Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grossed out by DH comments on Brand

165 replies

KidMeNottt · 12/11/2026 21:14

He said Brand obviously a creep and he agreed that having non consenting anal sex "probably is technically rape" but the fact the girl was cheating on her boyfriend and admitted to rimming Brand when they first met...it was more like the anal sex was "things getting out of hand". He said more like a "play fight gone wrong". She was "clearly into extreme stuff". He then backtracked saying "no, it is awful... but context changes things and she was no angel". He did say "no doubt the bloke should be in jail but 10 years given the context???"

Thoughts? I think its pretty disgraceful but interested to hear what people think.

OP posts:
Sewingbeedamned · 12/11/2026 23:29

FallingFlying · 12/11/2026 22:18

Absolutely this.

They don't think of themselves as an abuser so someone who has done similar can't be either.

There is a fascinating study of rapists who were interviewed - all could clearly define rape, and consent. And every single scumbag in the study insisted that what they did was not rape and they were not rapists. Its what this DH was doing, but taken to the extreme.

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · 12/11/2026 23:28

If the typical range of sentencing for rape is 4-19 years, then I'd expect 4 years for someone who didn't stop when previously given consent was withdrawn, and 19 years for grabbing a stranger off the street and subjecting them to a violent and prolonged attack, or for raping a young child.

I've survived rape of the kind I believe to be towards the most serious end of that scale, and rape at the less serious end. If we treat all rape like the worst rapes, then we aren't giving justice to the victims who've endured the worst.

If Brand is guilty of dozens of sexual crimes, as many have implied, then the sentence is deserved. But it's actually only for what he's been found guilty of.

Here's one example - far from the only one, but memorable to me for various reasons:

A guy called Quayum the same sentence - 10 years - for two different sexual assaults and raping three girls (as opposed to Brand's one victim), all of whom were underage I think, and none of whom consented to any sexual activity.

All rapists should serve time in prison, but the law ought to be applied consistently and fairly. It's possible to think a particular sentence for rape is far too harsh without being on the side of rapists.

Vaxtable · 12/11/2026 23:24

I would ask him if he would feel the same if this was you or his daughter. Then I would reiterate those brilliant words which should be shouted from the rooftops that the judge made

"Whatever women wear, wherever they go, indeed whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and to demand justice from the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Russell Brand, act without their consent.

Then I would be considering if I really wanted to stay with someone like this

CrazyMidget · 12/11/2026 23:24

GumyBand · 12/11/2026 23:05

Ask your husband if he thinks this was rape or not. Here is my rape story... within a relationship... and looking back I now realise it was rape and did nothing about it at the time. I suppose I couldn't.

I was on holiday with my boyfriend, in the middle of nowhere in Slovakia on a wilderness type mountain break in a small hotel where I didn't speak the language and hardly anyone spoke English.

I'm not at all traumatised by this now that it's over 20 years ago, at the time that it happened, I didn't know whether I had been raped or not, as he was my boyfriend, we were about to have sex, and I wanted to have sex with him. He held me down and refused to put a condom on and told me he had decided to get me pregnant. He had never been violent before and we always used condoms, however, he was constantly demanding sex, all day and all night. Looking back he was a very sick individual but I was young and caught up in idealisation and projection. He was also, like Brand, very charming and clever. He was good looking. On paper, the perfect catch. But I did not give my consent that night and he forced himself onto me without a condom.

That is rape. Despite the fact that we were together. Despite the fact that I DID want sex with him. Not like that though. The Brand trial has made me realise I was raped by this horrible ex. Again, not traumatised or upset now BUT.. if I had a daughter and she was telling me this had happened to her... I'd be straight to the police with her.

That is HORRIBLE. I am so sorry.

Tinytinytinypony · 12/11/2026 23:23

CrazyMidget · 12/11/2026 23:22

Sigh. The only POSSIBLE excuse for this, and other men's remarks, is that they've never had anal sex and therefore don't know that you need BUCKETS of lube, that you need to work up to it over time with small butt plugs, and that he needs to go very slow. But this is a very kind interpretation. Has he ever considered the enormous amount of pain that would result from having a penis shoved unceremoniously into your anus without any lube or prep?

But as to the comment "she's no angel" - omg, I can't think of any excuse for that. Oh, so people who are into sexual experimentation (not saying she was) are less entitled to have their consent listened to than others? WTAF?

I think you should tell your husband of the facts: That it would have been enormously painful; that there was zero consent; that he took the condom off; and that he did finish, meaning that someone ejaculated inside her without her consent, and that this is like a spiritual death for women. To have someone ejaculate inside you when you don't want them to and have not given consent is a total humiliation and makes you feel like nothing. And then, in addition to all this trauma, she was really worried about HIV because of what he did.

You REALLY need to tell your husband this stuff. Perhaps he's just clueless.

It’s not her job to tell a rape apologist / misogynist this stuff. The best thing she can do is get the fuck away

Tinytinytinypony · 12/11/2026 23:22

Everlygreen · 12/11/2026 23:18

I must live under a rock but what is this establishment that I see all over? Not only on Mn, comments everywhere. Is it a firm, people, who or what is it?

How do you not know this? The establishment is a privately owned company, headed up by Musk and the recently departed CEO of NVidia, Heung. Educate yourself.

CrazyMidget · 12/11/2026 23:22

Sigh. The only POSSIBLE excuse for this, and other men's remarks, is that they've never had anal sex and therefore don't know that you need BUCKETS of lube, that you need to work up to it over time with small butt plugs, and that he needs to go very slow. But this is a very kind interpretation. Has he ever considered the enormous amount of pain that would result from having a penis shoved unceremoniously into your anus without any lube or prep?

But as to the comment "she's no angel" - omg, I can't think of any excuse for that. Oh, so people who are into sexual experimentation (not saying she was) are less entitled to have their consent listened to than others? WTAF?

I think you should tell your husband of the facts: That it would have been enormously painful; that there was zero consent; that he took the condom off; and that he did finish, meaning that someone ejaculated inside her without her consent, and that this is like a spiritual death for women. To have someone ejaculate inside you when you don't want them to and have not given consent is a total humiliation and makes you feel like nothing. And then, in addition to all this trauma, she was really worried about HIV because of what he did.

You REALLY need to tell your husband this stuff. Perhaps he's just clueless.

Crispynoodle · 12/11/2026 23:21

This is why we must educate our sons

Mumtoabillion · 12/11/2026 23:19

Yes I would also be desperately sad to be married to a man who minimises rape. I hope you don't have any daughters. Or sons either really. If you do have children please ask him to keep this sort of nasty belief system to himself.

Everlygreen · 12/11/2026 23:18

I must live under a rock but what is this establishment that I see all over? Not only on Mn, comments everywhere. Is it a firm, people, who or what is it?

CherryBlossom321 · 12/11/2026 23:14

Gross. That would be the end for me.

Tinytinytinypony · 12/11/2026 23:11

You don’t have to be ‘desperately sad’ op. Just dump the cunt

Tinytinytinypony · 12/11/2026 23:08

You understand that your husband is a rape apologist that much is clear. Now, what are you going to do about it?

GumyBand · 12/11/2026 23:05

Ask your husband if he thinks this was rape or not. Here is my rape story... within a relationship... and looking back I now realise it was rape and did nothing about it at the time. I suppose I couldn't.

I was on holiday with my boyfriend, in the middle of nowhere in Slovakia on a wilderness type mountain break in a small hotel where I didn't speak the language and hardly anyone spoke English.

I'm not at all traumatised by this now that it's over 20 years ago, at the time that it happened, I didn't know whether I had been raped or not, as he was my boyfriend, we were about to have sex, and I wanted to have sex with him. He held me down and refused to put a condom on and told me he had decided to get me pregnant. He had never been violent before and we always used condoms, however, he was constantly demanding sex, all day and all night. Looking back he was a very sick individual but I was young and caught up in idealisation and projection. He was also, like Brand, very charming and clever. He was good looking. On paper, the perfect catch. But I did not give my consent that night and he forced himself onto me without a condom.

That is rape. Despite the fact that we were together. Despite the fact that I DID want sex with him. Not like that though. The Brand trial has made me realise I was raped by this horrible ex. Again, not traumatised or upset now BUT.. if I had a daughter and she was telling me this had happened to her... I'd be straight to the police with her.

AlonsoMosley · 12/11/2026 22:58

bringonyourwreckingball · 12/11/2026 21:43

I really think a lot of men don’t understand what rape is, they think of it like bad sex. Not a horrifically violating experience where you feel fear and powerlessness and total lack of agency.

HARD agree.

I think that most women would define rape in a way that would be entirely different from what a man thinks it is.

I think that 99% of men think rape is jumping out from behind a bush kind of thing. With that in mind, men should not be the ones to get to define it.

Have a look at Douglas is Cancelled. There is a very oppressive episode where they examine the idea of coercion brilliantly. Coercion is often a precursor to rape, making it so there is no way out, and therefore "consent" is given.

AutumnFroglets · 12/11/2026 22:56

KidMeNottt · 12/11/2026 21:43

He does know its rape. He seems to think there is "less bad" rape if you've acted in certain ways beforehand. It was like he was saying it was accidental.

I keep coming back to this OP.

Have you ever been enthusiastic about sex with DH, even if it was only on your wedding night? Because this gives the impression he doesn't feel the need for full consent anymore, especially if you've had a drink or two and might be a little confused or tired. Watch yourself as he might decide one night he can do whatever he wants as it's not technically rapey as you're married.

ClaredeBear · 12/11/2026 22:54

Superduper02 · 12/11/2026 22:24

I think the pile onto your DH is a bit much. A lot of men struggle to understand the situations which count as rape and sexual assault because this is a man's world. They just need education, again and again until they truly get it.

E.g. thinking rape must be a woman being dragged off the street protesting rather than consensual foreplay which became unconsensual sex. Alot of men would strongly condemn the first but be more understanding of 'confusion' and 'mixed signals' in the second example.

You have literally defined the problem. You have just spelled out that some men don’t know the difference between consent and assault - but still it’s not their fault. Is this a joke?

GumyBand · 12/11/2026 22:54

Blackbird2409 · 12/11/2026 22:27

This sounds like when my ex husband said it was fine the Madeleine McCanns parents had left her in the apartment alone and I was being a snob for saying otherwise. My heart left the relationship that day and we divorced not soon enough after.

Glad you divorced him!! Unforgivable!

Kitte321 · 12/11/2026 22:52

Superduper02 · 12/11/2026 22:24

I think the pile onto your DH is a bit much. A lot of men struggle to understand the situations which count as rape and sexual assault because this is a man's world. They just need education, again and again until they truly get it.

E.g. thinking rape must be a woman being dragged off the street protesting rather than consensual foreplay which became unconsensual sex. Alot of men would strongly condemn the first but be more understanding of 'confusion' and 'mixed signals' in the second example.

I really do think men deserve more credit than that. I strongly believe that the vast majority of men have the cognitive ability to work out what is consent. And to understand that engage in anal sex that wasn’t consented to explicitly is, in fact, rape.

Suggesting they’re confused or receiving mixed signals is just pandering to a victim blaming narrative.

GumyBand · 12/11/2026 22:52

OMG.

Wasn't there a recent post on here by a woman whose boyfriend said there would be less rape if there were more available prostitutes or something along those lines? As if rape is OK for certain women but not for others.

I just despair at some men. It really does seem to be a small percentage of them that are decent!

Maybe I'm spending too much time on here or something.

ClaredeBear · 12/11/2026 22:50

OP, I would like you to contrast what your partner said with my husband, who at the teeniest, tiniest thought that I might be even slightly uncomfortable when we are being intimate, will lose his errction.
.

hettie · 12/11/2026 22:49

Superduper02 · 12/11/2026 22:24

I think the pile onto your DH is a bit much. A lot of men struggle to understand the situations which count as rape and sexual assault because this is a man's world. They just need education, again and again until they truly get it.

E.g. thinking rape must be a woman being dragged off the street protesting rather than consensual foreplay which became unconsensual sex. Alot of men would strongly condemn the first but be more understanding of 'confusion' and 'mixed signals' in the second example.

Well..... Just no.....Every kid in the last 10 years has had 'the cup of tea' consent video played to them in PSE.
Many parents will therefore have had the 'cup of tea' dinner conversation (unless they have checked out from parenting).
So do 'most men' need educating? Probably not, they choose to ignore the consent conversation or choose to embrace convenient stereotypes so that they can justify their shitty behaviour

ClaredeBear · 12/11/2026 22:47

I’d be wondering what he’s done in his past that he’s trying to justify this, tbh.

ThreadGuardDog · 12/11/2026 22:33

KidMeNottt · 12/11/2026 21:43

He does know its rape. He seems to think there is "less bad" rape if you've acted in certain ways beforehand. It was like he was saying it was accidental.

Ask him if it’s ‘accidental’ that Brand removed the condom during the non-consensual anal sex, thus putting her at hugely increased risk of HIV. Or the gagging order he got, preventing his victim from speaking about the assault.

Tortielady · 12/11/2026 22:30

Whatever "extreme stuff" she was into when RB attacked her, she wasn't into the particular form of penetration he forced on her and which resulted in her needing hospital treatment. Consent to one form of activity doesn't mean consent to everything and at all times. Women (and men for that matter) absolutely have the right to pick and choose and say no and have their no heard and respected. Anything else is rape, nothing more or less and anyone who seeks to rationalise or justify it it should have a word with themselves.