Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is this victim blaming?

617 replies

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:26

Just to begin, I consider myself a feminist, advocate for women’s rights (of course!) etc etc.

but I struggle with the line when it comes to victim blaming in some cases of rape and sexual assault.

In recent years, we’ve seen a rise in cases regarding women (often drunkenly) going back to hotel rooms and being raped once there. I fully support the conviction in such cases and have sympathy for the women.

However, I just don’t understand why some women put themselves in such dangerous situations? It’s a shame we have to think this way (ie. Be ‘on guard’ and cautious of men/rape/sexual assault), but it’s clear that something like this could happen if going to a hotel room with a man you do not know very well. So why do it?
I compare this to walking alone in the dark - we should be able to do this as women! But unfortunately, the vast majority of women wouldn’t do this due to the perceived danger. Yet why is pointing out the danger of going to a hotel room of a man you do not know considered victim blaming?

OP posts:
nietzscheanvibe · 10/11/2026 13:52

ConstantlyFuriosa · 10/11/2026 13:49

It’s not helpful to compare burglary with sexual assault or murder. It reduces the victims to an object.

I take your point, but the analogy is useful in highlighting an inconsistency in attitudes nonetheless.

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/11/2026 13:52

shuggles · 10/11/2026 13:49

@Feedingmybaby I compare this to walking alone in the dark - we should be able to do this as women!

I never understand this one. No one expects to able to walk safely at night, hence why taxis exist.

So why should women be able to do something that no one else can freely do?

Huh? You think women in London- that's the only city I have experience of- don't walk alone? We do.

twistytwin · 10/11/2026 13:52

I don’t think OP is victim blaming. Like a poster said, you can concurrently believe that a) a woman who is sexually assaulted is not at fault, solely the man assaulting her is, and b) that we do live in a world where rapists exist and therefore it’s sensible to take precautions, despite the fact we really shouldn’t have to, and I hate that we do have to.

How many of you would advise your daughters not to take any precautions because they shouldn’t have to? It’s not realistic in the world we live in where it’s not all men, but it’s bloody always a man. I don’t tell my daughter how to dress on a night out, but I do make sure she knows how to keep herself safe.

mysittingduck · 10/11/2026 13:52

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:29

Of course they don’t! And in these cases, I fully support the women and agree that the men should be prosecuted and that they are not to blame.

but equally, I do think “why would they put themselves in such a scary situation?!”

I am with you OP in wishing that women would take account of the danger they are in and in particular that would avoid getting drunk except in really safe spaces, eg in their own homes and with people they can trust. It is not their 'fault' if they are abused and they have committed no 'crime' by deciding to go into a hotel room with a strange man, but the fact is that it's really dangerous. The fact that it shouldn't be dangerous isn't really the point.

themarvelofmarvels · 10/11/2026 13:51

OP, you are right in that women do need to protect themselves and not put themselves into positions of danger.

DD is 18 and at Uni now. I talked to her about not drinking so much that she passes out or doesn't know what she is doing and about not walking home on her own from a club at 3am. I told her about drink spiking and not to leave drinks unattended or accept them from strangers.

I did those things in the same way that I told her not to walk around waving her mobile phone in front of her, and also told her to keep her handbag zipped and near her front at all times.

It is not victim blaming to tell a woman to keep herself safe. The rapist or robber are still in the wrong and will always be the ones to blame, but there are things that you can do to reduce the odds of it happening.

Glowingup · 10/11/2026 13:51

ThreadGuardDog · 10/11/2026 13:48

I don’t think telling women to stay indoors because there’s a lunatic serial killer active and on the loose is remotely the same thing as advising women to limit what they do to mitigate the behaviour of men in general. At all.

Well I'd say it's quite similar actually. What if it's a serial rapist rather than a killer? What if a university has had numerous reports of drug-rape on campus and tells female students never to leave a drink unattended and to avoid drinking to excess? When is it okay to warn people about safety and when should we class it as victim-blaming?

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:51

Bloozie · 10/11/2026 13:46

For a woman to do as you describe here and mark herself safe from men, she needs to cover all bare flesh, stay indoors after dark, and not drink alcohol in the presence of men. She should avoid conversation with any man she does not intend to sleep with. If she has a conversation with a man and changes her mind, that's on her.

Are you SURE you want to pursue this line of thought? Not least because we know it doesn't stop the raping. The biggest protection against rape for a woman is to isolate herself from all male partners, friends and relatives, and never be in their company alone, as 70% of rapes are inflicted by someone you know very well or have an intimate relationship with.

Are you SURE women's behaviour is the problem, and they should know better?

I haven’t said women’s behaviour is the problem? I’m saying that it surprises me sometimes that women are ok taking such big risks knowing how awful many men are.

OP posts:
LetMeGoogleThat · 10/11/2026 13:50

ThreadGuardDog · 10/11/2026 13:42

This. Sums it up perfectly. It all seems perfectly reasonable until we get to a situation where the fact that a woman has done anything perceived as risky is used in mitigation.

Can you imagine the police questioning of men for any crime committed against them:

But what were you wearing?
Did you say no?
Did you try to push them off?
Did you scream?
Had you been drinking?
Did you cover drinks?
Why did you chose to walk alone?
Did you take drugs?
Did you give an indication earlier that you wanted to be insert crime?

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:50

ThreadGuardDog · 10/11/2026 13:46

That’s it. I’m out. I thought we moved away from this kind of ‘she was asking for it m’lud’ kind of shit years ago.

Where did I say that?

OP posts:
ConstantlyFuriosa · 10/11/2026 13:49

nietzscheanvibe · 10/11/2026 13:45

If your house gets burgled after you go out for the day leaving all your doors unlocked, people might say you were unwise to take that risk, even though you have a right not to be burgled. Why is it that people are happy to take precautions that will protect mere property, houses, cars, and suchlike, but will take risks with their lives? Yes, you're right, you shouldn't have been raped, and the rapist is to blame, and you shouldn't have been murdered, and the murderer is to blame, but your DEAD! Even though you win the semantic argument FFS

It’s not helpful to compare burglary with sexual assault or murder. It reduces the victims to an object.

shuggles · 10/11/2026 13:49

@Feedingmybaby I compare this to walking alone in the dark - we should be able to do this as women!

I never understand this one. No one expects to able to walk safely at night, hence why taxis exist.

So why should women be able to do something that no one else can freely do?

Glowingup · 10/11/2026 13:49

Then we educate the men - although why they should need this in this day and age is ridiculous - not tell women to limit or control the way they behave just in case the men attack them. Ffs, it’s not difficult.

Well I'd say it is difficult. We have been 'educating' for a very long time. One of the most heinous and socially reviled crimes is child sexual abuse, yet many men still commit it. Some people will never give a fuck however much you tell them that something is wrong. Especially men who prey on women down dark alleys. The ones where it might work a bit are the ones who commit date-rape or take advantage of drunk friends. But even then, I am pretty sure they know it's wrong but if they think they can get away with it, they will.

Another relevant point is the huge number of women who claim their DS is an angel and would never engage in anything untoward and treat grown men or nearly grown men like children and make every excuse in the book for their abusive and nasty behaviour.

mamaof4losingmymind · 10/11/2026 13:48

Its very very rare women get raped or murdered by complete strangers.

ThreadGuardDog · 10/11/2026 13:48

Glowingup · 10/11/2026 13:43

Well for a start, a man is statistically at more risk of being physically attacked if walking by himself (not raped but beaten up or stabbed) so that is not true.

No it's not a woman's fault but what good is blame if it's already happened? The woman will already have to live with having been attacked. It's like the Yorkshire Ripper when he was active in Leeds. They told women not to go out. Victim-blaming? Does blame matter when, if you did end up one of his victims when walking alone, you end up dead? It's about keeping safe.

I don’t think telling women to stay indoors because there’s a lunatic serial killer active and on the loose is remotely the same thing as advising women to limit what they do to mitigate the behaviour of men in general. At all.

Whyarepeople · 10/11/2026 13:46

Your original question was 'so why do it?'

To give you a genuine answer to this question, women do it for the same reason anyone does anything, which is because they want to.

That's not the actual question you're asking though. What you're asking is, 'why don't some women respond to the threats men make towards them in the way that society expects them to?'

I'm not sure why you're asking this question. Are you annoyed at those women? Or jealous of them? Or something else?

Bloozie · 10/11/2026 13:46

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:40

Yes I would think that! I own expensive jewellery and wouldn’t wear it in central London as I know about the risks of people having jewellery stolen. I turn my engagement ring around on the tube too.

I don’t think it’s right that we should have to do these things, but if it means I’m less likely to have them stolen, then I’ll leave my expensive watch at home and turn my ring around.

Edited

For a woman to do as you describe here and mark herself safe from men, she needs to cover all bare flesh, stay indoors after dark, and not drink alcohol in the presence of men. She should avoid conversation with any man she does not intend to sleep with. If she has a conversation with a man and changes her mind, that's on her.

Are you SURE you want to pursue this line of thought? Not least because we know it doesn't stop the raping. The biggest protection against rape for a woman is to isolate herself from all male partners, friends and relatives, and never be in their company alone, as 70% of rapes are inflicted by someone you know very well or have an intimate relationship with.

Are you SURE women's behaviour is the problem, and they should know better?

ThreadGuardDog · 10/11/2026 13:46

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:19

Hmmmmm. I’m not sure. I’m an ideal world a woman should be able to wear whatever she wants to! But do I think that a woman dressed in a super revealing way will attract more male attention? Yes. And that if a woman doesn’t want this kind of attention then it would be best not to dress like this? Maybe. It depends how upset she would be with this attention I suppose. Unfortunately there are lots of men out there who would probably jump to conclusions about why she’s dressed like this and think nothing of behaving horribly (in my opinion - I suppose some women may like this behaviour?) due to the way she’s dressed.

I don’t think it would make her more likely to be raped. But I think a portion of men may believe she would be more up for sex? And therefore would treat her in a more sexual way?

I don’t agree with this, but unfortunately we don’t live in an ideal world.

That’s it. I’m out. I thought we moved away from this kind of ‘she was asking for it m’lud’ kind of shit years ago.

ScaredButUnavoidable · 10/11/2026 13:46

MajorProcrastination · 10/11/2026 13:36

This is victim blaming 101.

You can be drunk and consent to going to a room with a man you fancy to kiss, you might also be totally up for going further but you absolutely don't want anal sex or sex without a condom or rough sex or vaginal sex, whatever, that person is absolutely allowed to be clear about what they're comfortable to do and the moment the other person forces things further, or ignores them that's a completely non-consensual situation. It doesn't matter that she's been drinking and wants to kiss or be intimate in any way, it still is rape if he does anything further than she wants to do.

And everyone knows and agrees with this.

Well, every woman does anyway.

The problem is that men seem to have a problem understanding it (or they just don’t give a shit about consent usually) which is why we should always view them as a potential risk to our safety.

mamaof4losingmymind · 10/11/2026 13:45

Because men like this lie and charm there way into tricking women into these situations and a lot of the time the rapist knows the victim so there is a level of trust already.

CurlewKate · 10/11/2026 13:45

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:26

Just to begin, I consider myself a feminist, advocate for women’s rights (of course!) etc etc.

but I struggle with the line when it comes to victim blaming in some cases of rape and sexual assault.

In recent years, we’ve seen a rise in cases regarding women (often drunkenly) going back to hotel rooms and being raped once there. I fully support the conviction in such cases and have sympathy for the women.

However, I just don’t understand why some women put themselves in such dangerous situations? It’s a shame we have to think this way (ie. Be ‘on guard’ and cautious of men/rape/sexual assault), but it’s clear that something like this could happen if going to a hotel room with a man you do not know very well. So why do it?
I compare this to walking alone in the dark - we should be able to do this as women! But unfortunately, the vast majority of women wouldn’t do this due to the perceived danger. Yet why is pointing out the danger of going to a hotel room of a man you do not know considered victim blaming?

Human beings are allowed to be stupid and not be raped by other human beings.

IsItSnowing · 10/11/2026 13:45

But OP you say yourself. Women should be able to do all these things without fear of being attacked. The victims are just that, victims. What they did or didn't do is irrelevent.
Nobody should be blamed for doing anything just because it precedes getting attacked. Trying to make what they did or didn't do part of the equation is quite simply victim blaming.

nietzscheanvibe · 10/11/2026 13:45

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/11/2026 13:26

It's the very definition of victim blaming.

Especially as most of us take bigger risks every day.

If your house gets burgled after you go out for the day leaving all your doors unlocked, people might say you were unwise to take that risk, even though you have a right not to be burgled. Why is it that people are happy to take precautions that will protect mere property, houses, cars, and suchlike, but will take risks with their lives? Yes, you're right, you shouldn't have been raped, and the rapist is to blame, and you shouldn't have been murdered, and the murderer is to blame, but your DEAD! Even though you win the semantic argument FFS

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:45

Bloozie · 10/11/2026 13:40

Yes, you are victim blaming. Massively.

A man can walk anywhere at any time of day or night, in any state, and be ok. He is arguably safER if a woman is around, because should he find himself so incapacitated he can't care for himself, we are likely to help rather than assault him.

The fact a woman cannot do the same is not her fault. It is the man's fault. ALWAYS. There are no mitigations. She should have known better, she should have dressed differently, she shouldn't have had a drink with him if she wasn't going to fuck him... Consent is not a grey area.

I would also advise my sons to not walk alone late at night and to not engage in arguments after alcohol has been consumed etc. (with the risk of men fighting after a drink).

OP posts:
NovemberMorn · 10/11/2026 13:45

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:36

Where did I say I blame women?

Where did anyone say that??

JuliaMaesa · 10/11/2026 13:44

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:40

Yes I would think that! I own expensive jewellery and wouldn’t wear it in central London as I know about the risks of people having jewellery stolen. I turn my engagement ring around on the tube too.

I don’t think it’s right that we should have to do these things, but if it means I’m less likely to have them stolen, then I’ll leave my expensive watch at home and turn my ring around.

Edited

OK, fair enough then.

Let's move from the law protecting everyone equally (not that it does) to the law only protecting those that can protect themselves.

Which isn't really a change is it ? Not quite sure how it could sustain a 200+ post thread really.