Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To actually feel a bit sorry for men who grew up in the 90s/00s?

214 replies

fetchmycatsocks · 10/11/2026 14:47

I've NC because I feel this is a bit of a controversial opinion

But AIBU to actually feel a bit sorry for men who grew up in the era of Nuts/Zoo/'Shagger of the Year' awards? Whatever their characters, they weren't encouraged to believe that consent should be unequivocally sought and given. They had awful men feted by the media as role models. Awful behaviour towards women was celebrated and joked about, on TV, in magazines, everywhere. I can remember as a teenager really having no clue about what my 'rights' were as a woman around consent, etc - absolutely nobody ever spelled it out to me, or to the girls and boys around me.

I guess I'm asking AIBU to feel a bit sad that men who grew up in that era probably did have a bit of a tricky time working out how to be men?

To be very clear, I absolutely believe that all the decent boys and men worked it out fine for themselves. I just think - kids look to the world to learn how to be, and the world we grew up in taught us some really crap things when it came to this

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 11/11/2026 07:16

JenniferBooth · 10/11/2026 22:53

More was where i learnt about the abolition of the wages councils and how it lead to poverty pay 1994

Discrimination against lesbian mothers I remember Sandi Toksvig being in the article 1995.

More was a magazine about sex, clubbing, fashion and things like that. They might have had one serious article a fortnight. Maybe.

ZenNudist · 11/11/2026 07:18

No one needs a magazine or a TV show tell them.not to rape.

Lexibletheflexible · 11/11/2026 07:20

itsnotkooking · 10/11/2026 22:52

I agree to some extent. There were some boundaries that I think everyone was taught and understood even if a lot of men went on to ignore them in practice because they were terrible people (although many presented as good people, good friends and latterly good fathers etc - sadly you genuinely can't always tell who the bad ones are). Anyone would have been able to tell you that "no means no" if they were quizzed on their understanding of consent.

But there were other areas which weren't so clear. Regarding Brand, there are multiple examples of him committing sexual assault (or what could be argued to be sexual assault - some of these cases ended up in court and others didn't) in public places with those around him at the time (victims and bystanders), responding with laughter and seeming to finding it all hilarious (whether or not they actually did find it hilarious). And this is where I do have some sympathy with children/teens growing up and witnessing similar - I wouldn't have blamed a "minor" growing up and watching adults behaving as if it was all just so funny when these things happened, for not understanding that this was assault and could carry a jail term (not saying there were minors around Brand). And if these types of incident continued to happen as they themselves became adults I can also understand why they might see no harm in joining in (especially if the main perpetrators were popular amongst their peer group and with the opposite sex). What other serious crimes would people respond to in this way? If a non-sexual assault occurred in these situations the police would likely be called and nobody would be laughing. The person might lose their job. People make the point that the good ones work it out but I do think it's possible that a small number of people who genuinely meant no harm have ended up in trouble in very young adulthood, before they were able to work it out.

That said, I have no sympathy for Brand who I think was unambiguously a predator who knew he was doing great harm and belongs in jail.

Exactly. Nobody can say this wasnt happening because we have numerous examples of it through him.

Lexibletheflexible · 11/11/2026 07:21

EveningSpread · 10/11/2026 16:28

Well no, of course I can’t. But I know plenty of men who grew up in the specified time period who are perfectly decent men, who aren’t confused about consent because of “the times”.

I think there are perfectly decent men of every generation, so I’m just not as sympathetic to the idea of “different times” as an excuse as I used to be.

Again, this thing with "Ben is a really nice guy, he painted my shed, no way would he do that if he was also sexually coercive to women he dates".

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · 11/11/2026 07:25

Or because hes a pillar of the community, runs the local football club, is a vicar, an alderman, councillor or other Elder-type.

Lexibletheflexible · 11/11/2026 07:27

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · 11/11/2026 07:25

Or because hes a pillar of the community, runs the local football club, is a vicar, an alderman, councillor or other Elder-type.

"Last week I saw him push a toddler on a swing... definitely not a rapist".

PaisleyElephant · 11/11/2026 07:28

But lots of societal attitudes have changed. There was much more 'casual racism' back in the 70s or 80s, e.g. in the use of language to talk about/describe people from different ethnic backgrounds, even in the absence of those people holding racist views.

Same with homophobic language and attitudes, particularly during the AIDS crisis.

People become better informed and how language is used changes.

It's the same with the lads culture. Times change. People need to move with the times.

Not everyone was like that at the time either. Plenty of alternative role models and men who treat people with respect.

I agree with the PPs pointing out that the current Andrew Tate culture is far more damaging.

Persephonia1966 · 11/11/2026 08:08

Apotofrealcoffee · 10/11/2026 19:52

Yes it’s an uncomfortable topic to broach but I was at secondary in the 2000s and honestly unless you were there the sexual ‘culture’ is impossible to convey.

Boys were very publicly ‘accused’ of being gay and ridiculed unless they had lost their virginity by 16, and done some other stuff before then. There was a strong hierarchical system within boys and their friendship groups where the most popular ones were the ones who were having sex earliest and with the best looking girls. Nuts, ZOO, FHM, primitive porn websites, Playboy, page 3, all rammed down your throat. Then just general promiscuity lauded by programs like Skins.

The chat was constantly about sex, which is why The Inbetweeners was so popular and realistic. Everyone could relate to it.

Parents were very ‘hands off’ by then, it became trendy and normal to allow your teenage child as sex life and to turn a blind eye to them getting up to god knows what with no curfews. No AirTags back then, it was very easy to creep about and do what you liked.

There was a sexual health clinic down the road from our schools which girls were in & out of like a revolving door, getting the morning after pill.

As PP said, I don’t think I even heard the word ‘consent’ until at least 2012 and more like 2015. Rape was only rape if a stranger dragged you off the street, sexual assault was casual and often and people laughed.

Truly I think anyone who wasn’t a teenager between 1995-2010 won’t really get it. I know the eras before must’ve had their moments but it was something else entirely.

I do feel a bit sorry for the boys. And even more so for the girls. Ultimately they were bullied senseless if they didn’t present as red blooded and constantly up for it. It’s all very well judging them by today’s standards but it really was such a different time, albeit only 20 years ago.

But Russel Brand and Williams were not teenage boys trying to fit in/make sense of the world. They were fully grown adult men at that point. Not even particularly young men at that point.
I think a big part of the "lad culture" was it was actually being heavily pushed by older men in newspapers (page 3 papers were owned by the likes of Murdoch, hardly a spring chicken and TV producers/the people behind Nuts etc weren't teenagers either). It turns out many of the celebrities responsible for pushing this behaviour as aspirational were predators themselves. Predatory men do seem to have a thing for trying to write the culture for younger men. Either because of a perverse need to replicate their abusiveness in others or because it provides cover for their behaviour

I agree culture matters. But in these cases the abusive men were the ones helping to create that culture. It didn't come out of the ether and they were not unknowing victims of it.

hettie · 11/11/2026 08:28

Culture and class matters. I was at one of Mumsnet's much fêted Russell Group universities in the eraly 90's. Consent was absolutely a thing, being a creep or sexual predator was socially unacceptable. There was a guy who was promiscuous and unfaithful and he was not well liked. The openly out there misogyny of the current Andrew Tate times looks like a massive back slide to me. Having said that i worked in TV in the 90's, misogyny was rife. Very few female directors in the sector i worked in (they were seen only to be fit for 'lifestyle' type programmes). The gender split between production assistants/production managers and the creatives was huge (guess who got paid more). I heard tales of assistant producers being assaulted and shouted at but never saw or experienced anything. The only out and out overt sexism i experienced in that perio was when I moved careers and the 'Relate' service manager (you know the relationship counsellor people) twithdrew a job offer after I told them I was pregnant. Literally told me at the end of an interview, when i mentioned I was pregnant, tried to withdraw the offer of a training contract because it's be emotional and flaky on return from maternity!

SoftIce · 11/11/2026 09:36

I was on TSR in the late 00s. Rape jokes were very common. Ten years later, they had moved on. To domestic violence jokes.

I have no sympathy for men whatsoever.

LumberPainJackie · 11/11/2026 09:38

Re your OP, the issue has always been poor men. Even now men can't figure out how to be decent men. When have they ever actually managed it?
I don't think they need or want our pity.

marbIes · 11/11/2026 19:37

Persephonia1966 · 11/11/2026 08:08

But Russel Brand and Williams were not teenage boys trying to fit in/make sense of the world. They were fully grown adult men at that point. Not even particularly young men at that point.
I think a big part of the "lad culture" was it was actually being heavily pushed by older men in newspapers (page 3 papers were owned by the likes of Murdoch, hardly a spring chicken and TV producers/the people behind Nuts etc weren't teenagers either). It turns out many of the celebrities responsible for pushing this behaviour as aspirational were predators themselves. Predatory men do seem to have a thing for trying to write the culture for younger men. Either because of a perverse need to replicate their abusiveness in others or because it provides cover for their behaviour

I agree culture matters. But in these cases the abusive men were the ones helping to create that culture. It didn't come out of the ether and they were not unknowing victims of it.

Well said! I'm genuinely repulsed by the lengths people will go to excuse the behaviour of grown men.

As a teenager, nobody had to sit me down and explain that stealing from shops was wrong. I understood that it was wrong, that I was responsible for my actions and that there would be consequences if I chose to do it. Nobody would have suggested that I couldn't possibly be expected to know better, or that my behaviour was somehow someone else's responsibility.

Yet when it comes to men, apparently the rules change. Suddenly we're drowning in explanations about their upbringing, hormones, impulses, lack of education or inability to understand boundaries. It's extraordinary how quickly personal accountability disappears when the perpetrator is male.

If a teenage girl can be expected to understand right from wrong, why are we constantly infantilising fully grown men? its repulsive 🙄

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 19:45

marbIes · 11/11/2026 19:37

Well said! I'm genuinely repulsed by the lengths people will go to excuse the behaviour of grown men.

As a teenager, nobody had to sit me down and explain that stealing from shops was wrong. I understood that it was wrong, that I was responsible for my actions and that there would be consequences if I chose to do it. Nobody would have suggested that I couldn't possibly be expected to know better, or that my behaviour was somehow someone else's responsibility.

Yet when it comes to men, apparently the rules change. Suddenly we're drowning in explanations about their upbringing, hormones, impulses, lack of education or inability to understand boundaries. It's extraordinary how quickly personal accountability disappears when the perpetrator is male.

If a teenage girl can be expected to understand right from wrong, why are we constantly infantilising fully grown men? its repulsive 🙄

I agree but I think making this a case of clear cut right and wrong, good people and bad people, while dismissing every single environmental or social factor as irrelevant, is a bit nonsensical.

Of course people are influenced by their environments, they’re not born either nice or nasty. This is why abused children are more likely to go on to abuse themselves. This is why men brought up in very misogynistic countries are more likely to be misogynists - it isn’t genetic that Afghan men oppress women, it’s a learned behaviour.

Yes, the sexual environment in the 1990s was peaked, this is why this period had the highest teenage pregnancy rates on record. In the 1970s and 80s there was still societal embarrassment and prudishness around sex in general - even being a single parent was frowned upon in the 1970s and generally parents saw their children as an indicator of their family standing, so were very embarrassed by a teenage pregnant daughter.

That seemed to change with a more #bekind mindset in the 90s - couples living together unmarried became more normal; then single parenthood became more normal; then having open sexual relationships at a much younger age became normal; and finally, with the advent of pornography and all disapproval lauded as ‘prudishness’, the ride broke with porn mags, page 3, glamour models, endless content in magazines about sex and sexual behaviour, teen fiction full of sex and teen pregnancy, countdowns to celebrities turning 16, one night stand ‘tell alla’, sleazy mags, footballers trying to be as womanising as possible, boob jobs, naked calendars, ‘top shaggers’… I mean I could go on.

So while it’s easy and convenient to just chalk all men up to good and bad regardless of the environment, I think this is a dangerous game to play as it ultimately makes women less safe by indicating there should be no controls on anything. If the environment has no effect then why bother making certain types of violent porn illegal? Why hide away massage parlours? Why make risqué websites strictly 18 and over? Why have an age of consent?

Of course the environment influences behaviour, and yes this did get worse with the avalanche of sex and objectification of women which, while has always been pervasive, actually became fashionable and encouraged.

The only turning point was around 2014 with ‘me too’, and now behaviour that was absolutely fine 20 years ago is hugely unacceptable.

TheAbsentRoyalUmberella · 11/11/2026 20:57

Op it's always been like this ! It didn't just start in the 90 or 2000!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page