Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is this victim blaming?

617 replies

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:26

Just to begin, I consider myself a feminist, advocate for women’s rights (of course!) etc etc.

but I struggle with the line when it comes to victim blaming in some cases of rape and sexual assault.

In recent years, we’ve seen a rise in cases regarding women (often drunkenly) going back to hotel rooms and being raped once there. I fully support the conviction in such cases and have sympathy for the women.

However, I just don’t understand why some women put themselves in such dangerous situations? It’s a shame we have to think this way (ie. Be ‘on guard’ and cautious of men/rape/sexual assault), but it’s clear that something like this could happen if going to a hotel room with a man you do not know very well. So why do it?
I compare this to walking alone in the dark - we should be able to do this as women! But unfortunately, the vast majority of women wouldn’t do this due to the perceived danger. Yet why is pointing out the danger of going to a hotel room of a man you do not know considered victim blaming?

OP posts:
BusyGreySnail · 10/11/2026 12:40

I liked the social media campagin after the Cornell incident where people showed what women didi to men who were intoxicated and incapcitated at parties. Funnily enough, they weren't raped. Generally they were wrapped in blankets and given a non-alcoholic drink.

MaggieBsBoat · 10/11/2026 12:40

It is victim blaming, but I do understand you questioning some women's self-preservation instinct. Or lack thereof.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/11/2026 12:40

MagicMelanie · 10/11/2026 12:35

I just don’t get why a woman would put herself in a position where something scary like this could happen

I don't understand this either. In my youth I've been invited to a man's flat for a drink at the end of an evening and I've declined because I don't know him very well. I've had friends who've accepted invitations from men and been perfectly ok. But if you don't know a man very well, you don't know if he could be a rapist, so I always thought it best to err on the side of caution. Of course it's always the rapists fault and never the woman's fault. But why take risks?

Even if you do know a man very well, you don't know if he's a rapist. In fact, statistics show a man known to a woman is more likely to rape her.

So the biggest risk is actually getting to know men very well and believing you know he isn't a rapist.

I'm going to guess that the vast majority of women on here have taken that risk, even those who don't walk in the dark alone or would never go back to a strange man's hotel room/house.

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 12:40

JasmineMac · 10/11/2026 12:39

I don't like my 16yo travelling alone at night, ie taking buses or taxis, so I always collect her from places. I don't do this because I think if something happened to her it would be her own fault, I do it to minimise risk. Minimising risk is clearly the suggestion that @Feedingmybaby is making. In an ideal world, absolutely we wouldn't have to 'risk assess' individual situations. The world however is far from ideal.

Exactly this. In an ideal world, our daughters would be safe to walk home alone at 10pm. In reality, not many of us would allow this in order to minimise their risk.

OP posts:
Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 12:39

PrincessFairyWren · 10/11/2026 12:26

Men are excused for poor behavior because they are young and their frontal lobe isn’t fully developed. They are excused because they are drunk.

However female victims are to blame for being raped for these things.

I would never excuse a man for his behaviour in the way you are describing.

OP posts:
JasmineMac · 10/11/2026 12:39

I don't like my 16yo travelling alone at night, ie taking buses or taxis, so I always collect her from places. I don't do this because I think if something happened to her it would be her own fault, I do it to minimise risk. Minimising risk is clearly the suggestion that @Feedingmybaby is making. In an ideal world, absolutely we wouldn't have to 'risk assess' individual situations. The world however is far from ideal.

ThreadGuardDog · 10/11/2026 12:38

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:44

I’m not talking about these women.

Why ? Because you see them as the right kind of victim ? What you’re doing is asking women to risk assess everything they do to mitigate men’s behaviour. That’s victim blaming.

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 12:38

SafetyLady · 10/11/2026 12:36

You are being unreasonable. Even if you and many others wouldn't have done it, clearly some people were not too scared to be in those situations. Whether you can imagine feeling that way is irrelevant. Maybe they thought they were with someone they could trust? Maybe they just never thought it would happen to them? Maybe they felt pressured? Maybe they're just not as good at anticipating possible outcomes as you? Loads of possible reasons.

Focusing on what the victim could have done to guard against being assaulted is implying that the crime is at least partly their fault, i.e. Victim blaming.

Maybe they were up for sex but then the sex became violent, degrading and non-consensual. So they said no. As all women are allowed to do at any time.

Comeondoreen · 10/11/2026 12:38

I understand where you’re coming from to an extent

it’s possible to believe someone behaved foolishly (I know very little about this case so I’m not saying I believe she was foolish, I don’t know anything about it, I am just speaking generally) and simultaneously believe they, of course, did not deserve to be raped. I don’t think it’s necessarily blaming someone to acknowledge that they might have protected themselves better.

I say this as someone who was drugged and I suppose then assaulted by a male “friend” (ha) when younger. I don’t think I was to blame for what happened, but I do look back and think “I will make sure my daughter knows to protect herself better than I did”. That doesn’t mean I blame myself, or any other woman who experienced something like what I did.

In a similar but not exactly comparable way, there is never an excuse for violence but I will teach my son not to deliberately wind people up and provoke people into fights - not because I condone a man punching another man in response to a verbal insult, but because I want my child to have the best possible chance to avoid those situations.

I suppose the thing I do wonder, OP, is what is the point of discussing this explicitly in reference to this case right now? We can discuss general safety advice for women without linking it to a specific woman’s newsworthy rape case, which to me feels insensitive.

Conniebygaslight · 10/11/2026 12:38

I don't think that women should have to keep themselves safe, but unfortunately the reality is that we do, wherever possible. That does not make it the woman's fault. I say this a victim of SA.

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 12:38

BusyGreySnail · 10/11/2026 12:13

Sure there are things women can do to have less of a risk of being raped. They can avoid getting drunk? They can avoid walking in the dark? They can avoid ever being alone with any man (or probably a group of men, because gang rape)? They could wear a chastity belt? They could lock themselves in their house and never go outside (and probably best never to let any man into the house either)?

We can think of loads of things, reasonable and not, but they all do the same thing, but the onus on the woman to prevent her own rape which, inherently leads to victim blaming if she doesn't. And if so why on earth is the onus on them to do those things rather than the men just not to rape?

If you can't see this you are not the feminist you proclaim to be.

I agree with everything you’ve written. But I would still advise my daughters to not drink to excess, to remain vigilant around men and to always let others know their location. It’s sad but that’s the world we live in. And I want to lower their risks of being sexually assaulted.

Another comparison - I wouldn’t leave my daughter in the sole care of a man other than her father either.

OP posts:
KnittedPenguinHat · 10/11/2026 12:37

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:36

Im furious that there is a need for the sign. The fury should be directed at the rapist, not the victim.

This! But I’m also furious that the bar knows there’s a risk to its female patrons but thinks that this sign is the solution!!

DarkAngel23 · 10/11/2026 12:37

Are you saying a woman agreeing to go back to the hotel room creates an expectation of sex that then overrides her right to say no or change her mind?

I was in situations when I was (too) young where I initially consented to sexual activity but it became too painful and I withdrew my consent. I thought those people would respect my wishes but they did not and continued. Their right to sex and power over me then became more important than my consent. Am I then at fault because I created that expectation of sex and they got frustrated at being asked to stop?

Its a slippery argument that hinges on (men) having a ‘right’ to sex, and that women should automatically expect to be raped and shamed if they are alone with a male in a hotel room.

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:37

Ethelspagetti · 10/11/2026 12:25

Rape is rape but harder to prove if they’ve agreed to drunken sex and woke up being raped later in the night. It’s still rape but she’s made herself vulnerable with an unknown person. Bit like walking about with a thousand pounds cash in our hands. Theft is still theft but better to hide the money and valuables away.

You just compared a womans body to an object. Thats what rapists do.

SafetyLady · 10/11/2026 12:36

You are being unreasonable. Even if you and many others wouldn't have done it, clearly some people were not too scared to be in those situations. Whether you can imagine feeling that way is irrelevant. Maybe they thought they were with someone they could trust? Maybe they just never thought it would happen to them? Maybe they felt pressured? Maybe they're just not as good at anticipating possible outcomes as you? Loads of possible reasons.

Focusing on what the victim could have done to guard against being assaulted is implying that the crime is at least partly their fault, i.e. Victim blaming.

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:36

LVPLVT · 10/11/2026 12:35

Picture this - you’re in a bar and you see a sign suggesting you should try not to leave your drink unattended.

Do you think:
a) that sounds sensible; or
b) OMG I am furious.

Im furious that there is a need for the sign. The fury should be directed at the rapist, not the victim.

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 12:35

Where do you draw the line? Some ppl think women should be covered head to toe or at least modestly dressed at all timea. I originally come from such a modest culture though I have long since left it behind.
Should I advise my dd to cover herself lest a man is tempted?

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:35

OneNewLeader · 10/11/2026 12:32

Years ago, a man once put it quite simply, rape is an act of violence, unexpected and undeserved, in all cases. If a man is stabbed, no one questions his clothes, his location or his sobriety.

Yep, because womens bodies are still seen as objects for men.

LVPLVT · 10/11/2026 12:35

BillieWiper · 10/11/2026 12:23

You can be raped by any man, usually one you do know well.

So should we just never ever be alone in the same building as a member of the opposite sex else it's totally our own fault if we get raped because it's totally fucking inevitable?!

OMG this makes me furious.

Picture this - you’re in a bar and you see a sign suggesting you should try not to leave your drink unattended.

Do you think:
a) that sounds sensible; or
b) OMG I am furious.

MagicMelanie · 10/11/2026 12:35

I just don’t get why a woman would put herself in a position where something scary like this could happen

I don't understand this either. In my youth I've been invited to a man's flat for a drink at the end of an evening and I've declined because I don't know him very well. I've had friends who've accepted invitations from men and been perfectly ok. But if you don't know a man very well, you don't know if he could be a rapist, so I always thought it best to err on the side of caution. Of course it's always the rapists fault and never the woman's fault. But why take risks?

KnittedPenguinHat · 10/11/2026 12:34

dairydebris · 10/11/2026 12:30

To those who say the OP is victim blaming.

Would you advise your daughter to go back to a hotel room with a man she just met if she was drunk.

I think most would not. I would advise my own daughter against this.

Would you advise your daughter to end a relationship if she told you about red flag behavior? I would.

Yet would you be potentially victim blaming your daughter if she failed to follow your advice and did it anyway? And a SA occurred?

I don't think you'd see it as her fault. I wouldn't.

That's all the OP is saying I think.

Do you not think that maybe she would though?

Victims often blame themselves and that’s one reason why reports and convictions are so low.

Even your wording here implies it would be her fault for “failing” to follow your advice!

Victim blaming language is embedded in these conversations.

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:33

I had somebody make a rape attempt on me when I was jogging. Fortunately, I am quite tall and strong and have done some martial arts so I fought them off. It was absolutely, no question a rape attempt, they jumped out at me and grabbed me, covered my mouth with their hand so I couldnt scream etc.
I wasnt drunk or 'revealingly dressed', I was wearing baggy track suit.
Do you think I 'put myself in that situation' op 🙄
Rape is a power crime.

Happyjoe · 10/11/2026 12:33

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:37

Of course a woman reserves the right to say no, even if she is naked with a man on top of her. and I don’t think a woman would be in any way in the wrong if she did this.

I’m not disputing this.

I just don’t get why a woman would put herself in a position where something scary like this could happen.

Perhaps she went back to the hotel room drunk, feeling 'up for it' but then changed her mind, perhaps sobering up a little or just doesn't want to anymore? That's allowed. And a man should stop, unless of course he's a rapist.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/11/2026 12:32

TheFriendlyPotato · 10/11/2026 12:23

I’m not preaching, nor do I have a small life. I’m simply weighing up the reality that the life I want may come with higher risks than the choices of someone who decides to avoid those risks.

I’m genuinely curious why you feel so hostile towards this perspective. I’ve been assaulted; I’m not naive about the realities of the world. If acknowledging those realities makes you uncomfortable, then you’re perfectly entitled to carry on as you are. That’s absolutely fine.

But what is your alternative? Beyond simply repeating that men shouldn’t behave this way?

Of course men shouldn’t. We all know that. Nobody is disputing it. But saying what should happen doesn’t change the fact that some men will still behave that way. So what do you actually suggest women do? Just keep repeating that men shouldn’t do it, without having an honest conversation about how we navigate the reality that they sometimes do?

I’m trying to approach this conversation as kindly and reasonably as I can, but the hostility really isn’t necessary. We can disagree without making it personal.

Edited

But they aren't higher risks. Most women aren't raped by strangers in dark alleys.

Most women are raped by men they know and sometimes love. The higher risk is to allow men in your circle, in your bed but the vast majority of women take that risk yet it isn't seen that way.

The alternative is acknowledging the fact that men are going to rape and they will always find a way to rape. It can't be prevented. Women should continue their lives as is because making changes isn't going to make a difference in reality, especially when those changes are largely regarding the most unlikely rapes to happen in stranger rapes.

OneNewLeader · 10/11/2026 12:32

Years ago, a man once put it quite simply, rape is an act of violence, unexpected and undeserved, in all cases. If a man is stabbed, no one questions his clothes, his location or his sobriety.

Swipe left for the next trending thread