Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think removing phones from all children is a good idea, but...

93 replies

Redbags · 10/11/2026 12:09

You need to reinstate payphones.

I know from my own phone usage and the way I've wasted my entire morning that phones are addictive and their content harmful, but they are also now our only way to contact anyone, including emergency services.

Yes, I know we all managed perfectly well without them, but we were taught from a young age how to use payphones and always to have 2p for the phone in our sock.

OP posts:
IPM · 10/11/2026 12:30

If you mean the telephone companies, I cannot see them paying out all that money for installation and maintenance because schools have changed their rules.

Shame though.

Redbags · 10/11/2026 12:32

IPM · 10/11/2026 12:30

If you mean the telephone companies, I cannot see them paying out all that money for installation and maintenance because schools have changed their rules.

Shame though.

No I imagine for a minute the companies are going to do it, at least not for free, but if government plan to ban phones for children, they need to make sure infrastructure is in place to support that.

OP posts:
Redbags · 10/11/2026 12:32

IPM · 10/11/2026 12:30

If you mean the telephone companies, I cannot see them paying out all that money for installation and maintenance because schools have changed their rules.

Shame though.

It's not the schools who have changed the rules, it's the government.

OP posts:
GoodGirlFaith · 10/11/2026 12:38

We can't (and should not) go backwards. There is no way that most parents will stop allowing their children to take their mobiles into school; I wouldn't.

Our local secondary school now has lockers the pupils put their phone in every morning to collect at school finish. I think this is what will happen in most schools.

NameChangeScot · 10/11/2026 12:43

Our secondary school has just introduced an app for children to pre-order their lunch to combat queues in the lunch hall. This needs to go on the pupils phone, not parent (as options can change and your can only have one account linked).

The school bus pass is on an app.

My son's gym membership, guess what is on an app.

Sports teams communicate via WhatsApp.

Cinema and concert tickets etc all done on an app.

I just don't see how we can go back in time.

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:46

My children started high school age 11. They bus themselves as we work full time. The bus is very unreliable, and theres no payphone. Damn straight they have a mobile phone, for safety. I can see their location, and they can call for help.
Im in Australia so possibly the payphone situation is worse here but Im so tired of reading from people whose kids are 3 years old about how bad it is for my kids to have a phone. Those people have literally no idea.

Iizzyb · 10/11/2026 20:21

Bus tickets, live bus updates if a bus is late, ring mum or dad for a lift for you & your mates if the bus just doesn’t turn up at all. Then there’s D of E which you have to download an app for too. Plus we have life 360 so we know where each other is

the world has massively moved on - if kids travel to get to school of course they need a phone

PerdreLeBleu · 10/11/2026 20:26

But they’re not saying they can’t have phones just that they can’t have them during the school day. So they hand them in first thing or they’re put in those lockable pouches. Not sure what the drama is and no child needs their phone during the school day.

BoredZelda · 10/11/2026 20:33

No it isn’t a good idea, there is no evidence it’s a good idea, just another thing to bash young people with, whilst refusing to fix any of the actual problems in education.

BoredZelda · 10/11/2026 20:34

PerdreLeBleu · 10/11/2026 20:26

But they’re not saying they can’t have phones just that they can’t have them during the school day. So they hand them in first thing or they’re put in those lockable pouches. Not sure what the drama is and no child needs their phone during the school day.

There are actually children who need their phone in the day.

SquigglePigs · 10/11/2026 20:45

The biggest issue as I see it is the number of public transport companies where the passes are electronic. How are teens meant to get to school without their phones if their bus pass is on their phone!

ThreeMogsAndCounting · 10/11/2026 20:48

BoredZelda · 10/11/2026 20:34

There are actually children who need their phone in the day.

Like diabetic kids on pumps? I presume they'd have an exemption?

ThreeMogsAndCounting · 10/11/2026 20:49

SquigglePigs · 10/11/2026 20:45

The biggest issue as I see it is the number of public transport companies where the passes are electronic. How are teens meant to get to school without their phones if their bus pass is on their phone!

Nobody is saying they can't have phones before an after school. Just not at school.

My kids' school has had a phone ban during school hours for as long as they've been there. Its all fine.

Why so much handwriting and drama?

Zanatdy · 10/11/2026 20:49

yes we had pay phones, but how often did you use them in an emergency? I never did. Plenty of adults who would allow a child to call their mum from their phone if need be. It won’t happen anyway taking phones completely so not something to worry about.

MotherofTeenDragons · 10/11/2026 20:57

Our school has pouches that work really well. They like not having their phones to tempt them during the day but having it after school to make plans and communicate with me when I’m at work. Dd1 is now at uni. She once fainted on the school bus and the driver was able to call me because she had her phone. He waited at the stop until I arrived. Just because we didn’t have this option in the 1980s doesn’t mean we should go backwards. But equally, schools taking phones and being responsible for storing them is a logistical nightmare. The pouches are costly but work well imo.

Velumental · 10/11/2026 20:58

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:46

My children started high school age 11. They bus themselves as we work full time. The bus is very unreliable, and theres no payphone. Damn straight they have a mobile phone, for safety. I can see their location, and they can call for help.
Im in Australia so possibly the payphone situation is worse here but Im so tired of reading from people whose kids are 3 years old about how bad it is for my kids to have a phone. Those people have literally no idea.

See I think it would be bad for. 3 yr old to have a phone, I don't intend to give my almost 9 yr old a phone yet but he'll walk to secondary school from 11 and I'll give him one then

ProfessorofDarkArts · 10/11/2026 21:03

It’s only during school hours they won’t be allowed, nobody’s saying they can’t use them on the way there and back - how could that possibly be enforced?

There’s no reason I can think of that kids need a phone during school time apart from the example mentioned above where there’s a genuine medical need - I assume diabetes monitoring can require an app?

I’m sure a whole load of new and urgent ‘medical exemptions’ will suddenly appear though for all those who don’t want to follow the rules.

Namemechangey · 10/11/2026 21:04

They need to make the streets safer before removing the one item that gives them a lifeline when out and about. There are too many dangers out there especially in and near cities. Maybe they make sure no kids are carrying knives before they bother with phones.

itstoolateforsnacks · 10/11/2026 21:08

NameChangeScot · 10/11/2026 12:43

Our secondary school has just introduced an app for children to pre-order their lunch to combat queues in the lunch hall. This needs to go on the pupils phone, not parent (as options can change and your can only have one account linked).

The school bus pass is on an app.

My son's gym membership, guess what is on an app.

Sports teams communicate via WhatsApp.

Cinema and concert tickets etc all done on an app.

I just don't see how we can go back in time.

I get you, it feels impossible. But we’ve hugely fucked up as a society by creating this dependency and children are paying the price. Ridiculous for pp to say there’s no evidence of a need for a ban; there's an abundance of it. If we are not convinced by deteriorating attainment and social skills, spiralling MH issues in young people, we have our own experience of the addictiveness of smartphones and deteriorating attention spans.

If we care about what’s good for children we will roll back on all the apps. We should be lobbying the bus companies to do what’s right for kids, not saying ‘I need to keep my kid connected to this device that’s stealing their childhood because it’s too inconvenient to protect them’.

Shade17 · 10/11/2026 21:21

PerdreLeBleu · 10/11/2026 20:26

But they’re not saying they can’t have phones just that they can’t have them during the school day. So they hand them in first thing or they’re put in those lockable pouches. Not sure what the drama is and no child needs their phone during the school day.

Some children actually DO need their phones during the day, so there will be exceptions

Sherrystrull · 10/11/2026 21:47

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:46

My children started high school age 11. They bus themselves as we work full time. The bus is very unreliable, and theres no payphone. Damn straight they have a mobile phone, for safety. I can see their location, and they can call for help.
Im in Australia so possibly the payphone situation is worse here but Im so tired of reading from people whose kids are 3 years old about how bad it is for my kids to have a phone. Those people have literally no idea.

This

Pearlstillsinging · 10/11/2026 21:49

Redbags · 10/11/2026 12:32

No I imagine for a minute the companies are going to do it, at least not for free, but if government plan to ban phones for children, they need to make sure infrastructure is in place to support that.

The gvt isn't banning phones for children they are banning phones in school and apparently providing finance to help schools to make arrangements for storage during the school day. Pupils will still have their phones on the way to and from school. If parents need to contact them during the school day, they can ring the school, which us better than giving bad news directly to the child over a mobile phone, anyway.

MidnightPatrol · 10/11/2026 21:53

A friend of mine lives in Sweden and the kids have these smart watches which they can use to call their parents, but only their parents.

This seems like a good idea - can get in contact, but nothing else.

UserName00767 · 10/11/2026 21:55

Parents need to start coming to the school gate and start supplying back up phones to their little darlings who will be suffering withdrawal symptoms (like that school in Leeds where the parents brought chips when healthy lunches were introduced).

Sherrystrull · 10/11/2026 21:56

UserName00767 · 10/11/2026 21:55

Parents need to start coming to the school gate and start supplying back up phones to their little darlings who will be suffering withdrawal symptoms (like that school in Leeds where the parents brought chips when healthy lunches were introduced).

Do your teens not have phones?