Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think cannabis should be legalized and alcohol made illegal at the same time?

216 replies

OonaStubbs · 10/11/2026 22:23

It would solve so many problems. The tax revenue lost by not being levied on alcohol sales could be levied on cannabis. It would massively reduce the violence and conflict caused by drunkenness and whilst increased cannabis use would undoubtedly cause some problems, it is far less destructive.

OP posts:
Erin1975 · 11/11/2026 11:51

mcmuffin22 · 11/11/2026 08:34

My neighbour- a weed smoker for 15+ years - has psychotic episodes where he turns violent and aggressive. He's been sectioned a number of times. I don't think legalising cannabis is the answer to society's problems.

You are basing your judgement on a very extreme user. The equivalent would be an alcoholic who drinks a bottle of vodka a day.

There are many people who smoke occasionally and do not get these problems.

mcmuffin22 · 11/11/2026 11:55

Erin1975 · 11/11/2026 11:51

You are basing your judgement on a very extreme user. The equivalent would be an alcoholic who drinks a bottle of vodka a day.

There are many people who smoke occasionally and do not get these problems.

Lots of people also drink alcohol in moderation and are fine too.

Also this guy didn't start off as an extreme user. I've been his neighbour since he was a teenager. Prolonged use a few times a week has got him to this point. He's in his early 30s now.

Wopple · 11/11/2026 11:59

Erin1975 · 11/11/2026 11:51

You are basing your judgement on a very extreme user. The equivalent would be an alcoholic who drinks a bottle of vodka a day.

There are many people who smoke occasionally and do not get these problems.

This whole thread is about comparing the two. And both can have issues. Someone who drinks occasionally isn’t a problem either. The problem is many people have addiction issues and when either drug - cannabis or alcohol - is abused can cause issues.

AutumnsFinallyHere · 11/11/2026 12:28

SalmonandCreamCheeseLibertyBagelPlease · 10/11/2026 22:34

It also legalised cannabis in 2021 and after a recent trip to New York I couldn’t believe the pungent stench of weed most places we went to, it was disgusting. In fact all the amazing things we did there the main thing that sticks in my head is the smell of weed! 😳

I love New York but my God last time I went there it stunk of weed, and as with you it’s a memory that stays with me.

PencilsInSpace · 11/11/2026 13:00

I don't see how you could realistically outlaw alcohol. You'd have to ban sugar and yeast.

uhhuhyeahok · 11/11/2026 13:03

My neighbours smoke a lot of weed. They smoke it outside (I assume to not stink out their own house). It bleeds into my house to the point where I might as well be smoking it myself. Its disgusting.

Its becoming more common to smell it just walking around cities now, why should we all be subjected to it?

Walker1178 · 11/11/2026 13:08

What a ridiculous idea! DP can happily sit in our lounge sipping a pint of Guinness. It doesn’t pollute the air I’m breathing, I can’t taste or smell it and has no knock effect for me. Swap that pint for a joint and my evening would be unbearable; I hate smoke and can’t stand the smell of cannabis.

MickyMoonshine · 11/11/2026 13:08

AutumnsFinallyHere · 11/11/2026 12:28

I love New York but my God last time I went there it stunk of weed, and as with you it’s a memory that stays with me.

Same here. It was awful. NY has always been one of my favourite places but I'd be reluctant to go back because the smell of weed everywhere ruined it for me.

pointythings · 11/11/2026 13:12

Erin1975 · 11/11/2026 11:51

You are basing your judgement on a very extreme user. The equivalent would be an alcoholic who drinks a bottle of vodka a day.

There are many people who smoke occasionally and do not get these problems.

There's also the question of whether the cannabis is causal in such cases or whether it's a symptom, I.e. the user self medicating with it.

DewDropsAndCobWebs · 11/11/2026 13:21

I think you all are forgetting cannabis doesn't need to be smoked.
We have it in drinks, pill, lozenge, capsules, tincture, cream, infused cookies, chocolate, marshmallow bars, gummies, cheek pouches, and inhalers.
As a mid way point there are a thousand vape options too, but some do have a smell.

Truetoself · 11/11/2026 13:25

cannabis induced psychosis is little talked about but real……

HoppityBun · 11/11/2026 13:41

DewDropsAndCobWebs · 11/11/2026 13:21

I think you all are forgetting cannabis doesn't need to be smoked.
We have it in drinks, pill, lozenge, capsules, tincture, cream, infused cookies, chocolate, marshmallow bars, gummies, cheek pouches, and inhalers.
As a mid way point there are a thousand vape options too, but some do have a smell.

Edited

I don’t know if you understand what you’re talking about. The products you list contain CBD. The constituent that has psychoactive effects is THC, which cannot lawfully be included in those products.

Metalmotha · 11/11/2026 13:56

Christ alive. It’s like some people don’t even have google to do the most simplistic of searches.

Having a point is part of British culture! Weed is far from harmless.

keep our pubs open serving alcohol.

Savenny · 11/11/2026 14:00

pinck · 10/11/2026 23:50

Lol, you’re being a little dramatic. I remember Times Square smelling strongly ofweed on my first visit after legalization—which I only walk through to get to the theaters—but not really anywhere else and hardly at all on subsequent trips. I also live in Chicago where it’s legal too, and never smell it (even when I'm smoking it so you’d think you’d had to crawl through a dispensary to reach your hotel.

We went to New York last year. I was really struck by the strong smell of cannabis everywhere. I live and work in London and I’m not hit by the smell of cannabis everywhere in the centre. It was a real eye-opener.

And my NY friend said the use of cannabis there had gone up hugely and she commented on it too.

Yourchildrenwillbegiants · 11/11/2026 14:26

HRTQueen · 10/11/2026 23:04

I do not think it will be long before we legalise cannabis the only positive is the revenue and that you can buy different strains where as much of what is sold has very high levels of thc

but we can’t make comparisons as far more people drink regularly than smoke cannabis regularly

and what we are aware of is seeing an ever increasing number of young people being treated for drug induced psychosis and often ongoing mh issues and it’s nearly always cannabis

and while it become legal in many countries the increase in drug use and issues around drug use has also increased how will that be managed

I hope you are wrong. Legalising cannabis is a terrible idea.

DewDropsAndCobWebs · 11/11/2026 15:01

@HoppityBun yes you can, where it is legal, like here in Canada, as I posted further yup thread.
Each dose contains between 0 to 10 mg THC, as per regulations. You are allowed to purchase multiple packs, but are limited to 30 grams total

schnubbins · 11/11/2026 16:28

Cannabis is antisocial and stinks like cat-piss .Cant believe we used to think cigarette smoke stank .It does but cannabis permeates everything and makes me feel ill.
It is destroying the mental health of many young people especially boys and I know through seeing it in many of my two young adult son's peers who are now dealing with psychosis , depression and in one case Schizophrenia.All leading back to cannabis use in their teenage years .My own son's say that going to some party now is a waste of time as so many are stoned out of their minds and completely boring. I have heard many of their peers saying the same
The effect on the aging brain should also be noted ,memory loss with some folk only having up to ten clear memories of their lifetime (heavy users )

mcmuffin22 · 11/11/2026 17:03

pointythings · 11/11/2026 13:12

There's also the question of whether the cannabis is causal in such cases or whether it's a symptom, I.e. the user self medicating with it.

Could you not say that about every substance legal or illegal?

I can absolutely guarantee you that cannabis does not chill this guy out. It makes him paranoid and makes him verbally and physically abusive towards his mum who has to leave her own house when he is having a psychotic episode.

EdgyNewt · 11/11/2026 17:09

schnubbins · 11/11/2026 16:28

Cannabis is antisocial and stinks like cat-piss .Cant believe we used to think cigarette smoke stank .It does but cannabis permeates everything and makes me feel ill.
It is destroying the mental health of many young people especially boys and I know through seeing it in many of my two young adult son's peers who are now dealing with psychosis , depression and in one case Schizophrenia.All leading back to cannabis use in their teenage years .My own son's say that going to some party now is a waste of time as so many are stoned out of their minds and completely boring. I have heard many of their peers saying the same
The effect on the aging brain should also be noted ,memory loss with some folk only having up to ten clear memories of their lifetime (heavy users )

^This!

Cannabis is one of the most antisocial drugs.

It absolutely stinks. It should absolutely NOT be smoked in a household with children, but it also smells really bad when smoked outside. Perhaps climb inside a wheely bin with the lid shut and smoke it if you're that desperate??

My SIL uses it and has such bad paranoia due to prolonged use.

And it turns most users into the most dull and boring zombies! Except they seem to think they're the most interesting people...

Cuttertheduck · 11/11/2026 17:11

EmeraldShamrock000 · 11/11/2026 08:19

I disagree. Regular popular cannibas use is a new thing. It wasn’t as accessible twenty or forty years ago. How many families twenty or forty years ago had an alcoholic or three within the wider family.
Anything done to excess food, alcohol and drugs have to potential to be an all consuming addiction.
8% of users approx will suffer from weed addiction disorder. Likewise there will always be people who enjoy a drink occasionally and others who knocks one back in the morning.
It has a lot to do with personality types.

It is 23% for alcoholism. Korsakoff syndrome via constant alcohol consumption can cause long term brain damage .
Also alcohol withdrawal or poisoning can lead to hallucinations, black outs and death.
Cannabis addiction can be seriously damaging, but it has a much lower direct fatality risk than alcohol addiction.

Cuttertheduck · 11/11/2026 17:16

EdgyNewt · 11/11/2026 17:09

^This!

Cannabis is one of the most antisocial drugs.

It absolutely stinks. It should absolutely NOT be smoked in a household with children, but it also smells really bad when smoked outside. Perhaps climb inside a wheely bin with the lid shut and smoke it if you're that desperate??

My SIL uses it and has such bad paranoia due to prolonged use.

And it turns most users into the most dull and boring zombies! Except they seem to think they're the most interesting people...

Alcohol leads to more domestic violence, road accidents and premature deaths.
I think I take the smell over those effects.

pointythings · 11/11/2026 17:19

mcmuffin22 · 11/11/2026 17:03

Could you not say that about every substance legal or illegal?

I can absolutely guarantee you that cannabis does not chill this guy out. It makes him paranoid and makes him verbally and physically abusive towards his mum who has to leave her own house when he is having a psychotic episode.

You could, but it's difficult to separate cause and effect. Alcohol killed my husband and my mum. When I started opening up about my husband's alcohol addiction, it was shocking how many people I spoke to knew at least one person who was also an alcoholic.

And of course prohibiting something doesn't stop people from using it - it just enriches criminals and means that what you buy isn't subject to quality control. If you look at countries that pursue policies of regulation, harm reduction and treating addiction as a medical issue rather than a criminal one, they tend go have better outcomes.

Lastly, I have a DS who suffers from chronic pain. When we were in Canada a few weeks ago, he used edibles on both nights that he had the opportunity. Result: a pain free night's sleep. He could get that here, but he would have to leap through so many hoops, and the cost would be prohibitive. We need to find a better balance.

pointythings · 11/11/2026 17:20

EdgyNewt · 11/11/2026 17:09

^This!

Cannabis is one of the most antisocial drugs.

It absolutely stinks. It should absolutely NOT be smoked in a household with children, but it also smells really bad when smoked outside. Perhaps climb inside a wheely bin with the lid shut and smoke it if you're that desperate??

My SIL uses it and has such bad paranoia due to prolonged use.

And it turns most users into the most dull and boring zombies! Except they seem to think they're the most interesting people...

You don't have to smoke it. Edibles do not smell at all.

HRTQueen · 11/11/2026 17:30

Cuttertheduck · 11/11/2026 17:16

Alcohol leads to more domestic violence, road accidents and premature deaths.
I think I take the smell over those effects.

Far less people are smoking cannabis regularly than drinking alcohol regularly so the points you make are not so clear cut

paranoia is very often a side effect of smoking cannabis paranoia often leads to an increase in violent behaviour

far more young people are being admitted to psychiatric wards due to cannabis use than any other substance and people with ongoing mh issues life expectancy is lower

Wopple · 11/11/2026 17:32

Cuttertheduck · 11/11/2026 17:16

Alcohol leads to more domestic violence, road accidents and premature deaths.
I think I take the smell over those effects.

If everyone swapped alcohol to cannabis I don’t think that would eradicate drug induced violence or car accidents. Someone who is going to drink drive will likely drug drive.