Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
153
EleanorMc67 · 01/11/2026 19:13

Ruthietuthie · 01/11/2026 18:46

It would be most unusual if the Bobbi Brown make-up tutorial wasn't a "redeem your 75GBP against the make-up you buy." That's what usually happens. Plus, they will only use BB products, so it might not be quite what you are looking for. I would be very clear with the consultant exactly what you want to purchase - a lipliner and lipstick? Something to make your eye-make up stand out a little more?
If you enjoy your current make-up look, do you perhaps need a setting spray to make it last all day? I like the Charlotte Tilbury one, which you can get in the mini size to fit in your purse.
To me, the most critical thing is base - as I've got older, and as my skin is quite dry and sensitive, that's the thing that has become harder to get right. With @EleanorMc67, I really like the Armani luminous silk foundation.

Yes, I think they will be offset. And agree that having an idea of what gaps to fill would be the best way to spend wisely.

I like Urban Decay setting spray, though I've not tried Charlotte Tilbury.

(Funnily enough, I have combination/oily skin, which hasn't really dried out that much with age - & am devoted to Armani Luminous Silk as it works so well on my skin too! I've been using it for decades now ...)

ihaveafavouritecat · 01/11/2026 19:22

PassengerDerby · 01/11/2026 16:17

I'm still checking in although haven't offered any advice since the very beginning. So glad you got there with the shoes and bag in the end @ihaveafavouritecat and found gorgeous stuff that you love and feels like you. I love your choices. You're going to look beautiful!

Agree with a PP that this has been one of the very loveliest S&B threads, I think a lot of it is due to how you engaged with the replies and you also landed on a good, smallish group of opinion givers who stuck with you to the end! A genuine group effort; it's cheering to see 😊

Thanks @PassengerDerby, glad you’ve enjoyed the thread too. Yes, a real group effort, and so good natured. It’s been quite special really ☺️

OP posts:
minnowonthesay · 01/11/2026 20:13

I think Elf products are great, I only wanted you to have the Guerlain lipstick as it’s so special and almost a keepsake.
I do think that you need a really good base and setting spray.
If you have a good foundation on you’ll need a blush or light bronzer, you might look too flat otherwise.
Definitely a lip liner, preferably waterproof that you can use all over your lips, then put lipstick on top - l’Oreal or Max Factor are great price points and really good products.
Waterproof eyeliner that you can smudge in - again Avon Glimmerstic, Maybelline Tattoo liner are both cheaper brands that work well.
So in short
Good base £30 -£40
Powder compact to fluff on - Charlotte Tilbury is very good - £26
Setting Spray - £10 -£20
Elf waterproof eyebrow pencil - £4
Avon glimmerstick - Amazon about £5
Blush or Bronze - L’Oreal Infallible £10
Lip liner waterproof - Huda £17 ASOS or Boots
Lipstick - L’Oreal or Max Factor £10

Thats about £130, with the base and powder taking up half of the budget!

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/11/2026 20:15

You definitely don’t need to spend a fortune on makeup. In fact, you could probably just go to the Number 7 counter in Boots at a quiet time and ask for advice.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/11/2026 20:17

Or go to the Estée Lauder counter and ask for some foundation samples. They’re usually quite generous with them!

minnowonthesay · 01/11/2026 20:20

For those of you that like a setting spray, I’ve just bought the small size Vieve one from Space NK to try - Trinny said she’ll never make one for her range as the Vieve one is unbeatable.
I’m very impressed, it smells beautiful - I usually use Charlotte Tilbury, Urban Decay or L’Oreal the red can one.

Nylonflares · 01/11/2026 20:33

@minnowonthesay stop! Im
an addict, I now need this 😂

minnowonthesay · 01/11/2026 20:36

Sorry @Nylonflares you need to self exclude!

EleanorMc67 · 01/11/2026 20:37

minnowonthesay · 01/11/2026 20:36

Sorry @Nylonflares you need to self exclude!

I think I might have to as well! I've just run out of my Urban Decay one ...

ihaveafavouritecat · 01/11/2026 20:40

EleanorMc67 · 01/11/2026 18:45

I've never spent £60+ on a lipstick either, OP - despite my naturally profligate nature! But I have bought a few expensive lipsticks that I loved via eBay/Vinted.

What are the actual items in your make-up bag? As it would be useful to know what you currently wear. And are you happy with them?

Current make up bag contents:
Maybelline sky high mascara: okay, one of the better ones I’ve used lately, but don’t feel it’s v impactful, under eye concealer: okay, and brow pencil: okay, I’ve used others, think I had an Urban Decay one I liked better, but was discontinued I think.
Laura Geller colour correcting foundation, bronzer and an eyeshadow set that I only use for the mirror ! Bought 2-3 years ago, easy to apply, quite like it.
Elf blush tint, fine, v easy to apply, only bought this year
Dcypher foundation (all over social media and I got influenced) new this year.
Origins tinted moisturiser, used for years, when I don’t want to wear foundation
Clarins lip perfector gloss ‘pomegranate glow’, used for years
That’s it 🤷🏼‍♀️

I’m not really wedded to any of these items, although I’ve used some of them for quite a few years. I suppose I’ve never had the interest/confidence/motivation to explore alternatives. I don’t know why really. .. I do now though because I need to look my best for my boy’s wedding!

OP posts:
ihaveafavouritecat · 01/11/2026 20:43

Ooh thanks everyone I can see you’re on a roll again!

OP posts:
RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/11/2026 20:45

I rate:

Estee Lauder Futurist foundation
Nars liquid blush in Orgasm
Mac eyeliner and a matching eyeshadow- I use Teddy
Benefit Rollerlash mascara
Chanel for a lipstick that will make you feel like a movie star every time you get it out of your bag

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/11/2026 20:46

Urban Decay eyeliners and eyeshadow also brilliant

ihaveafavouritecat · 01/11/2026 20:56

minnowonthesay · 01/11/2026 20:13

I think Elf products are great, I only wanted you to have the Guerlain lipstick as it’s so special and almost a keepsake.
I do think that you need a really good base and setting spray.
If you have a good foundation on you’ll need a blush or light bronzer, you might look too flat otherwise.
Definitely a lip liner, preferably waterproof that you can use all over your lips, then put lipstick on top - l’Oreal or Max Factor are great price points and really good products.
Waterproof eyeliner that you can smudge in - again Avon Glimmerstic, Maybelline Tattoo liner are both cheaper brands that work well.
So in short
Good base £30 -£40
Powder compact to fluff on - Charlotte Tilbury is very good - £26
Setting Spray - £10 -£20
Elf waterproof eyebrow pencil - £4
Avon glimmerstick - Amazon about £5
Blush or Bronze - L’Oreal Infallible £10
Lip liner waterproof - Huda £17 ASOS or Boots
Lipstick - L’Oreal or Max Factor £10

Thats about £130, with the base and powder taking up half of the budget!

This is so helpful @minnowonthesay thank you. I’ve taken a screenshot of your ‘shopping list’ and I will investigate. I still need some advice on application though… is there anyone on Instagram or YouTube that you’d recommend I take a look at, who demonstrates easy to follow make up routines?

OP posts:
minnowonthesay · 01/11/2026 20:59

Yes, good point @RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie Estée Lauder will fill little bottles for you in a couple of colours to try at home - that’ll save you £40 if you think you won’t wear it again.
My everyday make up is:-
Eborian CC cream
Foundation - Double Wear or the fir best, Victoria Beckham 😬
Concealer - Victoria Beckham
Powder - Charlotte Tilbury
Brows -Elf
Eyes - Brown Maybelline tatto liner & Beauty Pie waterproof mascara. I curl my dead straight lashes, this mascara holds the curl.
Cheeks - Clinique blush
Bronze - Guerlain
Lip liner - Huda waterproof
Lipstick - whatever takes my fancy and goes with what I’m wearing, cheap up to high end Victoria Beckham
Setting spray - Vieve

minnowonthesay · 01/11/2026 21:03

I think this is a really good starting point for make up, it’s a brilliant video, has had 17 million views - she makes up both sides of her face, one is the right way, one is the wrong way, you can really see the difference and just take on board the bits you would do

Sensitive content
Mother of the Groom: get me to the finish line!
EleanorMc67 · 01/11/2026 21:07

ihaveafavouritecat · 01/11/2026 20:56

This is so helpful @minnowonthesay thank you. I’ve taken a screenshot of your ‘shopping list’ and I will investigate. I still need some advice on application though… is there anyone on Instagram or YouTube that you’d recommend I take a look at, who demonstrates easy to follow make up routines?

Won't the Bobbi Brown consultant show you application techniques etc? I thought that was the session you'd chosen?

ihaveafavouritecat · 01/11/2026 22:07

Yes that’s what I’m hoping for @EleanorMc67 - worth a try I think, I’m sure I’ll pick up some tips at least. I was just acknowledging that even with Minnow’s shopping list, I’ll still need guidance on how to apply. Hopefully some social media content and the BB session will do the trick.

OP posts:
EleanorMc67 · 01/11/2026 22:14

I have a feeling, OP, that you might get overwhelmed with make-up advice from us all (like the clothing thread!), & it will all be different!

This is a list of my own daily make-up items - but I'm not sure how useful they would be, as I'm not you?! I have swapped a few things of late, & at other times in my life, to save on costs - but I have researched them beforehand so will add those too. If it helps, I am quite pale, with dark blue-gray eyes & strawberry blonde hair, & combination skin with occasional redness (FWIW my colouring is soft autumn leaning towards bright spring, or something like that?! Warm & soft, anyway!)

  • Primer - I think this might be worth it if your make-up has a tendency to slip? And/or a setting spray - but I do have combination/oily skin. I use a Clinique one that is also green-tinted because I have a tendency to flush - but the best budget one is meant to be e.l.f Power Grip. The NYX version is also meant to be pretty good.
  • Foundation - Armani Luminous Silk. (I like medium coverage as I have some unevenness/high colouring, with concealer then added.) Colour-matched perfectly in Brown Thomas decades ago, bought full-price for years when I was a high-flying(ish!) consultant - now bought for around £20-25 on eBay/Vinted whenever I spot my shade, & stockpiled! I have used the Boots No 7 equivalent in the past, & it's perfectly decent too.
  • Concealer - for undereyes I recently swapped from Lancôme to Nyx Bare With Me & it's great!!! For blemishes (menopausal spots - the bastards!), I use No 7 Stay Perfect, & have done for years.
  • Mascara - Max Factor Aqualash. Worn it for decades, it won't budge until you remove it with baby oil. Highly recommended!
  • Contour/bronzer/blusher - I'm pale, so just use a light touch with e.l.f Soft Glam stick as a contour, then Nars Orgasm as a blusher. Also used the latter for years. It lasts me a year despite daily use, so I've never looked for a cheaper alternative.
  • Eyebrows - mine have faded & become a bit thinner & patchy in the last few years. I use Benefit Gimme Brow, which is tinted & has microfibres in it, to strengthen the colour & thicken them. It is expensive, comes in a tiny shitty cheap-looking little plastic tube - & it's brilliant ....!! I can almost go without eyebrow pencil, it's that good. I am, however, about to try e.l.f Wow Brow (I didn't like the NYX alternative). I then fill in & define with NYX Micro Brow pencil, which is really easy to use, & long-lasting.
  • Eyeshadow - I have lots, but my go-to used to be Mac Satin Taupe. It's a really good neutral that suits most colourings, & has a soft sheen to it (not glittery though). I've been using an eyeshadow stick of late though. I did try the Bobbi Brown one - but the e.l.f No Budge one is even better IMO! The Magnetic Pull shade is like a softer stick version of the Mac eyeshadow. Cheap, so easy to apply - & lasts all day! I don't use eyeliner at all, as I think it can look too harsh on me - but I usually intensify my eyeshadow next to my lashes with an extra stroke.
  • Lipstick & liner - my favourite Bobbi Brown Ballet Pink lipliner is now discontinued! The lipliners are great though, so if you find one that suits you I'd buy that after your session, OP. They're the perfect texture & consistency. Lipsticks - many ... almost all expensive (but bought from resale platforms). Again, if you like what they use on you at Bobbi Brown, I think that's a good thing to offset against the fee. I also quite often forgo lipliner & use a coloured balm-type lipstick that is easy to just smudge on.
  • Setting spray - Urban Decay, for now ...!
EleanorMc67 · 01/11/2026 22:25

ihaveafavouritecat · 01/11/2026 20:40

Current make up bag contents:
Maybelline sky high mascara: okay, one of the better ones I’ve used lately, but don’t feel it’s v impactful, under eye concealer: okay, and brow pencil: okay, I’ve used others, think I had an Urban Decay one I liked better, but was discontinued I think.
Laura Geller colour correcting foundation, bronzer and an eyeshadow set that I only use for the mirror ! Bought 2-3 years ago, easy to apply, quite like it.
Elf blush tint, fine, v easy to apply, only bought this year
Dcypher foundation (all over social media and I got influenced) new this year.
Origins tinted moisturiser, used for years, when I don’t want to wear foundation
Clarins lip perfector gloss ‘pomegranate glow’, used for years
That’s it 🤷🏼‍♀️

I’m not really wedded to any of these items, although I’ve used some of them for quite a few years. I suppose I’ve never had the interest/confidence/motivation to explore alternatives. I don’t know why really. .. I do now though because I need to look my best for my boy’s wedding!

From this, it sounds to me as if you're already okay for:

  • Foundation;
  • Undereye concealer;
  • Bronzer & blusher.

So I'd suggest you focus on:

  • Waterproof mascara (I've suggested Max Factor);
  • Eyeshadow or eyeshadow stick (go for BB if you like what they apply, otherwise I'd suggest the e.l.f stick for ease);
  • Lipstick & lipliner (again, a good thing to spend on at BB).

Eyeliner if you want to, ditto with primer & fixing spray - & you're done!

Obviously, those are just my preferences. Others have suggested alternatives that might work for you better. So once you've had your BB session, I would spend an afternoon with a friend going around Boots trying out all the suggestions & having some fun!!

EleanorMc67 · 01/11/2026 22:33

I should also say that I don't think that this should be a time for too much experimentation? As you should feel comfortable & relaxed, just like with your clothes & footwear! (Although certainly do try out & wear everything beforehand - not just to practice application, but also to make sure that nothing irritates your skin or eyes over the day.)

If you're not used to eyeliner, you might find yourself a bit self-conscious wearing it, in case it rubs/smudges. Ditto if you're not used to wearing lipliner & lipstick together. Some people find those to be essential - but you might not? Personally I think that neither is absolutely necessary for a natural look (although lipliner helps with longevity).

minnowonthesay · 01/11/2026 22:42

I love the Mac satin taupe shadow @EleanorMc67although the plastic see through bit of the lid keeps pushing through, so I’m going to try the Elf shadow stick, thank you for that.

ihaveafavouritecat · 01/11/2026 23:14

You guys are excelling yourselves again 😁 Thanks so much for generously sharing all your preferred make up, it’s so nice to have your recommendations.

Okay well don’t overwhelm me, let me do a bit of research, and maybe buy some of the cheaper recommendations you’ve shared like Elf and so on, and then perhaps by the end of the week, when I’ve had my BB session, I’ll know better what I still need advice and help with.

By the way, I picked up the M+S faux fur jacket today, whilst simultaneously returning two pairs of shoes. It’s a lovely warm chocolate-y brown colour… but much more lightweight than the R/Island jacket… no real warmth in it if outdoors for any length of time, I wouldn’t have thought. They’re very different. I’ll reflect a bit more, and perhaps try all my outfits together soon… I haven’t actually done this yet.

OP posts:
RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/11/2026 23:16

Looking forward to pics of it all tried on.

EleanorMc67 · 01/11/2026 23:38

minnowonthesay · 01/11/2026 22:42

I love the Mac satin taupe shadow @EleanorMc67although the plastic see through bit of the lid keeps pushing through, so I’m going to try the Elf shadow stick, thank you for that.

I think they might have changed (ie economised!) on the packaging lately, as it hasn't always done that! I actually use the e.l.f stick more on a day-to-day basis now, as it's soooo easy! Two swipes per eye, then I smooth it with my fingers & I'm done! See what you think ...