Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Tempest v Rural Payments Agency Tribunal Thread 8

645 replies

myladydisdainisyetliving · 10/07/2026 10:44

Previous thread: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5551959-tempest-v-rural-payments-agency-tribunal-thread-7

TT substack: https://tribunaltweets.substack.com/p/tempest-vs-defra-and-rural-payments

Tempest (a TW) is claiming discrimination, harassment and/or victimisation on grounds of gender reassignment. Central to the claim is the existence of the Sex Equality and Equity Network in the Civil Service (SEEN). SEEN has been granted right to intervene. Parts of the original claim against the co-chair of SEEN (Elspeth Duemmer-Wrigley) and another party (Andreas Mueller) were struck out or narrowed. Another claimant, PQ, is no longer part of the case.

Please note that Elspeth still has a garden in need of seeds and water to support the ability of SEEN to be an intervenor in this case. The claim originated because she said "only women menstruate" and a search with her name and those terms at the usual gardening website should point you to her plot.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
Tallisker · 10/07/2026 13:56

LexLutherPops · 10/07/2026 13:43

And they to be heard today?
All done and dusted today or time set aside next week? C has just been in the box answering HH questions for 2 days.

If so it's very sloppy on HH's part.
But I assume they're the R witnesses, so maybe killing time

No, it was clear yesterday that they would only her the rest of CA’s evidence this week. If HH bucked her ideas up and gave NC time to question CA.

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 13:56

J: We think then that it's best to pause CA evidence at this point; we factored in that as you are retired, the restriction on not discussing the case will be much less onerous?
CA: Yes agree

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 13:56

CA: I understand, it's just my gut instinct is to do as much as possible.

Translation: I just want this finished and out of my bloody life so I can enjoy my retirement in peace and not have to think about it.

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 13:55

J: I think you would find it hard to pick up. Even if we decided to sit a little later. HH: The C also wd have liked to get as much as poss done - has to leave 4.30 at latest and while happy for me to carry on w/out C present ...
AL: We have all looked at mutual availability for counsel and we think it would be 7 months or so before we can resume.
J: Which is unfortunate but we are where we are.

MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 13:54

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 13:54

Is it fair to leave a witness under oath for months?

She could be released from her oath, and sworn again when the tribunal restarts.

SigrunGard · 10/07/2026 13:54

Madcats · 10/07/2026 13:34

I would so love it if, over lunch, Naomi sent her instructing solicitor back to the office to pick up a projector/cables and a screen.

It sounds to me as if they could simply freeze a couple of rows of titles and columns and pop on a couple of data filters and the whole thing would be easy to interrogate.

If HH and ST are super-paranoid they could be asked to "protect" key cell ranges.

Unfortunately the office I think is the other end of the M62!

Boiledbeetle · 10/07/2026 13:54

Is it fair to leave a witness under oath for months?

myladydisdainisyetliving · 10/07/2026 13:53

The judge wants to watch the tennis doesn’t he?

OP posts:
BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 13:53

J: I hear that. Experience of hearing cases suggests - if there can be a natural break, as here, it is usually better to take that break. Ms Airs?
CA: I understand, it's just my gut instinct is to do as much as possible.

MoistVonL · 10/07/2026 13:52

MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 12:57

As someone (please feel free to remind me who deserves the credit) said in a prior thread "I asked the members of the Agrees-with-me club and 168 of them said they agree with me."

I am keeping that line.

That would be me. You're most welcome to it.

Bill Murray Drink GIF
BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 13:52

AL: In tribunal's hands obviously but I did ask Ms Airs for her input - she would prefer to press on to get as much as possible done.

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 13:51

From TT

J: Before break we were discussing - has anyone more to say?
NC: Yes - on reflection I do not think I will finish today,
J: Then we must decide what to do.

spannasaurus · 10/07/2026 13:50

LexLutherPops · 10/07/2026 13:43

And they to be heard today?
All done and dusted today or time set aside next week? C has just been in the box answering HH questions for 2 days.

If so it's very sloppy on HH's part.
But I assume they're the R witnesses, so maybe killing time

The tribunal will finish part heard today and will resume possibly in September

BettyBooper · 10/07/2026 13:50

fanOfBen · 10/07/2026 13:48

I'm back now and can c&p this afternoon if that's useful? @BettyBooper was doing it last I think but I haven't caught up with the thread and don't know if you want relieved... [Ah, I see you said you could do until 3 if needed but would you rather I just take over now? I'm free the rest of the afternoon.]

Edited

Thanks! I'll continue until you're caught up if you like?

Let me know when is good for you to take over?

myladydisdainisyetliving · 10/07/2026 13:49

PrettyDamnCosmic · 10/07/2026 13:36

I'm impressed. Those are decent sized venues. They must have quite a following still.

Yep. They’re doing a very popular USA tour atm. They were in Boston when Scotland were playing by some fluke of booking schedule and apparently played the best gig of their lives.

OP posts:
fanOfBen · 10/07/2026 13:48

I'm back now and can c&p this afternoon if that's useful? @BettyBooper was doing it last I think but I haven't caught up with the thread and don't know if you want relieved... [Ah, I see you said you could do until 3 if needed but would you rather I just take over now? I'm free the rest of the afternoon.]

LexLutherPops · 10/07/2026 13:48

Did anyone think to survey their local foxes den about their opinions on henhouses?

Madcats · 10/07/2026 13:47

There are two more DEFRA witnesses (not sure who, but please let's hope that they had have nothing to do with the bloody s/sheet) and Elspeth.

My understanding is that they will all get examined in September (with a week allocated for the rest of the trial).

Londonmummy66 · 10/07/2026 13:46

Incoming survey - results 81% of mumsnetters strongly agreed and the remainder agreed.

LexLutherPops · 10/07/2026 13:43

Tallisker · 10/07/2026 13:41

I think there are two or three witnesses still. At least one from Defra plus EDW.

And they to be heard today?
All done and dusted today or time set aside next week? C has just been in the box answering HH questions for 2 days.

If so it's very sloppy on HH's part.
But I assume they're the R witnesses, so maybe killing time

ProfLargofesse · 10/07/2026 13:43

CriticalCondition · 10/07/2026 13:14

Lunchbreak observations on this morning.

The judge was definitely losing patience with HH's continued ramblings, repetition and inefficiency. Impatient tone as he had to repeatedly cut in to get to the point.

His tone was much more conciliatory to NC today. I think she impressed him this morning by immediately offering him her nailed on verbatim note of a section of CA's evidence that he hadn't been quick enough to write down. The contrast with HH's performance today was stark.

Of course, it may all change this afternoon but NC is starting off on a much better footing with him than she's had so far.

Possibly a reflection overnight about her 'marker' about policing of her language. As I said earlier I think he has been so laser focused on what he has to adjudicate he's seen her as noises off because he is not adjudicating what she brings. However, the marker yesterday will have caused him to have a bit of a rethink (perhaps someone at home mentioned he was coming across as an arse!)

I also agree that her ability to find his place and give a verbatim note will have impressed given that he seems to have written her off based on back-room gossip.

Remember that so much of the judiciary is capture, even worse than civil service, that his backrooms will be full of admin staff etc slagging off Naomi for being a witch.

poppsocks · 10/07/2026 13:43

Shedmistress · 10/07/2026 11:57

Invisible Women, Miss Dunn explains for exclusion of TW, NB women women of colour

Jesus h christ alive on a fucking bike

Did HH actually say "non-binary women"? Would love to know.
It is genocidal to say that NB people are women or men.

KnottyAuty · 10/07/2026 13:42

MyAmpleSheep · 10/07/2026 12:47

We did everything we could to foster good relations but when we have one side that says only way forward is to disband SEEN and silence GC voices difficult to move on from there

I think this is an example of the danger of cross examining an intelligent, eloquent and well-informed witness when you have a weak case. They come up with neat and tidy demolitions of everything you've been trying to persuade the panel about for the last few days.

I wouldn't be surprised if the Judge wrote that down verbatim and quotes it back in the judgment.

And just like that it was HH’s case that ceased to exist

Fire Boom GIF by Crowd Multiplier
Tallisker · 10/07/2026 13:41

I think there are two or three witnesses still. At least one from Defra plus EDW.

CriticalCondition · 10/07/2026 13:40

<perks up at mention of Del Amitri>

I saw them headline a local festival a few years ago. They were great. Glad to hear they're still going.