Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think removing phones from all children is a good idea, but...

93 replies

Redbags · 10/11/2026 12:09

You need to reinstate payphones.

I know from my own phone usage and the way I've wasted my entire morning that phones are addictive and their content harmful, but they are also now our only way to contact anyone, including emergency services.

Yes, I know we all managed perfectly well without them, but we were taught from a young age how to use payphones and always to have 2p for the phone in our sock.

OP posts:
TheDrsDocMartens · 14/11/2026 07:30

I’ve no objection to the ‘no phones during the school day (except for the obvious exceptions)’

but the cost to schools of pouches and devices to lock/unlock is a cost schools have to find at the expense of everything else. £20+ per student on a 1500 pupil school is money that could pay for an extra member of staff.

RancidRuby · 14/11/2026 07:35

Tickingcrocodile · 14/11/2026 07:13

The whole situation seems overkill. Just let them keep their phones switched off in the bottom of their bags and confiscate any that are seen. Buying a load of school pouches or lockers seems like a total waste of funding. My daughter has to catch a public bus to our village which leaves soon after school which she will miss if there are delays in opening pouches or getting phones out of lockers.

My kid’s school use the pouches and I thought maybe it would be chaos at the end of the day with all the kids scrambling to unlock them but it’s been fine. The first day was a little bit chaotic but that was just because the kids were all a bit panicked about ensuring their pouch was unlocked, by the end of the first week it was just a completely normal process. School has installed plenty of unlocking stations and they just whack the pouch on one as they walk past, it doesn’t take any extra time at all. I think as long as individual schools implement them adequately then there should be no issues.

Unfortunately a lot of kids just wouldn’t obey the keep phone switched off in bag rule and that also relies on them actually being caught in the act, it’s much easier to just have them locked away rather than waste teachers time having to constantly police them.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 14/11/2026 07:36

Ultraalox · 14/11/2026 06:58

Our has banned phones from the school grounds entirely. Not even allowed in bags.
school bus is a credit card size thing, but guess what, half of the teacher still set homework on the school app! It’s such a joke.

Why is it a joke? Presumably he's not doing his homework on the way to and from school? So he just accesses his homework when he's at home?

Ultraalox · 14/11/2026 07:44

StepAwayFromGoogling · 14/11/2026 07:36

Why is it a joke? Presumably he's not doing his homework on the way to and from school? So he just accesses his homework when he's at home?

Ahhh.. so he doesn’t have a phone at home, the ban came in at the start of secondary so we never got one.
to me it seems daft as they got all the children a homework diary which most teachers use to set homework (so no need for a phone at all). But the ability to set on the app still exists, so some use this method.
It now means I have to have the app and check for homework. I thought at secondary kids were supposed to be independent?

lljkk · 14/11/2026 08:12

My kids are beyond school age so I am grateful to be a simple observer. their school had rules like "no phone use in class or assembly unless authorised". Otherwise, pupils could carry phones, use phones between classes, and even use phones sometimes in class as calculator etc. The school embraced the phones as useful.

What happened a lot, also made phones useful, was my kids being asked last minute to join a sports or even some other event, or the details of the sports event changing, or my kids forgetting their lunch or their sports kit (for the sports event). My kids could communicate with me about all that and then tell adults what I said.

It would have given the staff a huge lot more work to deploy staff who talked to the kid, tried to ring me or their dad but I might not pick up or hear the call and honestly my kid would know to whatsApp me instead and could take time to repeatedly try, then if staff had to track the kid down again to talk to the kid about what I said, then tried me again if more dialogue needed, just to organise the missing lunch / let me know they'd be late home from school / ask if they could do the sport after 3pm and would they have transport if they did the sport given the sport bus would get back after school buses, or could I bring the sports kit etc. Or if the kids were told they were doing a sport event that parents could attend, I'd get live updates about the real bus arrival time.

Always feels to me like A LOT more work for schools if schools ban kids having any access to their phones during school day.

ShanghaiDiva · 14/11/2026 12:54

SalemsPl0t · 14/11/2026 04:28

So the phone companies want parents to buy their children their products, then government ban them 🤔

the ban is during school, which seems reasonable. How much time children spend on phones outside school is for patents to police, or not.

BestZebbie · 14/11/2026 13:44

RancidRuby · 14/11/2026 07:35

My kid’s school use the pouches and I thought maybe it would be chaos at the end of the day with all the kids scrambling to unlock them but it’s been fine. The first day was a little bit chaotic but that was just because the kids were all a bit panicked about ensuring their pouch was unlocked, by the end of the first week it was just a completely normal process. School has installed plenty of unlocking stations and they just whack the pouch on one as they walk past, it doesn’t take any extra time at all. I think as long as individual schools implement them adequately then there should be no issues.

Unfortunately a lot of kids just wouldn’t obey the keep phone switched off in bag rule and that also relies on them actually being caught in the act, it’s much easier to just have them locked away rather than waste teachers time having to constantly police them.

I don't have any experience of this system, so I'm curious -

  1. are the unlocking stations on some kind of timer so they don't work during the day?
  2. do phones have to be switched off in the pouch, as what happens if they ring during a lesson and no-one can answer them/turn them off/to silent?
Sherrystrull · 14/11/2026 14:10

I’m not against the idea but only if the government fund it. Telling schools to pay for pouches or lockers or metal detectors rather than having money for teachers, support staff and books is completely wrong.

ShanghaiDiva · 14/11/2026 14:19

Sherrystrull · 14/11/2026 14:10

I’m not against the idea but only if the government fund it. Telling schools to pay for pouches or lockers or metal detectors rather than having money for teachers, support staff and books is completely wrong.

I imagine when up and running that parents will be expected to fund the pouches as part of the school uniform.

TempestTost · 14/11/2026 14:24

The evidence for problems caused by kids having phones is increasing every day. I think within 5 years we are going to be seeing phones, and a lot of the tech used in schools, being removed. I'm already seeing more and more individual teachers removing it from their teaching practice and finding immediate positive results.

It's not just phones in schools though, more and more serious deficits are showing up in children related to screens, specifically phones and tablets, but also constantly available tv. Motor issues, speech issues, cognition.

I strongly suspect that 10 years from now there will be hard recommendations not to allow children to have any personal screens at all and eventually people will look at it as similar to giving them drugs.

Probably many ways they are being used now will be walked back. Kids needing to access aps and shit like that.

As for pay phones, maybe. That could certainly work in places like schools or public buildings and would probably be quite welcome to those who can't afford phones. Flip phones are another option though. They are still used a lot in many places.

TempestTost · 14/11/2026 14:34

Bundleflower · 12/11/2026 10:12

Mine do. But I see no benefit to them taking them to school. They stay at home. They also take school transport there. Being out of contact for a brief while shouldn’t be such a cause of stress. There’s the school office if they need to contact home.

This is actually something that really concerns me.

The level of stress parents and kids feel when not being in direct contact through a phone.

It's fed into parenting styles that are really detrimental to kids and are contributing to anxiety and MH issues.

And the parents now think it's just normal. It's really not, there should not normally be massive stress around a child going to school on a school bus or walking to the local park at age 8.

Kids are not being allowed to do things the need to be doing for development of cognitive skills, executive function, and emotional regulation.

CrispySquid · 14/11/2026 14:38

BestZebbie · 14/11/2026 13:44

I don't have any experience of this system, so I'm curious -

  1. are the unlocking stations on some kind of timer so they don't work during the day?
  2. do phones have to be switched off in the pouch, as what happens if they ring during a lesson and no-one can answer them/turn them off/to silent?

Our school bought in the Yondr pouches this September and they have been fantastic.

Each morning, every tutor watches each student in their tutor group place the phone in their Yondr pouch and lock it. We watch them turn their phone off and place it in the pouch. This takes maximum 5 minutes and forms part of tutor time. Students are ready with this routine. They are all ready with their phone and pouch in their hand when you come down the line and they then put it in and seal it up under your watch. They turn the pouch upside down to verify the pouch is sealed. Parents pay £20ish pounds for the pouch. It’s a requirement for all students enrolling at the school. I almost know off by heart what each of my tutor group main phone looks like and their phone network!

At the end of the day, when students are dismissed, outside the main school gates and various other school exits, there are several magnetic unlocking stations. Around 30 in total. When exiting the school, each student presses their phone against this panel and the pouch opens instantly. It takes less than a second per student. Similar speed to scanning your Oyster card on the London Underground. School finishes at 3pm and by 3.05pm, almost every single student has their pouch unlocked and has cleared the premises.

If a student has not turned off their phone before putting it in their pouch and it goes off, you just inform OnCall who brings round a handheld unlocking panel and the student unlocks the pouch there and then, turns their phone off and re-locks it. In my lessons, this has only happened once in the two months we’ve had them.

Any student found with either a second phone or who has tried to break into their pouch or has their phone on them for any reason receives a three day suspension and upon return, is searched by SLT each morning going forward. This takes again five minutes and so far in the school out of 1250 students only about 10 have knowingly done this so they are the ones who are searched each day.

It has been such an utter success, it has been indescribable. I could not recommend them more to other schools.

Sherrystrull · 15/11/2026 10:03

ShanghaiDiva · 14/11/2026 14:19

I imagine when up and running that parents will be expected to fund the pouches as part of the school uniform.

I think that’s a good idea but what happens when the child forgets theirs or the parent doesn’t agree with the policy and refuses to buy one? It becomes a huge headache for everyone.

ShanghaiDiva · 15/11/2026 12:50

Sherrystrull · 15/11/2026 10:03

I think that’s a good idea but what happens when the child forgets theirs or the parent doesn’t agree with the policy and refuses to buy one? It becomes a huge headache for everyone.

I imagine the phone would need to be handed to reception and collected at the end of the school day.

RancidRuby · 15/11/2026 14:15

BestZebbie · 14/11/2026 13:44

I don't have any experience of this system, so I'm curious -

  1. are the unlocking stations on some kind of timer so they don't work during the day?
  2. do phones have to be switched off in the pouch, as what happens if they ring during a lesson and no-one can answer them/turn them off/to silent?

The unlocking stations are in the car park and by the pedestrian exit gate, during the school day these areas aren’t accessible to students.

Phones are meant to be switched off, not sure what happens if someone forgets to do that as my kids have never forgotten and haven’t mentioned anyone else forgetting either.

RancidRuby · 15/11/2026 14:22

Sherrystrull · 15/11/2026 10:03

I think that’s a good idea but what happens when the child forgets theirs or the parent doesn’t agree with the policy and refuses to buy one? It becomes a huge headache for everyone.

At our school a pouch is a mandatory item of uniform. If you don’t want to buy a pouch then you can’t bring a phone into school. If you forget your pouch then you have to hand the phone in for the day and then collect it at home time, kids generally don’t forget it more than once as it’s a longer process to get it back as opposed to just simply unlocking the pouch on the way out of school grounds.

Sherrystrull · 15/11/2026 14:51

Makes sense! Thanks. I know some kids will be looking for loop holes!

GintyMcGinty · 15/11/2026 15:29

Unfortunately there are very few payphones left.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread