Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Lactation support conference in Ireland - the quiet part out loud

537 replies

ArabellaScott · 25/08/2026 11:16

https://genspect.org/where-does-male-lactation-fit-in-breastfeeding-support-networks/

'This year’s program lists a lactation consultant called Jacob Engelsman speaking on “communicating inclusively: creating gender-affirming clinical spaces for families” and “lactation support for gender-diverse families”.'

'Jacob Engelsman is a Certified Lactation Consultant based in the US. He describes himself as an infant care specialist, speaker, and writer. He is the author of a recently published book, Lactation for the Rest of Us: A Guide for Queer and Trans Parents and Helpers, and specialises in inducing lactation in non-gestational parents (parents who haven’t given birth). “Lactation is for anyone” Jacob tells us in this podcast interview.
Engelsman’s interest and expertise is not limited to lactation for the purpose of feeding an infant. One of his previous presentations was “Inducing Lactation for Kinksters” and according to his CV he has been giving various talks including on lactation at Frolicon, an adult lifestyle and fetish convention held annually in Atlanta, Georgia with substantial programming around kink, BDSM, sexuality, polyamory, LGBTQ+ relationships and alternative sexual/family cultures.
He is not a nurse, midwife, doctor, or healthcare professional (nor does he claim to be). He is not a parent or someone with personal experience of breastfeeding. He got his certification five years ago and prior to that worked in the food service industry.'
...
'Why would a man want to lactate? In Engelsman’s own words:
“There are several reasons a person may choose to lactate regardless of whether they can gestate a child…a non-gestational parent might choose to induce lactation as a way to feel emotionally closer to the baby, assert their own feelings of parenthood, gender euphoria, or just for the unique experience of it.” (p.49)
Writing specifically about “cis” men, that is men who identify as men, he says:
“As to the question of why they would want to, it seems reasonable to believe that cis men want to lactate for the same reasons as anyone else. Which is to say, usually to feed and bond with their baby and to a lesser extent for curiosity, fun, or sexual gratification.” (p.152)'

Where Does Male Lactation Fit in Breastfeeding Support Networks? — Genspect

The Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland (ALCI) will host its annual conference this coming October in Galway. Promotional posts on social media feature a lactation consultant, Jacob Engelsman, who promotes some practices that many people fi...

https://genspect.org/where-does-male-lactation-fit-in-breastfeeding-support-networks/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
40
ArabellaScott · 29/08/2026 09:53

Another interesting section here, where he claims that mothers who say they are exclusively breastfeeding 'are lying'.

'....it's funny you say that because every mom I'm friends with their baby is exclusively breasted.
And I was like, no, they're lying to you. They don't want to lose face because there's shame surrounding it.
You are all just lying to each other. And if one of you would own up and say at some point my baby had some formula and it wasn't the end of the world, you would all be better off for it.'

How interesting. Why would he say this? Cast mothers as liars?

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 29/08/2026 09:52

'I was a fancy wine and cheese guy at a grocery store, which I love was great, but I knew that it wasn't what I wanted to do for the rest of my life.
So I figured out what my ideal job would be,then figured out the word for that job. The word that I came up with was postpartum doula.
I did a doula training. I met some people. I googled Atlanta doulas,and then I had coffee with a dozen different people.
So I did a postpartum doula training. I made friends with some people.
I ended up doing a birth doula training and attended a birth. I realized that being a doula is not really what I wanted to do because that is more taking care of parents. It's more parent care and less infant care.
But Atlanta has this huge birth worker and lactation community, which is great,
and a lot of people were really supportive. So I got a job as the secretary at a clinic called Breastfeed Atlanta, where my entire job was schedule consultations, organize breast pump rentals and file insurance claims, and
after about six months, the owner was like, Jacob, you should just become an I-B-C-L-C.
You're really into the work, even if you decide you don't want to be a lactation consultant for the rest of your life, but it'll only ever look good on a resume that you were an I-B-C-L-C for a while, even if you let it lapse. No.
Yeah, it's never going to be a hindrance, and I didn't realize at the time,
but for most people, the hard part is getting your clinical hours.
I already worked at a clinic, so I was like, yeah, okay, that seems like a good idea'

A man who dedicates his life to working with babies, but isn't interested in 'parent care'.

The whole enterprise looks like him working out access.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nuDUvtKS4FI

OP posts:
nicepotoftea · 29/08/2026 09:48

plausible deniability that when he talks about sexual gratification and kink, of course hes not talking about involving babies being fed, purely the act of producing and secreting 'milk'.

But can't they see how harmful it is to normalise 'lacation kinks'. Regardless of what they say, inclusion of this man in a main stream conference does endorse everything he does.

ArabellaScott · 29/08/2026 09:41

Sidenote - milk donation is amazing, literally life saving, and the poster casting aspersions on it is at best very misinformed.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 29/08/2026 09:39

What I find astounding is that this man has been so successful. Welcomed onto a podcast by lesbian mothers. Works as a nanny. Works in early years/nursery setting. Worked, according to his own account, as a receptionist/admin in a lactation service and from there kind of 'accidentally' became a consultant.

In his role as a baby person, he talks about how he loves babies, was drawn to work with babies, etc. But doesn't want to be a parent, doesn't want to be a medic, just wanted a job he could work with babies.

Conversely there is his 'kink' and 'gender' stuff. The fetish stuff.

And the massive and undeniable problem is that a normal person would keep those two fields completely apart from each other. But he has brought them together.

OP posts:
FanOfGailDines · 29/08/2026 09:38

It beggars belief: Jasmin Sussex case from Australia.

https://www.2gb.com/breastfeeding-counsellor-sacked-as-mother-deemed-hate-speech/

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/this-isnt-about-same-sex-relationships-jasmine-sussex/video/8662664a94f78179ad4a72fb8d9d7c20

News of the breastfeeding conference might help Ireland to realise that something needs to be done about the madness. It's not a side issue. The obvious safeguarding implications might help wake people and politicians up. The cruelty to women and invasion of their space is very clear when you are talking about breastfeeding a child.

Breastfeeding counsellor SACKED as 'mother' deemed 'hate speech'

An Aussie mum has been sacked as a breastfeeding counsellor because she used the word ‘mother’ rather than the gender-neutral term ‘parent’. The term ‘mother’ is being categorised as “hate speech” by the Breastfeeding Association- of which Jasmine Suss...

https://www.2gb.com/breastfeeding-counsellor-sacked-as-mother-deemed-hate-speech/

AstonCanKissMyArse · 29/08/2026 09:36

Cailin66 · 29/08/2026 09:14

I had a good look at the ALCI website. Someone is very busy on there. No longer are the two posters for the conference visible. Nor is there a link to purchasing entry tickets. Ardilaun Hotel Galway not mentioned. I highly suspect the hotel has been contacted, that’s the way these things work in Ireland. It’s a small family hotel, well known in Galway, and yes I’ve been there and will be actually in Galway the week after the conference. (I live on the continent).

The membership is clearly 100% women. The listed professionals are all women, I’ve only a doubt about one named individual that doesn’t have a photo. Photos from prior conferences are 99.9% women. Breastfeeding professionals. The .01% is a male presenter from the conference 2 years ago. Plus a picture of a couple with a pregnant woman.

What strikes me is how strong is the word Lactation, rather than Breast-feeding. Also striking is the avoidance of the word Woman. I’m beyond wondering is it an error, or my heightened senses, because I’m certain it’s deliberate.

The link for board members is missing.

Edited

I wonder whether by using the word 'lactation', he has the (not very) plausible deniability that when he talks about sexual gratification and kink, of course hes not talking about involving babies being fed, purely the act of producing and secreting 'milk'.

Yeah, right.

On another note, I dont understand the disapproval of donor breast milk upthread by a PP. Some tiny prem babies, including my own, cannot tolerate formula - their tiny unformed bodies cannot process it. If i hadn't been able to express I dread to think what would have happened because our hospital didn't have a milk bank facility. They can literally be life saving.

Lifestyle questionnaires for donors and screening the milk, just like they do for blood donations ensures its as safe as possible. Its no different to donor blood! If you accept the concept of lifesaving blood donations, why not milk?

No Mother is using donor milk just because she 'prefers' it to formula - that's a horribly ignorant thing to say and implies its an unnecessary lifestyle choice.

Cailin66 · 29/08/2026 09:14

I had a good look at the ALCI website. Someone is very busy on there. No longer are the two posters for the conference visible. Nor is there a link to purchasing entry tickets. Ardilaun Hotel Galway not mentioned. I highly suspect the hotel has been contacted, that’s the way these things work in Ireland. It’s a small family hotel, well known in Galway, and yes I’ve been there and will be actually in Galway the week after the conference. (I live on the continent).

The membership is clearly 100% women. The listed professionals are all women, I’ve only a doubt about one named individual that doesn’t have a photo. Photos from prior conferences are 99.9% women. Breastfeeding professionals. The .01% is a male presenter from the conference 2 years ago. Plus a picture of a couple with a pregnant woman.

What strikes me is how strong is the word Lactation, rather than Breast-feeding. Also striking is the avoidance of the word Woman. I’m beyond wondering is it an error, or my heightened senses, because I’m certain it’s deliberate.

The link for board members is missing.

nicepotoftea · 29/08/2026 09:09

MarieDeGournay · 28/08/2026 22:11

This is an example of the damage that the 'LGBTQ+ acronym does to the LGB community - men attempting to appropriate women's biological functions is not a lesbian and gay thing, it's a trans thing, and yet again 'Gender Diversity' = transgenderism.

But you can see how it will be portrayed - pearl-clutching right-wingers cancelling an LGBTI+ speaker. The ALCI statement is clinging to the 'diversity' line, and specifically refers to the Irish govt's 'LGBTQI+ [sic]' strategy as justification.
LGB✂T is urgently needed.

But it's not like the ALCI's invitation to JE was an oversight, and they didn't check what he was going to be talking about .
They make it clear on their website that 'chestfeeding' by men is part of their 'ethos'
ALCI Ethos
ALCI is dedicated to the Protection, Promotion and Support of Breastfeeding for all persons. ALCI is inclusive to all persons and the intention of our written material, protocols, statements and position statements is to remain inclusive to all breastfeeding, chest feeding and human milk feeding individuals. For the purpose of such materials, and throughout ALCI Education Events, the terms Breastfeeding and Mother are chosen without bias or prejudice. ALCI fosters a positive ethos and operates a policy of equal respect, regard and fair treatment for all Council Members, Members, Attendees, Speakers, Exhibitors, Hospitality Staff and Visitors.
Term and Conditions of ALCI's Events - ALCI

So even if they were not aware of JE's comment about sexual gratification, they deliberately invited him as a promoter of 'human milk feeding individuals'.

The hotel were very wise to decide that having talk about men chestfeeding was controversial enough, but if he is on record as having associated that activity with sex, that would be a PR disaster for them.

When they talk about chestfeeding by men isn't it more likely that this refers to women who identify as men?

nicepotoftea · 29/08/2026 09:07

For the purpose of such materials, and throughout ALCI Education Events, the terms Breastfeeding and Mother are chosen without bias or prejudice.

I know others might not agree, but I do give them credit for agreeing that 'mother' and 'breastfeeding' can be used as neutral terms that don't imply anything about identity/personality/behavour/preferences.

However, I'm baffled that they don't understand why it's necessary to exclude fetishists/the fetish adjacent from their conference, or why they think somebody with these links is the best person to advise the people who are overwhelmingly likely to be seeking their advice - women, regardless of how they identify.

It's all very Jolyon Maugham 'helping black and brown people'.

Datun · 29/08/2026 09:05

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 29/08/2026 08:53

It is amazing that he feels he can say what he says with impunity. The problem is that he's purely talking about the reactions of the men in these circumstances. Is stating that a sufficient defence against the kind of criticism you're making?
I'm not looking to split hairs, I just wonder if listing the benefits to men falls into the strict legal category you're suggesting?

Edited

I don't know. But he's already set up a thing called breastfeeding for kinksters.

The entire concept would be illegal. I'm sure it's only a question of time.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 29/08/2026 08:53

Datun · 29/08/2026 08:45

I'm sure there's truth in that.

But be that as it may, it's illegal to encourage people into the sexual abuse of a child. It doesn't matter how much they fondly imagine it's progressive.

It is amazing that he feels he can say what he says with impunity. The problem is that he's purely talking about the reactions of the men in these circumstances. Is stating that a sufficient defence against the kind of criticism you're making?
I'm not looking to split hairs, I just wonder if listing the benefits to men falls into the strict legal category you're suggesting?

Datun · 29/08/2026 08:45

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 29/08/2026 08:35

A big part of this movement is that it's been adopted by apparently the cleverest most intelligent people. Certainly the most upwardly mobile educated and credentialised classes.
I read a blog which stated that these are precisely the classes who believe themselves to be so above reproach, the least likely to self reflect, the most unwilling to consider alternate points of view.
This combination of self-selected ruling class can only see their viewpoint, people with views that differ are there not to be convinced otherwise by argument, but to be educated to think straight.
Inviting this fellow would have been all part of this, he's self identified (sorry for the pun) into the credentialised groupthink culture, and this means the organisers have a blind spot on his more, how shall I call it, outré opinions.
To be so convinced by your own cultured worldview and effete superiority that you as a breastfeeding body can bury the "ick factor" when you read he talks about biological men being encouraged to chest feed babies amongst other things to derive sexual gratification, is an absolute sign less of group think than group.psychosis.
But the arrogant conceit you're "better" than the dissenter class is a powerful all-consuming drug.

I'm sure there's truth in that.

But be that as it may, it's illegal to encourage people into the sexual abuse of a child. It doesn't matter how much they fondly imagine it's progressive.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 29/08/2026 08:35

Datun · 29/08/2026 01:02

What's fascinating about the conference organizer's "defence" is that even when the quote of "sexual gratification" is made known to them, they don't immediately disagree and show horror.
No, they're too busy saying nothing can stick to them.
Cowards in every way, covering their backs rather than being humble and apologetic.

Worrying, isn't it? Why aren't they bloody shocked??

Well, now the spotlight is on them. They will be scrutinised wherever they set up shop. Time will tell whether it was cowardice, or complicity.

A big part of this movement is that it's been adopted by apparently the cleverest most intelligent people. Certainly the most upwardly mobile educated and credentialised classes.
I read a blog which stated that these are precisely the classes who believe themselves to be so above reproach, the least likely to self reflect, the most unwilling to consider alternate points of view.
This combination of self-selected ruling class can only see their viewpoint, people with views that differ are there not to be convinced otherwise by argument, but to be educated to think straight.
Inviting this fellow would have been all part of this, he's self identified (sorry for the pun) into the credentialised groupthink culture, and this means the organisers have a blind spot on his more, how shall I call it, outré opinions.
To be so convinced by your own cultured worldview and effete superiority that you as a breastfeeding body can bury the "ick factor" when you read he talks about biological men being encouraged to chest feed babies amongst other things to derive sexual gratification, is an absolute sign less of group think than group.psychosis.
But the arrogant conceit you're "better" than the dissenter class is a powerful all-consuming drug.

Cailin66 · 29/08/2026 07:44

Kingdomofsleep · 28/08/2026 20:54

I'm really glad your baby (now a grown up!) Is all ok in the end. I very much care about babies getting the support they need and I hope you didn't think I was being flippant about the babies needing the breastmilk, just concerned about the food-safety if you like, when it's being expressed at home (not in your case but just as a general thing). I understand there are couriers but unless they watch it being expressed (which would be weird!) we still don't know much about it. And as we know, there are bad actors out there, even if very rare.

Until this thread I was unaware of breast milk being couried etc. My firstborn was in the neonatal unit for 10 days, the nurse knew I wished to breastfeed, so she fed my baby from a cup instead of a bottle until I managed to get there from my hospital room the next morning. From the babies I saw there I learnt that breast milk was liquid gold and the marvellous nurses were really grateful that I donated mine to help those babies thrive.

There was no watching me, there was a special room for me to be with my baby (and husband).

I’m really outraged that something so special, so important for women and babies is now something equated with sexual deviants in men. Will these men with sexual perversion ever leave us women anything which is pure and beautiful. The senior consultant, a wonderfully talented man, demonstrated my baby the day we left to a junior doctor and emphasised the importance of breastfeeding. There was nothing wrong with my baby, they were concerned about low birthweight, so it was nothing to me to donate my breast milk to the hard working dedicated nurses doing everything to help the poor mites i saw in the neonatal unit.

Datun · 29/08/2026 01:02

What's fascinating about the conference organizer's "defence" is that even when the quote of "sexual gratification" is made known to them, they don't immediately disagree and show horror.
No, they're too busy saying nothing can stick to them.
Cowards in every way, covering their backs rather than being humble and apologetic.

Worrying, isn't it? Why aren't they bloody shocked??

Well, now the spotlight is on them. They will be scrutinised wherever they set up shop. Time will tell whether it was cowardice, or complicity.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 29/08/2026 00:21

LifeInAHamsterWheel · 28/08/2026 19:54

I'm glad the hotel have cancelled but I'm not convinced the event itself won't still go ahead but somewhere else. Given the statement they put out they clearly don't see anything wrong with helping men indulge their paedophile fetishes 😠

From the statement "Families accessing lactation services have diverse [...] feeding goals".

Well, there's diverse and diverse isn't there?

The feeding goal - the only feeding goal - should be nourishing the child. That may have diverse elements - establishing feeding, increasing supply, mixed feeding, extended feeding etc - but the ultimate goal is getting the best food into the baby as effectively as possible.

Other goals, like gender euphoria and sexual gratification, are a diversity that should be absolutely nowhere near it.

ArabellaScott · 28/08/2026 22:47

I'm reading the transcript, but it does make it very hard to know what's happening when someone has multiple partners, but 'they' might be referring to a non-binary person.

OP posts:
OP posts:
MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 28/08/2026 22:33

MarieDeGournay · 28/08/2026 22:15

Steady on, Marc! - this is a very serious matter, but Nazi sympathiser/synagogue/Jewish charity would be a hugely different level of serious.

I'm obviously exaggerating to make a point, but the point still holds. The organizers didn't call the speaker to account when his views were made known, and even now, there's no contrition, just the legalese of "our utilizing his services in no way means all his views ally with ours".
They know they're so in hot water, so drawing a legal distinction is all they have.

EdithStourton · 28/08/2026 22:31

AngleofRepose · 28/08/2026 20:12

I also note that we have had zero interest on this thread from the Usual Suspects. Does no one want to post here in support of this "lactation consultant?" No one? No? 🤔

(I wonder why?)

Angle, I'm just as baffled as you are...
...not!

Earlier on today I did contemplate tagging a few of them into the discussion, but it probably counts as bullying, so I didn't.

GlosGirl82 · 28/08/2026 22:19

What the actual F????

MarieDeGournay · 28/08/2026 22:15

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 28/08/2026 22:01

This is like a Jewish charity inviting a speaker to a synagogue who's bio includes the phrase "the Nazis didn't get everything wrong, what we can learn from them", and then throwing their hands up that they can't be held accountable for these views.
What's fascinating about the conference organizer's "defence" is that even when the quote of "sexual gratification" is made known to them, they don't immediately disagree and show horror.
No, they're too busy saying nothing can stick to them.
Cowards in every way, covering their backs rather than being humble and apologetic.

Edited

Steady on, Marc! - this is a very serious matter, but Nazi sympathiser/synagogue/Jewish charity would be a hugely different level of serious.

MarieDeGournay · 28/08/2026 22:11

nicepotoftea · 28/08/2026 21:39

"Jacob's profession work and educational experience focuses specifically on supporting gender diverse and LGBTQ+ families within lactation care"

Except according to his website his actual focus is non-gestational parents and according to his CV he isn't really too bothered about whether they are parents. And that's before you get to kinks. Are there no female LGBTQ+ lactation consultants who could give advice based on their own experience?

"Nor does inviting a speaker constitute endorsement of every view that speaker may hold"

WTF???!!!

This is an example of the damage that the 'LGBTQ+ acronym does to the LGB community - men attempting to appropriate women's biological functions is not a lesbian and gay thing, it's a trans thing, and yet again 'Gender Diversity' = transgenderism.

But you can see how it will be portrayed - pearl-clutching right-wingers cancelling an LGBTI+ speaker. The ALCI statement is clinging to the 'diversity' line, and specifically refers to the Irish govt's 'LGBTQI+ [sic]' strategy as justification.
LGB✂T is urgently needed.

But it's not like the ALCI's invitation to JE was an oversight, and they didn't check what he was going to be talking about .
They make it clear on their website that 'chestfeeding' by men is part of their 'ethos'
ALCI Ethos
ALCI is dedicated to the Protection, Promotion and Support of Breastfeeding for all persons. ALCI is inclusive to all persons and the intention of our written material, protocols, statements and position statements is to remain inclusive to all breastfeeding, chest feeding and human milk feeding individuals. For the purpose of such materials, and throughout ALCI Education Events, the terms Breastfeeding and Mother are chosen without bias or prejudice. ALCI fosters a positive ethos and operates a policy of equal respect, regard and fair treatment for all Council Members, Members, Attendees, Speakers, Exhibitors, Hospitality Staff and Visitors.
Term and Conditions of ALCI's Events - ALCI

So even if they were not aware of JE's comment about sexual gratification, they deliberately invited him as a promoter of 'human milk feeding individuals'.

The hotel were very wise to decide that having talk about men chestfeeding was controversial enough, but if he is on record as having associated that activity with sex, that would be a PR disaster for them.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 28/08/2026 22:01

nicepotoftea · 28/08/2026 21:39

"Jacob's profession work and educational experience focuses specifically on supporting gender diverse and LGBTQ+ families within lactation care"

Except according to his website his actual focus is non-gestational parents and according to his CV he isn't really too bothered about whether they are parents. And that's before you get to kinks. Are there no female LGBTQ+ lactation consultants who could give advice based on their own experience?

"Nor does inviting a speaker constitute endorsement of every view that speaker may hold"

WTF???!!!

This is like a Jewish charity inviting a speaker to a synagogue who's bio includes the phrase "the Nazis didn't get everything wrong, what we can learn from them", and then throwing their hands up that they can't be held accountable for these views.
What's fascinating about the conference organizer's "defence" is that even when the quote of "sexual gratification" is made known to them, they don't immediately disagree and show horror.
No, they're too busy saying nothing can stick to them.
Cowards in every way, covering their backs rather than being humble and apologetic.