'll leave it at that.

Genesis1v27 · 05/09/2026 14:18

FanOfGailDines · 05/09/2026 13:54

What does the article in the Irish version of The Times say?

Alison O'Connor has a piece for the Sunday Times, to be in the paper tomorrow. The online article is behind a paywall, but here's an automated summary.

Lactation support conference in Ireland - the quiet part out loud
FanOfGailDines · 05/09/2026 13:54

What does the article in the Irish version of The Times say?

BruachAbhann · 05/09/2026 13:39

ArabellaScott · 05/09/2026 11:57

We can acknowledge that some women are unable to bf, but that should be based on evidence. A random figure with a percentage attached is not clear, evidenced information.

It's estimated at 1-5 percent. Like most women's issues it probably hasn't been studied or addressed enough. I don't blame you being sceptical about it. Even the first two lactation consultants were unaware of the specific issue I had ( which I would rather not post scientific research on as I already feel I've shared too much personal info). I just want to flag that it does happen. This is the kind of thing that the ALCI should actually be addressing, and should be helping women where they can.

BruachAbhann · 05/09/2026 13:20

Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 12:29

No, I know that sometimes this happens, but I’m saying that making it into an issue of personal success or failure is a huge mistake. A lot of women are put under pressure to breastfeed and led to believe that they have failed morally as mothers if they don’t succeed. In reality it’s quite a tricky thing to do when you don’t have the social support network of women who have already breastfed, and so “failure” is far more likely. That’s not to say it’s impossible, just that a new mother needs to be taught, when women are told it’s instinctive. It’s not really.

But all of that is a failure of society, not of the woman. And then people explaining it away by unevidenced claims that a high percentage of healthy women are physically unable to breastfeed may make the individual woman feel slightly less of a failure, but at the longer term cost of making the next generation of new mothers feel that it’s all too hit-and-miss and “maybe I’m just one of those who can’t and let’s just go straight to bottle feeding”. Which is such a pity, because once BF-ing is well installed it’s just so easy (and cheap) compared to bottle feeding.

Making it into a moral failing is the first mistake IMO. Trying to get out of that moral failing by saying that lots of healthy women genuinely can’t produce enough milk is understandable but is still the wrong solution.

Anyway. I know that won’t convince lots of women who still secretly fear that not breastfeeding is a moral failing and so want desperately to prove that it’s a physical impossibility. I think it’s just very hard to do first time round without someone to teach you.

I’ve never seen any actual evidence that modern, well fed, healthy women with just one or two children cannot physically breast feed. If you have any, I’d be interested to see it.

Edited

Well, I am evidence that there is at least 1! :-) it's a bit insulting to be told that because there is insufficient scientific evidence that it can't be true. I certainly didn't imagine what I went through.

'And then people explaining it away by unevidenced claims that a high percentage of healthy women are physically unable to breastfeed may make the individual woman feel slightly less of a failure, but at the longer term cost of making the next generation of new mothers feel that it’s all too hit-and-miss and “maybe I’m just one of those who can’t and let’s just go straight to bottle feeding”. Which is such a pity, because once BF-ing is well installed it’s just so easy (and cheap) compared to bottle feeding.'

I get the dangers that some people might erroneously be put off breastfeeding when they can actually do it. My point is that it is also not in the mother or child's interest to not acknowledge that sometimes it just isn't physically possible. It's not a high percentage. It's estimated to be between 1% -5 %.

I don't want to derail the thread with this issue. I wanted to point out that sometimes it won't physically work no matter what you do so that people who are reading who may struggled don't internalise is as something they are necessarily doing wrong.

I find your post a bit insensitive to be honest.

'I’ve never seen any actual evidence that modern, well fed, healthy women with just one or two children cannot physically breast feed. If you have any, I’d be interested to see it.'

I've just told you it happened to me.

Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 12:29

BruachAbhann · 05/09/2026 11:52

But I'm still reading your post as not understanding that sometimes there is a physical reason why women can't breastfeed. It's not always down to lack of knowledge. Sometimes it is.

No, I know that sometimes this happens, but I’m saying that making it into an issue of personal success or failure is a huge mistake. A lot of women are put under pressure to breastfeed and led to believe that they have failed morally as mothers if they don’t succeed. In reality it’s quite a tricky thing to do when you don’t have the social support network of women who have already breastfed, and so “failure” is far more likely. That’s not to say it’s impossible, just that a new mother needs to be taught, when women are told it’s instinctive. It’s not really.

But all of that is a failure of society, not of the woman. And then people explaining it away by unevidenced claims that a high percentage of healthy women are physically unable to breastfeed may make the individual woman feel slightly less of a failure, but at the longer term cost of making the next generation of new mothers feel that it’s all too hit-and-miss and “maybe I’m just one of those who can’t and let’s just go straight to bottle feeding”. Which is such a pity, because once BF-ing is well installed it’s just so easy (and cheap) compared to bottle feeding.

Making it into a moral failing is the first mistake IMO. Trying to get out of that moral failing by saying that lots of healthy women genuinely can’t produce enough milk is understandable but is still the wrong solution.

Anyway. I know that won’t convince lots of women who still secretly fear that not breastfeeding is a moral failing and so want desperately to prove that it’s a physical impossibility. I think it’s just very hard to do first time round without someone to teach you.

I’ve never seen any actual evidence that modern, well fed, healthy women with just one or two children cannot physically breast feed. If you have any, I’d be interested to see it.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 05/09/2026 12:13

I think it interesting that a woman may be able to breastfeed one or more babies perfectly ok but fail to produce enough milk for another one. It's particularly interesting if the one she can't breast-feed because the supply simply isn't there is a middle child rather than a first or a last one. What is the cause? How can that be addressed? To hell with men wanting to torment babies, there's a whole lot of important stuff that lactation consultants could be looking at to help actual women who are actually breast-feeding babies, or want to and are having trouble doing it.

And let's not even start on idiot "experts" who fail to notice for over a week that a baby has a tongue-tie and can't suck properly!

ArabellaScott · 05/09/2026 11:57

BruachAbhann · 05/09/2026 11:29

I was one of the 5% who couldn't exclusively breastfeed unfortunately. I was so determined to do it and it was really important to me but it was physically impossible. I just couldn't produce enough milk. Perfectly healthy in every other way. I got 3 different lactation consultants, one each time I had a baby. On the first two I had to resort to bottle feeding as they lost too much weight. On the third I bottle fed and gave my baby 'dessert breastmilk' for 11 months as I wanted to give him what I could.

I think it's a dangerous narrative not to acknowledge that some women have genuine problems breastfeeding despite their best intentions. I kept thinking I just needed to stick with it and not give a bottle but I probably endangered my baby's life and if there was more open dialogue about some women genuinely unable to breastfeed I wouldn't have thought to try persevere as much. Luckily I got the lactation consultant very early and got his weight up with the bottle.

I remember feeling like a total failure and thinking if I'd lived a hundred years ago my baby would have died and the lactation consultant matter of factly said yes, that's true. In reality I suppose a wet nurse would have been used, or cows milk or something.

The difference of course is that as a mother you want to do everything you can that's in the best interests of your baby. You will literally sacrifice your own health if it means keeping your baby alive. The fact that Cuidiu, ALCI and the HSE is entertaining this pervert in any way and allowing him a platform to speak on behalf of 'chest feeding men' is abhorrent and beyond distressing.

We can acknowledge that some women are unable to bf, but that should be based on evidence. A random figure with a percentage attached is not clear, evidenced information.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 05/09/2026 11:55

Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 11:15

I wonder too if it’s 5-10% of ALL women, which would include those with chronic illnesses which might all make BF-ing an extra strain on the body.
I think it’s important to point out that women in the past went on getting pregnant despite past miscarriages and other illnesses, so that it’s not surprising that after baby number 6 and pregnancy number 9 (say), a woman without lots of help at home would be so exhausted that her milk supply would suffer. I have no ideas of numbers though.

Extrapolating from those women to modern women who have two or three children, well spaced out, and moreover are not doing the sort of heavy physical work that someone like my grandmother would have done, to say that significant numbers of healthy women today can’t produce enough milk doesn't make a lot of sense to me.

PP hasn't shared where the figures are from. So without reference we really have no idea how relevant or realistic they may or may not be.

OP posts:
BruachAbhann · 05/09/2026 11:52

Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 11:47

No you’re misunderstanding me. I’m not saying women should just carry on and it will sort itself out. I’m saying that we (society, health professionals etc) more or less accidentally broke the link of women teaching each other how to breastfeed during the 20th century, and that you can no more expect all women to be able to breastfeed straight out of the block than you can expect children to know how to ride a bike without any help. Some do, but most need to be taught, and there’s no shame in that.
But if you have nobody to teach you, how can you learn? You could keep going, with a skinny, distressed baby - but l don’t think BF-ing is worth that.

So I’m not criticising women for not succeeding. It’s inevitable in our fragmented society. I’m just lamenting the loss of that expertise that was previously passed on over countless generations.

ETA “the baby would have died … the lactation consultant matter of factly said yes, that's true”

See I’m not convinced by this. It’s like the “fertility collapses after 35” axiom, which comes from French data from the 17th and 18th centuries. It’s not comparable to modern 35 year olds because women of 35 at that time had generally been having sex for a decade, possibly two - so if they had never been pregnant by 35, the problem was not the age, but the pre existing infertility. And if they stopped having babies at 35 after already having had several before that, again, that may be explained by lots of reasons other than primary infertility.
https://www.med.unc.edu/timetoconceive/how-long-can-you-wait-to-have-a-baby/

Whereas women nowadays may only be starting to try to get pregnant at 35, which is not the same thing at all.
Same with “babies died in the past” well yes they did but did they really die from lack of milk or from a cold that became bronchitis or whatever? Some women couldn’t produce milk - but had they themselves been properly nourished as children and had the healthcare that women nowadays have grown up with? How many other children were those women looking after at the same time? Maybe it was just physical exhaustion that led them to have a lower milk supply. Our reproductive lives are not directly comparable to theirs, and that affects milk supply.

Edited

But I'm still reading your post as not understanding that sometimes there is a physical reason why women can't breastfeed. It's not always down to lack of knowledge. Sometimes it is.

Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 11:47

BruachAbhann · 05/09/2026 11:29

I was one of the 5% who couldn't exclusively breastfeed unfortunately. I was so determined to do it and it was really important to me but it was physically impossible. I just couldn't produce enough milk. Perfectly healthy in every other way. I got 3 different lactation consultants, one each time I had a baby. On the first two I had to resort to bottle feeding as they lost too much weight. On the third I bottle fed and gave my baby 'dessert breastmilk' for 11 months as I wanted to give him what I could.

I think it's a dangerous narrative not to acknowledge that some women have genuine problems breastfeeding despite their best intentions. I kept thinking I just needed to stick with it and not give a bottle but I probably endangered my baby's life and if there was more open dialogue about some women genuinely unable to breastfeed I wouldn't have thought to try persevere as much. Luckily I got the lactation consultant very early and got his weight up with the bottle.

I remember feeling like a total failure and thinking if I'd lived a hundred years ago my baby would have died and the lactation consultant matter of factly said yes, that's true. In reality I suppose a wet nurse would have been used, or cows milk or something.

The difference of course is that as a mother you want to do everything you can that's in the best interests of your baby. You will literally sacrifice your own health if it means keeping your baby alive. The fact that Cuidiu, ALCI and the HSE is entertaining this pervert in any way and allowing him a platform to speak on behalf of 'chest feeding men' is abhorrent and beyond distressing.

No you’re misunderstanding me. I’m not saying women should just carry on and it will sort itself out. I’m saying that we (society, health professionals etc) more or less accidentally broke the link of women teaching each other how to breastfeed during the 20th century, and that you can no more expect all women to be able to breastfeed straight out of the block than you can expect children to know how to ride a bike without any help. Some do, but most need to be taught, and there’s no shame in that.
But if you have nobody to teach you, how can you learn? You could keep going, with a skinny, distressed baby - but l don’t think BF-ing is worth that.

So I’m not criticising women for not succeeding. It’s inevitable in our fragmented society. I’m just lamenting the loss of that expertise that was previously passed on over countless generations.

ETA “the baby would have died … the lactation consultant matter of factly said yes, that's true”

See I’m not convinced by this. It’s like the “fertility collapses after 35” axiom, which comes from French data from the 17th and 18th centuries. It’s not comparable to modern 35 year olds because women of 35 at that time had generally been having sex for a decade, possibly two - so if they had never been pregnant by 35, the problem was not the age, but the pre existing infertility. And if they stopped having babies at 35 after already having had several before that, again, that may be explained by lots of reasons other than primary infertility.
https://www.med.unc.edu/timetoconceive/how-long-can-you-wait-to-have-a-baby/

Whereas women nowadays may only be starting to try to get pregnant at 35, which is not the same thing at all.
Same with “babies died in the past” well yes they did but did they really die from lack of milk or from a cold that became bronchitis or whatever? Some women couldn’t produce milk - but had they themselves been properly nourished as children and had the healthcare that women nowadays have grown up with? How many other children were those women looking after at the same time? Maybe it was just physical exhaustion that led them to have a lower milk supply. Our reproductive lives are not directly comparable to theirs, and that affects milk supply.

Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 11:40

Oh and my first was a big, fat but still non-sleeping baby - if I’d obeyed the “rules” on not co-sleeping when feeding, I’d have had a mental breakdown! I fed him at night until he was one, but only because I could bring him into the bed stick him on the boob and then waken up some hours later with him still sound asleep in the crook of my arm. As I knew that my GM had never owned a cot, and was horrified at my mother’s “modern” ideas of putting babies in cots, I had no problem with doing that. None of her 10 children died of cosleeping.

Again I know it happens, and I’m not dismissing it at all (I had a neighbour who lost two babies to SIDS) but I think it’s either children who are already vulnerable, like my neighbour’s babies, or women taking sleeping tablets or other.

Concerning my neighbour, the second baby died during a midday nap, so co-sleeoing can’t have been the cause, but he did always seem to have a runny nose and a cold, even at a few months old. He was the same age as my daughter so I saw him a lot before he died. The first baby had died before I knew her but she had told me about him. She followed all the rules about back sleeping and no cosleeping etc for the second one.

BruachAbhann · 05/09/2026 11:29

Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 11:06

The exact dates for that claim matter hugely though: my mother was told in the mid 60s that she didn’t have enough milk to feed me because breastfeeding was actively discouraged at the time. She went on to breastfeed her 3rd and subsequent children perfectly well (in the 70s, when the “hippy movement had changed attitudes I suppose, not that my mum was a hippy obviously!), so clearly she just needed help with her first that she didn’t get, and then didn’t have the confidence to even try with the second.

Basically I don’t think we can assume that supposed problems with breastfeeding in the last century are necessarily indicative of physiological problems. Remember that even in famines many women continued to feed their children while their own bodies were starving - obviously they probably weren’t producing enough milk for the baby to thrive, but my point is that the body makes milk production one of its priorities, certainly over the woman’s physical comfort. It was always said that each baby cost its mother a tooth - that’s about her body using up its calcium stocks to provide what the baby needs.

So I was making a more general point that isn’t about what women in a medicalised situation were told by the “experts”. I’d be really surprised if anything like 10% of healthy women in societies where BF-ing is the norm are genuinely unable to produce enough milk to feed their babies other than occasional drops in production that don’t threaten the baby’s life.

I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if 10-15% of women were told that though, because the medical staff found it easier to give the baby a bottle than to wait and see.

I was one of the 5% who couldn't exclusively breastfeed unfortunately. I was so determined to do it and it was really important to me but it was physically impossible. I just couldn't produce enough milk. Perfectly healthy in every other way. I got 3 different lactation consultants, one each time I had a baby. On the first two I had to resort to bottle feeding as they lost too much weight. On the third I bottle fed and gave my baby 'dessert breastmilk' for 11 months as I wanted to give him what I could.

I think it's a dangerous narrative not to acknowledge that some women have genuine problems breastfeeding despite their best intentions. I kept thinking I just needed to stick with it and not give a bottle but I probably endangered my baby's life and if there was more open dialogue about some women genuinely unable to breastfeed I wouldn't have thought to try persevere as much. Luckily I got the lactation consultant very early and got his weight up with the bottle.

I remember feeling like a total failure and thinking if I'd lived a hundred years ago my baby would have died and the lactation consultant matter of factly said yes, that's true. In reality I suppose a wet nurse would have been used, or cows milk or something.

The difference of course is that as a mother you want to do everything you can that's in the best interests of your baby. You will literally sacrifice your own health if it means keeping your baby alive. The fact that Cuidiu, ALCI and the HSE is entertaining this pervert in any way and allowing him a platform to speak on behalf of 'chest feeding men' is abhorrent and beyond distressing.

Emilesgran · 05/09/2026 11:27

BernardBlacksMolluscs · 05/09/2026 11:16

having had a body that generally did anything I wanted it to to a reasonable standard, finding I was rubbish at making breast milk (and giving birth, but that's a different story) was quite the unpleasant surprise, and made me feel very inferior for a while. I'm completely sure I made a lot more milk the second time around, but it still felt a bit touch and go.

I was much more prepared second time around for the physical side of breastfeeding. I just found endlessly sitting on the sofa while DS1 dozed and fed unbelievably depressing with my first but rather relished it the second time (probably because I knew it was for such a relatively short time).

I also actually drank somewhere near enough water second time.

I knew what breast feeding actually looked like, so I could tell when DS2 was actively feeding or just having a comforting snooze.

and I had the confidence to ignore advice and co-sleep and let DS2 night feed which was when my body was actually making the most milk I think.

I probably could have exclusively breast fed DS1, but he would have been one of those skinny, grizzly, non sleeping babies and frankly I was not up for that, so formula it was.

even with DS2, the minute I introduced solid food he was like 'actual food in quantities that fill me up. I am hereby done with breast milk'.

Bearing in mind how much I hated breast feeding DS1 (because it went so badly and made me feel such a failure), it's strange to find that I look back with some fondness on breast feeding DS2.

It's such a complex thing isn't it? hard to see how a man could understand and give advice on it.

It may well have been on MN that I learned fairly recently that in humans, unlike most mammals, the feeding instinct is not nearly so well developed among both mothers and babies, and has to be actually learned.

As I said earlier, the huge luck I had was in the first couple of days being in a hospital ward beside a woman who knew what she was doing, and in a couple of minutes just because she was in the bed next to me whenever I fed, she showed me the most important things - like she told me to take him off the breast far sooner than the nurses had, which I now know both increases milk supply but also (which is what she told me) stops the nipples from getting painful or cracked.

Sadly I think a lot of that knowledge has been lost in the west, so first time mothers often just don’t have the support circle needed to succeed right from the start. That’s why it took you two goes to really get it!

BernardBlacksMolluscs · 05/09/2026 11:16

having had a body that generally did anything I wanted it to to a reasonable standard, finding I was rubbish at making breast milk (and giving birth, but that's a different story) was quite the unpleasant surprise, and made me feel very inferior for a while. I'm completely sure I made a lot more milk the second time around, but it still felt a bit touch and go.

I was much more prepared second time around for the physical side of breastfeeding. I just found endlessly sitting on the sofa while DS1 dozed and fed unbelievably depressing with my first but rather relished it the second time (probably because I knew it was for such a relatively short time).

I also actually drank somewhere near enough water second time.

I knew what breast feeding actually looked like, so I could tell when DS2 was actively feeding or just having a comforting snooze.

and I had the confidence to ignore advice and co-sleep and let DS2 night feed which was when my body was actually making the most milk I think.

I probably could have exclusively breast fed DS1, but he would have been one of those skinny, grizzly, non sleeping babies and frankly I was not up for that, so formula it was.

even with DS2, the minute I introduced solid food he was like 'actual food in quantities that fill me up. I am hereby done with breast milk'.

Bearing in mind how much I hated breast feeding DS1 (because it went so badly and made me feel such a failure), it's strange to find that I look back with some fondness on breast feeding DS2.

It's such a complex thing isn't it? hard to see how a man could understand and give advice on it.