Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grossed out by DH comments on Brand

165 replies

KidMeNottt · 12/11/2026 21:14

He said Brand obviously a creep and he agreed that having non consenting anal sex "probably is technically rape" but the fact the girl was cheating on her boyfriend and admitted to rimming Brand when they first met...it was more like the anal sex was "things getting out of hand". He said more like a "play fight gone wrong". She was "clearly into extreme stuff". He then backtracked saying "no, it is awful... but context changes things and she was no angel". He did say "no doubt the bloke should be in jail but 10 years given the context???"

Thoughts? I think its pretty disgraceful but interested to hear what people think.

OP posts:
Luckyingame · 13/11/2026 17:14

Yuck.
However, I saw posts on YT basically saying
"It's horrible what has happened to him, political for sure, Elon Musk (?) is going to be next....."
Both myself and my husband (76) felt sick at the statement being read at the Court.

kkloo · 13/11/2026 17:21

Superduper02 · 12/11/2026 22:24

I think the pile onto your DH is a bit much. A lot of men struggle to understand the situations which count as rape and sexual assault because this is a man's world. They just need education, again and again until they truly get it.

E.g. thinking rape must be a woman being dragged off the street protesting rather than consensual foreplay which became unconsensual sex. Alot of men would strongly condemn the first but be more understanding of 'confusion' and 'mixed signals' in the second example.

If that is the case why do you think women are wrong for 'piling on'?

It's a 'bit much' for people to pile on and it's less bad for men to be understanding of 'confusion' and 'mixed signals' when rapes occur is it?

Are we meant to feel sorry for these silly little ignorant men while they show understanding to the rapists?

ollilili · 13/11/2026 17:24

Would he have the same views if it was his daughter?

Cherrytree86 · 13/11/2026 17:34

I’d divorce him.

Muffsies · 13/11/2026 18:23

kkloo · 13/11/2026 15:08

The rimming was on a separate occasion.

Either way on the day of the rape, at his house, the victim had only agreed to vaginal sex, there was no consent given whatsoever for anal sex, so it wasn't withdrawn, it wasn't given in the first place.

Basing prison sentences on trauma could result in wildly different sentences for identical offences. That isn't justice.

I'm not basing it on trauma, that is considered a factor for sentencing, but I'm basing it on the offence.

You believe that rape isn't as bad of an offence if consent was previously given or if the person had consented to other kinds of sex beforehand whereas I completely disagree and think it can be just as bad, and am glad that the sentencing in this case reflects that.

There was a 24 hours in Police Custody episode called The Predator about a gay guy who used grindr for hookups, and would then assault the guys he met by making them do something they didn't consent to, such as unprocted sex or anal sex that they decided to withdraw consent to during the hookup.

They managed to charge the guy with two cpunts of rape. Guess how long he got? 10 years. Having sex with someone who withdraws consent, even if they initially agreed to it IS rape, and you'll go to prison for a long time if it's a proven pattern of behaviour.

Judging by thus case, i think Brand's sentence is exactly right and consistent.

PinkyFlamingo · 13/11/2026 18:24

KidMeNottt · 12/11/2026 21:43

He does know its rape. He seems to think there is "less bad" rape if you've acted in certain ways beforehand. It was like he was saying it was accidental.

And? What are you going to do about it?

KidMeNottt · 13/11/2026 22:25

PinkyFlamingo · 13/11/2026 18:24

And? What are you going to do about it?

Well, quite possibly split up by the looks of things.

Its been rough for some time. We havent slept in the same bed for a year or so. He has become increasingly angry, mean, shitty comments about my work and friends but we have had counselling and we have good days too and we have young kids

But tonight he went to the gym for 4 hours. I made one comment when he came home. It erupted. And I've just told him I want to split up. He told me to "fucking own it or take it back right fucking now". And i chose to not take it back. And im now lying in my kids room in the dark, heart pounding.

OP posts:
KidMeNottt · 13/11/2026 22:54

If anyone was has any reassuring words that would be wonderful

He's been making sexist remarks for some time. Some of you have blamed me somehow sayinh no sympathy and he must have always held these views but he has definitely got more extreme in the last few yrs!

OP posts:
DeeDeeSharpWhatKindOfLadyNSoul · 13/11/2026 22:59

I'd be wondering what he's viewing online etc
Andrew Tate style crap perhaps.

ForgiveMeFatherForIHaveGinned · 13/11/2026 23:00

Sorry to hear about the difficulties with your DH. Absolutely no judgement from me towards you, you can't be held responsible for his thoughts and actions. However I would strongly advise you to reflect on this and the other behaviours you have mentioned in your posts, as you have indicated. My DH and I have also been discussing the Brand case tonight and he is 100% of the same view as me and many others (women in particular, but also must acknowledge many good men sharing these views) as to what consent means and that in these cases there clearly wasn't consent hence why he has been found guilty. As OPs have said, the judge in this case gave a very clear summing up message. I do worry that men who disagree with the guilty outcome are reflecting on some of their own behaviours and how these may have been non-consensual.

Sassysangria2201 · 13/11/2026 23:37

I haven’t been in your position but I think your gut is telling you that this is who he is. Maybe not constantly, but at his core. And that’s why you couldn’t take it back, because being stuck with this ongoing would be pretty bloody rough.

I’m so sorry you are having to go through this. I am guessing the Russell Brand thing has just shed an even brighter light on parts of your DH that you )and most people) find intolerable/disgusting.

I have heard a few male casual acquaintances say similar, and they are all selfish, characters who lack empathy (but expect lots in return). Again, not all the time but it’s at the core of who they are.

I wish I had better advice but all I can suggest is deep breath, try not to let your thoughts race. Tell yourself you will make a plan, and get some sleep so you can feel strong in the morning

Persephonia1966 · 14/11/2026 02:32

KidMeNottt · 13/11/2026 22:54

If anyone was has any reassuring words that would be wonderful

He's been making sexist remarks for some time. Some of you have blamed me somehow sayinh no sympathy and he must have always held these views but he has definitely got more extreme in the last few yrs!

I'm so sorry!
It's easy to say "if my husband said that he would be out on his ear no regrets" but it's a lot harder when you have built a life with someone. I do have experience of living with someone who changed, in that case by getting very immersed in online content/the more toxic bits of the manosphere. It isn't quite the same situation as yours because in your case the breaking point was your husband's views on rape whereas in mine it was increasing anger at sexist double standards/female hegomeny blah blah (I never cheated and his life was good. It reminded me of people living very safe lives but getting angry at the fact London, where they never visit, is so dangerous. Basically online perceptions being more real and emotionally triggering than reality).
The relationship did not survive but I'm doing great. If someone wants to pay more attention to the online world than the real world then there is a limit to what you can do to pull them out (I know there is an irony to saying this on Mumsnet which is also online). However it is ironic that that sort of online radicalisation is supposed to affect very young men/lonely men but married middle aged men seem to be the most likely to get sucked in.

I don't know if any of that was reassuring. But I don't think you are alone in having seen people you love change their views or express previously hidden opinions. It isn't your fault.

KidMeNottt · 14/11/2026 08:26

@Sassysangria2201 a selfish man who lacks empathy. that is it. over the years, his lack of empathy has been horrible in many situations. i remember going a close friend's funeral and coming home to H in a silent sulk because of something that had happened to him at work and i spent the evening comforting him, or telling me when i had morning sickness that it was 'one big pity party'. but then he coudl be funny. but the main thing is fear and guilt about the kids that has kept us together. i cannot shake the feeling i'm risking my kids safety and happiness in order to improve mine. but it's just becoming intolerable at home. and the brand conversation was one more thing where i just feel staggered that this is who i'm sharing my life with.

typical that i've been thinking/trying to leave for years, and then seemingly it is going to happen a month out of christmas.

OP posts:
EveningSpread · 14/11/2026 08:36

His comments show that he’s sanctioning/justifying/excusing things that have sent a man to jail. For a long time.

What’s his point? That he thinks criminal behaviour is not that bad? Sex offenders often get a hard time in prison. Is your husband more understanding than other hardened criminals, who generally take a dim view of sex crimes?

If you both split up and he dates other women, will he do what Brand has done, since it’s so completely explainable? Well, if he does, he could go to jail. And he’ll be the one on the receiving end of what a lot of blokes think of men who do that stuff.

I just couldn’t respect a man who was guilty of such obvious stupidity. Even if he’s just trying to wind you up, he’s making himself look really foolish by making these statements, when the above is them taken to their logical conclusion.

He sounds like an odious man, and arguably he shouldn’t even be around children (or women) with those views.

PBramble · 14/11/2026 10:07

KidMeNottt · 14/11/2026 08:26

@Sassysangria2201 a selfish man who lacks empathy. that is it. over the years, his lack of empathy has been horrible in many situations. i remember going a close friend's funeral and coming home to H in a silent sulk because of something that had happened to him at work and i spent the evening comforting him, or telling me when i had morning sickness that it was 'one big pity party'. but then he coudl be funny. but the main thing is fear and guilt about the kids that has kept us together. i cannot shake the feeling i'm risking my kids safety and happiness in order to improve mine. but it's just becoming intolerable at home. and the brand conversation was one more thing where i just feel staggered that this is who i'm sharing my life with.

typical that i've been thinking/trying to leave for years, and then seemingly it is going to happen a month out of christmas.

Wow did you marry my ex husband? I decided to end the relationship as i felt my child would be safer keot away from the toxicity. I didnt want the way he treated me to be the model for her relationships later in life. She does go to him but the relarionship is quite strained as he hasnt worked on his issues.

Barnbrack · 14/11/2026 10:18

So, it's not actually that straightforward to have anal sex even on purpose. It's not a self lubricating organ, to do it remotely comfortably requires planning, cooperation and lubrication as well as a lot of relaxation. The horrific pain of unplanned, unprepared and unexpected anal sex must be absolutely horrendous. It would be hugely violent and forceful just to make it happen. It's a horrendous form of rape. All rape is obviously horrible but the betrayal of being naked and engaging with someone and then being treated like that. Nightmare fodder.

Formerbadboy · 14/11/2026 10:33

I have engaged in anal sex with many women, sometimes after a boozy night out. But it was never hard to ensure they were fully onboard & consented to having a penis going up a very delicate and sensitive part of their anatomy.

They were never left sore, injured or required medical assistance afterwards like Brand’s victim(s).

Moving to anal sex is not like going from kissing a woman’s lips to her neck. It’s a very serious and intimate act that requires consent & trust.

JasmineMac · 14/11/2026 13:35

Sometimes people make flippant comments in the absence of knowledge. One of my (female) friends also casually commented that she thought his sentence was excessive. She hadnt been paying close attention to the case, and the only news item she'd saw was a report on his KC's angry exchange with the journalist who broke the initial story. From her limited knowledge (not everyone gets invested in current affairs) there was an impression that Brand's crimes weren't as serious as they actually were.

It sounds though that your relationship had turned toxic and was on the ropes way before this situation. I wish you all the best in moving away and on from it.

GumyBand · 14/11/2026 14:40

Anyone seen this on Facebook from Melanie Tonia Evans? Bold text bolded by me.

"Russell Brand …
I’m going to weigh in.
And the reason I’m doing this is that I’m passionate about freeing people for REAL from narcissistic abuse.

Not just offer lip service, or join in on what people necessarily want to hear.
A lot of you may not hear from me what you expect, and I am NOT going to apologise.

Nor am I going to lead with “Of course rape is bad and should never be condoned.” Any decent adult with a pulse knows that! And I refuse to beg you to believe that I KNOW that too.

I, too, have been a victim of this, as have many women. And it may surprise you that we don’t all see what’s happened to Russell the same way.

I refuse to be steered into “It has to be THIS or THAT.” Yes, a jury convicted Russell Brand of rape and sexual assault. Fact.

However, I find the timing very, very interesting. The offences Russell was convicted of happened between 2004 and 2009. A time when the system adored him, and he could never do any wrong.

Then, in September 2023, after speaking out so heavily about the establishment, the industrial-military complex, big pharma, and big corps, with millions of followers awakening to what he was saying and also questioning the system, the story broke.

Hollywood defectors have historically suffered huge repercussions. Many spoke out about fearing what may happen, before being silenced - sometimes permanently. Russell also said they were after him. He has been sharing that for 5 years.

A Times journalist said publicly that reporters had approached women before publication.

After the story came out, police say women who didn’t know each other contacted detectives. I find that timing striking.

There are women reporting they were offered money to speak against Russell and refused. I can't confirm this as true, yet women are saying it publicly.

I will say, it’s been a long time since I trusted any institutional system, especially over the last six years. I know, and it's been proven time and time again, that agendas, lies and coordination happen. History shows us repeatedly that the system does NOT have the general public's interest at heart.

So let’s get very REAL about how the media covers this case and how the system handles others.

Unfortunately, many people, maybe even you, get on the bandwagon and join in demonising the NEXT person who’s been thrown to the wolves.

You may say "I never liked him" ... "I knew there was something wrong, my intuition told me!"

Are you a big enough woman or man to stop acting on your internal triggers and drop into your soul and look deeper?

You may not like aspects of someone's personality, but that doesn't mean they are ALL bad, or even necessarily guilty of "what they are smeared with".
It's actually decidedly narcissistic to be that BLACK and WHITE.

Have you stopped to think Russell was convicted for events over 20 years ago that were NOT reported back then, .... and who came forward to report assault out of ALL these people? (supposedly more coming now) ..

I also wonder why there were NOT outraged brothers, fathers, and even boyfriends or husbands if he was such a rapacious sexual non-consensual fiend who may have taken summary justice into their own hands?

GOD, we need men like that (just a side note!)

And now today there is zero forensic evidence regarding what Russell did. No credible witnesses to these events, just victim accounts.

As a narcissistic abuse expert, you may wonder WHY I’m questioning the narrative.

HUGELY because of this... Because I KNOW, oh how I KNOW, how powerful people and narcissists of any variety shape a story and how quickly the rest of us can get pulled into repeating it.

I pay attention to who gets heard, who gets dismissed and who gets protected.
CLOSE attention. To OBVIOUS inconsistencies. (They always expose lies)

The glaring hypocrisy, to me, is this...
The Epstein files are public. Where is the sustained pressure to investigate, trial, and convict people for some of the most heinous sexual depravity and exploitation of the innocent, known to humanity?

Children, completely non-consensual.

Not adults following around movie stars or rubbing shoulders with them.
Where is the same outrage when someone convicted of sexually assaulting a child walks away with a suspended sentence in so many major cities?
(Happening worldwide RIGHT now)

Come on … THINK, people!

Do you REALLY think your government and media give two craps about standing up for you and protecting women and children?
(There wouldn't be the toxins in our food, air, medicines, sky and systems if they DID!)

And .... WHY are so many other survivors of sexual abuse still fighting to be heard?

Why haven’t more victims of abuse by powerful people been given their day in court?

Sooo many have reported and got nowhere.

What happens when the people you report to are part of the very institutions you’re asking to help you?

People are threatened, smeared, ridiculed and silenced.

ALL the time ...the testimonies are everywhere. Just because it's not the media narrative, you decide not to believe it? (Why? Because the media TOLD you not to! Do you not know yet the media is the BULLHORN of the system?)

As long as those institutions can protect their own, how are extremely damaged survivors supposed to get justice?

How are the people who are experiencing unchecked, systematic, ongoing abuse, including sexual abuse, able to be helped when everyone's head is up their arse demonising Russell Brand?

If the Epstein files and the scale of sexual assault worldwide haven’t awakened you to that, I HONESTLY don’t know what to say to you!

What I find RIDICULOUS is how quickly the public can rally around one case while people who’ve spent years asking for help are still waiting for someone to listen.

I want that same sustained attention on what happens when survivors report abuse by the people with money, influence or institutional power who are WITH the system and NOT against it.

Because those are the people who are the worst offenders, turning you to look at VERY low-hanging fruit who don't have a patch on what they do... constantly... as their usual ritualistic behaviour. (Please refer to the Epstein Files.

It's all there, and Epstein was only one cog in a very big wheel)

People need to wake up to the REAL narcissistic abuse.

I’m a woman who feels solid in my body and trusts my own awareness and judgement. I’ve done the work on my own wounds, and that work has changed how I respond when I’m told who to hate.

I refuse to take my internal unhealed, unresolved pain out on the next person the media tells me to hate.

Sadly, I see FAR too much of that in this narcissistic abuse community. Usually from the people who don't do the inner shadow work on their own traumas.

Aren’t we here to evolve, heal and STOP having the wool pulled over our eyes?

Aren’t we sovereign ENOUGH yet and FREE to think for ourselves?

I stand with Russell, unapologetically and unashamedly. I’m not backing down on this, even if you decide I'm something like a "rape apologist" or some other stupid label that gets used to defame critical-thinking people.
(Something else the establishment got you to parrot!)

That’s totally okay.

I, for one, REFUSE to be a pawn in this terrible game that is SO much bigger than "Russell Brand".
Love,
Mel "

CrazyMidget · 14/11/2026 14:44

Barnbrack · 14/11/2026 10:18

So, it's not actually that straightforward to have anal sex even on purpose. It's not a self lubricating organ, to do it remotely comfortably requires planning, cooperation and lubrication as well as a lot of relaxation. The horrific pain of unplanned, unprepared and unexpected anal sex must be absolutely horrendous. It would be hugely violent and forceful just to make it happen. It's a horrendous form of rape. All rape is obviously horrible but the betrayal of being naked and engaging with someone and then being treated like that. Nightmare fodder.

This. One hundred percent. The pain would have been horrific without copious amounts of lube and preparation and going slow. And yes, it would have had to be hugely forceful and violent to make it happen. And he took the condom off, and he came inside her. It must surely count as aggravated rape. Brand is so much worse than I ever imagined. The sheer cruelty of sudden, forced anal rape; his utter cruelty to Katy Perry when he texted her asking for a divorce moments before she was due on stage; the way he treated his dog; the other women he's raped and assaulted....he's BEYOND vile. Really malevolent and sinister.

Any man who doesn't shudder at the thought and doesn't think that Brand deserved everything he got is not a good man.

CrazyMidget · 14/11/2026 14:50

@GumyBand I don't know who that person is, but I wouldn't waste any time on them. I couldn't finish the whole post. There are always going to be people with wonky views. They're mad, and the less headspace you give them the better, in my view.

GumyBand · 14/11/2026 14:57

CrazyMidget · 14/11/2026 14:50

@GumyBand I don't know who that person is, but I wouldn't waste any time on them. I couldn't finish the whole post. There are always going to be people with wonky views. They're mad, and the less headspace you give them the better, in my view.

The fact that she states that she stands with Russell is unbelievable for a woman who sells course and books on healing from abuse!!!

kkloo · 14/11/2026 15:05

A major problem with the conspiracy theory is what has Russell Brand said that was so uniquely threatening that powerful people/groups would supposedly arrange to have him prosecuted?

It's certainly not unusual these days to criticise governments, the media, pharmaceutical companies, wealthy elites or the 'establishment' , plenty of people do it. He hasn't said anything new or particularly wild or exposed anything new or put any new ideas out there as far as I am aware.

ThePoetsWife · 14/11/2026 15:07

Bringemout · 12/11/2026 21:45

Has he read about what happened? He flipped her over, removed a condom and raped her badly enough that she sought medical attention. Thats not bad sex.

And without using lube

KidMeNottt · 14/11/2026 15:14

kkloo · 14/11/2026 15:05

A major problem with the conspiracy theory is what has Russell Brand said that was so uniquely threatening that powerful people/groups would supposedly arrange to have him prosecuted?

It's certainly not unusual these days to criticise governments, the media, pharmaceutical companies, wealthy elites or the 'establishment' , plenty of people do it. He hasn't said anything new or particularly wild or exposed anything new or put any new ideas out there as far as I am aware.

100%. He was literally a zero threat to anyone. The idea of him as some great truth teller is ridiculous. The idea that the "establishment" would be prioritising silencing a washed up comedian over all the actual global threats...forget about Putin....let's bring down the bloke who used to be famous who now just spouts covid theories on YouTube.

OP posts: