Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Tempest v Rural Payments Agency Tribunal Thread 8

645 replies

myladydisdainisyetliving · 10/07/2026 10:44

Previous thread: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5551959-tempest-v-rural-payments-agency-tribunal-thread-7

TT substack: https://tribunaltweets.substack.com/p/tempest-vs-defra-and-rural-payments

Tempest (a TW) is claiming discrimination, harassment and/or victimisation on grounds of gender reassignment. Central to the claim is the existence of the Sex Equality and Equity Network in the Civil Service (SEEN). SEEN has been granted right to intervene. Parts of the original claim against the co-chair of SEEN (Elspeth Duemmer-Wrigley) and another party (Andreas Mueller) were struck out or narrowed. Another claimant, PQ, is no longer part of the case.

Please note that Elspeth still has a garden in need of seeds and water to support the ability of SEEN to be an intervenor in this case. The claim originated because she said "only women menstruate" and a search with her name and those terms at the usual gardening website should point you to her plot.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
GailBlancheViola · 10/07/2026 12:35

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 12:32

HH:.... Put to you this disadvantage trans colleagues, as network for spreading anti trans views

To repeat my earlier post:

Fuck off. Fuck off. Fuck off.

I would have been swearing like a trooper by now if I was faced with HH's utter nonsense, credit to CA for staying so calm and measured when even the Judge is getting tetchy.

Tallisker · 10/07/2026 12:35

MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 12:32

No, she absolutely meant to accuse them of staying public deliberately, most likely a transcription error by TT. It's a perfectly proper thing to put to the witness, and for the panel to conclude either way.

We are in total agreement. She just didn’t say the words ‘they did it deliberately’. She used double and triple negatives.

Justabaker · 10/07/2026 12:35

PrettyDamnCosmic · 10/07/2026 12:26

Maybe TT misreported because in that case it should be "don't accept it was inadvertent"

Yes, that's what she said but then seemed to draw back from the abyss.

SlackJawedDisbeliefXY · 10/07/2026 12:34

MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 12:32

No, she absolutely meant to accuse them of staying public deliberately, most likely a transcription error by TT. It's a perfectly proper thing to put to the witness, and for the panel to conclude either way.

Even though CA would not be involved in any decision to remain public made by SEEN?

SternJoyousBeev2 · 10/07/2026 12:34

I’m considering allowing Arthur to play charades.

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 12:33

HH - it created distress and unsafe as no other group of people having reality questioned
CA nobody having reality questioned. We understood concern which we sought to address. Not unsafe, all measures to ensure safe for GC and trans
HH third PCP that is agreed - that was applied in written word from May 2023 CA can't remember prob May
HH in practice from Nov 23, when a number of posts removed for that reason
J this is policy, this is an allegation, when do you say policy applied?

<bold mine!>

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 12:32

HH:.... Put to you this disadvantage trans colleagues, as network for spreading anti trans views

To repeat my earlier post:

Fuck off. Fuck off. Fuck off.

GailBlancheViola · 10/07/2026 12:32

I take my hat off to CA for standing so firm and resolute in the face of this barrage of crap from HH.

MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 12:32

Tallisker · 10/07/2026 12:29

I think this is correct. She just stopped short of accusing SEEN of deliberately staying public.

No, she absolutely meant to accuse them of staying public deliberately, most likely a transcription error by TT. It's a perfectly proper thing to put to the witness, and for the panel to conclude either way.

MyrtleLion · 10/07/2026 12:32

@MarieDeGournay

as requested on previous thread. Was busy before. Only on page 2 here.

Tempest v Rural Payments Agency Tribunal Thread 8
MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 12:30

ItsCoolForCats · 10/07/2026 12:27

With zero evidence, of course.

You can put any kind of allegation you like to a witness in cross examination, you don't need evidence. Their response becomes the evidence: "She said she didn't do it, but she's an habitual liar, from which the court should conclude that she did do it."

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 12:30

HH just want to move on to 2nd pcp that all colleagues..protected characteristics do you accept this applied. Put to you this disadvantage trans colleagues, as network for spreading anti trans views
AL not accepted
There is some discussion between J, AL and HH whether something is a proposition or a question about whether PCP applied.
J - why asking witness about it?
HH stepping stone
HH that PCP put trans colleagues at disadvant as allowed creation
CA allowed creation of network of colleagues who held protected char, and don't accept spreading anti trans views.

Szygy · 10/07/2026 12:29

HH - allow me one minute I don't want to repeat myself

Oh Brother Facepalm GIF by Rafa Rosa
Tallisker · 10/07/2026 12:29

PrettyDamnCosmic · 10/07/2026 12:26

Maybe TT misreported because in that case it should be "don't accept it was inadvertent"

I think this is correct. She just stopped short of accusing SEEN of deliberately staying public.

Rightsraptor · 10/07/2026 12:29

CriticalCondition · 10/07/2026 12:13

No. Her clerk will have agreed a fixed brief fee for the first day of the hearing which will cover her time in preparation for it plus a fixed daily refresher fee for every day thereafter. So after the brief fee it's effectively a daily rate, whether she's 'on her feet' or not.

Somehow the words 'brief' and 'Helen H' don't quite sit well together.

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 12:29

At this point if I had a whiteboard in front of me I'm fairly confident I could give a 5 minute presentation to the court on how moderation on Yammer worked and explain the changes made when it changed to new system

MarieDeGournay · 10/07/2026 12:28

CA don't accept unsafe environment for anyone who has chosen not to be in that group
👏

CriticalCondition · 10/07/2026 12:27

PrettyDamnCosmic · 10/07/2026 12:21

HH - don't accept it wasn't inadvertent

What argument is HH trying to make? If it wasn't inadvertent then it was intentional but if she doesn't accept it was intentional then she is accepting that it was inadvertent.

She's not making an argument. She's leaving a smell in the air.

DrBlackbird · 10/07/2026 12:27

PrettyDamnCosmic · 10/07/2026 12:21

HH - don't accept it wasn't inadvertent

What argument is HH trying to make? If it wasn't inadvertent then it was intentional but if she doesn't accept it was intentional then she is accepting that it was inadvertent.

Sly insinuation that Seen was public as deliberate antagonism. Trying to create doubt in J’s mind about their motivations. But my god, you’d have to be incredibly self centred to the point of paranoia to assume everything is about you to this nth degree.

murasaki · 10/07/2026 12:27

MarieDeGournay · 10/07/2026 12:19

Blazing sunshine at Lord's, I'm afraid.
India 82-2. Mandhana 6 away from a half-century.
No early lunch there, either😐

Not today, no. I'm watching it! Historic day for the teams.

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 12:27

CA - they are mod within closed groups, don't accept unsafe environment for anyone who has chosen not to be in that group
HH but closed happen much later
CA - missed sorry think she said yes, later
J - wasn't until Oct. Was it part of policy they would go back to public?
CA had the facility to do that, not aware they were doing that, once we had senior mgt approval to mandate private groups, tech team took action on it.

HH just checking a reference

ItsCoolForCats · 10/07/2026 12:27

MarieDeGournay · 10/07/2026 12:15

J are you contending that they delib switched to public?
HH - don't accept it wasn't inadvertent

That's a pretty serious accusation, isn't it?

With zero evidence, of course.

Justnot · 10/07/2026 12:27

I’d have lost my mind by now, sat there for days, HH is taking the fucking piss

MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 12:26

Tallisker · 10/07/2026 12:24

It came across that she was saying SEEN did it deliberately without making an actual direct accusation.

It means she can refer to it in submissions. "CA said that it was inadvertent, but I invite the court to conclude she was lying, and it was deliberate".

If you don't cross examine on a point then you have implicitly accepted their version, and you can't do the "but that wasn't true, the truth was actually..." in your submissions.

PrettyDamnCosmic · 10/07/2026 12:26

Tallisker · 10/07/2026 12:24

It came across that she was saying SEEN did it deliberately without making an actual direct accusation.

Maybe TT misreported because in that case it should be "don't accept it was inadvertent"