Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think cannabis should be legalized and alcohol made illegal at the same time?

218 replies

OonaStubbs · 10/11/2026 22:23

It would solve so many problems. The tax revenue lost by not being levied on alcohol sales could be levied on cannabis. It would massively reduce the violence and conflict caused by drunkenness and whilst increased cannabis use would undoubtedly cause some problems, it is far less destructive.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wadsworthy · Today 17:17

Prohibition never works. Look at the "War on Drugs."

I quite like the occasional gin & tonic. I cannot stand cannabis, and the effect it has on me. Half a puff 40 years ago was more than enough for me.

XenoBitch · Today 17:16

OonaStubbs · Today 00:38

People make their own crack cocaine. It doesn't follow that those drugs should be legal. Fewer people would die or have health problems from alcohol if was banned than currently do. Particularly when they could easily buy legal cannabis, it wouldn't be like prohibition in the 30s when alcohol was banned and people had nothing to replace it with. IMO it is a brilliant idea and definitely something that Andy Burnham should seriously consider.

Note that I would not advocate banning alcohol immediately, there would be a few years notice so that breweries, pubs etc could adjust their business strategies and convert to cannabis.

I have no interest in cannabis at all. But I like alcohol.

BunkBedsArePeopleShelves · Today 08:56

morningspa · 10/11/2026 22:28

The USA has already tried the banning of alcohol, look up Prohibition in the USA (1920-1933). It just went underground and didn’t reduce violence.

People drank more than ever, in fact. .
Banning alcohol would help nothing at all.

pointythings · Today 08:55

OonaStubbs · Today 00:38

People make their own crack cocaine. It doesn't follow that those drugs should be legal. Fewer people would die or have health problems from alcohol if was banned than currently do. Particularly when they could easily buy legal cannabis, it wouldn't be like prohibition in the 30s when alcohol was banned and people had nothing to replace it with. IMO it is a brilliant idea and definitely something that Andy Burnham should seriously consider.

Note that I would not advocate banning alcohol immediately, there would be a few years notice so that breweries, pubs etc could adjust their business strategies and convert to cannabis.

Making your own crack is significantly more difficult and dangerous than making your own booze, and the number of drinkers us exponentially larger than the number of cracked users. The death toll from home distilling errors would be high. I favour regulating cannabis, but I don't think banning alcohol would be helpful.

OonaStubbs · Today 00:38

pointythings · 14/11/2026 09:37

Oona, if you banned alcohol, people would make their own. That would include distilled alcohol, i.e. spirits. The problem is that distilling is a highly skilled process, and if you get it wrong you end up with methanol, not ethanol. Methanol kills people - look up events in Laos in 2024 where young people died from drinking bootleg fake alcohol. So the alcohol might not be stronger, but it would be potentially dangerous.

As mentioned many times on this thread, Canada regulates weed. You know what you're getting and it's quality controlled. I get that the smoke smells bad, I agree with that - but you can get properly dosed gummies. My DS had two completely pain free nights while we were over there because of those, and that was for the first time since he turned 18. He's 23, so think on that.

A prohibitionist approach doesn't work, has never worked, will never work. We need common sense solutions based around harm reduction and regulation.

People make their own crack cocaine. It doesn't follow that those drugs should be legal. Fewer people would die or have health problems from alcohol if was banned than currently do. Particularly when they could easily buy legal cannabis, it wouldn't be like prohibition in the 30s when alcohol was banned and people had nothing to replace it with. IMO it is a brilliant idea and definitely something that Andy Burnham should seriously consider.

Note that I would not advocate banning alcohol immediately, there would be a few years notice so that breweries, pubs etc could adjust their business strategies and convert to cannabis.

OP posts:
spongebunnyfatpants · Yesterday 23:00

No thanks, I don't want to walk around with everywhere stinking of weed. It's absolutely disgusting.

pointythings · 14/11/2026 09:37

OonaStubbs · 14/11/2026 08:22

Why? Do people at the moment drink alcohol that is illegal and stronger than what is sold legally in shops?

Oona, if you banned alcohol, people would make their own. That would include distilled alcohol, i.e. spirits. The problem is that distilling is a highly skilled process, and if you get it wrong you end up with methanol, not ethanol. Methanol kills people - look up events in Laos in 2024 where young people died from drinking bootleg fake alcohol. So the alcohol might not be stronger, but it would be potentially dangerous.

As mentioned many times on this thread, Canada regulates weed. You know what you're getting and it's quality controlled. I get that the smoke smells bad, I agree with that - but you can get properly dosed gummies. My DS had two completely pain free nights while we were over there because of those, and that was for the first time since he turned 18. He's 23, so think on that.

A prohibitionist approach doesn't work, has never worked, will never work. We need common sense solutions based around harm reduction and regulation.

OonaStubbs · 14/11/2026 08:22

XenoBitch · 14/11/2026 01:27

No, there would still be illegal and stronger weed.

Why? Do people at the moment drink alcohol that is illegal and stronger than what is sold legally in shops?

OP posts:
manicmania · 14/11/2026 08:14

SalmonandCreamCheeseLibertyBagelPlease · 10/11/2026 22:34

It also legalised cannabis in 2021 and after a recent trip to New York I couldn’t believe the pungent stench of weed most places we went to, it was disgusting. In fact all the amazing things we did there the main thing that sticks in my head is the smell of weed! 😳

it’s awful isn’t it? I felt ill because the smell was so pungent.

I would be interested to know if there’s been a rise in psychosis, paranoia and other mental health problems in NYC since cannabis was legalised.

Just to say I know of 5 people (2 teens) whose use of cannabis triggered mental health crisis - 2 ended up in secure units for a time and all find everyday life overwhelming.

Lhori · 14/11/2026 06:05

RaggedRocks · 10/11/2026 22:43

If it was legal, users would be vaping it, less stinky.

Why does it stink so much in the US then?

Missey85 · 14/11/2026 05:51

FlowerMug · 10/11/2026 22:35

I don't want to spend time with people who are plastered but lightly drunk is still a pleasant social thing, whereas lightly stoned people are boring AF.
For the sake of sociability I choose booze.

You probably think your a joy to be around drunk but I'm sure there are people that just see a drunk 🤣🤣🤣

XenoBitch · 14/11/2026 01:27

OonaStubbs · 14/11/2026 01:15

If weed was legal it would be easier to control the strength and potency of it.

No, there would still be illegal and stronger weed.

OonaStubbs · 14/11/2026 01:15

If weed was legal it would be easier to control the strength and potency of it.

OP posts:
pinck · 13/11/2026 18:08

mcmuffin22 · 13/11/2026 17:56

The OP's thread title includes the banning of alcohol.

Okay, then take that up with the OP. Everyone knows the UK is never going to ban alcohol. I was talking about how people actually use alcohol and weed now.

mcmuffin22 · 13/11/2026 17:56

pinck · 13/11/2026 15:26

Um, who said anything about banning alcohol? I’m talking about how people actually use both, and you’ve jumped straight to a hypothetical alcohol ban where everyone suddenly starts smoking high-potency weed several times a day. Yes, alcohol use is more common. And yes, people would still drink if it were illegal, just as people already use cannabis where it’s illegal. We agree on that part. What I’m asking is how you got from there to being so sure that cannabis use would be excessive and that those same people would “likely” be drinking excessively too. Where did that last bit even come from?

I genuinely don’t know a single person who sits down to smoke multiple times a day the way you’re describing. The people I know generally have a hit or two in the evening. Some might take a couple of hits spaced out over the day. If you want to call that “multiple times daily,” fine, but how much they’re actually using matters. You’re willing to distinguish someone having a glass of wine with dinner from someone drinking heavily every night. Can we apply that same basic logic to weed, please? And what is the prison population supposed to tell us about the person taking two hits after dinner? You’ve skipped about six steps there.

If you think I was being unfair by comparing occasional cannabis use with heavy drinking, fair enough. Compare occasional use of both, then compare heavy use of both. But you went straight from “you’re comparing different levels of use” to comparing someone having a glass of wine with dinner to someone using high-potency weed repeatedly anddrinking excessively. How are you going to tell me my comparison is unfair and then give your weed smoker a second substance problem halfway through yours?

The OP's thread title includes the banning of alcohol.

pinck · 13/11/2026 15:26

Portmore · 13/11/2026 10:00

Alcohol use is far higher than cannabis use in both the US & UK.

If you banned alcohol & legalized cannabis you would have greater cannabis use & greater excessive use - psychosis, paranoia & other mental illnesses are factors in criminality (about 90% of prison population has mental illness)

There would still be problem alcohol use as many people would continue to use it illegally. (Cannabis being illegal does not stop it being used)

Your argument is flawed in so many ways. You are trying to compare occasional.cannabis use with heavy drinking alcoholism but failing to look at the reverse - occasional alcohol use ( the majority of the population) compared with daily , or multiple times daily high potency cannabis use which would likely still come with excessive alcohol use.

Um, who said anything about banning alcohol? I’m talking about how people actually use both, and you’ve jumped straight to a hypothetical alcohol ban where everyone suddenly starts smoking high-potency weed several times a day. Yes, alcohol use is more common. And yes, people would still drink if it were illegal, just as people already use cannabis where it’s illegal. We agree on that part. What I’m asking is how you got from there to being so sure that cannabis use would be excessive and that those same people would “likely” be drinking excessively too. Where did that last bit even come from?

I genuinely don’t know a single person who sits down to smoke multiple times a day the way you’re describing. The people I know generally have a hit or two in the evening. Some might take a couple of hits spaced out over the day. If you want to call that “multiple times daily,” fine, but how much they’re actually using matters. You’re willing to distinguish someone having a glass of wine with dinner from someone drinking heavily every night. Can we apply that same basic logic to weed, please? And what is the prison population supposed to tell us about the person taking two hits after dinner? You’ve skipped about six steps there.

If you think I was being unfair by comparing occasional cannabis use with heavy drinking, fair enough. Compare occasional use of both, then compare heavy use of both. But you went straight from “you’re comparing different levels of use” to comparing someone having a glass of wine with dinner to someone using high-potency weed repeatedly anddrinking excessively. How are you going to tell me my comparison is unfair and then give your weed smoker a second substance problem halfway through yours?

Lincslady53 · 13/11/2026 10:56

Well. Our son has spent the last 3 years in hell, through drug induced paranoia, caused by his cannabis use while at Uni. 3 months in a secure unit, then needing drugs and support to help him get through. He has done really well to get, and hold down a job for 2 years now, but minimum wage and if the pressure starts to rise he gets panic attacks. It is awful. I would go the other way and really clamp down on cannabis use, particularly with younger people whose brains are still developing

Churchbell · 13/11/2026 10:50

I don't think I could bear the stink of more cannabis everywhere.

Portmore · 13/11/2026 10:00

pinck · 13/11/2026 00:18

“It’s fundamentally a food” is a very generous way of describing what people are doing with tequila shots at midnight. I’m sure they’re all thinking about preserving the harvest. Plenty of people drink without getting drunk, sure. People also use cannabis without getting obliterated and if nutritional value is the test for what adults should be allowed to enjoy, I have some bad news for the liquor aisle.

And since we’re comparing harms, I’d be interested in how often alcohol and cannabis are involved in murder, sexual assault, and other violent crimes. The U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics has documented alcohol involvement in a substantial share of violent crime. I haven’t found an equivalent count for cannabis that would make for a fair comparison. And where you live, what are you basing “cannabis-impaired driving is more common” on? Are those actual impairment figures, or are you counting everyone who tested positive for THC? That seems like a detail worth clearing up before we give alcohol a pass for being historically useful to farmers.

Alcohol use is far higher than cannabis use in both the US & UK.

If you banned alcohol & legalized cannabis you would have greater cannabis use & greater excessive use - psychosis, paranoia & other mental illnesses are factors in criminality (about 90% of prison population has mental illness)

There would still be problem alcohol use as many people would continue to use it illegally. (Cannabis being illegal does not stop it being used)

Your argument is flawed in so many ways. You are trying to compare occasional.cannabis use with heavy drinking alcoholism but failing to look at the reverse - occasional alcohol use ( the majority of the population) compared with daily , or multiple times daily high potency cannabis use which would likely still come with excessive alcohol use.

pinck · 13/11/2026 00:18

TempestTost · 12/11/2026 22:43

Alcohol can cause serious issues. However, many people drink it with no issues and without even becoming buzzed. And it's fundamentally a food. Allowing or causing fermentation is a way to preserve the harvest, and a more important one than a lot of modern people realise.

Weed OTOH, while it has medicinal use, recreational use is only to get a buzz on. And it has no nutritional value.

It's also more dangerous than a lot of people realise. Which might not be so bad if people treated it accordingly, but for some reason they don't. It's legal where I live and driving under the influence of cannabis is now more common that with alcohol.

“It’s fundamentally a food” is a very generous way of describing what people are doing with tequila shots at midnight. I’m sure they’re all thinking about preserving the harvest. Plenty of people drink without getting drunk, sure. People also use cannabis without getting obliterated and if nutritional value is the test for what adults should be allowed to enjoy, I have some bad news for the liquor aisle.

And since we’re comparing harms, I’d be interested in how often alcohol and cannabis are involved in murder, sexual assault, and other violent crimes. The U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics has documented alcohol involvement in a substantial share of violent crime. I haven’t found an equivalent count for cannabis that would make for a fair comparison. And where you live, what are you basing “cannabis-impaired driving is more common” on? Are those actual impairment figures, or are you counting everyone who tested positive for THC? That seems like a detail worth clearing up before we give alcohol a pass for being historically useful to farmers.

pinck · 13/11/2026 00:11

Portmore · 12/11/2026 22:22

Regarding mental health & cannabis use, try this systematic review & meta analysis

Gobbi, G., Atkin, T., Zytynski, T., Wang, S., Askari, S., Boruff, J., Ware, M., Marmorstein, N., Cipriani, A., Dendukuri, N., & Mayo, N. (2019). Association of cannabis use in adolescence and risk of depression, anxiety, and suicidality in young adulthood: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Psychiatry, 76(4), 426–434. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2018.4500 �

For psychosis, try this one. Found 3.2 times the odds of psychotic disorder in occasional, low potency cannabis use rising to 4.8 times in high potency, daily use

Di Forti, M., Quattrone, D., Freeman, T. P., Tripoli, G., Gayer-Anderson, C., Quigley, H., Rodriguez, V., Jongsma, H. E., Ferraro, L., La Cascia, C., La Barbera, D., Tarricone, I., Berardi, D., Szöke, A., Arango, C., Tortelli, A., Velthorst, E., Bernardo, M., Del-Ben, C. M., … Murray, R. M. (2019). The contribution of cannabis use to variation in the incidence of psychotic disorder across Europe (EU-GEI): A multicentre case-control study. The Lancet Psychiatry, 6(5), 427–436.

And your references?

Reid’s paper is a review and the “one joint equals 2.5–5 cigarettes” figure comes from a study of airflow obstruction. You can’t swap in “cancer” and keep the number and “one joint” as a unit in a paper doesn’t mean everyone smokes a whole one every time they light up. For example, my dad’s been smoking weed since he was a teenager. He takes what he calls “one guys” (a single hit) a few times throughout the day and I don’t think I’ve ever seen him or anyone else smoke a whole joint in one sitting. That’s why I asked how much each group actually smoked. Karimi’s pooled cohort studies found an association with lung cancer and the pooled case-control studies were inconclusive. The authors also flagged the difficulty of accounting for tobacco use. Which result shows that cannabis smokers get cancer more often than cigarette smokers?

And as for psychosis, Di Forti’s 3.2 times the odds was for daily use overall compared with never using cannabis. The figures were 2.2 for daily low-potency use and 4.8 for daily high-potency use. You managed to copy the entire author list and somehow lose the word daily. Gobbi’s review looked at adolescent use and later depression, anxiety, and suicidality and since you asked for my references, my dad is doing extremely well. Undoubtedly better than your dad, lol. Feel free to cite that as a finding from the Royal College of My Dad Could Beat Up Your Dad.

TempestTost · 12/11/2026 22:43

Alcohol can cause serious issues. However, many people drink it with no issues and without even becoming buzzed. And it's fundamentally a food. Allowing or causing fermentation is a way to preserve the harvest, and a more important one than a lot of modern people realise.

Weed OTOH, while it has medicinal use, recreational use is only to get a buzz on. And it has no nutritional value.

It's also more dangerous than a lot of people realise. Which might not be so bad if people treated it accordingly, but for some reason they don't. It's legal where I live and driving under the influence of cannabis is now more common that with alcohol.

Portmore · 12/11/2026 22:22

pinck · 12/11/2026 20:54

Yes, I’m comfortable reading scientific papers, thanks for checking. The difficult part is reading one you haven’t linked. You managed to answer exactly zero of my questions, which is impressive considering I now know how an entire conference room felt about legalization. Did the study actually find higher cancer rates in cannabis smokers than in cigarette smokers? How much was each group smoking, and did the researchers account for people who smoked both? Even if people take deeper drags or hold them longer, a hit or two in the evening and twenty cigarettes a day are very different habits. I know people who smoke weed and cigarettes, but I don’t know anyone who mixes tobacco into their weed. Either way, if people in the study used both, that’s exactly why I’m asking how the researchers accounted for tobacco.

And lol, “the overlap is huge” between cannabis use and what, specifically? Which diagnosis, how frequent was the cannabis use, and huge compared to what? You’ve managed to give me a second claim to ask for a source for while I’m still waiting on the first.

Regarding mental health & cannabis use, try this systematic review & meta analysis

Gobbi, G., Atkin, T., Zytynski, T., Wang, S., Askari, S., Boruff, J., Ware, M., Marmorstein, N., Cipriani, A., Dendukuri, N., & Mayo, N. (2019). Association of cannabis use in adolescence and risk of depression, anxiety, and suicidality in young adulthood: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Psychiatry, 76(4), 426–434. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2018.4500 �

For psychosis, try this one. Found 3.2 times the odds of psychotic disorder in occasional, low potency cannabis use rising to 4.8 times in high potency, daily use

Di Forti, M., Quattrone, D., Freeman, T. P., Tripoli, G., Gayer-Anderson, C., Quigley, H., Rodriguez, V., Jongsma, H. E., Ferraro, L., La Cascia, C., La Barbera, D., Tarricone, I., Berardi, D., Szöke, A., Arango, C., Tortelli, A., Velthorst, E., Bernardo, M., Del-Ben, C. M., … Murray, R. M. (2019). The contribution of cannabis use to variation in the incidence of psychotic disorder across Europe (EU-GEI): A multicentre case-control study. The Lancet Psychiatry, 6(5), 427–436.

And your references?

Portmore · 12/11/2026 22:04

pinck · 12/11/2026 20:54

Yes, I’m comfortable reading scientific papers, thanks for checking. The difficult part is reading one you haven’t linked. You managed to answer exactly zero of my questions, which is impressive considering I now know how an entire conference room felt about legalization. Did the study actually find higher cancer rates in cannabis smokers than in cigarette smokers? How much was each group smoking, and did the researchers account for people who smoked both? Even if people take deeper drags or hold them longer, a hit or two in the evening and twenty cigarettes a day are very different habits. I know people who smoke weed and cigarettes, but I don’t know anyone who mixes tobacco into their weed. Either way, if people in the study used both, that’s exactly why I’m asking how the researchers accounted for tobacco.

And lol, “the overlap is huge” between cannabis use and what, specifically? Which diagnosis, how frequent was the cannabis use, and huge compared to what? You’ve managed to give me a second claim to ask for a source for while I’m still waiting on the first.

“Cannabis and the lung” by P. T. Reid, J. Macleod and J. R. Robertson. It was published in December 2010 in the Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh, 40(4), 328–334. DOI

The “one joint was comparable to 2.5–5 tobacco cigarettes” figure that was quoted in the paper was Sarah Aldington et al. (2007), “Effects of cannabis on pulmonary structure, function and symptoms,” Thorax, 62(12), 1058–1063

There's a recent meta analysis that references both papers.:

Karimi, M., Kazemi, K., Pourhanifeh, M. H., Irajian, P., & Asbaghi, O. (2026). Marijuana (cannabis) smoking increases the risk of lung cancer: Evidence from a systematic review and meta-analysis. Addiction & Health, 18, Article 1710.

pinck · 12/11/2026 20:54

Portmore · 12/11/2026 20:28

The study was completed in Scotland around 2012 & published in a Respiratory medicine journal. The author gave a presentation to The Royal college of psychiatrists conference which I remember. I can probably dig out the reference you are comfortable reading scientific papers.

The precise reasons were not clear but it was thought that cannabis smokers inhale more deeply, tend to breath hold as they smoke & are less likely to use filters when they smoke which then increases the amount of cancer causing chemicals reaching the lungs. Burning cannabis (both natural & synthetic) is similar to burning tobacco & releases carcinogens. Cannabis & tobacco are often mixed & smoked together meaning more harmful carcinogens.

The overlap between severe mental illness & cannabis use is huge & also well studied.

There was not one person at that conference who thought legalizing cannabis was a good idea

Yes, I’m comfortable reading scientific papers, thanks for checking. The difficult part is reading one you haven’t linked. You managed to answer exactly zero of my questions, which is impressive considering I now know how an entire conference room felt about legalization. Did the study actually find higher cancer rates in cannabis smokers than in cigarette smokers? How much was each group smoking, and did the researchers account for people who smoked both? Even if people take deeper drags or hold them longer, a hit or two in the evening and twenty cigarettes a day are very different habits. I know people who smoke weed and cigarettes, but I don’t know anyone who mixes tobacco into their weed. Either way, if people in the study used both, that’s exactly why I’m asking how the researchers accounted for tobacco.

And lol, “the overlap is huge” between cannabis use and what, specifically? Which diagnosis, how frequent was the cannabis use, and huge compared to what? You’ve managed to give me a second claim to ask for a source for while I’m still waiting on the first.