Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grossed out by DH comments on Brand

165 replies

KidMeNottt · 12/11/2026 21:14

He said Brand obviously a creep and he agreed that having non consenting anal sex "probably is technically rape" but the fact the girl was cheating on her boyfriend and admitted to rimming Brand when they first met...it was more like the anal sex was "things getting out of hand". He said more like a "play fight gone wrong". She was "clearly into extreme stuff". He then backtracked saying "no, it is awful... but context changes things and she was no angel". He did say "no doubt the bloke should be in jail but 10 years given the context???"

Thoughts? I think its pretty disgraceful but interested to hear what people think.

OP posts:
PBramble · 14/11/2026 10:07

KidMeNottt · 14/11/2026 08:26

@Sassysangria2201 a selfish man who lacks empathy. that is it. over the years, his lack of empathy has been horrible in many situations. i remember going a close friend's funeral and coming home to H in a silent sulk because of something that had happened to him at work and i spent the evening comforting him, or telling me when i had morning sickness that it was 'one big pity party'. but then he coudl be funny. but the main thing is fear and guilt about the kids that has kept us together. i cannot shake the feeling i'm risking my kids safety and happiness in order to improve mine. but it's just becoming intolerable at home. and the brand conversation was one more thing where i just feel staggered that this is who i'm sharing my life with.

typical that i've been thinking/trying to leave for years, and then seemingly it is going to happen a month out of christmas.

Wow did you marry my ex husband? I decided to end the relationship as i felt my child would be safer keot away from the toxicity. I didnt want the way he treated me to be the model for her relationships later in life. She does go to him but the relarionship is quite strained as he hasnt worked on his issues.

EveningSpread · 14/11/2026 08:36

His comments show that he’s sanctioning/justifying/excusing things that have sent a man to jail. For a long time.

What’s his point? That he thinks criminal behaviour is not that bad? Sex offenders often get a hard time in prison. Is your husband more understanding than other hardened criminals, who generally take a dim view of sex crimes?

If you both split up and he dates other women, will he do what Brand has done, since it’s so completely explainable? Well, if he does, he could go to jail. And he’ll be the one on the receiving end of what a lot of blokes think of men who do that stuff.

I just couldn’t respect a man who was guilty of such obvious stupidity. Even if he’s just trying to wind you up, he’s making himself look really foolish by making these statements, when the above is them taken to their logical conclusion.

He sounds like an odious man, and arguably he shouldn’t even be around children (or women) with those views.

KidMeNottt · 14/11/2026 08:26

@Sassysangria2201 a selfish man who lacks empathy. that is it. over the years, his lack of empathy has been horrible in many situations. i remember going a close friend's funeral and coming home to H in a silent sulk because of something that had happened to him at work and i spent the evening comforting him, or telling me when i had morning sickness that it was 'one big pity party'. but then he coudl be funny. but the main thing is fear and guilt about the kids that has kept us together. i cannot shake the feeling i'm risking my kids safety and happiness in order to improve mine. but it's just becoming intolerable at home. and the brand conversation was one more thing where i just feel staggered that this is who i'm sharing my life with.

typical that i've been thinking/trying to leave for years, and then seemingly it is going to happen a month out of christmas.

OP posts:
Persephonia1966 · 14/11/2026 02:32

KidMeNottt · 13/11/2026 22:54

If anyone was has any reassuring words that would be wonderful

He's been making sexist remarks for some time. Some of you have blamed me somehow sayinh no sympathy and he must have always held these views but he has definitely got more extreme in the last few yrs!

I'm so sorry!
It's easy to say "if my husband said that he would be out on his ear no regrets" but it's a lot harder when you have built a life with someone. I do have experience of living with someone who changed, in that case by getting very immersed in online content/the more toxic bits of the manosphere. It isn't quite the same situation as yours because in your case the breaking point was your husband's views on rape whereas in mine it was increasing anger at sexist double standards/female hegomeny blah blah (I never cheated and his life was good. It reminded me of people living very safe lives but getting angry at the fact London, where they never visit, is so dangerous. Basically online perceptions being more real and emotionally triggering than reality).
The relationship did not survive but I'm doing great. If someone wants to pay more attention to the online world than the real world then there is a limit to what you can do to pull them out (I know there is an irony to saying this on Mumsnet which is also online). However it is ironic that that sort of online radicalisation is supposed to affect very young men/lonely men but married middle aged men seem to be the most likely to get sucked in.

I don't know if any of that was reassuring. But I don't think you are alone in having seen people you love change their views or express previously hidden opinions. It isn't your fault.

Sassysangria2201 · 13/11/2026 23:37

I haven’t been in your position but I think your gut is telling you that this is who he is. Maybe not constantly, but at his core. And that’s why you couldn’t take it back, because being stuck with this ongoing would be pretty bloody rough.

I’m so sorry you are having to go through this. I am guessing the Russell Brand thing has just shed an even brighter light on parts of your DH that you )and most people) find intolerable/disgusting.

I have heard a few male casual acquaintances say similar, and they are all selfish, characters who lack empathy (but expect lots in return). Again, not all the time but it’s at the core of who they are.

I wish I had better advice but all I can suggest is deep breath, try not to let your thoughts race. Tell yourself you will make a plan, and get some sleep so you can feel strong in the morning

ForgiveMeFatherForIHaveGinned · 13/11/2026 23:00

Sorry to hear about the difficulties with your DH. Absolutely no judgement from me towards you, you can't be held responsible for his thoughts and actions. However I would strongly advise you to reflect on this and the other behaviours you have mentioned in your posts, as you have indicated. My DH and I have also been discussing the Brand case tonight and he is 100% of the same view as me and many others (women in particular, but also must acknowledge many good men sharing these views) as to what consent means and that in these cases there clearly wasn't consent hence why he has been found guilty. As OPs have said, the judge in this case gave a very clear summing up message. I do worry that men who disagree with the guilty outcome are reflecting on some of their own behaviours and how these may have been non-consensual.

DeeDeeSharpWhatKindOfLadyNSoul · 13/11/2026 22:59

I'd be wondering what he's viewing online etc
Andrew Tate style crap perhaps.

KidMeNottt · 13/11/2026 22:54

If anyone was has any reassuring words that would be wonderful

He's been making sexist remarks for some time. Some of you have blamed me somehow sayinh no sympathy and he must have always held these views but he has definitely got more extreme in the last few yrs!

OP posts:
KidMeNottt · 13/11/2026 22:25

PinkyFlamingo · 13/11/2026 18:24

And? What are you going to do about it?

Well, quite possibly split up by the looks of things.

Its been rough for some time. We havent slept in the same bed for a year or so. He has become increasingly angry, mean, shitty comments about my work and friends but we have had counselling and we have good days too and we have young kids

But tonight he went to the gym for 4 hours. I made one comment when he came home. It erupted. And I've just told him I want to split up. He told me to "fucking own it or take it back right fucking now". And i chose to not take it back. And im now lying in my kids room in the dark, heart pounding.

OP posts:
PinkyFlamingo · 13/11/2026 18:24

KidMeNottt · 12/11/2026 21:43

He does know its rape. He seems to think there is "less bad" rape if you've acted in certain ways beforehand. It was like he was saying it was accidental.

And? What are you going to do about it?

Muffsies · 13/11/2026 18:23

kkloo · 13/11/2026 15:08

The rimming was on a separate occasion.

Either way on the day of the rape, at his house, the victim had only agreed to vaginal sex, there was no consent given whatsoever for anal sex, so it wasn't withdrawn, it wasn't given in the first place.

Basing prison sentences on trauma could result in wildly different sentences for identical offences. That isn't justice.

I'm not basing it on trauma, that is considered a factor for sentencing, but I'm basing it on the offence.

You believe that rape isn't as bad of an offence if consent was previously given or if the person had consented to other kinds of sex beforehand whereas I completely disagree and think it can be just as bad, and am glad that the sentencing in this case reflects that.

There was a 24 hours in Police Custody episode called The Predator about a gay guy who used grindr for hookups, and would then assault the guys he met by making them do something they didn't consent to, such as unprocted sex or anal sex that they decided to withdraw consent to during the hookup.

They managed to charge the guy with two cpunts of rape. Guess how long he got? 10 years. Having sex with someone who withdraws consent, even if they initially agreed to it IS rape, and you'll go to prison for a long time if it's a proven pattern of behaviour.

Judging by thus case, i think Brand's sentence is exactly right and consistent.

Cherrytree86 · 13/11/2026 17:34

I’d divorce him.

ollilili · 13/11/2026 17:24

Would he have the same views if it was his daughter?

kkloo · 13/11/2026 17:21

Superduper02 · 12/11/2026 22:24

I think the pile onto your DH is a bit much. A lot of men struggle to understand the situations which count as rape and sexual assault because this is a man's world. They just need education, again and again until they truly get it.

E.g. thinking rape must be a woman being dragged off the street protesting rather than consensual foreplay which became unconsensual sex. Alot of men would strongly condemn the first but be more understanding of 'confusion' and 'mixed signals' in the second example.

If that is the case why do you think women are wrong for 'piling on'?

It's a 'bit much' for people to pile on and it's less bad for men to be understanding of 'confusion' and 'mixed signals' when rapes occur is it?

Are we meant to feel sorry for these silly little ignorant men while they show understanding to the rapists?

Luckyingame · 13/11/2026 17:14

Yuck.
However, I saw posts on YT basically saying
"It's horrible what has happened to him, political for sure, Elon Musk (?) is going to be next....."
Both myself and my husband (76) felt sick at the statement being read at the Court.

CatSquirrelDuck · 13/11/2026 16:56

Superduper02 · 12/11/2026 22:24

I think the pile onto your DH is a bit much. A lot of men struggle to understand the situations which count as rape and sexual assault because this is a man's world. They just need education, again and again until they truly get it.

E.g. thinking rape must be a woman being dragged off the street protesting rather than consensual foreplay which became unconsensual sex. Alot of men would strongly condemn the first but be more understanding of 'confusion' and 'mixed signals' in the second example.

So you think men are hard done by because they don't have the learning capacity to understand what consent/rape is? But women manage just fine and that's somehow different...?

WTF is wrong with you?

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 13/11/2026 16:41

KidMeNottt · 12/11/2026 21:43

He does know its rape. He seems to think there is "less bad" rape if you've acted in certain ways beforehand. It was like he was saying it was accidental.

Less bad rape.

The woman's anus was bleeding and she needed medical attention. That's "less bad" is it.

Fuck what a man you have unfortunately married.

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 13/11/2026 16:38

Trentdarkmore · 12/11/2026 21:17

It's not "technically rape". It IS rape.

This.

Your husband is a rape denier/minimiser. There are lots of them around ready to stand up for RB.

It's not a good look.

throwawayimplantchat · 13/11/2026 16:10

Ukkake · 13/11/2026 15:46

I must admit, I’ve been away for a couple of weeks and haven’t had the opportunity to read through the media articles regarding the trial.

What was the evidence of what RB has been charged with? Genuinely curious.

Read the judges sentencing remarks for an overview of everything.

https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/R-v-Russell-Brand-Sentencing-Remarks-9.11.26.pdf

Ukkake · 13/11/2026 15:46

I must admit, I’ve been away for a couple of weeks and haven’t had the opportunity to read through the media articles regarding the trial.

What was the evidence of what RB has been charged with? Genuinely curious.

Scarlettpixie · 13/11/2026 15:36

KidMeNottt · 12/11/2026 21:43

He does know its rape. He seems to think there is "less bad" rape if you've acted in certain ways beforehand. It was like he was saying it was accidental.

The sentencing already reflects how 'bad' the rape was if it is possible to think about it in those terms. For a more violent or prolonged attack the sentence would be/should be longer. Rape is still rape! In this case the 9 years was justified. I would really struggle if my partner said something like this OP (although I am sure more men think it than would be stupid enough to say it to their wife/girlfriend). The judges comments summed it up well I thought. Maybe get him to watch the sentencing and see what he thinks after that.

kkloo · 13/11/2026 15:08

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · 13/11/2026 13:42

The law being applied consistently and fairly is vital to justice. So do I think four years would be enough for this? No not really. But 10 years when worse offences get less certainly isn't fair.

The sentencing range for rape is 4-19 years. IMO both ends of that range are too low.

I hadn't read the details of this case. I guess I'd put continuing with intercourse once consent is withdrawn at the bottom of the range (obviously depending in circumstances). I'd put anal rape when no consent had been given for penetrative, but it followed on from rimming etc as warranting a longer sentence than withdrawn consent, but a lower sentence than where the victim had refused all sexual activity.

People respond to the same things with different degrees of trauma. When a drunk man grabbed me on the street a few years ago it felt afterwards like reliving all the trauma of rape. But he couldn't have known that.

On the other hand, one very autistic survivor of rape that I knew processed things very differently. Frankly, she just wasn't as traumatised as everyone else in the group. But her attacker deserved just as much prison time as mine.

Basing prison sentences on trauma could result in wildly different sentences for identical offences. That isn't justice.

The rimming was on a separate occasion.

Either way on the day of the rape, at his house, the victim had only agreed to vaginal sex, there was no consent given whatsoever for anal sex, so it wasn't withdrawn, it wasn't given in the first place.

Basing prison sentences on trauma could result in wildly different sentences for identical offences. That isn't justice.

I'm not basing it on trauma, that is considered a factor for sentencing, but I'm basing it on the offence.

You believe that rape isn't as bad of an offence if consent was previously given or if the person had consented to other kinds of sex beforehand whereas I completely disagree and think it can be just as bad, and am glad that the sentencing in this case reflects that.

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · 13/11/2026 13:42

The law being applied consistently and fairly is vital to justice. So do I think four years would be enough for this? No not really. But 10 years when worse offences get less certainly isn't fair.

The sentencing range for rape is 4-19 years. IMO both ends of that range are too low.

I hadn't read the details of this case. I guess I'd put continuing with intercourse once consent is withdrawn at the bottom of the range (obviously depending in circumstances). I'd put anal rape when no consent had been given for penetrative, but it followed on from rimming etc as warranting a longer sentence than withdrawn consent, but a lower sentence than where the victim had refused all sexual activity.

People respond to the same things with different degrees of trauma. When a drunk man grabbed me on the street a few years ago it felt afterwards like reliving all the trauma of rape. But he couldn't have known that.

On the other hand, one very autistic survivor of rape that I knew processed things very differently. Frankly, she just wasn't as traumatised as everyone else in the group. But her attacker deserved just as much prison time as mine.

Basing prison sentences on trauma could result in wildly different sentences for identical offences. That isn't justice.

kkloo · 13/11/2026 11:18

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · 13/11/2026 10:49

Shockingly, I even have an opinion that some murders are worse than others too, in spite of never having been murdered. 🙄

Saying that some rapes are even worse than others isn't saying that any rape is ok, or not a big deal, or not worth punishing. There are different degrees in most awful things.

For example, war is bad and causes suffering. The Falklands war was awful and it's tragic that so many died. WW1 was even worse. If those who started wars always had to pay reparations, Id argue that Germany should pay more than Argentina (which of course they did). I still think Argentina was utterly wrong.

For example, theft is always wrong. But swindling pensioners out of all their savings deserves a greater punishment than when I stole someone's pencil at school.

Save your outrage for the rapists and maybe reread what we both wrote with calm and logical consideration. No, I don't have authority to define the relative severity of all other rape just because I've been raped. But I'm as entitled to an opinion as you are.

And, anecdotal though this is, in all my time in support and therapy groups for survivors of rape/abuse/violence, there was always a consensus that (1) all rape/abuse is awful (2) some is worse than others (3) legal punishments should reflect this (4) men got away with rape far too often.

Shockingly, I even have an opinion that some murders are worse than others too, in spite of never having been murdered. 🙄

Yeah but would you suggest that in some cases that the person should get the minimum time in jail, if the minimum was fuck all time because you don't think the murder was that bad?

I can see cases, like in the case of euthanasia for example where they tried to help out a desperate person so I'm not talking about cases like that, but other murders, where the person did not want to die?

For example, theft is always wrong. But swindling pensioners out of all their savings deserves a greater punishment than when I stole someone's pencil at school.

This is a terrible example, because when it comes to things like rape, the circumstances of the rape and the psychological consequences are different things. Some women end up extremely traumatised for life even if their rape was non violent and had no aggravating factors. In your example you're comparing things where there would be a lot of trauma versus something where there would be none, or maybe a slightly annoyance/upset that your pencil got robbed.

And, anecdotal though this is, in all my time in support and therapy groups for survivors of rape/abuse/violence, there was always a consensus that (1) all rape/abuse is awful (2) some is worse than others (3) legal punishments should reflect this (4) men got away with rape far too often.

Legal punishments do reflect that, but you're saying you think that in this case he only deserved 4 years, which is wholly offensive to many victims.

Also the woman in this case did not 'withdraw consent'. She had never given consent for anal sex, you can't withdraw it if you haven't given it.

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · 13/11/2026 10:49

Tinytinytinypony · 12/11/2026 23:31

What the actual fuck? Just because something awful happened to you, it doesn’t give you the power to define what kind of rape is ‘not so bad.’ Jesus Christ

Shockingly, I even have an opinion that some murders are worse than others too, in spite of never having been murdered. 🙄

Saying that some rapes are even worse than others isn't saying that any rape is ok, or not a big deal, or not worth punishing. There are different degrees in most awful things.

For example, war is bad and causes suffering. The Falklands war was awful and it's tragic that so many died. WW1 was even worse. If those who started wars always had to pay reparations, Id argue that Germany should pay more than Argentina (which of course they did). I still think Argentina was utterly wrong.

For example, theft is always wrong. But swindling pensioners out of all their savings deserves a greater punishment than when I stole someone's pencil at school.

Save your outrage for the rapists and maybe reread what we both wrote with calm and logical consideration. No, I don't have authority to define the relative severity of all other rape just because I've been raped. But I'm as entitled to an opinion as you are.

And, anecdotal though this is, in all my time in support and therapy groups for survivors of rape/abuse/violence, there was always a consensus that (1) all rape/abuse is awful (2) some is worse than others (3) legal punishments should reflect this (4) men got away with rape far too often.