Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The Welsh Gender Service (WGS): a "potential Service of Concern"

92 replies

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 21/08/2026 16:12

Meanwhile, a bit of news from Wales: Another piece of reporting from Nick Wallis' GenderBlog from 19 August 2026:

Welsh gender clinic “potential Service of Concern” – GenderBlog

The Welsh Gender Service (WGS) has been described as a “potential Service of Concern” in an internal NHS document published online. A Service of Concern is a formal NHS designation, meaning there has been “significant singular service failures, or cumulative or systemic concerns regarding a service or setting”.
^^
The WGS, based in Cardiff, is the only clinic in Wales allowed to refer NHS patients for genital surgeries and mastectomies. In May, GenderBlog revealed that the WGS was referring adult patients for genital surgeries and mastectomies at three to four times the rate per head of population than other UK clinics. If the Service of Concern process establishes there is “a clear and significant risk to patient safety”, the WGS will go into special measures.

.…………

In the meantime, WGS will continue to receive referrals. (I surmise, just in case they are not put into special measures.)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
19
AimsAndObjectives · 18/09/2026 10:29

Heggettypeg · 18/09/2026 01:58

Reading the article, it looks as though there may be two different issues.

One has nothing to do with the desirability or otherwise of the surgical procedure, but is about whether the patient is surgery-ready in terms of their overall health. Things like obesity, smoking etc. It sounds as though the Welsh service has been referring people whom the English service don't feel are fit to proceed on grounds of that sort.

The other issue is whether there has been adequate exploration of why the patient wants the surgery, and of possible less drastic alternatives. It is not clear to me from the article whether the English service has been querying referrals on that basis too, or not.

Yes, I agree. There are two separate issues, and it is unclear if the 'inadequate exploration' issue has been flagged as a concern.

I think that the term 'unmanaged health conditions' is possibly of interest. It could simply be controlling the patient's health condition (eg diabetes) before referral for surgery. However, it could also include addressing co-morbidities, such as ADHD, PTSD, depression, anxiety, which have the potential to relieve the 'gender dysphoria' to an extent that surgery would be unnecessary.

Heggettypeg · 18/09/2026 01:58

AimsAndObjectives · 17/09/2026 21:39

But did NHS England still go ahead with the surgeries even though there were 'concerns'?

Nick's previous article says that:

"a significantly lower proportion of Welsh patients were progressing to surgery compared with patients referred from English gender services.
This is an obvious red flag. "

So it looks like those surgeries didn't go ahead. Nice to see that even gender surgeons draw the line somewhere.🙄

https://genderblog.net/wgs-surgery-referral-free-for-all/

Reading the article, it looks as though there may be two different issues.

One has nothing to do with the desirability or otherwise of the surgical procedure, but is about whether the patient is surgery-ready in terms of their overall health. Things like obesity, smoking etc. It sounds as though the Welsh service has been referring people whom the English service don't feel are fit to proceed on grounds of that sort.

The other issue is whether there has been adequate exploration of why the patient wants the surgery, and of possible less drastic alternatives. It is not clear to me from the article whether the English service has been querying referrals on that basis too, or not.

AimsAndObjectives · 17/09/2026 21:39

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 17/09/2026 21:27

Thanks for the update. I feel quite sick to my stomach when I read about this, it's so very, very wrong, and I'm afraid this investigation will just end up concluding some mealy mouth 'lessons have been learnt' and now back to the butchery.

"The Chief Commissioner also states that NHS Wales had received concerns about WGS from clinicians in NHS England who raised queries about the “appropriateness of referrals and clinical suitability. Such concerns have been echoed in complaints and correspondence received from members of the public.”

But did NHS England still go ahead with the surgeries even though there were 'concerns'?

Edited

But did NHS England still go ahead with the surgeries even though there were 'concerns'?

Nick's previous article says that:

"a significantly lower proportion of Welsh patients were progressing to surgery compared with patients referred from English gender services.
This is an obvious red flag. "

So it looks like those surgeries didn't go ahead. Nice to see that even gender surgeons draw the line somewhere.🙄

https://genderblog.net/wgs-surgery-referral-free-for-all/

WGS surgery referral free-for-all

WGS patient Sion Jewell on BBC Wales on Tuesday On Tuesday this week, 29 year old Sion Jewell told the BBC about the cancellation of her double mastectomy. “It was just the most heartbreaking…

https://genderblog.net/wgs-surgery-referral-free-for-all/

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 17/09/2026 21:27

Thanks for the update. I feel quite sick to my stomach when I read about this, it's so very, very wrong, and I'm afraid this investigation will just end up concluding some mealy mouth 'lessons have been learnt' and now back to the butchery.

"The Chief Commissioner also states that NHS Wales had received concerns about WGS from clinicians in NHS England who raised queries about the “appropriateness of referrals and clinical suitability. Such concerns have been echoed in complaints and correspondence received from members of the public.”

But did NHS England still go ahead with the surgeries even though there were 'concerns'?

fromorbit · 17/09/2026 20:54

Latest from Nick Wallis important

NHS Wales to review “paused” surgeries by Christmas
The independent clinical review panel has been appointed, and, subject to “final governance approval”, will begin its work on Tuesday. The Chief Commissioner is “confident” all sixty people who have had their surgeries postponed can be reviewed before the end of December.

In newly-published information for 2025/26, it appears WGS was referring people at a rate “varying between approximately three and five times higher per head of population”, when compared to English gender clinics. See table below:
https://genderblog.net/nhs-wales-to-review-paused-surgeries-by-christmas/

NHS Wales to review “paused” surgeries by Christmas

St David’s Hosptial in Cardiff, home of the Welsh Gender Service Around sixty people whose gender surgeries were cancelled by NHS Wales are expected to have an investigation into the necessit…

https://genderblog.net/nhs-wales-to-review-paused-surgeries-by-christmas/

EnfysPreseli · 08/09/2026 19:47

It's a pointless petition, directed at the wrong organisation. Like a lot of the lobbying on this issue in Wales it's all about grandstanding and virtue-signaling. It's like they've all gone a bit bonkers.

Anyone who genuinely cares about a group of people as vulnerable as they claim to be would want them to get the most appropriate, safest, evidence-based care and psychological support. No other group of patients would be allowed to get anywhere near deciding on what the treatment pathway and service model should be in a publicly-funded health service. And if there was any hint of there being clinical concerns, the same politicians would be horrified if surgery and other irreversible treatments continued unabated without rigorous investigation and review.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 07/09/2026 09:04

Thanks for the update, I think it would be counterproductive to start a petition in support of the stopage, the silent majority might be in support of an investigation but the problem is they're silent, including not going to sign a petition.
The other side are activists, so they're more than willing to sign a petition, it presents a lop sided view and they'll happily use the low number of signatures on a petition that supports the pause as a justification of their views.

fromorbit · 07/09/2026 08:03

Getting more reporting.

https://pembrokeshire-herald.com/147987/nhs-details-clinical-concerns-behind-welsh-gender-surgery-pause/

The TAs have got a petition together.

Petition calling for gender-affirming surgery pause to be lifted passes 10,000 signatures

First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth has said the review should be completed quickly.

Twenty-six of Plaid Cymru’s 28 backbench Senedd members have also written to NWJCC chairman Ian Green expressing “profound disappointment” at the decision, saying it had caused “distress, fear and a deep sense of uncertainty” among the trans community.

Reform UK and the Welsh Conservatives have backed the pause.

Reform’s Welsh leader Dan Thomas said “sensible-minded people in Wales” would welcome the suspension, while Welsh Conservative health spokeswoman Natasha Asghar said it was “imperative” to establish why a higher proportion of patients in Wales had been referred for surgery, and whether assessment processes and safeguards were sufficiently robust.

https://nation.cymru/news/petition-calling-for-gender-affirming-surgery-pause-to-be-lifted-passes-10000-signatures/

Pretty clear that Plaid wants to continue without real checks.

I don't know if it would be useful to start a counter petition or how we would word it.

Meanwhile this petition has way less

Fund more care & support for women’s gynaecological & reproductive health
1,801 signatures

Petition calling for gender-affirming surgery pause to be lifted passes 10,000 signatures

Nation.Cymru staff A petition calling for the immediate resumption of gender-affirming surgery for NHS patients in Wales has attracted more than 10,000 signatures in less than 48 hours. The Senedd petition, launched by Christopher May, calls on the Wel...

https://nation.cymru/news/petition-calling-for-gender-affirming-surgery-pause-to-be-lifted-passes-10000-signatures/

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 06/09/2026 17:27

fromorbit · 06/09/2026 07:43

The fix maybe in. Please do your best to draw attention to this scandal.

Ben Sears
Another update from the WGS 👇 It seems they will be marking their own homework: 'Experienced gender specialists' following WPATH standards of care ARE the problem. The NWJCC need to independently review whether strong clinical evidence is underpinning the service. If they do, they will see it is not.
https://x.com/BJ_Sears/status/2096110961526558972

Nick Wallis

"Cardiff and Vale University Health Board remains committed to providing high-quality, evidence-based and person-centred gender affirming care."

If you affirm every patient, you end up with precisely the problems the Welsh Gender Service is facing.
Welsh Gender Service update – 3 September 2026
https://cavuhb.nhs.wales/news/latest-news/welsh-gender-service-update-3-september-2026/

It beggars belief they would make this statement when there is a concern they may have affirmed too many people.

Thank you for posting this- boy, they really have learned nothing after Tavistock and Cass, have they?!

OP posts:
borntobequiet · 06/09/2026 09:09

Wallis latest blog post is a must read

It really is. The people responsible for this truly awful “care” need serious investigation.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 06/09/2026 08:30

"...person-centred gender affirming care."

That's the core of the problem isn't it, they're just giving whatever the 'person' demands, that's not what clinicians are supposed to do, there's nothing evidenced based about it this clinic.

fromorbit · 06/09/2026 07:43

The fix maybe in. Please do your best to draw attention to this scandal.

Ben Sears
Another update from the WGS 👇 It seems they will be marking their own homework: 'Experienced gender specialists' following WPATH standards of care ARE the problem. The NWJCC need to independently review whether strong clinical evidence is underpinning the service. If they do, they will see it is not.
https://x.com/BJ_Sears/status/2096110961526558972

Nick Wallis

"Cardiff and Vale University Health Board remains committed to providing high-quality, evidence-based and person-centred gender affirming care."

If you affirm every patient, you end up with precisely the problems the Welsh Gender Service is facing.
Welsh Gender Service update – 3 September 2026
https://cavuhb.nhs.wales/news/latest-news/welsh-gender-service-update-3-september-2026/

It beggars belief they would make this statement when there is a concern they may have affirmed too many people.

Ben Sears (@BJ_Sears) on X

Another update from the WGS 👇 It seems they will be marking their own homework: 'Experienced gender specialists' following WPATH standards of care ARE the problem. The NWJCC need to independently review whether strong clinical evidence is underpinn...

https://x.com/BJ_Sears/status/2096110961526558972

Chersfrozenface · 05/09/2026 09:25

Stap me, this is a reasonable headline from the Beeb.

Photo for "balance", I suppose.

"Transgender surgery halted over concerns patients were not properly assessed"

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ce8x2jglljpo

A crowd of people walking down a busy shopping street. The young person at the front of the group has tied-back brown hair and glasses and is wearing a red face mask. Their sign, which they are holding above their head, says: "Surgery saves lives".

Wales: Transgender surgery halted over concerns patients were not properly assessed

The decision to pause surgeries at the Welsh Gender Service has been met with mixed reaction.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ce8x2jglljpo

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 03/09/2026 19:17

fromorbit · 03/09/2026 18:56

David Deans

Health minister Mabon ap Gwynfor spoke for the first time on the surgery crisis impacting the Welsh Gender Service on Radio Wales Breakfast this morning. He said the trans community would see it as a "hammerblow". The minister said he was told there was a "spike" in the data.
He says he will meet the committee involved tomorrow. "I've asked to see that data myself", ap Gwynfor said.

I've been in meetings with Health Professionals, who have stats that show one thing and then someone from the WAG shows up and the stats get turned around and show something different.
I hope the Tory's are keeping a close eye 👀 on these muppets to make sure the stats don't magically change after this meeting. 😤

fromorbit · 03/09/2026 18:56

David Deans

Health minister Mabon ap Gwynfor spoke for the first time on the surgery crisis impacting the Welsh Gender Service on Radio Wales Breakfast this morning. He said the trans community would see it as a "hammerblow". The minister said he was told there was a "spike" in the data.
He says he will meet the committee involved tomorrow. "I've asked to see that data myself", ap Gwynfor said.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 03/09/2026 06:03

PC are committed ideologs, the FM is no doubt under pressure from his own nutters to make grandstanding statements. Let's hope the health trust ignores him and all the gender harpies in his party and do a proper investigation.

fromorbit · 02/09/2026 21:47

Another important article from David Deans on BBC

Review into Welsh transgender surgery must be quick, first minister says
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2ry8yjrm1o
Footage
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/6ufdhuotjzA

Tories AND Reform scenting blood
https://www.conservatives.wales/news/questions-over-welsh-gender-service-must-be-answered

Cristiana Emsley MS

46m
On 30 June, the First Minister called on politicians to “cool down the temperature” around the debate on sex and gender.

Perhaps he should now take his own advice.

Today, he says the independent review into the Welsh Gender Service “must be quick” and that he will be “pressing for answers”.

The review must be thorough, genuinely independent and led by the evidence, not political pressure!

NHS Wales did not intervene on a whim. The Welsh Gender Service has been escalated to Level 3, following concerns including significantly higher surgical referral rates and aspects of its assessment and referral processes.

These are serious questions of clinical safety, governance and safeguarding.

So PrifWeinidog: cool down the temperature, step back and let the independent experts do their job.

Patients deserve compassion but they also deserve safe medicine, rigorous assessment and robust clinical governance.

Clinical safety before politics. Safeguarding before ideology.

Follow the evidence wherever it leads, however uncomfortable the answer.

Meanwhile earlier BBC coveragehad activist lyong on it.

Ben Sears
14h
Deeply irresponsible of BBCWalesNews not to provide a counter to the claim that gender affirming care is suicide prevention and that it is helping people.

The best available evidence shows increased suicide rates post-surgery and there is no good evidence it improves long-term MH.

A person holds a sign up that reads "SURGERY SAVES LIVES".

First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth wants swift Welsh Gender Service review

Rhun ap Iorwerth said the Welsh government sympathised with those impacted by the gender service pause.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2ry8yjrm1o

NotAtMyAge · 02/09/2026 20:04

MyPearlViper · 02/09/2026 18:31

The egregious Erin Reed :

The sheer speed and totality of the care stoppage appears to be unprecedented in the context of this kind of complaint. It stands in especially stark contrast to the agency’s handling of Dr. Ian Paterson, an English surgeon who performed over a thousand botched or unnecessary procedures, largely mastectomies, on patients. It took over a decade for the NHS to shut him down.

I mean, I'm both laughing and crying at the comparison with 'botched or unnecessary procedures'.

The author also doesn't seem to know that no "gender-affirming" operations are performed in Wales at all, as NHS Wales has no gender surgeons. All surgery is performed in England after referral from the Welsh clinic. Cross-border referral for medical treatment is quite routine in the more rural parts of Wales bordering England.

UtopiaPlanitia · 02/09/2026 19:48

MyPearlViper · 02/09/2026 18:31

The egregious Erin Reed :

The sheer speed and totality of the care stoppage appears to be unprecedented in the context of this kind of complaint. It stands in especially stark contrast to the agency’s handling of Dr. Ian Paterson, an English surgeon who performed over a thousand botched or unnecessary procedures, largely mastectomies, on patients. It took over a decade for the NHS to shut him down.

I mean, I'm both laughing and crying at the comparison with 'botched or unnecessary procedures'.

That blogger is just the platonic ideal of the Dunning-Kruger Effect.

MyPearlViper · 02/09/2026 18:31

The egregious Erin Reed :

The sheer speed and totality of the care stoppage appears to be unprecedented in the context of this kind of complaint. It stands in especially stark contrast to the agency’s handling of Dr. Ian Paterson, an English surgeon who performed over a thousand botched or unnecessary procedures, largely mastectomies, on patients. It took over a decade for the NHS to shut him down.

I mean, I'm both laughing and crying at the comparison with 'botched or unnecessary procedures'.

Wales Gender Clinic In The UK Pauses Surgeries Over Accusations That They Help Too Many Trans Patients

UK doctors are notorious for delaying trans people’s care. One clinic didn’t—now, they’re being targeted.

https://www.erininthemorning.com/p/wales-gender-clinic-in-the-uk-pauses

ThisFunSheep · 02/09/2026 18:17

That's a better article. Unfortunately the impression very much got out that it is just about the higher referral rates which it isn't.

I have sympathy with the NHS here as there may well be information they simply can't release because it's personal, and also aren't used to this level of publicity over pausing a particular treatment at a particular service.

Quinney woman is clearly has anger management issues, I can imagine her being dismissive and unpleasant to family members, although of course we don't know it was her.

I.e. she complained to the police about someone filming her at a public protest, i.e. where it's common to film for various reasons. And then knocked someone's phone out of their hands who was filming her rather than walking away.

Further ended up being grabbed by the police, for reasons we don't know if it's about this or something else.

That's not someone you want dealing with complaints or managing an NHS service. I would go so far as call it "unhinged".

Igmum · 02/09/2026 17:48

lcakethereforeIam · 02/09/2026 01:09

This article I found on the BBC gives a little more information

Welsh Gender Service: Transgender patients told surgery cancelled in hospital - BBC News https://share.google/4N20p8twVvrKWteyq

Thanks Cake. I think it’s a positive sign that the BBC actually reports that one of their informants had her surgery cancelled twice for mental health reasons and also quotes the mother Nick Wallis interviewed whose autistic son with learning difficulties was up for various operations. It’s about time people realised just how vulnerable many of those who transition are. This is held out as a magic cure-all.

AlexaAdventuress · 02/09/2026 13:39

Marius Gustavson, better known as 'Mr Eunuch Maker' was sent to prison for 22 years a couple of years ago. Maybe he should just have moved to Wales and called himself a 'gender clinic'.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 02/09/2026 10:48

Thanks for the links above.
Deansof Cardiff's is pretty damning

Most clinicians employed in adult gender clinics are committed to a gender affirmative model, in which the patient always knows best, and the job of the clinician is simply to facilitate access to the desired hormones or surgery.

When you have a 'trans' ID male in charge how could it be anything but.

"the job of the clinician is simply to facilitate access to the desired hormones or surgery."

That is not what the job of clinicians is

Well done to the parents whose dogged persistence has helped bring the horrendous inadequacy of this service to light.

I hope too god heads roll for this.