Shockingly, I even have an opinion that some murders are worse than others too, in spite of never having been murdered. 🙄
Yeah but would you suggest that in some cases that the person should get the minimum time in jail, if the minimum was fuck all time because you don't think the murder was that bad?
I can see cases, like in the case of euthanasia for example where they tried to help out a desperate person so I'm not talking about cases like that, but other murders, where the person did not want to die?
For example, theft is always wrong. But swindling pensioners out of all their savings deserves a greater punishment than when I stole someone's pencil at school.
This is a terrible example, because when it comes to things like rape, the circumstances of the rape and the psychological consequences are different things. Some women end up extremely traumatised for life even if their rape was non violent and had no aggravating factors. In your example you're comparing things where there would be a lot of trauma versus something where there would be none, or maybe a slightly annoyance/upset that your pencil got robbed.
And, anecdotal though this is, in all my time in support and therapy groups for survivors of rape/abuse/violence, there was always a consensus that (1) all rape/abuse is awful (2) some is worse than others (3) legal punishments should reflect this (4) men got away with rape far too often.
Legal punishments do reflect that, but you're saying you think that in this case he only deserved 4 years, which is wholly offensive to many victims.
Also the woman in this case did not 'withdraw consent'. She had never given consent for anal sex, you can't withdraw it if you haven't given it.