Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Tempest v Rural Payments Agency Tribunal Thread 8

645 replies

myladydisdainisyetliving · 10/07/2026 10:44

Previous thread: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5551959-tempest-v-rural-payments-agency-tribunal-thread-7

TT substack: https://tribunaltweets.substack.com/p/tempest-vs-defra-and-rural-payments

Tempest (a TW) is claiming discrimination, harassment and/or victimisation on grounds of gender reassignment. Central to the claim is the existence of the Sex Equality and Equity Network in the Civil Service (SEEN). SEEN has been granted right to intervene. Parts of the original claim against the co-chair of SEEN (Elspeth Duemmer-Wrigley) and another party (Andreas Mueller) were struck out or narrowed. Another claimant, PQ, is no longer part of the case.

Please note that Elspeth still has a garden in need of seeds and water to support the ability of SEEN to be an intervenor in this case. The claim originated because she said "only women menstruate" and a search with her name and those terms at the usual gardening website should point you to her plot.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
SternJoyousBeev2 · 18/07/2026 13:31

I keep coming back to Tink’s numerous statements about visibility of SEEN and how it was a sign of people not having his best interests at heart….why the fuck should anyone have his best interests at heart especially when those interests are opposed to others on the same workplace. GI really attracts the most selfish people. If ‘best interests’ comes from the PSED then perhaps it does need to be scrapped.

MyrtleLion · 18/07/2026 09:59

I find it hard to believe that ST has legal aid. He’s returned to work as an HEO (I believe) and starting salary is about £32k.

Also legal aid would have oushed for a settlement, amd as someone else said above, not available for a tribunal.

lcakethereforeIam · 18/07/2026 09:46

I posted on one of the Amnesty threads that, if not for ST's brief boring on, this case would have wrapped up and the panel beginning their deliberations just in time for the anti-rights report release. As all the SEEN networks were listed as anti-rights on the report i wondered if this was done deliberately to influence the findings before dismissing the idea as a bit conspiracy theory-esque.

However, I've still been thinking and I've decided it doesn't matter if it was part of some plan or not. The report, even inadvertently, could have had the effect of influencing the panel. The ET is, in part, about the existence of SEEN and here's a renown Human Rights organisation unequivocally denouncing them. IANAL i don't know if AI have broken any law if they have, even accidentally, attempted to interfer in the Tribunal. I'm minded to think they probably haven't. It would be difficult to publish anything if you were meant to avoid any possible overlap with ongoing cases. It's just this is a hell of an overlap and it makes the taste left by the report even nastier.

Mmmnotsure · 18/07/2026 09:21

PrettyDamnCosmic · 18/07/2026 08:37

The transcript refers at one point to For Women Scotland as "poor women's Scotland" & at another to "four women Scotland".😀

That's quite nice, actually, given that they were originally four women Scotland. At one stage they thought it was only the four of them who thought like this about the Scottish Goverment's legislation.

PrettyDamnCosmic · 18/07/2026 08:37

Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/07/2026 00:24

I saw that the other day, got bored after a couple of minutes. The funniest bit is that the subtitles mishear and say that RMW is a hardworking barista 🤣 🤣

The transcript refers at one point to For Women Scotland as "poor women's Scotland" & at another to "four women Scotland".😀

Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/07/2026 00:24

Hyenana · 17/07/2026 16:58

SO WHO FUNDS TINKERBELL'S CASE?

Today I stumbled upon this video, in which the lovely RMW (ex-barrister in this case) and the equally lovely Rachel Saunders (middle-aged philosopher bloke who plays on a women's hockey team in his free time) are having a lovely chat about how to overturn the FWS SCJ via lawfare.

And according to RWM, it is really important to find the right test case, and that is one who has access to legal aid, so that the whole business has to get funded by the taxpayer (because apparently only those stupid wimmin do crowdfunders to ask for money from people who want to support their case, the right side of history takes it from the taxpayers, including those whose rights they are trying to take away).

So is it possible that Tinks qualified for legal aid because of being unable to work for 6+ months, despite being on full pay for most of the time? (RMW did not mention him, but apparently plans something with those TIMs who have to go to men's prison now).

Does anybody know exactly how this works?

(I think that part was at about 15 min)

m.youtube.com/watch?v=1kdov-0KFW4

I saw that the other day, got bored after a couple of minutes. The funniest bit is that the subtitles mishear and say that RMW is a hardworking barista 🤣 🤣

SqueakyDinosaur · 17/07/2026 18:49

I think it's more likely that there's a JKR for the other side. Just one who's a little more shy about expressing support.

Hedgehogforshort · 17/07/2026 17:30

I do not think you can get full legal aid for an employment tribunal, only for advice not representation at the proceedings.

And it is means tested. So tinker bell would probably not qualify for any funding.

Hyenana · 17/07/2026 17:11

Hyenana · 17/07/2026 16:58

SO WHO FUNDS TINKERBELL'S CASE?

Today I stumbled upon this video, in which the lovely RMW (ex-barrister in this case) and the equally lovely Rachel Saunders (middle-aged philosopher bloke who plays on a women's hockey team in his free time) are having a lovely chat about how to overturn the FWS SCJ via lawfare.

And according to RWM, it is really important to find the right test case, and that is one who has access to legal aid, so that the whole business has to get funded by the taxpayer (because apparently only those stupid wimmin do crowdfunders to ask for money from people who want to support their case, the right side of history takes it from the taxpayers, including those whose rights they are trying to take away).

So is it possible that Tinks qualified for legal aid because of being unable to work for 6+ months, despite being on full pay for most of the time? (RMW did not mention him, but apparently plans something with those TIMs who have to go to men's prison now).

Does anybody know exactly how this works?

(I think that part was at about 15 min)

m.youtube.com/watch?v=1kdov-0KFW4

Also in this lovely video (at about 5 min):

Overthrowing FWS by putting babies to trans moobs!

Yes seriously. Apparently the EHRC wrote a guidance that says that the PC of maternity extends to women who breastfeed children they haven't given birth to.
And since TIMs also 'breastfeed', they have to get recognised as women, otherwise the category of woman is incoherent and unworkable. Or something.

So it's not just a fetish, it is trying to create a case for TWAW in law! 🤮🤬

Is it just a coincidence that Tinks was hanging around in women's breastfeeding support groups? Is that just his personal voyeurism, or are other things at play here?

And does anyone know more about this maternity guidance, which is apparently different from the definition in the EA and that RMW thinks he can use? Could that even work?!

And all of that just in the first 20 min of that video - I haven't got the stomach to watch/listen to the rest right now...

Hyenana · 17/07/2026 16:58

SO WHO FUNDS TINKERBELL'S CASE?

Today I stumbled upon this video, in which the lovely RMW (ex-barrister in this case) and the equally lovely Rachel Saunders (middle-aged philosopher bloke who plays on a women's hockey team in his free time) are having a lovely chat about how to overturn the FWS SCJ via lawfare.

And according to RWM, it is really important to find the right test case, and that is one who has access to legal aid, so that the whole business has to get funded by the taxpayer (because apparently only those stupid wimmin do crowdfunders to ask for money from people who want to support their case, the right side of history takes it from the taxpayers, including those whose rights they are trying to take away).

So is it possible that Tinks qualified for legal aid because of being unable to work for 6+ months, despite being on full pay for most of the time? (RMW did not mention him, but apparently plans something with those TIMs who have to go to men's prison now).

Does anybody know exactly how this works?

(I think that part was at about 15 min)

m.youtube.com/watch?v=1kdov-0KFW4

Tallisker · 17/07/2026 13:32

PrettyDamnCosmic · 17/07/2026 13:22

Don't forget that she is now retired & free to speak her mind.

True. But she absolutely wasn’t on the side of the law when SEEN first launched. She did learn, though, probably helped along by the behaviour of the TRA side as evidenced in this tribunal, plus having the actual law constantly pointed out to her. Eyes have been opened in all sorts of ways by this tribunal.

PrettyDamnCosmic · 17/07/2026 13:22

Tallisker · 17/07/2026 10:53

She was great in cross examination but she wasn’t like that when the issues were live in 2022/23. As anyolddinosaur points out, it took her quite a while to follow the actual law.

Don't forget that she is now retired & free to speak her mind.

Tallisker · 17/07/2026 10:53

She was great in cross examination but she wasn’t like that when the issues were live in 2022/23. As anyolddinosaur points out, it took her quite a while to follow the actual law.

SqueakyDinosaur · 17/07/2026 10:07

I think that, as for many of us, it took CA a while to realise the profound and toxic selfishness with which ST and his ilk view and interact with the world. I suspect she went into this assuming both sides would act like rational adults.

anyolddinosaur · 17/07/2026 08:20

Better make it a small cake then. As mentioned upthread she placed restrictions on SEEN. She followed the law eventually but she wasnt unbiased. The garden still needs more plants folks, chair of SEEN sued for saying only women menstruate finds it.

SqueakyDinosaur · 16/07/2026 16:47

We should arrange a posse to give CA a birthday cake once she's finished giving evidence on the first day of the December session!

Hyenana · 15/07/2026 18:17

MyAmpleSheep · 15/07/2026 15:12

I posted a thread that included a link to a crowd fund campaign - it was the one seeking a JR into the published EHRC code of practice, by TransLucent - and it was initially delayed, then approved, by MNHQ.

So if links to crowd funders are forbidden and that one was approved, then I really don't understand the logic of it. 🤔
I assumed it depended on how likely it was to get noticed, depending on the method of posting.
Eta just saw @Ereshkigalangcleg 's post which probably explains the logic part of it.

MyAmpleSheep · 15/07/2026 15:40

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/07/2026 15:35

I imagine because you weren’t personally promoting it. The prohibition is nothing to do with GC issues, it’s because they were abused to manipulate people for money in the past.

I'm sure you are correct. There is half a raised eyebrow that a TRA campaign can be posted here but not a GC one.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/07/2026 15:35

MyAmpleSheep · 15/07/2026 15:12

I posted a thread that included a link to a crowd fund campaign - it was the one seeking a JR into the published EHRC code of practice, by TransLucent - and it was initially delayed, then approved, by MNHQ.

I imagine because you weren’t personally promoting it. The prohibition is nothing to do with GC issues, it’s because they were abused to manipulate people for money in the past.

MyAmpleSheep · 15/07/2026 15:12

Hyenana · 15/07/2026 12:03

The 'logic' might just be that it's easier to automatically check posted links against a list of forbidden sites, than to analyse the content of screenshots.
So if someone were to complain about that screenshot, you could still get in trouble - probably not terribly likely on this thread that hasn't seen a lot of drive-by scolders, but you never know.

Edited

I posted a thread that included a link to a crowd fund campaign - it was the one seeking a JR into the published EHRC code of practice, by TransLucent - and it was initially delayed, then approved, by MNHQ.

Thehorticulturalhussie · 15/07/2026 12:59

I thought The Driveby Scolders were fantastic, what's not to love about a reggae flamenco fusion band? Their critically acclaimed 2nd album Activists And Allies Eat My Shorts was a work of genius and at 9 hours and 27 minutes only slightly too long.

Hyenana · 15/07/2026 12:03

Boiledbeetle · 15/07/2026 07:26

For some reason they don't seem bothered by the screenshots. I try not to overthink mnhq logic on these matters as that way madness lies.

The 'logic' might just be that it's easier to automatically check posted links against a list of forbidden sites, than to analyse the content of screenshots.
So if someone were to complain about that screenshot, you could still get in trouble - probably not terribly likely on this thread that hasn't seen a lot of drive-by scolders, but you never know.

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · 15/07/2026 08:51

WFTCHTJ · 15/07/2026 03:17

Is that the one that goes "Bumba Liar! Bumba Liar"? It was very popular in the Sandie Peggie threads IIRC.

I like a name you can dance to.

Boiledbeetle · 15/07/2026 07:26

anyolddinosaur · 15/07/2026 07:04

@Boiledbeetle sorry, as links to crowdfunding sites are not permitted and deleted I assumed screenshots were banned too.

For some reason they don't seem bothered by the screenshots. I try not to overthink mnhq logic on these matters as that way madness lies.

Swipe left for the next trending thread