Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is this victim blaming?

617 replies

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:26

Just to begin, I consider myself a feminist, advocate for women’s rights (of course!) etc etc.

but I struggle with the line when it comes to victim blaming in some cases of rape and sexual assault.

In recent years, we’ve seen a rise in cases regarding women (often drunkenly) going back to hotel rooms and being raped once there. I fully support the conviction in such cases and have sympathy for the women.

However, I just don’t understand why some women put themselves in such dangerous situations? It’s a shame we have to think this way (ie. Be ‘on guard’ and cautious of men/rape/sexual assault), but it’s clear that something like this could happen if going to a hotel room with a man you do not know very well. So why do it?
I compare this to walking alone in the dark - we should be able to do this as women! But unfortunately, the vast majority of women wouldn’t do this due to the perceived danger. Yet why is pointing out the danger of going to a hotel room of a man you do not know considered victim blaming?

OP posts:
nietzscheanvibe · 10/11/2026 16:45

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/11/2026 13:56

The fact that several people have compared women to objects such as houses and cars is part of the problem.

But why would people take fewer risks with their property than they do with themselves is the point I'm making?

shuggles · 10/11/2026 16:45

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 16:14

That's your prerogative.

I feel perfectly safe walking alone at night in Central London. Far safer than I feel in a rural village. Been doing it for years and never met any thugs or degenerates.

That's completely bonkers. I would never walk alone in London, or any other major city, at night.

I was brought up not to. Either get a taxi, or be with a crowd of people. That's the rule.

worldshottestmom · 10/11/2026 16:44

dairydebris · 10/11/2026 16:27

Blame lies only where there is wrongdoing.

Personal responsibility is only the responsibility for one's own actions.

Therefore, when a rape takes place, there is personal responsibility on both sides, the rapist is personally responsible for the rape. The person who was raped was still responsible for being in the situation. It sounds awful to say, but yes, we are responsible for where we are, if we ourselves were there of our own free will.

The blame lies only where there is wrongdoing. The rape is the wrongdoing. So 100% of the blame is there.

Wearing a short skirt is not wrong.
Being drunk is not wrong.
Taking part in risky behavior is not wrong.
Staying in a relationship with someone you love who is displaying red flags isn't wrong, although probably ill advised, youre not doing anything wrong.
Hence no blame here.

We have control of our own personal responsibilities. I think we should allow that.

We don't have control of other peoples personal responsibilities. And we certainly don't take blame for their wrongdoing.

This way we have control with no victim blaming.

Where have I gone wrong?

I'm a bit confused by this comment, it feels it starts one way then ends somewhere else.

So, when my sister was asleep in bed and her partner raped her, it was her fault for being asleep in her own bed and putting herself in that situatuon? It was her fault for choosing a bad partner? Is that correct? Sorry I am genuinely trying to understand if this would be in line with the logic of your comment, or if I've misunderstood.

shuggles · 10/11/2026 16:43

DuncinToffee · 10/11/2026 16:24

What masculine qualities?

Respect, kindness, thoughtfulness, compassion, and listening more than speaking.

Years ago, there were far more of these people in the UK, which is why it was safer to walk the streets.

Nowadays, we have delinquents and yobs, obsessed with physical strength, who no longer display these masculine qualities. In addition, there has been a breakdown in cultural values of people being king to one another. This is why our cities are no longer safe for men or women to walk alone at night.

Bloozie · 10/11/2026 16:38

blondeseaside · 10/11/2026 15:43

If i go to a hotel room and say no and get raped - Its HIS fault

No one, including the Op, is denying this. The point isthough, you are increaseing your chances of being raped by 100% if you go to a hotel room with a man you only just met. And I say this as someone who, when younger, has taken this risk. When I look back I count my lucky stars that the sex we had was nice, and didn't turn into something hideous, that I couldn't get away from.

I do remember a ONS where I stayed the night in a man's flat, and when I left the next day, I noticed a collection of axes mounted on his wall (his hobby), and I did think to myself, what a stupid twat I had been, being so risky with my safety.

We make calculations all day when it comes to our safety. Don't switch the light of with a wet hand. Don't walk into the road when a car is coming. Don't slam the car door on a finger, don't eat the food before it's cooled, etc etc. But all too often, when it comes to men we fancy, we forget to just stop and think about what risks we might be taking. Maybe it's lust, I don't know. In any case it's not really avoidable, because at some point you have to be alone with a man, whether it's after a 1st date or a 10th date, or you'd never move the relationship along. Not sure what the answer is.

you are increaseing your chances of being raped by 100% if you go to a hotel room with a man you only just met.

Are you? Where do you get this conviction from?

dairydebris · 10/11/2026 16:27

Blame lies only where there is wrongdoing.

Personal responsibility is only the responsibility for one's own actions.

Therefore, when a rape takes place, there is personal responsibility on both sides, the rapist is personally responsible for the rape. The person who was raped was still responsible for being in the situation. It sounds awful to say, but yes, we are responsible for where we are, if we ourselves were there of our own free will.

The blame lies only where there is wrongdoing. The rape is the wrongdoing. So 100% of the blame is there.

Wearing a short skirt is not wrong.
Being drunk is not wrong.
Taking part in risky behavior is not wrong.
Staying in a relationship with someone you love who is displaying red flags isn't wrong, although probably ill advised, youre not doing anything wrong.
Hence no blame here.

We have control of our own personal responsibilities. I think we should allow that.

We don't have control of other peoples personal responsibilities. And we certainly don't take blame for their wrongdoing.

This way we have control with no victim blaming.

Where have I gone wrong?

DuncinToffee · 10/11/2026 16:24

shuggles · 10/11/2026 16:10

I would never walk alone around London late at night.

Cities are not safe to walk around late at night due to the number of thugs and degenerates who freely roam the streets. Culture and society has completely broken down in Britain, and men no longer display the masculine qualities they would have done years ago.

What masculine qualities?

PeasOff · 10/11/2026 16:20

Of course there are precautions women can take to reduce risk, but the problem is that the narrative always comes back to what the woman should or shouldn't have done.

She should have dressed differently, drunk less, not walked alone, not gone back to his hotel room. Also the suggestion that women simply shouldn't walk alone at night is ridiculous. What about women who work shifts, finish work late, have no family nearby, or rely on public transport? Are they supposed to put their lives on hold because it's dark?!

At what point do we stop making women responsible for managing the risk of male violence? Even with a woman following all of the precautions I've listed - still not enough to keep her completely safe from the risk of rape. What does that tell you...?

LVPLVT · 10/11/2026 16:20

Tulipsriver · 10/11/2026 15:28

Your experience wasn't universal. I was at university at the same time and remember an ethics seminar called something like "can no mean yes?". Plenty of people, including the female lecturer, argued that women often say no during sexual encounters when they mean yes, and that this can be confusing for men. (The highlight was a girl laughing at my male friend and telling him no wonder he couldn't pull if he waited for girls actually say yes to him... not sexy back then apparently?).

We also had safety events that concentrated heavily on telling us to protect ourselves, our drinks, and our friends, no equivalent sessions were run for male students suggesting they kept their hands to themselves.

Just look at old media, raping women too drunk to say no was seen as a valid technique to gain sex not that long ago. I don't think I even heard the term 'enthusiastic consent' until my mid twenties. I didn't realise I had been raped until years later because I hadn't actually said no and nobody ever taught me that I didn't need to.

It's also wildly misleading to take rape being illegal as proof that men were historically taught not to rape women (in our modern understanding of the word). Violent rape of a woman you weren't married to might have been viewed in this way, but raping a woman who had kissed you, had gone somewhere private with you, or suggested in any way that she wasn't the perfect victim, would often not have been categorised in this way.

The issue is, boys might have always been taught not to hold someone down kicking and screaming... but that only accounts for the tiniest proportion of assaults. Most of the rapes that have ever occurred would have been committed by someone who would never have considered their actions to be rape, and wouldn't see themselves as a rapist, because we haven't taught people, male or female, what true consent looks like on a consistent level until very recently.

I was responding to a poster who said it was straightforward and we simply needed to teach men not to harm women. I don’t think it is at all straightforward, I think men know they shouldn’t harm women, and I think it’s a fantasy that we can eradicate rape.

I am all for education, and my hope is that it is effective, but I will still be advising my daughter in the reasonable steps she can take to mitigate risk whilst assuring her that if anything were ever to happen, it would not be her fault.

Your university experience sounds wildly different to mine - our SU’s banned the song “blurred lines” from being played for example. There were certainly no discussions about whether women saying no should be confusing to men.

”Enthusiastic consent” is a great principle for promoting healthy sexual relationships but as far as I know it isn’t the legal test and someone can consent to sex without saying yes and without being particularly enthusiastic about it.

Augarden · 10/11/2026 16:17

I think there's a difference in the conversations we would have with someone who has suffered an assault, and with our daughters when telling them to stay safe.

"Stay with your friends, get a taxi home, keep to brightly lit streets, don't think a man is any safer to be around because he's got long hair and a blouse on" etc is all good advice and we would be doing girls a disservice to not tell them these things. But that doesn't mean there's ever any excuse for assault, even if they broke all those rules.

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 16:14

shuggles · 10/11/2026 16:10

I would never walk alone around London late at night.

Cities are not safe to walk around late at night due to the number of thugs and degenerates who freely roam the streets. Culture and society has completely broken down in Britain, and men no longer display the masculine qualities they would have done years ago.

That's your prerogative.

I feel perfectly safe walking alone at night in Central London. Far safer than I feel in a rural village. Been doing it for years and never met any thugs or degenerates.

shuggles · 10/11/2026 16:10

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 13:52

Huh? You think women in London- that's the only city I have experience of- don't walk alone? We do.

I would never walk alone around London late at night.

Cities are not safe to walk around late at night due to the number of thugs and degenerates who freely roam the streets. Culture and society has completely broken down in Britain, and men no longer display the masculine qualities they would have done years ago.

MaggieBsBoat · 10/11/2026 16:09

EmBear91 · 10/11/2026 15:55

Yes OP. It’s victim blaming. And no, you’re not a feminist.

Ridiculous. And wrong.

EmBear91 · 10/11/2026 15:55

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:26

Just to begin, I consider myself a feminist, advocate for women’s rights (of course!) etc etc.

but I struggle with the line when it comes to victim blaming in some cases of rape and sexual assault.

In recent years, we’ve seen a rise in cases regarding women (often drunkenly) going back to hotel rooms and being raped once there. I fully support the conviction in such cases and have sympathy for the women.

However, I just don’t understand why some women put themselves in such dangerous situations? It’s a shame we have to think this way (ie. Be ‘on guard’ and cautious of men/rape/sexual assault), but it’s clear that something like this could happen if going to a hotel room with a man you do not know very well. So why do it?
I compare this to walking alone in the dark - we should be able to do this as women! But unfortunately, the vast majority of women wouldn’t do this due to the perceived danger. Yet why is pointing out the danger of going to a hotel room of a man you do not know considered victim blaming?

Yes OP. It’s victim blaming. And no, you’re not a feminist.

Dutch1e · 10/11/2026 15:53

TheignT · 10/11/2026 14:35

Yes, it's a bit like me crossing the road. I look both ways even if it's a one way street. I know traffic should only come from one direction but years ago my husband stepped out as no traffic approaching except a car was coming from the wrong direction narrowly missing him. So I always check both ways but I do go out and I do cross roads I'm just aware drivers make mistakes.

It's nothing like looking both ways before crossing the street.

Two tonnes of steel hurtling through space is an innate and undeniable risk. It's simple physics.

Your implication then is that men are innately, scientifically, driven to rape.

Dutch1e · 10/11/2026 15:48

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 14:32

That’s great. But I’d hazard a guess that says women who do these things are less likely to be raped by a stranger.

Sure, and women who are banned from any public space unless accompanied by a male relative are probably safest of all from being raped by a stranger. I'm not sure what point you're trying to make here - it seems like we're saying the same thing, we just disagree.

TotaleclipseinFrance · 10/11/2026 15:47

DeftGoldHedgehog · 10/11/2026 14:56

In any event none of this bullshit about risk applies to most rapes which are carried out by someone the woman knows.

Agree.
IF the only rapes that ever occurred where of the stranger, dark alley, knife-wielding type then logically the way to avoid it would be to never go out without a chaperone or two.
Though of course we still wouldn't blame the victim, just like we wouldn't blame somebody for being mugged.

That is not the only type of rape that occurs, though. It happens in a wide range of circumstances.

The only way to be safe from rape is to NEVER meet any men.

I suppose you could go and live on a female only commune, even then you may be attacked by a gang of men.

blondeseaside · 10/11/2026 15:43

Kerrylass · 10/11/2026 13:08

If i walked out in front of a car - its my fault if i get knocked down.
If i go to a hotel room and say no and get raped - Its HIS fault.

STOP THIS STUPID NARRATIVE

no wonder women don't speak out and don't report assaults, you are victim blaming no matter how you frame it.
Of course women should take precautions to protect themselves but if they are assaulted its not their fault.

This thread should be reported. Boils my piss!!!!

If i go to a hotel room and say no and get raped - Its HIS fault

No one, including the Op, is denying this. The point isthough, you are increaseing your chances of being raped by 100% if you go to a hotel room with a man you only just met. And I say this as someone who, when younger, has taken this risk. When I look back I count my lucky stars that the sex we had was nice, and didn't turn into something hideous, that I couldn't get away from.

I do remember a ONS where I stayed the night in a man's flat, and when I left the next day, I noticed a collection of axes mounted on his wall (his hobby), and I did think to myself, what a stupid twat I had been, being so risky with my safety.

We make calculations all day when it comes to our safety. Don't switch the light of with a wet hand. Don't walk into the road when a car is coming. Don't slam the car door on a finger, don't eat the food before it's cooled, etc etc. But all too often, when it comes to men we fancy, we forget to just stop and think about what risks we might be taking. Maybe it's lust, I don't know. In any case it's not really avoidable, because at some point you have to be alone with a man, whether it's after a 1st date or a 10th date, or you'd never move the relationship along. Not sure what the answer is.

ruethewhirl · 10/11/2026 15:41

Bloozie · 10/11/2026 14:18

Saying all of those things to your daughters is fine.

Saying that women who go to places alone where men might be, and/or heaven forbid get drunk where men might be, are essentially asking for it... What do they expect?... This is risky behaviour.... They could have protected themselves simply by NOT being there, yet they chose not to... All that is unfeminist victim blaming.

And misandrist, actually. Because most men can control themselves around a drunk woman. There is nothing inevitable about a situation with a drunk woman, or an alone woman, in male company.

It's when the man is a predator, that the consequence becomes inevitable. Because of his behaviour, not hers.

Edited

Perfectly summed up. 👏

Tulipsriver · 10/11/2026 15:36

Glowingup · 10/11/2026 15:33

There has been so much stuff on consent. The thing is that there will still be rape. It is such a fantasy to think it can be eliminated and so delusional to think that these poor rapists just don’t understand that someone needs to consent. I’d say things have become worse not better. When I was at uni rape happened but nearly all guys would deny that they would ever do anything like that. Now you get men boasting in WhatsApp groups about being rapists and looking up to idiots like Andrew Tate.

They always know it’s wrong but they think they can do it anyway.

Ok, so if boys all understand enthusiastic consent without needing to be taught, was I just an idiot for not recognising it when it happened to me? I was brought up in the same cultural context as him, internalised the same attitudes, and received broadly the same education?

Edited to add: there will always be rapists, unfortunately. Just like there will always be thieves, murderers, racists, homophobes etc. That doesn't mean that education and a shift in cultural norms can't improve things.

cestlavielife · 10/11/2026 15:33

Cone on op you can see easily how it happens ...if not an attack dragging her in then it is manipulation .
"Oh we on same floor. Come by my room for a coffee. I got some paracetamol for you. We dont need to do anything. Let s talk. You understand me so well. I have a wife. "Etc. Lays on charm etc

Then he rapes her.

Glowingup · 10/11/2026 15:33

Tulipsriver · 10/11/2026 15:28

Your experience wasn't universal. I was at university at the same time and remember an ethics seminar called something like "can no mean yes?". Plenty of people, including the female lecturer, argued that women often say no during sexual encounters when they mean yes, and that this can be confusing for men. (The highlight was a girl laughing at my male friend and telling him no wonder he couldn't pull if he waited for girls actually say yes to him... not sexy back then apparently?).

We also had safety events that concentrated heavily on telling us to protect ourselves, our drinks, and our friends, no equivalent sessions were run for male students suggesting they kept their hands to themselves.

Just look at old media, raping women too drunk to say no was seen as a valid technique to gain sex not that long ago. I don't think I even heard the term 'enthusiastic consent' until my mid twenties. I didn't realise I had been raped until years later because I hadn't actually said no and nobody ever taught me that I didn't need to.

It's also wildly misleading to take rape being illegal as proof that men were historically taught not to rape women (in our modern understanding of the word). Violent rape of a woman you weren't married to might have been viewed in this way, but raping a woman who had kissed you, had gone somewhere private with you, or suggested in any way that she wasn't the perfect victim, would often not have been categorised in this way.

The issue is, boys might have always been taught not to hold someone down kicking and screaming... but that only accounts for the tiniest proportion of assaults. Most of the rapes that have ever occurred would have been committed by someone who would never have considered their actions to be rape, and wouldn't see themselves as a rapist, because we haven't taught people, male or female, what true consent looks like on a consistent level until very recently.

There has been so much stuff on consent. The thing is that there will still be rape. It is such a fantasy to think it can be eliminated and so delusional to think that these poor rapists just don’t understand that someone needs to consent. I’d say things have become worse not better. When I was at uni rape happened but nearly all guys would deny that they would ever do anything like that. Now you get men boasting in WhatsApp groups about being rapists and looking up to idiots like Andrew Tate.

They always know it’s wrong but they think they can do it anyway.

Tulipsriver · 10/11/2026 15:28

LVPLVT · 10/11/2026 15:07

If it’s so straightforward why isn’t it working? Rape has generally been a criminal offence in the UK for the last 750 years (though has obviously the exact definition has evolved in that time). As disgusting as it was, the marriage exemption was repealed before I was even born. I went to university in 2012 and we had talks on consent - that was not the first time I had been ‘educated’ on it.

Presumably, parents of boys have been telling them not to rape women for decades if not centuries. At a societal level, rape is often seen as equivalent in severity to murder and child molestation.

Men know it is wrong, they know they shouldn’t do it, and in my view, no amount of education is going to eradicate it. If we lived in an ideal world no one would ever harm anyone else! But that isn’t the reality.

Your experience wasn't universal. I was at university at the same time and remember an ethics seminar called something like "can no mean yes?". Plenty of people, including the female lecturer, argued that women often say no during sexual encounters when they mean yes, and that this can be confusing for men. (The highlight was a girl laughing at my male friend and telling him no wonder he couldn't pull if he waited for girls actually say yes to him... not sexy back then apparently?).

We also had safety events that concentrated heavily on telling us to protect ourselves, our drinks, and our friends, no equivalent sessions were run for male students suggesting they kept their hands to themselves.

Just look at old media, raping women too drunk to say no was seen as a valid technique to gain sex not that long ago. I don't think I even heard the term 'enthusiastic consent' until my mid twenties. I didn't realise I had been raped until years later because I hadn't actually said no and nobody ever taught me that I didn't need to.

It's also wildly misleading to take rape being illegal as proof that men were historically taught not to rape women (in our modern understanding of the word). Violent rape of a woman you weren't married to might have been viewed in this way, but raping a woman who had kissed you, had gone somewhere private with you, or suggested in any way that she wasn't the perfect victim, would often not have been categorised in this way.

The issue is, boys might have always been taught not to hold someone down kicking and screaming... but that only accounts for the tiniest proportion of assaults. Most of the rapes that have ever occurred would have been committed by someone who would never have considered their actions to be rape, and wouldn't see themselves as a rapist, because we haven't taught people, male or female, what true consent looks like on a consistent level until very recently.

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 10/11/2026 15:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

So you’re saying these women weren’t “victims”?

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/11/2026 15:27

Whyarepeople · 10/11/2026 14:59

This is an important point. I don't know why so much emphasis is put on stranger rape, which is actually very rare. While women are curtailing their lives 'keeping themselves safe' most rapes occur in homes and workplaces. What is the motivation for making it seem like stranger rape is more common than it is? I have a few theories and all of them relate to much easier it makes it for men to rape and get away with it.

I feel it is largely to do with the control aspect which has already been brought up to a various degree.

The reality that actually, there is very little you can do to avoid rape as you are most likely to be raped by a man you know, trust and maybe even love is scarier than thinking you have some aspect of control over it. It's comforting to think that it won't happen to you because you make good decisions like not walking alone at night.