Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Tempest v Rural Payments Agency Tribunal Thread 8

645 replies

myladydisdainisyetliving · 10/07/2026 10:44

Previous thread: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5551959-tempest-v-rural-payments-agency-tribunal-thread-7

TT substack: https://tribunaltweets.substack.com/p/tempest-vs-defra-and-rural-payments

Tempest (a TW) is claiming discrimination, harassment and/or victimisation on grounds of gender reassignment. Central to the claim is the existence of the Sex Equality and Equity Network in the Civil Service (SEEN). SEEN has been granted right to intervene. Parts of the original claim against the co-chair of SEEN (Elspeth Duemmer-Wrigley) and another party (Andreas Mueller) were struck out or narrowed. Another claimant, PQ, is no longer part of the case.

Please note that Elspeth still has a garden in need of seeds and water to support the ability of SEEN to be an intervenor in this case. The claim originated because she said "only women menstruate" and a search with her name and those terms at the usual gardening website should point you to her plot.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 12:48

Missed a question
HH a policy [refers to military - gay bisexual]
CA - OK to be gay and bi if don't tell anyone, that's the comparison
HH given your experience in EDI including work on hate crime, given your background, comparing a restriction to systemic policy in US military is offensive in extreme
CA sorry you feel that way, not meant to be offensive at all.
[me - not clear who says this ->]Refers to 'you can be what you like as long as you never say it.
HH that comparison triv suffering gay and lesbian
CA no it does not

nicepotoftea · 10/07/2026 12:47

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 12:33

HH - it created distress and unsafe as no other group of people having reality questioned
CA nobody having reality questioned. We understood concern which we sought to address. Not unsafe, all measures to ensure safe for GC and trans
HH third PCP that is agreed - that was applied in written word from May 2023 CA can't remember prob May
HH in practice from Nov 23, when a number of posts removed for that reason
J this is policy, this is an allegation, when do you say policy applied?

<bold mine!>

I'd think this were a ridiculous thing to try to argue (doesn't a tribunal essentially have to decide between two parties' version of reality?) but then I remember Sandie Peggie and Judge Kemp

MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 12:47

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 12:44

HH - before introd the 3rd PCP - you didn't analyse the discrim imposing that PCP would have on trans people
CA it didn't have a discrim effect. Having a series of posts accusing SEEN of being transphobic was not acceptable. We did everything we could to foster good relations but when we have one side that says only way forward is to disband SEEN and silence GC voices difficult to move on from there

We did everything we could to foster good relations but when we have one side that says only way forward is to disband SEEN and silence GC voices difficult to move on from there

I think this is an example of the danger of cross examining an intelligent, eloquent and well-informed witness when you have a weak case. They come up with neat and tidy demolitions of everything you've been trying to persuade the panel about for the last few days.

I wouldn't be surprised if the Judge wrote that down verbatim and quotes it back in the judgment.

MarieDeGournay · 10/07/2026 12:46

CA We did everything we could to foster good relations but when we have one side that says only way forward is to disband SEEN and silence GC voices difficult to move on from there

So much for the 'toxicity on both sides' claim, eh?

CriticalCondition · 10/07/2026 12:45

The trouble is I think everyone will need a longer not a shorter lunch break to recover from this morning.

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 12:45

HH the agender survey showed that the SEEN beliefs created hostile environment
CA the agender survey was across agender network with leading questions.

I want her to say

CA: Enough of this absolute twaddle Helen

myladydisdainisyetliving · 10/07/2026 12:45

CA it didn't have a discrim effect. Having a series of posts accusing SEEN of being transphobic was not acceptable. We did everything we could to foster good relations but when we have one side that says only way forward is to disband SEEN and silence GC voices difficult to move on from there

Does HH not realise that the more she goes on, the more CA is highlighting who the real bullies are?

OP posts:
BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 12:44

HH - before introd the 3rd PCP - you didn't analyse the discrim imposing that PCP would have on trans people
CA it didn't have a discrim effect. Having a series of posts accusing SEEN of being transphobic was not acceptable. We did everything we could to foster good relations but when we have one side that says only way forward is to disband SEEN and silence GC voices difficult to move on from there

WomanInnaWoods · 10/07/2026 12:44

Justabaker · 10/07/2026 12:39

I'm working on drawing a timeline of events for Beetle's whiteboard

I was considering doing that, but was afraid I'd mostly channel Charlie Day!

Always Sunny Fx GIF
BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 12:43

IMHO, this really doesn't feel like HH presenting a case; it feels like her fishing to find one...

MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 12:42

Tallisker · 10/07/2026 12:39

What’s a PCP they’re talking about?

Provision, criterion or practice.

Things which can be the root of indirect discrimination.

LexLutherPops · 10/07/2026 12:42

Circles circles and more circles.

Wearisome to listen to as HH ploughs on still with the same questions she was toiling over with CA two days ago

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 12:42

HH the agender survey showed that the SEEN beliefs created hostile environment
CA the agender survey was across agender network with leading questions.
HH but at least they carried out. You did no analysis
AL we have had that q
HH - para 79 of your WS. All of actions taken were reactive not anticipatory?
CA - I think to an extent both - taking action to address how people thinking feeling
HH - you didn't sit down to assess matters listed para 79 at preventing trans discrim did you?
CA - our understanding was that we could not lawfully prevent as that would be discrim so we turned to seek reassure trans colleagues and to ensure SEEN weren't offensive to others.

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 12:41

Justabaker · 10/07/2026 12:39

I'm working on drawing a timeline of events for Beetle's whiteboard

I have to say I look magnificent there!

Justabaker · 10/07/2026 12:39

I'm working on drawing a timeline of events for Beetle's whiteboard

Tempest v Rural Payments Agency Tribunal Thread 8
MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 12:39

SlackJawedDisbeliefXY · 10/07/2026 12:34

Even though CA would not be involved in any decision to remain public made by SEEN?

Fair point. To be a bit more nuanced: she can ask CA if it was deliberate; CA can say I can't speak about the state of mind of SEEN (or the Judge can step in and say "this witness can't answer that.).

But CA can answer a question like "do you accept you had no reason to believe it wasn't deliberate?" or "Could it have been deliberate?" or "It was unreasonable of you to think it wasn't deliberate, wasn't it?"

HH can certainly suggest it was deliberate, she doesn't need to shy away from that idea.

Tallisker · 10/07/2026 12:39

What’s a PCP they’re talking about?

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 12:38

HH - you agreed about what data shows (surveys about bullying discrim in civil service, data showing no confidence in reporting) with that in mind.
CA - don't think it will discourage wrongdoing, what it discourages is accusing a network of people with a protected belief of it
HH - your evidence points that from Jan23 onwards and throughout 23 that complaints did drop off, it did put them at a disadvant
CA it's speculation why complaints reduced, my theory after closing Yammer, the temp dropped, and less heated exchanges like we had in Nov Dec

lcakethereforeIam · 10/07/2026 12:38

Anna Widdecombe has died. RIP.

CassOle · 10/07/2026 12:38

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 12:09

God there are some weird gifs in the gif drawer.

Edited

You may laugh, but I did read a post once where a bloke blamed poor old Bugs Bunny in this scene for making him trans.

ProfDrLapwing · 10/07/2026 12:37

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 12:29

At this point if I had a whiteboard in front of me I'm fairly confident I could give a 5 minute presentation to the court on how moderation on Yammer worked and explain the changes made when it changed to new system

If someone had included in the bundle, dare I say it, a spreadsheet of systems, networks and their owners, moderation methods and when systems were private or public we could have been done and dusted last week.

Shortshriftandlethal · 10/07/2026 12:36

HH - it created distress and unsafe as no other group of people having reality questioned

 They are having someone else's reality imposed
MarieDeGournay · 10/07/2026 12:36

MyrtleLion · 10/07/2026 12:32

@MarieDeGournay

as requested on previous thread. Was busy before. Only on page 2 here.

That's lovely thank you Myrtle!
I'd wear it!I t would confuse the f out of people, and I like that in a t-shirt😃

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 12:36

GailBlancheViola · 10/07/2026 12:35

I would have been swearing like a trooper by now if I was faced with HH's utter nonsense, credit to CA for staying so calm and measured when even the Judge is getting tetchy.

I would be an extremely hostile witness by now.

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 12:35

HH - let me just double check list of issues to make sure got this right
J end of 22? Jan 23?
CA initial version Nov Dec 22, can't remember in initial or May refresh
AL are you saying that wording in initial version
HH early iteration. In practice applied from Nov 22
J - that wording? [some reading by J of document]
AL it was May 23 Principles of Communications.
HH - that put the C and trans colleagues at a disadvantage as invasion of own freedom of speech about offense and discrim
CA to label an entire network as discrim was not appropriate and that's what we sought to stop

Swipe left for the next trending thread