Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think about claiming PIP in these circumstances?

148 replies

ATenFromShirley · 10/11/2026 12:31

I’ve NCd for this. I’m looking for some honest thoughts and opinions that I probably won’t get in real life.

I’m 34 and have MS. I tend to look ok (not to myself, but as in, you probably wouldn’t guess to look at me apart from on a very bad day). Lots of my symptoms are invisible: balance, muscle spasms, numbness, dizziness, and the worst of them all, fatigue.

I live with my parents, and I work full time. My parents do SO much for me, they do the food shop and all of the housework. I do pay my way (a third of everything, and a bit extra). I go to work, exercise twice a week and then crash at the weekends. I often won’t leave the sofa because I’m so exhausted. If I try to see friends etc, I’m done in for the next working week too. I truly can’t explain what the fatigue feels like- I’m so bone tired and brain foggy I’m tearful at the thought of another day ahead, even after nine hours sleep.

I desperately want to buy a house and have some independence, but I really can’t envisage being able to work full time and then do all of the life stuff that my parents currently are basically doing for me. I’ve realised I probably will never be able to have children (a whole other heartbreak in itself).

The thought of my life being as it is forever terrifies me. I feel like if I could work 3 days a week, I could still have 2 days for rest and be able to manage things like cooking and housework. But to do this financially, I’d have to look at PIP.

I think part of what makes this difficult is that I probably don't fit the stereotypical picture of someone who needs disability benefits. I work full time, I exercise twice a week, I look relatively well most of the time. I can do things, and I recognise that there are people with MS who are much more physically affected than I am.
But I also spend most of my non-working time recovering from the basics, and I rely heavily on my parents to do the things that make everyday life function.

I feel a bit stuck between two things. I don't feel disabled enough to justify asking for support, but I also know that I just can’t continue living like this indefinitely. I don't want to spend the next 30 years working full time, coming home exhausted and spending my weekends recovering. I want a home, independence, relationships, experiences and a life that isn't entirely dictated by how much energy I have left.

I suppose I'm asking whether reducing my working hours and potentially claiming PIP is a reasonable way of approaching this, or whether I'm being unrealistic and actually this is just what my life is going to look like. I also recognise that lots of people are exhausted from full time work!

I'd really appreciate honest opinions- I genuinely want to hear how other people see this, even if it's not necessarily what I want to hear. Thank you.

OP posts:
AuntiePettitoes · 10/11/2026 17:57

Of course you should claim Pip. You have a debilitating condition and probably tire easily. Can't believe some folk on here don't think you should get it.

Liverpoolery · 10/11/2026 17:58

I don’t know if you’ll get it OP, but if I were you I would apply and see what they say. You certainly sound to me as if you deserve it - and you’re sort of stuck in a catch 22. I understand the system is struggling and funds are limited but this is what it should be for imo

icecreamscreams · 10/11/2026 18:05

Passaggressfedup · 10/11/2026 14:47

This thread is showing exactly what is wrong with the system. Everyone wants more money, everyone think if X gets it, I should to.

Then, people tells you that if course you can get it as long as you know what to write and lie...

And then when we have threads about PIP being too easy to get, the government not being able to get, you get messages after messages going on about how hard it is to get it, that no one that can get on with next to a normal life could ever pass the eligibility test, and people who dare say they know someone who does gets vilified.

There is a section of people who are being totally missed who are well enough technically to work FT but unwell enough to not be able to do anything else

when I was struggling really badly with my condition, I nearly lost my job. I needed to cut my hours but as a single person couldn’t afford to. Was taking time off work due to excruciating pain that couldn’t be controlled and clung on to my job only as they knew I was waiting for an operation and trying my absolute best. I was working while on morphine regularly

on a bad week I go to work, come home, eat cereal and go to bed. On a good week I can exercise. I’m not bad enough for PIP but not well enough to function normally every week

dizzydizzydizzy · 10/11/2026 18:52

PAYE · 10/11/2026 14:15

Go ahead and apply but answer honestly and based on a typical day - not your worst day. So explain that you can cook a meal and work and basically live a normal life but get tired. If you get awarded it by answering honestly then fine.

Do not lie or exaggerate to claim points. That is fraud and theft and you are better than that.

That’s not what you are supposed to do. You describe your bad days and good days and tell them how many of each you have eg 20 bad days a month and 10 good days. A symptom diary is very useful for this.

ATenFromShirley · 10/11/2026 19:07

icecreamscreams · 10/11/2026 18:05

There is a section of people who are being totally missed who are well enough technically to work FT but unwell enough to not be able to do anything else

when I was struggling really badly with my condition, I nearly lost my job. I needed to cut my hours but as a single person couldn’t afford to. Was taking time off work due to excruciating pain that couldn’t be controlled and clung on to my job only as they knew I was waiting for an operation and trying my absolute best. I was working while on morphine regularly

on a bad week I go to work, come home, eat cereal and go to bed. On a good week I can exercise. I’m not bad enough for PIP but not well enough to function normally every week

This is exactly it.

There are some truly awful experiences shared on this thread. The system just isn’t fit for purpose. Thanks everyone for weighing in xx

OP posts:
stichguru · 10/11/2026 20:22

ATenFromShirley · 10/11/2026 12:56

This is exactly it. If I wrote it from the perspective of my worst days, I think I’d score points. But on good days (and without working 9-5) I absolutely can do everything on that list.

Surely though you write it as if you are working 9-5 because without PIP you WILL have to work and that WILL tire you and make you less capable of being independent, so you'll then need more paid help?

I have Cerebral Palsy. I work part-time. I manage this by having a professional job so part-time is still quite a decent wage, AND having a full time working husband also in a professional job. I couldn't work more though and without being able to rely on a husband for both some earnings and to do some house work etc, I'd be struggling and maybe need PIP like you do.

LordVoldetort · 10/11/2026 20:22

I have PIP for rheumatoid arthritis. I am ‘young’ for how severe it is, but to look at me you absolutely wouldn’t know.

I would apply if I were you, and base it on your worst days.
also, base your answers comparing yourself to someone without a disability because that’s the bench mark. Eg, my pain on a ‘normal day’ is probably 2-3 BUT if my husband experienced the same pain as a one off, it would probably be 7.

also, the one that got me for a long time was not thinking I used aids but I did. Eg, a step to get into the shower, a stool to sit on whilst I cooked etc.

Coconutter24 · 10/11/2026 20:27

ATenFromShirley · 10/11/2026 12:53

Thank you. I think the fear is really that if I can go to the gym or play badminton twice a week, I’m not eligible for the higher rate payments (and then I’d be living in fear about fraud!) But equally my neurologist has told me that exercise is crucial and I absolutely couldn’t manage it if I was doing everything else too.

If you currently work full time and go to the gym twice a week, why do you need two days off work and PIP to have your own house? Why can’t you work the full time you currently do, carry on with the gym that you are managing and pay your own way? If you’re alone and low income you may get UC to top you up.

icecreamscreams · 10/11/2026 20:35

Coconutter24 · 10/11/2026 20:27

If you currently work full time and go to the gym twice a week, why do you need two days off work and PIP to have your own house? Why can’t you work the full time you currently do, carry on with the gym that you are managing and pay your own way? If you’re alone and low income you may get UC to top you up.

she won’t get UC with a mortgage and no children even on min wage

Novjaro · 10/11/2026 20:35

Think a pp may have mentioned it but the questions also relate to whether you can do the tasks safely, reliably and repeatedly, which I’m sure would absolutely not be the case for someone with your health issues. Good luck OP.

Coconutter24 · 10/11/2026 20:59

icecreamscreams · 10/11/2026 20:35

she won’t get UC with a mortgage and no children even on min wage

You can claim UC even if you have a mortgage and even if you have no children you can claim it

ATenFromShirley · 10/11/2026 21:45

Coconutter24 · 10/11/2026 20:27

If you currently work full time and go to the gym twice a week, why do you need two days off work and PIP to have your own house? Why can’t you work the full time you currently do, carry on with the gym that you are managing and pay your own way? If you’re alone and low income you may get UC to top you up.

Because there’s no way I could cook/clean/do the washing/change the bedding/look after myself. At the moment I work FT, exercise twice and spend every evening and weekend lying horizontal to recover. The unfortunate reality is that I’m very reliant on my parents.

OP posts:
aCatCalledFawkes · 10/11/2026 21:49

icecreamscreams · 10/11/2026 20:35

she won’t get UC with a mortgage and no children even on min wage

I have a mortgage and claim UC. I’m hoping not for very long but you get a higher allowance before your payments decrease if don’t claim the housing element.
I have a friend who is single claiming it due to her business folding.

icecreamscreams · 10/11/2026 21:59

Coconutter24 · 10/11/2026 20:59

You can claim UC even if you have a mortgage and even if you have no children you can claim it

Well you can yes but OP would have to be on an incredibly low wage and wouldn’t get very much UC at all. Not enough to pay a mortgage and bills

icecreamscreams · 10/11/2026 22:09

aCatCalledFawkes · 10/11/2026 21:49

I have a mortgage and claim UC. I’m hoping not for very long but you get a higher allowance before your payments decrease if don’t claim the housing element.
I have a friend who is single claiming it due to her business folding.

I guess my point is that OP works FT and wants to buy a house
if she drops to 3 days, she’s not going to earn the same or more as FT by claiming even if she is eligible for UC which won’t allow her to buy a house
she can get what, £424? But she is likely to be found fit for work so that’s going to taper anyway

Pearlstillsinging · 10/11/2026 22:15

ATenFromShirley · 10/11/2026 12:56

This is exactly it. If I wrote it from the perspective of my worst days, I think I’d score points. But on good days (and without working 9-5) I absolutely can do everything on that list.

Please ask for help completing the form from Citizens Advice or a MS charity, PIP is intended to support people to ve able to work but you do need to word your answers in the 'right' way.

JaceLancs · 10/11/2026 22:43

I don’t know if it’s still the case but the last time I applied for a mortgage they would not take PIP into account as income

JaceLancs · 10/11/2026 22:44

On DLA I had a lifetime award but that was not counted towards mortgage income either
Good luck if you do decide to claim it’s an arduous process

eatreadsleeprepeat · 11/11/2026 00:40

ATenFromShirley · 10/11/2026 12:56

This is exactly it. If I wrote it from the perspective of my worst days, I think I’d score points. But on good days (and without working 9-5) I absolutely can do everything on that list.

Don’t use the best or worst days, use an average and the one that is most frequent. So if you have two or three less good days a week and four or five better then you need to use the better. You would need to prove mobility needs or care needs. If you genuinely would not be able to prepare a meal after working a full day then you say that. Give the picture of your capabilities, without any workarounds or aids you use.

WanderingWellies · 11/11/2026 11:03

ATenFromShirley · 10/11/2026 13:19

I totally get this, and I suppose that’s what I’m really asking.

I think I'm struggling to distinguish between the normal compromises everyone makes around work and the additional compromises I'm making because of my MS. I don't know whether I'm just expecting too much from life or whether I'm accepting a situation that I don't necessarily have to accept, if that makes sense.

It really isn’t normal to need to rest all weekend after a week of work when you aren’t doing the additional work of cooking for yourself and keeping up with housework. Or to be unable to function the next week if you do something socially. These aren’t compromises everybody makes. Apply for PIP but be prepared to have to appeal because most get turned down initially. (And remember to describe the worst days and what the impact of things actually is. There’s advice online if you look for it.)

charliehouse · 11/11/2026 11:09

WanderingWellies · 11/11/2026 11:03

It really isn’t normal to need to rest all weekend after a week of work when you aren’t doing the additional work of cooking for yourself and keeping up with housework. Or to be unable to function the next week if you do something socially. These aren’t compromises everybody makes. Apply for PIP but be prepared to have to appeal because most get turned down initially. (And remember to describe the worst days and what the impact of things actually is. There’s advice online if you look for it.)

It isn't normal but my own experience (I have MS and can only manage part time work) is that DWP won't give points for that. I also have the problem that I can barely move at all on a hot day but they weren't interested in that either as it doesn't meet any tick box.

Pickledonion1999 · 11/11/2026 11:28

WanderingWellies · 11/11/2026 11:03

It really isn’t normal to need to rest all weekend after a week of work when you aren’t doing the additional work of cooking for yourself and keeping up with housework. Or to be unable to function the next week if you do something socially. These aren’t compromises everybody makes. Apply for PIP but be prepared to have to appeal because most get turned down initially. (And remember to describe the worst days and what the impact of things actually is. There’s advice online if you look for it.)

It's fine to describe a worst day but also it must be clear how many days a worst day is. It could be once or twice a year. I see it said so many times on threads like this, people advising others to write the form based on a worst day and it's poor advice. No wonder so many are being awarded if everyone is basing their written and spoken answers on a worst day. PIP points are awarded on how someone is the majority of the time, so more than 50%. I appreciate it is must be a difficult job forr assessors especially when conditions are variable. I think the Timms report has highlighted this an as area that needs looking at and that the impact of variable conditions are often underestimated so hopefully there may be some changes as to how assessments are done.

JaceLancs · 11/11/2026 21:15

I haven’t got MS but on a normal week day when I work (not always a full day) I have no energy left for everything else
I only cook properly on a weekend, put a load of washing on, or change the bed or have a bath/shower
Monday to Friday I’m too exhausted to do more than the bare minimum which is clean teeth - get dressed - take meds and do some work

New posts on this thread. Refresh page