I have really felt for the OP on a few occasions across these two threads - but most of all now, I think!!
It feels like the school debating championship - with the measured eloquence of Calliopespa & Floisme on one side, & the passionate certainty of RuthieTuthie & NylonFlares on the other ...!!
And I am ... somewhere in the middle with a fence-post poking uncomfortably into me?!!! I think that morally I am on the side of the former, but aesthetically I am on the side of the latter ..? Not sure if that makes sense or if morally is quite the right word (& I'm also thinking as I type this, FFS it's just a pair of SHOES!!!).
They're not my thing. They're not fashionable (which doesn't bother me as such), but then I'm not sure that they're exactly unfashionable either? They sit almost outside of fashion ...??? I can't really say that I either like or dislike them, as they're so far off my radar. Like ski-suits or golf jumpers ... 😁!
But it's more in terms of the shape & style than the colour or fabric. I do agree with RuthieTuthie that I wouldn't pair plain teal shoes with a teal dress - as it would always be just slightly "off". Metallic teal shoes though? Maybe. Patterned teal shoes (brocade or lace or embroidered, say), also maybe - as they're not trying to match, just to accompany & sit in the same colour family. And if there's another colour in the pattern, then all to the good, as it can be picked out in bag/jewellery/jacket etc. Though personally, I'd probably go for an entirely different colour altogether!