Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is this victim blaming?

617 replies

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:26

Just to begin, I consider myself a feminist, advocate for women’s rights (of course!) etc etc.

but I struggle with the line when it comes to victim blaming in some cases of rape and sexual assault.

In recent years, we’ve seen a rise in cases regarding women (often drunkenly) going back to hotel rooms and being raped once there. I fully support the conviction in such cases and have sympathy for the women.

However, I just don’t understand why some women put themselves in such dangerous situations? It’s a shame we have to think this way (ie. Be ‘on guard’ and cautious of men/rape/sexual assault), but it’s clear that something like this could happen if going to a hotel room with a man you do not know very well. So why do it?
I compare this to walking alone in the dark - we should be able to do this as women! But unfortunately, the vast majority of women wouldn’t do this due to the perceived danger. Yet why is pointing out the danger of going to a hotel room of a man you do not know considered victim blaming?

OP posts:
Bloozie · 10/11/2026 14:03

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:45

I would also advise my sons to not walk alone late at night and to not engage in arguments after alcohol has been consumed etc. (with the risk of men fighting after a drink).

And given, as someone has pointed out, that men are statistically more vulnerable to physical attack when walking alone than women, would you therefore lament your sons' poor decision-making if they were attacked walking down the street on their way home?

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/11/2026 14:03

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:53

Do the police actually ask questions like this in rape cases? I can understand asking about alcohol and drug consumption as I suppose it changes the reliability of recall, but the other questions? I would be really shocked if they asked these questions for any other reason that information gathering!

Yes.

There was a well known case that went to court in America several years ago now which included showing everyone in court the victims knickers to try and prove that because they were wearing sexy knickers, they clearly wanted to have sex.

It's a reason why the vast majority of rapes go unreported.

NovemberMorn · 10/11/2026 14:02

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 10/11/2026 13:55

But what will you say to her if god forbid, she follows the rules and it happens anyway?

Probably the same thing she would say if she didn't follow the rules...it wasn't her fault, she is not to blame ... because she wouldn't be.

dairydebris · 10/11/2026 14:01

FunAtParties · 10/11/2026 14:00

Ps. You’re not a feminist. You’re not an advocate for women. Say what you like but cut the delusions that you are a friend to women.

You're speaking as if you know the OP.

You don't.

FunAtParties · 10/11/2026 14:00

Ps. You’re not a feminist. You’re not an advocate for women. Say what you like but cut the delusions that you are a friend to women.

NovemberMorn · 10/11/2026 14:00

Mulledjuice · 10/11/2026 13:53

i can't leave my fanny at home.

😆😆😆

dairydebris · 10/11/2026 14:00

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/11/2026 13:53

But the fact is that the biggest risk to a woman is a man that she knows, not a stranger.

I know. Which is why there are endless threads on here advising women to end relationships with men who display red flags.

It's not victim blaming to point out that there is a chance if you continue to spend time with this man there is a higher chance you will suffer abuse. It's good advice. It's advising taking personal responsibility for your safely given than man sounds like an increased risk.

I just don't think its victim blaming to point out certain behaviors come with increased risk. Its just reality.

If you don't enter a hotel room with a stranger you are less likely to get raped by said stranger. Less likely to have a fun night and meet your future husband too. We all weigh up the possibilities/ risks of both and choose according to our own personalities.

This isn't victim blaming imo.

'This wouldn't have happened if you hadnt done this.'

Isn't the same as

'It's your fault this happened.'

Personally I believe we should be free to say the former without people telling us we mean the latter.

Glowingup · 10/11/2026 13:59

ConstantlyFuriosa · 10/11/2026 13:49

It’s not helpful to compare burglary with sexual assault or murder. It reduces the victims to an object.

No, that's a cop-out. It's a similar principle other than that bodily integrity is so much more important than possessions so it's even more worthy of protection. While I could live with my property being violated, I'd find it much harder to live with my body being violated. So I would want to take every precaution I could to avoid it happening (even if I couldn't fully eliminate it).

Russell Brand has been blamed for rape and has been jailed but I bet you that his victims' lives are still destroyed by his actions. So I will continue to tell my DD when she's older to keep an eye on her drinks, do not get blackout drunk, do not go back to some random's house 'just to kiss' and do not walk alone in an unlit area. It won't be her fault if anything happens but I'd rather it didn't happen.

LetMeGoogleThat · 10/11/2026 13:59

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:53

Do the police actually ask questions like this in rape cases? I can understand asking about alcohol and drug consumption as I suppose it changes the reliability of recall, but the other questions? I would be really shocked if they asked these questions for any other reason that information gathering!

Yes, they do. And its also used in cross examination in court. Why do you think that 85% of rape is unreported? And that conviction rates are only 3.4% of that tiny minority?
The victim in a rape case doesn't own the process, we are literally just evidence to the proceedings, not even referred to as a victim. We are just a witness.

worldshottestmom · 10/11/2026 13:59

Women should be able to walk around outside naked and have nothing happen to them. However, we know that isn't the case, and not because she's doing anything wrong by being naked, but only because rapists exist. We have to keep ourselves safe from the scum predators that plague this Earth, taking precautions to mitigate the likelihood of such attacks occurring.

That being said, I would never, NEVER say to a woman that the SA happened because she "put herself in a dangerous situation". That exact statement, and that exact sentiment is itself putting the blame on the victim. Because you're saying had she not CHOSE to put herself in a dangerous situation, then she would not have been raped.

We know from the large array of different scenarios in which rape occurs that this is not a fool-proof way of stopping SA. You don't walk home late at night alone, you don't go out in the dark, you keep your keys pointed out of your fist, your cover yourself to not show skin, you walk home with a friend. Yet that night your husband decides to rape you. Do you see that? Do you see how not putting yourself in dangerous situations isn't the only mitigating factor to prevent this? You could take all the precautions in the world and it could still happen, because the problem is never the woman, its never the scenario, the problem is always the rapist.

I was drugged and raped at the age of 18 by a group of men on one of my first nights out in uni. My at the time boyfriend told me I put myself in that situation. And I did, I did put myself in the situatuion of going to a house party, I did not put myself in a situation of being drugged and raped. That was the choice of the rapists. Reading that exact statement now makes my blood fucking boil.

BackJustToSay · 10/11/2026 13:58

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 11:29

Of course they don’t! And in these cases, I fully support the women and agree that the men should be prosecuted and that they are not to blame.

but equally, I do think “why would they put themselves in such a scary situation?!”

Generally, the man has done a lot to give them the impression that they have nothing to fear, that it's platonic, they're just enjoying the conversation, just want a cuddle on the first night but will respect them and leave it at that, etc etc . They're not going back with a leery man that won't stop grabbing at them.

Dutch1e · 10/11/2026 13:57

Mulledjuice · 10/11/2026 13:53

i can't leave my fanny at home.

😂😂 brilliant!

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/11/2026 13:56

nietzscheanvibe · 10/11/2026 13:45

If your house gets burgled after you go out for the day leaving all your doors unlocked, people might say you were unwise to take that risk, even though you have a right not to be burgled. Why is it that people are happy to take precautions that will protect mere property, houses, cars, and suchlike, but will take risks with their lives? Yes, you're right, you shouldn't have been raped, and the rapist is to blame, and you shouldn't have been murdered, and the murderer is to blame, but your DEAD! Even though you win the semantic argument FFS

The fact that several people have compared women to objects such as houses and cars is part of the problem.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 10/11/2026 13:55

montysmaw · 10/11/2026 11:50

But the poster hasnt said that the rapists arent to blame.

I will certainly be teaching my daughters about safe choices and behaviors precisely because the world is full of male predators. It would be irresponsible not to.

That would not constitute victim blaming. I want them to be safe and aware and sadly, not trusting.

But what will you say to her if god forbid, she follows the rules and it happens anyway?

MajorProcrastination · 10/11/2026 13:55

Did you see the judge's statement at Russel Brand's sentencing hearing?

"They were both accomplished women who took perfectly reasonable decisions to go to a party and have a few drinks or to go to your house for one type of consensual sex they were no more or less vulnerable than any adult woman making those choices. I pause to add and stress at once the fact that they did so in no way shape or form diminishes your culpability for sexually assaulting one and raping the other."

He next says something that is really clear, really obvious and I hope answers your initial post:

“Whatever women wear, wherever they go, whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and demand justice in the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Mr Brand, act without their consent.”

WHATEVER.

Dutch1e · 10/11/2026 13:55

montysmaw · 10/11/2026 11:50

But the poster hasnt said that the rapists arent to blame.

I will certainly be teaching my daughters about safe choices and behaviors precisely because the world is full of male predators. It would be irresponsible not to.

That would not constitute victim blaming. I want them to be safe and aware and sadly, not trusting.

"why would they put themselves..."

The OP is shifting responsibility to the victims of rape.

Vespanest · 10/11/2026 13:55

How long do women have to wait until men educate themselves, it's not a lack of understanding. Yes women should be able to live in a society that is not controlled by fear but I would be a hypocrite if I didn't admit that I have influenced my daughter and nieces on the risks of trusting a man to recognise and agree to consent. I would never blame any woman but I'm always going to warn my daughter of these risks.

NovemberMorn · 10/11/2026 13:55

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:45

I would also advise my sons to not walk alone late at night and to not engage in arguments after alcohol has been consumed etc. (with the risk of men fighting after a drink).

Many men are attacked. My own son went to a college dance and was attacked by 3 or 4 strangers when walking home alone. We spent the night in A&E whilst he had his wounds cleaned and scans to his head.
Males just face different dangers.

PeasOff · 10/11/2026 13:55

Of course it’s victim blaming! How can it be anything but?! You’re essentially giving reasons why a woman should have avoided a situation, rather than focusing on the person who chose to rape her.

There’s a difference between acknowledging that risks exist and suggesting women are responsible for anticipating and avoiding them. The onus shouldn't be on women to restrict their social lives, choices or freedom because men might assault them. The onus should be on men just not feeling it's fine to bloody do as they want to another person's body.

ThreadGuardDog · 10/11/2026 13:54

Glowingup · 10/11/2026 13:49

Then we educate the men - although why they should need this in this day and age is ridiculous - not tell women to limit or control the way they behave just in case the men attack them. Ffs, it’s not difficult.

Well I'd say it is difficult. We have been 'educating' for a very long time. One of the most heinous and socially reviled crimes is child sexual abuse, yet many men still commit it. Some people will never give a fuck however much you tell them that something is wrong. Especially men who prey on women down dark alleys. The ones where it might work a bit are the ones who commit date-rape or take advantage of drunk friends. But even then, I am pretty sure they know it's wrong but if they think they can get away with it, they will.

Another relevant point is the huge number of women who claim their DS is an angel and would never engage in anything untoward and treat grown men or nearly grown men like children and make every excuse in the book for their abusive and nasty behaviour.

CSA is a very different beast. It’s not about what you do, it’s who you are and if that’s the case, no amount of ‘education’ is going to change anything.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 10/11/2026 13:54

OnionRingsss · 10/11/2026 11:45

i get what you mean op, but mumsnet is really weird about this kind of thing so don’t think you will get people agreeing with you on here mumsnetters seem very keen to push for sleeping with a man on the first date, like don’t they care about how dangerous it could be to be alone and naked with a man you just met? who is a stranger and can over power you, i find the attitude on here rather bizarre there is currently a thread running where the op waited 10 dates before sleeping with a man and is essentially advised to sleep with men as soon as possible (first or second date) i mean why would you be happy to be alone and naked with someone you just me like that, does make you wonder why put yourself in a vulnerable situation where anything can happen…

Edited

in my 20s I had lots of casual sex. So much. Often when drunk. You may have called me a slag. All consensual with men who also enjoyed casual sex.

Any woman should be allowed to do this if she pleases and be safe from rape and assault, even when drunk and be able at any time to say stop, or no not like that. And have that respected.

Any guy who disregards that is a predator. The man is the problem in that scenario

Mulledjuice · 10/11/2026 13:53

dairydebris · 10/11/2026 13:42

???

It doesn't mean its his fault the watch was stolen.

But it's still true to say if he had left his watch at home this wouldn't have happened.

His choice is to have the higher risk of having the watch stolen and enjoy the rewards of people admiring him for it, or on the other hand leave it at home in the drawer with less risk of getting nicked but less pleasure in showing it off.

Personal responsibility is a matter of actual real life fact.

Blame is different and always lies with the offender.

i can't leave my fanny at home.

Feedingmybaby · 10/11/2026 13:53

LetMeGoogleThat · 10/11/2026 13:50

Can you imagine the police questioning of men for any crime committed against them:

But what were you wearing?
Did you say no?
Did you try to push them off?
Did you scream?
Had you been drinking?
Did you cover drinks?
Why did you chose to walk alone?
Did you take drugs?
Did you give an indication earlier that you wanted to be insert crime?

Do the police actually ask questions like this in rape cases? I can understand asking about alcohol and drug consumption as I suppose it changes the reliability of recall, but the other questions? I would be really shocked if they asked these questions for any other reason that information gathering!

OP posts:
Tarttlet · 10/11/2026 13:53

Whyarepeople · 10/11/2026 13:46

Your original question was 'so why do it?'

To give you a genuine answer to this question, women do it for the same reason anyone does anything, which is because they want to.

That's not the actual question you're asking though. What you're asking is, 'why don't some women respond to the threats men make towards them in the way that society expects them to?'

I'm not sure why you're asking this question. Are you annoyed at those women? Or jealous of them? Or something else?

Also because good things can come from spending time alone with men, including in hotel rooms! You could have a great orgasm, have a laugh, make a friend, meet your DH...

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/11/2026 13:53

dairydebris · 10/11/2026 13:37

Come on. Thats not victim blaming. Thats literally a question about the psychology of the individual.

Some people do take more risks than others.

That doesn't mean they are more to blame. It just means they are slightly more likely to find themselves in a risky situation. I'm one of these people btw. I know for example getting on a plane by myself to some countries carries significantly more risk of violent crime than having a quiet spa weekend in Bath with a friend. I do it because the calculated benefit of seeing this place outweighs the risk. I take what precautions I can. If something bad happens to me I both know it wasn't my fault and that it would have been less likely to happen at home. ( non zero though! )

We risk not being able to speak in facts if we can't admit that some behaviors are riskier than others.

But the fact is that the biggest risk to a woman is a man that she knows, not a stranger.

Swipe left for the next trending thread