Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is this victim blaming?

617 replies

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:26

Just to begin, I consider myself a feminist, advocate for women’s rights (of course!) etc etc.

but I struggle with the line when it comes to victim blaming in some cases of rape and sexual assault.

In recent years, we’ve seen a rise in cases regarding women (often drunkenly) going back to hotel rooms and being raped once there. I fully support the conviction in such cases and have sympathy for the women.

However, I just don’t understand why some women put themselves in such dangerous situations? It’s a shame we have to think this way (ie. Be ‘on guard’ and cautious of men/rape/sexual assault), but it’s clear that something like this could happen if going to a hotel room with a man you do not know very well. So why do it?
I compare this to walking alone in the dark - we should be able to do this as women! But unfortunately, the vast majority of women wouldn’t do this due to the perceived danger. Yet why is pointing out the danger of going to a hotel room of a man you do not know considered victim blaming?

OP posts:
Douglasmummy · 10/11/2026 13:27

LVPLVT · 10/11/2026 11:53

I think there are two different points at play:

  1. a woman is never to blame for being sexually assaulted; and
  2. there are things we can do as women to mitigate the risk of us being sexually assaulted

Those things can coexist.

It doesn’t mean that a woman had it coming if she does something which increases her risk (I.e going home with a man she doesn’t know), but it does mean that there are things we can teach our daughters to help them navigate the reality of the threat they face from men.

Yes I think I agree with this. It's too late after you've been raped. The man is still a rapist, you may or may not get a conviction ( probably not) and it's not your fault but none of that matters once you have to live with the psychological trauma of being raped. Surely in all situations you weigh up the risk in each circumstance and it's fine to say to young people ' don't put yourself in risky situations' because the consequences are so grave the arguments about who's fault it is don't really matter when you have to live with a terrible trauma that cannot be erased.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/11/2026 13:26

nietzscheanvibe · 10/11/2026 13:25

I agree, but it's not victim blaming to ask why some people decide to "take that risk".

It's the very definition of victim blaming.

Especially as most of us take bigger risks every day.

ThreadGuardDog · 10/11/2026 13:26

nietzscheanvibe · 10/11/2026 13:16

I'll get flamed, but i agree with the op. Yes, only the rapist is to blame for raping, but similarly, only a burglar is to blame for burgling, and only a car thief is to blame for stealing a car, and only a murderer is to blame for murdering, but we take precautions against all of these things because we recognise the risk. Pointing out inherent risk isn't 'victim blaming'.

How do you protect yourself against murder I wonder ? I agree that we protect ourselves against theft of all kinds but installing car and burglar alarms doesn’t limit your life in the way that women would have to, to mitigate the risk that men pose.

nietzscheanvibe · 10/11/2026 13:25

TheOriginalEmu · 10/11/2026 13:20

And as long as taking that risk isn’t part of the discussion about what happened or used as a basis for a defence of the perpetrator, that’s fine.

I agree, but it's not victim blaming to ask why some people decide to "take that risk".

DeftGoldHedgehog · 10/11/2026 13:23

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 13:21

Ah. Interesting. Your jeans and sweatshirt are' revealing' to some men, btw.

Edited

Indeed. And when did I get the most cat calls, staring and harassment in my life? Going to and from school in my uniform.

dairydebris · 10/11/2026 13:23

KnittedPenguinHat · 10/11/2026 13:09

I don’t think you understood my point. By saying that your daughter could “fail” to take your advice the victim blaming is already implied. It’s built in to the way we talk about this issue.

I’m not saying don’t warn your daughters, I’m saying be careful how we phrase things because even when we give safety advice like this it shifts the responsibly to the victim. But the risk is still never zero, no matter what we do. And if something awful happened god forbid then the implication is already there, you didn’t keep yourself safe enough. You didn’t follow the advice enough. You failed.

Yes sorry, I don't understand your point. Saying someone failed to take the advice means they failed to take that advice. It doesn't mean that failure means the rape is their fault. That's a huge, wrongly assumed leap.

We don't tell our daughters, walk wherever, whenever you want. It doesn't matter if you're drunk. Don't worry, because if you do get raped, you can take comfort in the fact it wasn't your fault. We tell them to be careful because we know what some men are like. We do not see ourselves and pre blaming the victim. We do not say- if you go out like that you will be raped, and it will be your fault- We say, please take responsibility for yourself and lessen the risks as much as possible, and we all the time know whether or not the worst happens it was never, ever the victims fault.

But still we would prefer our children take best precautions to not be a victim. We say this is the full belief that if they do become a victim it was never their fault. But yet, it could have still been preventable.

Perhaps the disputed bit is fault/ control?

As with anything bad that happens to us as a result of someone elses wrongs, there are many actions we could have taken to prevent that wrong from harming us. Thats the actual truth. It doesn't mean that the harm that came to us is our fault.

I see what the OP is saying and I don't think she's victim blaming.

BillieWiper · 10/11/2026 13:23

LVPLVT · 10/11/2026 12:35

Picture this - you’re in a bar and you see a sign suggesting you should try not to leave your drink unattended.

Do you think:
a) that sounds sensible; or
b) OMG I am furious.

Why? The question you're asking has nothing to do with the OP who says women shouldn't go into rooms alone with men unless they expect to be raped?!

MitohMit · 10/11/2026 13:21

The thing is, the victim did not "decide" to get plastered and go to a hotel room with a man she hardly knows. Therefore, she did not decide to put herself in a dangerous situation. She got into a dangerous situation after losing her capacity for making any kind of sound decision.

She simply decided to have one drink, initially. Then a second. At some point, she was no longer thinking straight. Maybe she loved the feeling of being drunk because it shut down her feelings of hurt, possibly trauma, and banished all her inhibitions. She may have been blaming all those inhibitions for preventing her from having a fulfilling life.

So you can't really ask "what made her decide to go to a hotel room with this man?". You can maybe ask what made her have that first drink, or second drink, if she knows herself well enough to know that was a bad idea.

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 13:21

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:19

Hmmmmm. I’m not sure. I’m an ideal world a woman should be able to wear whatever she wants to! But do I think that a woman dressed in a super revealing way will attract more male attention? Yes. And that if a woman doesn’t want this kind of attention then it would be best not to dress like this? Maybe. It depends how upset she would be with this attention I suppose. Unfortunately there are lots of men out there who would probably jump to conclusions about why she’s dressed like this and think nothing of behaving horribly (in my opinion - I suppose some women may like this behaviour?) due to the way she’s dressed.

I don’t think it would make her more likely to be raped. But I think a portion of men may believe she would be more up for sex? And therefore would treat her in a more sexual way?

I don’t agree with this, but unfortunately we don’t live in an ideal world.

Ah. Interesting. Your jeans and sweatshirt are' revealing' to some men, btw.

TheOriginalEmu · 10/11/2026 13:20

nietzscheanvibe · 10/11/2026 13:16

I'll get flamed, but i agree with the op. Yes, only the rapist is to blame for raping, but similarly, only a burglar is to blame for burgling, and only a car thief is to blame for stealing a car, and only a murderer is to blame for murdering, but we take precautions against all of these things because we recognise the risk. Pointing out inherent risk isn't 'victim blaming'.

And as long as taking that risk isn’t part of the discussion about what happened or used as a basis for a defence of the perpetrator, that’s fine.

ScaredButUnavoidable · 10/11/2026 13:20

DeftGoldHedgehog · 10/11/2026 13:15

When I went home with a stranger after a night out I had absolutely no idea what kind of man he was. I knew the risks that men pose to women and I chose to ignore it and just “hoped” he was one of the good ones. Im sure the fact I’d had some alcohol played a role in my decision as I wouldn’t make the same decision if I was sober). I put myself in a potentially very dangerous situation with absolutely nobody who could potentially rescue me from it, so yes, I consider myself very lucky that no harm came to me as a result.

But more rapes are not carried out by a complete stranger, but by someone the woman slightly knows and thought she could trust. A relative, a friend, a colleague, a fellow student, someone she has been on a couple of dates with. You don't know what kind of man they are either, you just think you do.

I agree.

We risk assess to the best we can (or not in my case) but everyone knows that no amount of risk assessment removes the danger completely.

The risk is always there no matter how safe we think we are.

nietzscheanvibe · 10/11/2026 13:20

renovationqueen2 · 10/11/2026 11:46

Because in your eyes they are the 'right type' of victim.

WTF? The OP's talking about a completely different type of situation!

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:19

Faceonthewrongfoot · 10/11/2026 13:10

Out of curiosity OP, do you think that if a woman wears a short skirt and a revealing top when on a night out, that is also risky behaviour? The outfit is going to draw attention from men, whereas something more modest probably wouldn't, so is that also high risk behaviour? What about flirting with a stranger in a bar? Would that be risky as its giving him the impression you're interested when you might not be? Where would you draw the line in terms of when you would think 'why would you do that?' about a woman that has been raped?

Hmmmmm. I’m not sure. I’m an ideal world a woman should be able to wear whatever she wants to! But do I think that a woman dressed in a super revealing way will attract more male attention? Yes. And that if a woman doesn’t want this kind of attention then it would be best not to dress like this? Maybe. It depends how upset she would be with this attention I suppose. Unfortunately there are lots of men out there who would probably jump to conclusions about why she’s dressed like this and think nothing of behaving horribly (in my opinion - I suppose some women may like this behaviour?) due to the way she’s dressed.

I don’t think it would make her more likely to be raped. But I think a portion of men may believe she would be more up for sex? And therefore would treat her in a more sexual way?

I don’t agree with this, but unfortunately we don’t live in an ideal world.

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 10/11/2026 13:19

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 12:07

No. I wouldn’t ever walk somewhere remote in the dark.

That's nice that you have the choice.

All sorts of jobs mean that people have to be places where they are alone or have to meet people in 'unsafe' locations. The list is huge and can cover anyone from carers to shopworkers.

Should women turn down these jobs?

ConstantlyFuriosa · 10/11/2026 13:19

Yes, you’re victim blaming. The mindset needs to change from ‘women: police your behaviour in order to stay safe’, to: ‘men, alter your behaviour and stop harming women’.

It’s really very straightforward.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 10/11/2026 13:19

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 13:16

Where do you draw the line? Are short skirts ok? Is going to bars ok? Because some men may take that as an invite to rape. And what makes your line the correct one?

Exactly and what about going running on your own? I used to do that a lot. The risk of getting run over on the street is a lot higher than the risk of being attacked while running on a rural footpath, so I decided it was reasonable to take that risk.

nietzscheanvibe · 10/11/2026 13:16

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:37

Of course a woman reserves the right to say no, even if she is naked with a man on top of her. and I don’t think a woman would be in any way in the wrong if she did this.

I’m not disputing this.

I just don’t get why a woman would put herself in a position where something scary like this could happen.

I'll get flamed, but i agree with the op. Yes, only the rapist is to blame for raping, but similarly, only a burglar is to blame for burgling, and only a car thief is to blame for stealing a car, and only a murderer is to blame for murdering, but we take precautions against all of these things because we recognise the risk. Pointing out inherent risk isn't 'victim blaming'.

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 13:16

ScaredButUnavoidable · 10/11/2026 13:12

But it’s not just about assault.

It’s about being lucky anytime we escape harm when we take any kind of risk.

If someone chooses to take drugs they’re lucky if no harm comes to them from it.

If someone chooses to get in the passenger seat of a drunk driver they’re lucky if they aren’t killed.

If someone chooses not to wear a seatbelt in a car that then crashes, they’re lucky if they survive.

If someone decides to take a walk across a frozen lake, falls in but thankfully gets rescued they’re lucky they didn’t drown.

If someone decides to go swimming at an Australian beach which is known for its dangerous waves, they get into danger but thankfully they are rescued by the Lifeguards, they are lucky they didn’t drown.

We all know how to risk assess and we choose what risks we take. Avoiding harm when you’ve done something knowingly risky is lucky.

When I went home with a stranger after a night out I had absolutely no idea what kind of man he was. I knew the risks that men pose to women and I chose to ignore it and just “hoped” he was one of the good ones. Im sure the fact I’d had some alcohol played a role in my decision as I wouldn’t make the same decision if I was sober). I put myself in a potentially very dangerous situation with absolutely nobody who could potentially rescue me from it, so yes, I consider myself very lucky that no harm came to me as a result.

A rape is ALWAYS the fault of the man and although women should be safe around men, we aren’t and everyone knows that.

To acknowledge that isn’t victim blaming.

We see countless threads on MN every day about the risks that men post to women when it comes to sexual assault, sexual violence, rape etc. Women know that men are a huge threat to our safety.

So as unfair as it may seem, we do have to risk assess how to keep ourselves as safe as can around men.

We risk assess all the time to avoid potentially dangerous situations and although it’s depressing that those assessments now need to include how to keep ourselves safe from men, thats sadly just the reality of the world.

Where do you draw the line? Are short skirts ok? Is going to bars ok? Because some men may take that as an invite to rape. And what makes your line the correct one?

DeftGoldHedgehog · 10/11/2026 13:15

When I went home with a stranger after a night out I had absolutely no idea what kind of man he was. I knew the risks that men pose to women and I chose to ignore it and just “hoped” he was one of the good ones. Im sure the fact I’d had some alcohol played a role in my decision as I wouldn’t make the same decision if I was sober). I put myself in a potentially very dangerous situation with absolutely nobody who could potentially rescue me from it, so yes, I consider myself very lucky that no harm came to me as a result.

But more rapes are not carried out by a complete stranger, but by someone the woman slightly knows and thought she could trust. A relative, a friend, a colleague, a fellow student, someone she has been on a couple of dates with. You don't know what kind of man they are either, you just think you do.

KnittedPenguinHat · 10/11/2026 13:13

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 13:00

Maybe because I am not a home and it enrages me that I am compared to an inanimate object that can be locked up.
Quite close to the logic of Islamists that women must be covered like a piece of meat.
Don't leave your jewellery out! 🙄

Edited

Yes I’m always bemused when it becomes an issue of protecting women as if they’re property how much misogyny our society has in common with extremists. What was she wearing? Cover up. Walking alone? Lock up your daughters and wives!

ScaredButUnavoidable · 10/11/2026 13:12

aberturret · 10/11/2026 12:54

I understand all this, I really do but I hate that we live in a world where we describe ourselves as “lucky” because we weren’t assaulted when we took a risk.

But it’s not just about assault.

It’s about being lucky anytime we escape harm when we take any kind of risk.

If someone chooses to take drugs they’re lucky if no harm comes to them from it.

If someone chooses to get in the passenger seat of a drunk driver they’re lucky if they aren’t killed.

If someone chooses not to wear a seatbelt in a car that then crashes, they’re lucky if they survive.

If someone decides to take a walk across a frozen lake, falls in but thankfully gets rescued they’re lucky they didn’t drown.

If someone decides to go swimming at an Australian beach which is known for its dangerous waves, they get into danger but thankfully they are rescued by the Lifeguards, they are lucky they didn’t drown.

We all know how to risk assess and we choose what risks we take. Avoiding harm when you’ve done something knowingly risky is lucky.

When I went home with a stranger after a night out I had absolutely no idea what kind of man he was. I knew the risks that men pose to women and I chose to ignore it and just “hoped” he was one of the good ones. Im sure the fact I’d had some alcohol played a role in my decision as I wouldn’t make the same decision if I was sober). I put myself in a potentially very dangerous situation with absolutely nobody who could potentially rescue me from it, so yes, I consider myself very lucky that no harm came to me as a result.

A rape is ALWAYS the fault of the man and although women should be safe around men, we aren’t and everyone knows that.

To acknowledge that isn’t victim blaming.

We see countless threads on MN every day about the risks that men post to women when it comes to sexual assault, sexual violence, rape etc. Women know that men are a huge threat to our safety.

So as unfair as it may seem, we do have to risk assess how to keep ourselves as safe as can around men.

We risk assess all the time to avoid potentially dangerous situations and although it’s depressing that those assessments now need to include how to keep ourselves safe from men, thats sadly just the reality of the world.

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 13:12

claphamjunction123 · 10/11/2026 13:08

irked? You sound increasingly insufferable, I hope you never end up on a jury trial

Luckily the judge in the RB case understood that women can change their minds at any time, even after they go to a man's room for sex, or to admire the view or to borrow a pencil, or any bloody reason.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 10/11/2026 13:11

The problem is women may consent to sex with that person.

Then the man takes that as carte blanche to do any type of sex she may not have consented to or bring their mates along to have a go. Are you seriously saying that you consent to "anything goes" if you go back to someone's hotel room? @Feedingmybaby

Faceonthewrongfoot · 10/11/2026 13:10

Out of curiosity OP, do you think that if a woman wears a short skirt and a revealing top when on a night out, that is also risky behaviour? The outfit is going to draw attention from men, whereas something more modest probably wouldn't, so is that also high risk behaviour? What about flirting with a stranger in a bar? Would that be risky as its giving him the impression you're interested when you might not be? Where would you draw the line in terms of when you would think 'why would you do that?' about a woman that has been raped?

KnittedPenguinHat · 10/11/2026 13:09

dairydebris · 10/11/2026 12:56

I don't think you understood my point. Don't we all advise our girls like this? But not see it as pre- victim blaming? Just good advice.
If they don't take the good advice, and the worst happens, is it their fault? No, it's the fault of the person who did it to them.

Do you honestly not warn your daughters along these lines?

If you do warn your daughters along these lines, it's not victim blaming is it?

I know life is just a series of choices that we make, each choice with a range of possible outcomes. Taking steps to minimize risk is a personal matter... with upsides and downsides. You go back to a hotel room with an unknown man, or for that matter stay in a relationship with a man who's waving red flags left right and centre, then you are taking on a higher level of risk than some others. It's not victim blaming I don't think. It's taking a risk adverse / risk accepting stance. That's real life.

It's separate to saying you are to blame for this. The rapist is always the one to blame.

Personally I find personal responsibility to be very, very key to how I see feminism.

I don’t think you understood my point. By saying that your daughter could “fail” to take your advice the victim blaming is already implied. It’s built in to the way we talk about this issue.

I’m not saying don’t warn your daughters, I’m saying be careful how we phrase things because even when we give safety advice like this it shifts the responsibly to the victim. But the risk is still never zero, no matter what we do. And if something awful happened god forbid then the implication is already there, you didn’t keep yourself safe enough. You didn’t follow the advice enough. You failed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread