Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Tempest v Rural Payments Agency Tribunal Thread 8

645 replies

myladydisdainisyetliving · 10/07/2026 10:44

Previous thread: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5551959-tempest-v-rural-payments-agency-tribunal-thread-7

TT substack: https://tribunaltweets.substack.com/p/tempest-vs-defra-and-rural-payments

Tempest (a TW) is claiming discrimination, harassment and/or victimisation on grounds of gender reassignment. Central to the claim is the existence of the Sex Equality and Equity Network in the Civil Service (SEEN). SEEN has been granted right to intervene. Parts of the original claim against the co-chair of SEEN (Elspeth Duemmer-Wrigley) and another party (Andreas Mueller) were struck out or narrowed. Another claimant, PQ, is no longer part of the case.

Please note that Elspeth still has a garden in need of seeds and water to support the ability of SEEN to be an intervenor in this case. The claim originated because she said "only women menstruate" and a search with her name and those terms at the usual gardening website should point you to her plot.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 10/07/2026 13:40

ProfLargofesse · 10/07/2026 13:37

I don't really understand it either? Can anyone explain? Was DEFRA suggesting you don't speak about your sexuality? Or did CA mention it in WS?

Also, did she not know that CA is a lesbian? As a parting shot that would be a huge risk if she did? Stupid if she didn't

I wonder if CA compared making SEEN unseen to don't ask don't tell?

HH walked right into that one.

Edited to add I see My Ample Sheep has elucidated.

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 13:40

From TT

Good afternoon. This is the afternoon of the final day (in this session) of Samantha Tempest v DEFRA & Rural Payments Agency.

The court is at present taking lunch, and the hearing will resume at 1.45pm. Caroline Airs (CA) will continue her evidence.

Naomi Cunningham (NC) barrister for SEEN (Sex Equality & Equity Network, intervening in the case) will begin cross-examination of CA.

We expect that before that there will be discussion of how the rest of the case will be heard, as this is at present the last available day and there is still one witness to be heard.

MyrtleLion · 10/07/2026 13:40

Tallisker · 10/07/2026 13:38

Poor Elspeth got very upset. Hope she’s ok. Hope the judge is as kind to her as he was to Tink.

I know she’s not going to be questioned this time round.

😢

MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 13:39

ProfLargofesse · 10/07/2026 13:37

I don't really understand it either? Can anyone explain? Was DEFRA suggesting you don't speak about your sexuality? Or did CA mention it in WS?

Also, did she not know that CA is a lesbian? As a parting shot that would be a huge risk if she did? Stupid if she didn't

CA suggested that "team GI" wanted and was asking DEFRA to adopt a "don't ask, don't tell" policy towards the characteristic of holding GC beliefs. You can be gender critical but it would be forbidden to say so in the workplace.

HH said this was trivializing the offence caused to LGB people by "don't ask don't tell", and CA said, as a lesbian myself I fully understand how offensive it is.

Tallisker · 10/07/2026 13:38

Poor Elspeth got very upset. Hope she’s ok. Hope the judge is as kind to her as he was to Tink.

I know she’s not going to be questioned this time round.

Madcats · 10/07/2026 13:38

Warm up just finishing at Wimbledon

MyrtleLion · 10/07/2026 13:37

I will have the tennis on as I refer to my iPad.

Purely to keep me awake.

I don’t know what HH was doing. I was drinking last night because DH was watching the France game, and I was tired after spending five hours with my learning disabled DSD, so I think last night as I ploughed through, I was blaming being tired on why it was so tiring to read.

But now I see it’s just that it’s repetitive and boring in the first instance.

Nobody cares HH. They probably moderated SEEN unnecessarily to please ST and his gang. Because everyone, including you, bends over backwards for the trans brigade.

Frankly if ST worked for me in the charity sector, I’d have said if you can’t stand disagreement about your views, such that you are caused extreme distress and “harm”, maybe this isn’t the job for you. Think on that for a week before I instigate a capability process.

ProfLargofesse · 10/07/2026 13:37

DrBlackbird · 10/07/2026 13:02

Not sure I understood what CA was being accused of, but "offensive in the extreme" comes across as an attempt to smear CA in the mind of the judge as the last parting shot. Especially as her arguments remained clear and reasonable throughout the tedious questioning. If you can’t attack the arguments, then attack the person.

I don't really understand it either? Can anyone explain? Was DEFRA suggesting you don't speak about your sexuality? Or did CA mention it in WS?

Also, did she not know that CA is a lesbian? As a parting shot that would be a huge risk if she did? Stupid if she didn't

PrettyDamnCosmic · 10/07/2026 13:36

Shedmistress · 10/07/2026 13:28

I'm impressed. Those are decent sized venues. They must have quite a following still.

ickky · 10/07/2026 13:34

I am also very sleepy and probably won't be able to lower the tone this afternoon.

Madcats · 10/07/2026 13:34

I would so love it if, over lunch, Naomi sent her instructing solicitor back to the office to pick up a projector/cables and a screen.

It sounds to me as if they could simply freeze a couple of rows of titles and columns and pop on a couple of data filters and the whole thing would be easy to interrogate.

If HH and ST are super-paranoid they could be asked to "protect" key cell ranges.

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 10/07/2026 13:34

Justnot · 10/07/2026 13:31

CA is taking one for the team

The same one, over and over and over again....

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 13:33

Was someone else lining up to do the c&p this afternoon? Sorry, I can't remember!

I can do up until 3ish if needed, but not after that.

Justnot · 10/07/2026 13:31

CA is taking one for the team

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 13:31

Shedmistress · 10/07/2026 13:30

I need a lie down.

I'm nodding off. I don't think I'll manage to stay awake all afternoon.

CriticalCondition · 10/07/2026 13:30

Londonmummy66 · 10/07/2026 13:17

I agree. I believe that he is also on the same circuit as the EJ in the Darlington nurses case and will have seen the media circus around that case and judgement and will want to try to avoid having similar here (whilst also not jeopardising his retirement day rate project....)

Way back at the start, such a loong time ago, I think I found that he'd been the judge on one of the early applications in the Darlington nurses case before it got to trial. So he'll know he and his judgment will be under scrutiny.
Which makes his ETBB ruling all the more extraordinary. I wonder if he's since realised what a massive cockup that was.

Shedmistress · 10/07/2026 13:30

I need a lie down.

MyrtleLion · 10/07/2026 13:30

PrettyDamnCosmic · 10/07/2026 13:26

Are they still playing? I saw them supporting Diesel Park West (who are still playing) in 1989.

They toured in 2024 and Justin had to sing lower and play different chords because of his Parkinson’s. I then saw that they were touring in 2025 as well.

ETA, saw @Shedmistress post. Yay! And nearer where I live.

ProfLargofesse · 10/07/2026 13:29

MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 12:32

No, she absolutely meant to accuse them of staying public deliberately, most likely a transcription error by TT. It's a perfectly proper thing to put to the witness, and for the panel to conclude either way.

And we would expect them to consider the credibility of the witness in their inferences. And it would be hard for anyone not to understand CA as an extremely credible witness.

Shedmistress · 10/07/2026 13:28

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 13:27

I bet she can pivot table the shit out of this. Mmm hmmm.

100%

Shedmistress · 10/07/2026 13:28

PrettyDamnCosmic · 10/07/2026 13:26

Are they still playing? I saw them supporting Diesel Park West (who are still playing) in 1989.

Yes!

DATES | Del Amitri

Del Amitri | Official Website | 'Fatal Mistakes' OUT NOW

Del Amitri. NEW ALBUM. Fatal Mistakes. OUT NOW ... 2021 TICKETS ON GENERAL SALE NOW ... Tickets for Del Amitri's full UK headline tour ...

https://www.delamitri.info/dates/

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 13:27

Shedmistress · 10/07/2026 13:14

I imagine NC is a secret spreadsheet queen.

I bet she can pivot table the shit out of this. Mmm hmmm.

anyolddinosaur · 10/07/2026 13:27

Catching up @Madcats the lack of reference to trans in Invisible Women was the complaint I think. Everything must centre them.

PrettyDamnCosmic · 10/07/2026 13:26

MyrtleLion · 10/07/2026 12:52

Nearly everything in this song (which I adore, and ai was lucky enough to see them live in 2024) has become obsolete. Yet millionaires still buy art for the price of a hospital wing…

Are they still playing? I saw them supporting Diesel Park West (who are still playing) in 1989.

Shedmistress · 10/07/2026 13:25

It really is quite an interesting and appropriate analogy, thanks CA. If you ever read this...