Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the problem is not that there aren’t enough good men about

315 replies

MrsShawnHatosy · 10/11/2026 10:42

But that too many women are not attracted to the kind of man that makes a good life partner? And are given the ick by such ridiculous trivial things? (The current ick thread demonstrates this quite well.). I’ve known women who are attracted to the same type over and over - alpha male or uber laddish types - and it never works out. Or they stay together but she puts up with him going to lap dancing clubs or repeatedly coming home drunk and pissing in wardrobes or even repeatedly cheating. I’ve seen this on here too.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Redbags · 10/11/2026 14:23

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 14:17

@Redbags “I think you can help it. You can do the work to understand why you always like bad boys and why one who presents more gently in socks and sandals is a turn off for you, for example.”

I wouldn’t be attracted to a man who wore socks with sandals. Just like I’m not attracted to short, bald or fat men. I’m attracted to
men who are intelligent and capable. Men who have some ‘get up and go’.

That doesn't make any sense though. A short , bald, fat man in socks and sandals could have more intelligence and get up and go than anyone you've ever met.

TiredShadows · 10/11/2026 14:20

MoreDangerousThanAWomanScorned · 10/11/2026 11:07

I’ve known women who are attracted to the same type over and over - alpha male or uber laddish types - and it never works out.

I've spent my whole life socialising with and working with the nerdy/arty, academic sort of man who is the opposite type to that. I can assure that plenty of them are misogynistic dicks, too.

I do think that some women choose abusive/unpleasant men over and over again. I also think that there are complex psychological reasons for this, and that it isn't as easy as saying 'oh well, you just go for the wrong type'.

Seconding all of this. The idea that it all comes down to type comes across as saying that if you picked a different type they'd automatically be good life partners. That's not how compatibility and life partnering works.

I've never dated an 'alpha male' or a laddish type - one of my 'icks'/absolute no to continuing a relationship is seeing a person drunk so I was never around that type long. I've still known plenty of nerdy, arty, academic, soft guy types who were absolutely not life partner material at that time. That's similar to a lot of women I know - I can't really think of any I know who fit the OP's stereotype of being into alpha male/laddish types.

Really, I think many cultures have largely moved more individualistic and not really setting people up to be life partners. It feels like at times it's pushing against social norms in many spaces to prioritise life partnering for both women and men, regardless of sexuality, rather than towards career or personal experiences.

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 14:17

@Redbags “I think you can help it. You can do the work to understand why you always like bad boys and why one who presents more gently in socks and sandals is a turn off for you, for example.”

I wouldn’t be attracted to a man who wore socks with sandals. Just like I’m not attracted to short, bald or fat men. I’m attracted to
men who are intelligent and capable. Men who have some ‘get up and go’.

AlonsoMosley · 10/11/2026 14:17

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 10:47

@MrsShawnHatosy “But that too many women are not attracted to the kind of man that makes a good life partner?”

You can’t help who you are attracted to. If I’m going to be intimate with a man, I’m going to be fussy!

I am not sure about that though @scoutzx

For me, there were always men I would like to have sex with but would not dream of having a relationship with never mind a child. I could appreciate their sexiness and have fun but leave it at that.

When I met dh I knew that he was long term relationship category, and I acted accordingly. We had shared values. That is what made him sexy to me.

My mum drummed a few things into me growing up, one being handsome is as handsome does! Meaning, how he behaves towards you and others are what make him.

Blueysmum2026 · 10/11/2026 14:17

Even the ‘nice’ ones are often horrible behind closed doors in my experience.

CrazyMidget · 10/11/2026 14:15

Redbags · 10/11/2026 14:07

I think you can help it. You can do the work to understand why you always like bad boys and why one who presents more gently in socks and sandals is a turn off for you, for example.

Otherwise women who continually move from one dreadful man to another can't help it, it's just what they're attracted to?

Socks and sandals though...

Redbags · 10/11/2026 14:10

It's interesting that this list of icks seems to be thongs that might apply to nice guys who aren't that bothered about appearances?

A shirtsleeved shirt, a bath, socks (I'll give you passing on the wardrobe).

If those are the kind of things that turn you off, you probably do need to have a think about why.

Redbags · 10/11/2026 14:07

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 14:03

None of it makes sense. You can’t help getting the ick over certain things. I couldn’t go out with a man who wore socks with sandals.

I think you can help it. You can do the work to understand why you always like bad boys and why one who presents more gently in socks and sandals is a turn off for you, for example.

Otherwise women who continually move from one dreadful man to another can't help it, it's just what they're attracted to?

CookerHat · 10/11/2026 14:05

You’re not wrong OP. And no wonder there are so many kids who don’t have dads on the scene, because low and behold it comes to fruition that these men often turn out feckless but they women couldn’t have possibly foreseen it coming….. You can generally tell them a mile off!

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 14:03

CrazyMidget · 10/11/2026 14:00

Me neither. I'm over here like "Eh? What's wrong with short-sleeve button-down shirts?"

As for getting the ick over a man having a bath, I despair.

None of it makes sense. You can’t help getting the ick over certain things. I couldn’t go out with a man who wore socks with sandals.

Bigtrapeze · 10/11/2026 14:01

FancyKitten · 10/11/2026 13:53

Ha ha… I remember a guy I dated (lovely guy, would have been a good husband) telling me that he used to have a bath with his ex (when they were together, like!). It was a bit icky.

But DH has pissed in the wardrobe. Real ick!

Edited

This made me laugh out loud! He's not alone. My DH hasn't but came home the other night after a few drinks and was delighted to have pissed in our front garden on his way in. Perfect end to a night out, apparently.

CrazyMidget · 10/11/2026 14:00

MrsShawnHatosy · 10/11/2026 10:58

You see that wouldn’t even register with me as an ick.

Me neither. I'm over here like "Eh? What's wrong with short-sleeve button-down shirts?"

As for getting the ick over a man having a bath, I despair.

Bigtrapeze · 10/11/2026 13:56

I think the sort of man I am attracted to would have a bath if he wanted one and be unapologetic, seeking someone who wouldn't dismiss him on that basis. That is the sort of confidence I am looking for, I think, and he needs to make me laugh.

What makes some men irresistible to women and others of no interest is quite complex, I think, but nice guys have not always prospered. It is fascinating. I can never say whether I find someone attractive from a photo as how they speak/come across is crucial to me. Without seeing someone's smile in real life, I can't say.

Finding someone attractive is a complicated thing, and we all have our 'Icks' I suppose. I think mine would be turning up in a mid life crisis sports car. I'd like a bicycle as a top choice and luckily DH drove an elderly Renault Cleo when we met, so all good. I could probably think someone was quite nice and revise my opinion entirely as they revved a Porsche Boxster in a crowded car park. Too try hard and performative for me. Luckily I'm happily married and lots of other women will like the sports car revving, so everyone's happy. 😃

FancyKitten · 10/11/2026 13:53

MrsShawnHatosy · 10/11/2026 10:57

Just that. A list of icks and one is a man taking a bath.

Ha ha… I remember a guy I dated (lovely guy, would have been a good husband) telling me that he used to have a bath with his ex (when they were together, like!). It was a bit icky.

But DH has pissed in the wardrobe. Real ick!

cardibach · 10/11/2026 13:47

Apotofrealcoffee · 10/11/2026 11:34

We can’t infer that at all. We can’t just scrabble around for reasons the stats don’t support us. The fact is lesbians are very nearly as likely to perpetrate domestic violence within a relationship as a heterosexual man.

I didn’t infer. I wondered but the post I replied to had explained the data anyway - as so often it was down to the research question. It really wouldn’t make sense for women to be as violent as men in just one small area of life.

Stompythedinosaur · 10/11/2026 13:38

I think that women are allowed to not want a relationship with a man for any reason they see fit! If there's a behaviour or character trait that bothers them, why should they have to put up with it because the op things it isn't a good enough reason to reject a partner?

My view is that our bar for what a "good man" looks like isn't nearly high enough! I think the absolute bare minimum expectation is a man with consistently good hygiene, who does half the housework and half the childcare, respects women, carries half the mental load, has a job and contributes to society, has decent morals and can match their partner intellectually. That would be "good enough" not even "good". Almost all women meet this bar, and only a tiny proportion of men.

Society is just skewed in what it expects women to contribute to a relationship vs men. No wonder an increasing number of women believe it's preferable to be alone than with a man!

brunettemic · 10/11/2026 13:31

I don’t think there’s a lack of good men out there, there’s probably a lack of single good men out there because all the good ones are taken. My DH is great, we work well together, share the burden of life and have fun (in many ways haha) together.

MrsShawnHatosy · 10/11/2026 13:10

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 12:24

Meanwhile some women love types considered more boring. I am happy for you. I wonder why OP is trying to get women to consider other guys they do not find attractive.

We are all allowed to be different. And we are all allowed to remain single if we don't find what we like.

I haven’t said we aren’t.

Interesting that the vote is pretty close on this. I was expecting to be flamed.

OP posts:
OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 12:24

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 12:11

I liked a man with some ‘oomph’ when I was young. An ex of mine was very spontaneous and I loved that about him. We backpacked around the world when our first child was a baby. I still like some ‘oomph’ in a man over dull and boring.

Meanwhile some women love types considered more boring. I am happy for you. I wonder why OP is trying to get women to consider other guys they do not find attractive.

We are all allowed to be different. And we are all allowed to remain single if we don't find what we like.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/11/2026 12:24

Chilly80 · 10/11/2026 11:59

And some of it is women's fault the women who raise these men as little princes who never have to clean or pick up after themselves and tell they them their wives aren't good enough for them

Do these men not have fathers? Or any personal responsibility as adults at all?

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 12:11

Wishingplenty · 10/11/2026 12:06

I think this is maybe half true. Very young woman consider decent types boring. I certainly did. It is only the wisdom of getting older that you see men like that in a different light. I never liked laddish men, but did prefer someone with a bit of oomph. Now that I am 48 I now realise that oomph means something else entirely and I would settle for bland and dull. Because then you have a blank canvas to work on.

I liked a man with some ‘oomph’ when I was young. An ex of mine was very spontaneous and I loved that about him. We backpacked around the world when our first child was a baby. I still like some ‘oomph’ in a man over dull and boring.

UniquePinkSwan · 10/11/2026 12:08

MyManinCaracas · 10/11/2026 10:56

When I met my now husband he wore a short sleeve button down shirt. Massive ick. Fortunately for me I gave him a chance, fell in love, and sorted out his clothes. This probably wouldn’t be acceptable to a younger generation woman “he can wear what he wants” but that’s how it worked.

Imagine a man changing the way a woman dresses…

Wishingplenty · 10/11/2026 12:06

I think this is maybe half true. Very young woman consider decent types boring. I certainly did. It is only the wisdom of getting older that you see men like that in a different light. I never liked laddish men, but did prefer someone with a bit of oomph. Now that I am 48 I now realise that oomph means something else entirely and I would settle for bland and dull. Because then you have a blank canvas to work on.

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 12:05

@MrsShawnHatosy This is very true. I wouldn’t think about the reason women were single unless they were my friends and were confiding in me. It would make me wonder why a man has been single for a long time. I would see it as a potential red flag.

MagnoliaParks · 10/11/2026 12:02

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 11:45

@MagnoliaParks “My DH is an absolute king compared to MN standards (does the majority of housework etc) but was single for years before we got together.”

Him being single for years would have put me off. I’d have wondered what was wrong with him. Obviously it’s worked out great for you.

He just hadn’t really met anyone tbh. He doesn’t go out drinking, didn’t do online dating so it wasn’t a red flag. We met through work and I asked him out on a date as he wouldn’t ever be so presumptuous. He has a huge group of male friends, but they were mostly Muslim (common where we live) so their socialising was based around food not drink.

The plus side of all that is I can’t see that I’ll ever need to post on MN about him rolling in drunk at 2am for the nth time this year and me not knowing where he was!

Swipe left for the next trending thread